WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.760
<v Phillip Adams>Jackie Huggins. Jackie is of the Bidjara people from central Queensland and the Birgubba Djudi people from north Queensland.

2
00:00:09.300 --> 00:00:15.860
<v Phillip Adams>She's currently the Deputy Director of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies Unit at the University of Queensland,

3
00:00:16.900 --> 00:00:21.860
<v Phillip Adams>a member of the Board of Reconciliation Australia, the National Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation,

4
00:00:22.240 --> 00:00:29.220
<v Phillip Adams>the State Library Board of Queensland, the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies Council,

5
00:00:29.220 --> 00:00:33.020
<v Phillip Adams>she's the Chair of Queensland's Domestic Violence Council,

6
00:00:33.240 --> 00:00:39.700
<v Phillip Adams>and the Co-Commissioner of Queensland for the Inquiry into the Separation of Aboriginal Children.

7
00:00:41.060 --> 00:00:46.920
<v Phillip Adams>Jackie is an historian and author, and she's also a remarkable woman,

8
00:00:47.060 --> 00:00:52.580
<v Phillip Adams>and will now provide the first of the responses to Sir Ronald's address.

9
00:01:04.340 --> 00:01:06.400
<v Marcia Langton>Thank you very much, Philip.

10
00:01:06.720 --> 00:01:16.280
<v Marcia Langton>And let me begin by acknowledging the traditional owners of the country, the Kaurna people, on whose land we are meeting tonight.

11
00:01:16.900 --> 00:01:23.240
<v Marcia Langton>I acknowledge their ancient and continuing cultures and the role they play in the life of this region.

12
00:01:24.200 --> 00:01:28.240
<v Marcia Langton>I also acknowledge those gone before us and those here today,

13
00:01:28.240 --> 00:01:34.680
<v Marcia Langton>who have suffered at the hands of assimilation policies and the search for peace and justice.

14
00:01:35.640 --> 00:01:40.120
<v Marcia Langton>Thank you to Carl and Waiter Telford up the back there.

15
00:01:40.480 --> 00:01:47.340
<v Marcia Langton>Thank you very much for the honourable welcome that we received here tonight, as well as with the little fella.

16
00:01:47.560 --> 00:01:50.980
<v Marcia Langton>So thank you, little fella. I don't know your name, but it's to you.

17
00:01:52.080 --> 00:01:52.600
<v Marcia Langton>.

18
00:01:55.820 --> 00:01:58.220
<v Marcia Langton>And I'm especially blessed when I come to the

19
00:01:58.220 --> 00:02:05.380
<v Marcia Langton>Adelaide because I'm always feeling the presence of the Kaurna people and their wonderful and continuing culture.

20
00:02:05.620 --> 00:02:06.900
<v Marcia Langton>So thank you very much.

21
00:02:07.260 --> 00:02:14.920
<v Marcia Langton>To thank you all, too, for the opportunity to share and talk about the process of reconciliation in this country.

22
00:02:15.900 --> 00:02:17.380
<v Marcia Langton>Is it in paralysis?

23
00:02:19.040 --> 00:02:24.020
<v Marcia Langton>I would like to argue that it's not certainly at a community level,

24
00:02:24.140 --> 00:02:26.280
<v Marcia Langton>but certainly at a political,

25
00:02:26.480 --> 00:02:27.000
<v Marcia Langton>ah,

26
00:02:27.660 --> 00:02:29.140
<v Marcia Langton>leadership in this country.

27
00:02:29.200 --> 00:02:33.580
<v Marcia Langton>Of course, we're stuck in a pause, as Sir Ronald aptly put it.

28
00:02:34.000 --> 00:02:39.840
<v Marcia Langton>I was very proud also to serve as one of Sir Ronald's deputies in Queensland

29
00:02:39.840 --> 00:02:47.880
<v Marcia Langton>on the inquiry into the separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children from their families and their communities.

30
00:02:48.920 --> 00:02:56.360
<v Marcia Langton>And every time I hear Sir Ronald talk about hearing the witness and the testimonies of those people,

31
00:02:57.040 --> 00:03:03.260
<v Marcia Langton>I often think about probably some counselling for my own self.

32
00:03:03.340 --> 00:03:09.820
<v Marcia Langton>Because once you hear those horrible testimonies and stories,

33
00:03:10.440 --> 00:03:12.780
<v Marcia Langton>they remain with you forever.

34
00:03:13.800 --> 00:03:21.920
<v Marcia Langton>And as Sir Ronald said, it is a life-changing transformation and exercise that each of us have been through.

35
00:03:22.440 --> 00:03:26.860
<v Marcia Langton>And I still very much live with the pain and live with the grief.

36
00:03:26.880 --> 00:03:26.980
<v Marcia Langton>.

37
00:03:26.980 --> 00:03:31.840
<v Marcia Langton>Of hearing those stories and still fighting for the justice for those people.

38
00:03:32.700 --> 00:03:35.980
<v Marcia Langton>In Queensland we have also National Sorry Day.

39
00:03:36.220 --> 00:03:42.520
<v Marcia Langton>And I spoke at Musgrave Park, as I always do when I'm at home, on National Sorry Day.

40
00:03:42.840 --> 00:03:52.240
<v Marcia Langton>And I said to our people, I hope this year I don't have to come here and talk to you as a person at a National Sorry Day.

41
00:03:52.380 --> 00:03:56.740
<v Marcia Langton>I want it to be a national forgiveness or a national celebration.

42
00:03:56.740 --> 00:04:01.320
<v Marcia Langton>Because hopefully by then we would have received the apology.

43
00:04:01.940 --> 00:04:03.620
<v Marcia Langton>I still live in that hope.

44
00:04:03.760 --> 00:04:08.580
<v Marcia Langton>And I still believe an apology is one of the central tenements to reconciliation.

45
00:04:09.260 --> 00:04:18.600
<v Marcia Langton>Along with other issues such as native title, of reducing the severe social disadvantage that my people still face.

46
00:04:18.860 --> 00:04:21.060
<v Marcia Langton>Along with a whole host of other things.

47
00:04:22.340 --> 00:04:22.980
<v Marcia Langton>.

48
00:04:22.980 --> 00:04:23.040
<v Marcia Langton>.

49
00:04:23.040 --> 00:04:30.020
<v Marcia Langton>The Council has aptly described the historical context of the reconciliation process.

50
00:04:30.260 --> 00:04:36.980
<v Marcia Langton>The Council and now Reconciliation Australia Foundation, of which I am now a member of.

51
00:04:37.260 --> 00:04:40.780
<v Marcia Langton>I might say that we are a team of nine members.

52
00:04:41.060 --> 00:04:43.540
<v Marcia Langton>We are autonomous, we're independent.

53
00:04:44.000 --> 00:04:51.020
<v Marcia Langton>We operate on a budget that the old Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation operated on for six months.

54
00:04:51.320 --> 00:04:51.480
<v Marcia Langton>.

55
00:04:51.480 --> 00:04:56.300
<v Marcia Langton>We have a six month budget to operate for a lifetime.

56
00:04:57.120 --> 00:05:06.300
<v Marcia Langton>Therefore we seek sponsorship and we seek the goodwill and the good grace of all Australians to support and to sponsor.

57
00:05:06.520 --> 00:05:12.760
<v Marcia Langton>So that we might be able to, in a very real way, keep driving the reconciliation process.

58
00:05:13.360 --> 00:05:16.800
<v Marcia Langton>As you may have seen, we've not been much in the media at all.

59
00:05:16.980 --> 00:05:19.560
<v Marcia Langton>Except when there are issues concerning our people.

60
00:05:19.560 --> 00:05:29.060
<v Marcia Langton>The most recent issue has been that of family, domestic and sexual abuse within Indigenous communities.

61
00:05:30.940 --> 00:05:38.740
<v Marcia Langton>We have had, in a very real sense, the opportunity to take the high ground on this.

62
00:05:38.860 --> 00:05:43.620
<v Marcia Langton>In terms of being able to say, what are we going to do about it?

63
00:05:43.740 --> 00:05:44.920
<v Marcia Langton>Is this reconciliation?

64
00:05:45.500 --> 00:05:47.840
<v Marcia Langton>Will we keep letting this happen to our people?

65
00:05:47.840 --> 00:05:50.280
<v Marcia Langton>Are governments going to stop this?

66
00:05:50.600 --> 00:05:58.880
<v Marcia Langton>Are people who are responsible for the relevant service providers and relevant organisations going to assist us?

67
00:05:59.140 --> 00:06:03.560
<v Marcia Langton>Well, let's use this as a test case for reconciliation.

68
00:06:04.260 --> 00:06:05.380
<v Marcia Langton>That's what it is.

69
00:06:05.440 --> 00:06:06.680
<v Marcia Langton>It's about forming partnerships.

70
00:06:07.120 --> 00:06:08.920
<v Marcia Langton>It's about forming alliances.

71
00:06:09.300 --> 00:06:11.480
<v Marcia Langton>And it's about fixing the problem.

72
00:06:12.020 --> 00:06:14.500
<v Marcia Langton>Well, we certainly want the problem fixed.

73
00:06:14.960 --> 00:06:16.840
<v Marcia Langton>And we certainly want to partner.

74
00:06:16.980 --> 00:06:21.760
<v Marcia Langton>We certainly want to partner with those who can help us along the road.

75
00:06:22.860 --> 00:06:28.820
<v Marcia Langton>I think Aidan Ridgway said recently, as yesterday, that reconciliation is here.

76
00:06:28.940 --> 00:06:29.940
<v Marcia Langton>It's here to stay.

77
00:06:30.520 --> 00:06:32.200
<v Marcia Langton>It's knocking at the door.

78
00:06:32.820 --> 00:06:34.980
<v Marcia Langton>And it certainly is knocking at the door.

79
00:06:35.100 --> 00:06:37.040
<v Marcia Langton>We just want to be allowed to come in.

80
00:06:37.300 --> 00:06:40.760
<v Marcia Langton>Come inside to the hearts and to the homes of people.

81
00:06:41.000 --> 00:06:44.420
<v Marcia Langton>We think we've done that in a very real way compared to ten years ago.

82
00:06:44.420 --> 00:06:48.160
<v Marcia Langton>But certainly there is still a very, very long way to go.

83
00:06:49.900 --> 00:06:56.020
<v Marcia Langton>As Sir Ronald mentioned, we saw millions of people walk across the bridges of Australia

84
00:06:56.760 --> 00:07:03.260
<v Marcia Langton>with a heartfelt glow about concern and justice for Indigenous Australians.

85
00:07:04.940 --> 00:07:08.120
<v Marcia Langton>We're saying, of course, that's still not enough.

86
00:07:08.340 --> 00:07:10.620
<v Marcia Langton>We still need to do something with that momentum.

87
00:07:11.400 --> 00:07:14.400
<v Marcia Langton>And the big question that I get asked all the time is,

88
00:07:14.400 --> 00:07:16.340
<v Marcia Langton>what now? What next?

89
00:07:17.300 --> 00:07:21.040
<v Marcia Langton>The question is one that many Australians want answered.

90
00:07:21.380 --> 00:07:24.120
<v Marcia Langton>Aboriginal people, Torres Strait Islanders,

91
00:07:24.240 --> 00:07:27.960
<v Marcia Langton>and people from all walks of life, from our diverse communities.

92
00:07:28.660 --> 00:07:33.760
<v Marcia Langton>And it's the question that still challenges and still haunts all of us.

93
00:07:34.000 --> 00:07:39.360
<v Marcia Langton>Because getting it right on reconciliation is vital to our future together

94
00:07:39.360 --> 00:07:43.840
<v Marcia Langton>and to our nation's sense of identity, purpose and pride.

95
00:07:44.400 --> 00:07:47.920
<v Marcia Langton>It's also the right thing to do.

96
00:07:51.400 --> 00:07:54.660
<v Marcia Langton>The public outpouring of public support we saw last year

97
00:07:54.660 --> 00:07:58.620
<v Marcia Langton>showed that reconciliation truly had become a people's movement

98
00:07:58.620 --> 00:08:00.720
<v Marcia Langton>with a relentless momentum.

99
00:08:01.480 --> 00:08:05.220
<v Marcia Langton>The challenge for all of us now is to translate that momentum

100
00:08:05.220 --> 00:08:08.980
<v Marcia Langton>into tangible outcomes which will make a real difference

101
00:08:08.980 --> 00:08:12.540
<v Marcia Langton>to the lives and the circumstances of Indigenous peoples.

102
00:08:12.540 --> 00:08:17.980
<v Marcia Langton>Such outcomes will be the measure of the progress towards true reconciliation.

103
00:08:19.080 --> 00:08:25.040
<v Marcia Langton>The current debate at the moment has two extremes.

104
00:08:25.380 --> 00:08:31.440
<v Marcia Langton>One verges on a new assimilationism which really says that Indigenous people

105
00:08:31.440 --> 00:08:34.200
<v Marcia Langton>should give up their own communities and cultures

106
00:08:34.200 --> 00:08:38.140
<v Marcia Langton>and be like the rest of us, of you.

107
00:08:39.240 --> 00:08:42.480
<v Marcia Langton>At the other end, an abstract and undefined

108
00:08:42.480 --> 00:08:42.520
<v Marcia Langton>and unambiguous debate about the future of Indigenous people.

109
00:08:42.520 --> 00:08:42.800
<v Marcia Langton>The second is that the new and unambiguous debate

110
00:08:42.800 --> 00:08:45.520
<v Marcia Langton>on the rights agenda is promoted which is remote

111
00:08:45.520 --> 00:08:48.480
<v Marcia Langton>from the day-to-day concerns of Indigenous peoples.

112
00:08:49.440 --> 00:08:53.480
<v Marcia Langton>And also risks disconnecting the essential public debate

113
00:08:53.480 --> 00:08:57.260
<v Marcia Langton>on Indigenous rights from the broad people's movement

114
00:08:57.260 --> 00:08:59.720
<v Marcia Langton>whose support is most critical.

115
00:09:02.380 --> 00:09:06.660
<v Marcia Langton>In recent weeks, some commentators have focused on harsh realities

116
00:09:06.660 --> 00:09:11.660
<v Marcia Langton>facing Indigenous people, including poverty, substance abuse,

117
00:09:11.660 --> 00:09:17.180
<v Marcia Langton>alcoholism and particularly domestic, family and sexual violence

118
00:09:17.180 --> 00:09:18.760
<v Marcia Langton>within our own communities.

119
00:09:20.660 --> 00:09:22.980
<v Marcia Langton>And the inadequate outcomes and responses

120
00:09:22.980 --> 00:09:24.940
<v Marcia Langton>from poorly coordinated programs.

121
00:09:26.660 --> 00:09:31.140
<v Marcia Langton>A common thread of the various commentators is that everyday circumstances

122
00:09:31.660 --> 00:09:35.520
<v Marcia Langton>of too many Indigenous families and communities are unacceptable.

123
00:09:36.480 --> 00:09:41.200
<v Marcia Langton>Unacceptable by anyone's standards in an insane,

124
00:09:41.200 --> 00:09:42.800
<v Marcia Langton>and a sane Australia.

125
00:09:44.180 --> 00:09:49.300
<v Marcia Langton>The tragedy is that while sometimes bitter and ideological debates rages,

126
00:09:49.560 --> 00:09:53.180
<v Marcia Langton>many Indigenous people continue to suffer and die.

127
00:09:53.940 --> 00:09:57.360
<v Marcia Langton>Unfortunately, the accusations and counter-accusations

128
00:09:57.360 --> 00:10:02.640
<v Marcia Langton>command more attention than views and proposals based on local experience.

129
00:10:05.000 --> 00:10:09.900
<v Marcia Langton>In particular, we want the latest crisis in Aboriginal affairs.

130
00:10:09.900 --> 00:10:14.660
<v Marcia Langton>That of domestic sexual and sexual violence.

131
00:10:15.360 --> 00:10:22.300
<v Marcia Langton>To become a test case about how will we all work together to fix it.

132
00:10:23.320 --> 00:10:27.260
<v Marcia Langton>That will be the challenge for us in the next couple of months,

133
00:10:27.380 --> 00:10:28.060
<v Marcia Langton>I should imagine.

134
00:10:30.060 --> 00:10:35.760
<v Marcia Langton>We should be concerned certainly with people and not theory.

135
00:10:36.160 --> 00:10:39.620
<v Marcia Langton>And recognise that no single theory or action

136
00:10:39.620 --> 00:10:41.160
<v Marcia Langton>is going to solve it.

137
00:10:41.380 --> 00:10:45.900
<v Marcia Langton>The diversity of Indigenous lives today does not lend itself so easily.

138
00:10:48.420 --> 00:10:57.580
<v Marcia Langton>To finish, we know that the Council now has ended its work.

139
00:10:57.880 --> 00:11:00.700
<v Marcia Langton>And our foundation, Reconciliation Australia,

140
00:11:01.040 --> 00:11:04.620
<v Marcia Langton>certainly has some core responsibilities from where to now.

141
00:11:05.060 --> 00:11:08.840
<v Marcia Langton>Yet as always, Australia's journey toward true reconciliation

142
00:11:08.840 --> 00:11:13.020
<v Marcia Langton>lies in the hands of people and of all governments, peak bodies

143
00:11:13.020 --> 00:11:16.220
<v Marcia Langton>and community organisations which represent them

144
00:11:16.220 --> 00:11:17.860
<v Marcia Langton>and are responsible to them.

145
00:11:18.120 --> 00:11:21.780
<v Marcia Langton>We cannot, we cannot hope to do it alone.

146
00:11:23.820 --> 00:11:29.640
<v Marcia Langton>We ask for all your support in continuing the work of reconciliation.

147
00:11:30.500 --> 00:11:36.140
<v Marcia Langton>The way that it is obviously the good news stories

148
00:11:36.140 --> 00:11:38.500
<v Marcia Langton>that we often hear around our communities.

149
00:11:38.840 --> 00:11:40.300
<v Marcia Langton>We are not getting in the media.

150
00:11:40.600 --> 00:11:44.060
<v Marcia Langton>There are some very vital and some very interesting things

151
00:11:44.060 --> 00:11:45.380
<v Marcia Langton>that are happening around our country.

152
00:11:45.560 --> 00:11:50.220
<v Marcia Langton>And through partnerships, we are forming a lot of alliances around the country.

153
00:11:50.560 --> 00:11:54.400
<v Marcia Langton>However, without the goodwill and the intent

154
00:11:55.060 --> 00:12:01.500
<v Marcia Langton>and of course the absolute support from those in leadership,

155
00:12:01.660 --> 00:12:05.360
<v Marcia Langton>the very highest echelons, we cannot hope to move any forward.

156
00:12:05.500 --> 00:12:06.140
<v Marcia Langton>Thank you.

157
00:12:11.200 --> 00:12:19.820
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you very much.

158
00:12:22.380 --> 00:12:26.660
<v Phillip Adams>Though a farmer, it never occurred to me for a nanosecond

159
00:12:26.660 --> 00:12:30.160
<v Phillip Adams>to join the National Farmers' Federation.

160
00:12:30.940 --> 00:12:34.520
<v Phillip Adams>I always regarded them as sort of a eucalyptic variant

161
00:12:34.520 --> 00:12:37.400
<v Phillip Adams>on America's National Rifle Association.

162
00:12:38.840 --> 00:12:42.120
<v Phillip Adams>Until I met Rick Farley.

163
00:12:42.240 --> 00:12:45.540
<v Phillip Adams>Now, to meet Rick in that context was a bit like discovering

164
00:12:45.540 --> 00:12:48.600
<v Phillip Adams>that Christopher Pearson and Paddy McGuinness

165
00:12:48.600 --> 00:12:50.580
<v Phillip Adams>had joined the Australian Ballet.

166
00:12:55.780 --> 00:12:58.060
<v Phillip Adams>How Farley got the job,

167
00:12:58.140 --> 00:13:00.120
<v Phillip Adams>and he was also running at the same time

168
00:13:00.120 --> 00:13:02.900
<v Phillip Adams>the Cattlemen's Union of Australia,

169
00:13:03.960 --> 00:13:06.780
<v Phillip Adams>makes the mind boggle, but he did it brilliantly.

170
00:13:06.780 --> 00:13:08.720
<v Phillip Adams>And he went on to facilitate

171
00:13:08.720 --> 00:13:11.180
<v Phillip Adams>the Cape York Land Use Heads of Agreement.

172
00:13:11.620 --> 00:13:15.520
<v Phillip Adams>He pioneered the National Land Care Program with the ACF.

173
00:13:16.220 --> 00:13:20.260
<v Phillip Adams>He was a key figure in the passage of the Native Title Act in 1993.

174
00:13:21.400 --> 00:13:23.660
<v Phillip Adams>And it was briefly my pleasure to work with Rick

175
00:13:23.660 --> 00:13:25.920
<v Phillip Adams>at the Commission for the Future,

176
00:13:26.000 --> 00:13:28.760
<v Phillip Adams>which was an outfit set up by my dear friend Barry Jones

177
00:13:29.460 --> 00:13:30.680
<v Phillip Adams>in the Hawke government,

178
00:13:30.780 --> 00:13:33.460
<v Phillip Adams>and the Commission for the Future ran out of future,

179
00:13:33.560 --> 00:13:35.220
<v Phillip Adams>which I thought was very symbolic for Australia.

180
00:13:38.200 --> 00:13:42.280
<v Phillip Adams>Rick has been a member of the National Native Title Tribunal,

181
00:13:42.400 --> 00:13:44.440
<v Phillip Adams>the Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation,

182
00:13:45.100 --> 00:13:50.560
<v Phillip Adams>is now the Managing Director of the Farley Consulting Group,

183
00:13:50.620 --> 00:13:53.120
<v Phillip Adams>which specialises in land use agreements.

184
00:13:53.740 --> 00:13:55.480
<v Phillip Adams>Look, his CV goes on for miles.

185
00:13:55.480 --> 00:13:56.720
<v Phillip Adams>It's like a Superman movie.

186
00:13:56.780 --> 00:13:57.320
<v Phillip Adams>His credits.

187
00:13:57.660 --> 00:13:59.720
<v Phillip Adams>And I welcome him to the microphone.

188
00:14:11.360 --> 00:14:12.720
<v Rick Farley>Well, good evening, everyone.

189
00:14:14.240 --> 00:14:18.060
<v Rick Farley>I'd also like to acknowledge the Kaurna people

190
00:14:18.060 --> 00:14:20.520
<v Rick Farley>as the traditional owners of the country where we meet tonight,

191
00:14:21.660 --> 00:14:26.760
<v Rick Farley>and to pay respect to their culture and to their elders.

192
00:14:29.700 --> 00:14:33.460
<v Rick Farley>I've worked in politics for 25 years.

193
00:14:35.480 --> 00:14:39.040
<v Rick Farley>My degree is actually in English drama and literature.

194
00:14:40.720 --> 00:14:44.660
<v Rick Farley>Some people have suggested that's a terrific grounding for politics.

195
00:14:47.900 --> 00:14:53.400
<v Rick Farley>Theatre of the absurd, black comedy, and so on.

196
00:14:54.600 --> 00:14:58.860
<v Rick Farley>But one of the things that I value the most out of that 25 years

197
00:14:58.860 --> 00:15:02.080
<v Rick Farley>is that I've had the rare privilege of being able to see issues

198
00:15:02.080 --> 00:15:03.440
<v Rick Farley>from the past 25 years.

199
00:15:03.460 --> 00:15:05.840
<v Rick Farley>I've seen issues from different sides of the political fence.

200
00:15:07.040 --> 00:15:10.740
<v Rick Farley>I've seen issues from the perspective of farmers.

201
00:15:11.080 --> 00:15:15.580
<v Rick Farley>I've seen the same issues from the perspective of environmentalists.

202
00:15:16.960 --> 00:15:20.180
<v Rick Farley>Issues from the perspective of Aboriginal people.

203
00:15:21.460 --> 00:15:24.640
<v Rick Farley>And also, through my term on the Native Title Tribunal,

204
00:15:25.560 --> 00:15:26.360
<v Rick Farley>the legal perspective.

205
00:15:28.480 --> 00:15:31.060
<v Rick Farley>So let me respond briefly

206
00:15:31.060 --> 00:15:33.440
<v Rick Farley>to what Sir Ronald had to say

207
00:15:33.460 --> 00:15:35.440
<v Rick Farley>in these terms.

208
00:15:37.020 --> 00:15:39.020
<v Rick Farley>First of all, he posed the question,

209
00:15:39.180 --> 00:15:40.020
<v Rick Farley>what's changed?

210
00:15:43.320 --> 00:15:44.800
<v Rick Farley>For a lot of Aboriginal people,

211
00:15:45.600 --> 00:15:47.560
<v Rick Farley>the answer is nothing.

212
00:15:48.440 --> 00:15:49.300
<v Speaker 4>Nothing's changed.

213
00:15:50.400 --> 00:15:52.640
<v Rick Farley>As a result of the reconciliation process.

214
00:15:54.080 --> 00:15:55.940
<v Rick Farley>And we need to bear in mind that

215
00:15:55.940 --> 00:15:58.980
<v Rick Farley>the reconciliation process in itself is a compromise.

216
00:15:59.360 --> 00:16:01.820
<v Rick Farley>You may recall that the Hawke government came to power

217
00:16:01.820 --> 00:16:03.240
<v Rick Farley>promising national land rights.

218
00:16:04.040 --> 00:16:04.880
<v Rick Farley>Never happened.

219
00:16:05.100 --> 00:16:07.280
<v Rick Farley>There was then going to be a treaty or Makarrata.

220
00:16:07.460 --> 00:16:08.300
<v Rick Farley>Never happened.

221
00:16:09.060 --> 00:16:11.980
<v Rick Farley>Instead, there was a 10-year process of reconciliation.

222
00:16:14.880 --> 00:16:16.260
<v Rick Farley>If you look around today,

223
00:16:16.380 --> 00:16:19.220
<v Rick Farley>Aboriginal people are 2% of the national population.

224
00:16:19.480 --> 00:16:22.540
<v Rick Farley>They're 40% of the prison population in New South Wales.

225
00:16:25.240 --> 00:16:29.420
<v Rick Farley>If you look at the percentage in jail under 15,

226
00:16:29.600 --> 00:16:32.200
<v Rick Farley>it's 60% in New South Wales.

227
00:16:33.940 --> 00:16:35.560
<v Rick Farley>We've all heard the statistics

228
00:16:36.720 --> 00:16:38.600
<v Rick Farley>which deal with social disadvantage,

229
00:16:39.000 --> 00:16:42.480
<v Rick Farley>life expectancy, employment, and so on.

230
00:16:43.200 --> 00:16:44.660
<v Rick Farley>And that is a shameful record

231
00:16:45.200 --> 00:16:46.880
<v Rick Farley>for a country like Australia.

232
00:16:47.080 --> 00:16:48.500
<v Rick Farley>A shameful record.

233
00:16:50.020 --> 00:16:52.140
<v Rick Farley>There is only one Aboriginal person

234
00:16:52.140 --> 00:16:53.640
<v Rick Farley>in federal parliament.

235
00:16:55.560 --> 00:16:58.900
<v Rick Farley>There's been no apology to the stolen generation.

236
00:16:59.240 --> 00:17:02.020
<v Rick Farley>There's been no response from the parliament

237
00:17:02.200 --> 00:17:04.920
<v Rick Farley>yet, or from any of the political parties,

238
00:17:05.620 --> 00:17:07.200
<v Rick Farley>to the report and recommendations

239
00:17:07.720 --> 00:17:09.980
<v Rick Farley>of the Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation.

240
00:17:15.220 --> 00:17:17.020
<v Rick Farley>I live in Sydney at the moment,

241
00:17:17.080 --> 00:17:20.960
<v Rick Farley>and I occasionally go down to Redfern, to the block.

242
00:17:23.100 --> 00:17:26.020
<v Rick Farley>And I've seen kids of 12

243
00:17:26.020 --> 00:17:29.140
<v Rick Farley>picking up used syringes out of the gutter

244
00:17:30.240 --> 00:17:32.180
<v Rick Farley>and injecting themselves to cigarettes.

245
00:17:32.200 --> 00:17:33.740
<v Rick Farley>I don't see if there's anything left in the bottom of it.

246
00:17:35.100 --> 00:17:36.700
<v Rick Farley>I've seen kids of that age

247
00:17:36.700 --> 00:17:40.120
<v Rick Farley>selling themselves into prostitution for drugs.

248
00:17:41.460 --> 00:17:42.760
<v Rick Farley>As Jackie mentioned,

249
00:17:42.980 --> 00:17:46.400
<v Rick Farley>it's been revealed publicly, I guess,

250
00:17:46.460 --> 00:17:47.540
<v Rick Farley>or exposed publicly.

251
00:17:49.840 --> 00:17:53.240
<v Rick Farley>Domestic violence is still rife.

252
00:17:54.380 --> 00:17:56.920
<v Rick Farley>It's still a huge problem for Aboriginal communities.

253
00:17:58.780 --> 00:18:01.540
<v Rick Farley>But you've got to ask yourself why those things happen.

254
00:18:01.540 --> 00:18:04.680
<v Rick Farley>And the conclusion that I'm forced to

255
00:18:04.680 --> 00:18:07.200
<v Rick Farley>is that successive generations of Australians,

256
00:18:07.640 --> 00:18:09.040
<v Rick Farley>successive parliaments,

257
00:18:09.680 --> 00:18:12.240
<v Rick Farley>have been unable to restore hope

258
00:18:12.240 --> 00:18:14.180
<v Rick Farley>to Aboriginal people,

259
00:18:14.900 --> 00:18:16.920
<v Rick Farley>to Indigenous people in this country.

260
00:18:17.040 --> 00:18:18.240
<v Rick Farley>And in the absence of hope,

261
00:18:19.020 --> 00:18:20.600
<v Rick Farley>people seek recourse

262
00:18:20.600 --> 00:18:24.460
<v Rick Farley>in substance abuse, alcohol, and so on.

263
00:18:24.540 --> 00:18:25.880
<v Rick Farley>It leads to domestic violence.

264
00:18:26.140 --> 00:18:27.900
<v Rick Farley>It leads to break-up of family units.

265
00:18:30.720 --> 00:18:31.520
<v Rick Farley>So the question is,

266
00:18:31.520 --> 00:18:33.120
<v Rick Farley>the question we've got to ask ourselves is,

267
00:18:33.220 --> 00:18:34.500
<v Rick Farley>what are we going to do about it?

268
00:18:34.920 --> 00:18:36.940
<v Rick Farley>Have we gone far enough? No.

269
00:18:37.020 --> 00:18:39.600
<v Rick Farley>We've had some attitudinal changes, yes.

270
00:18:40.620 --> 00:18:42.160
<v Rick Farley>But that's not enough.

271
00:18:42.860 --> 00:18:44.600
<v Rick Farley>The material circumstances,

272
00:18:45.060 --> 00:18:46.720
<v Rick Farley>the life circumstances

273
00:18:46.720 --> 00:18:49.300
<v Rick Farley>of most Aboriginal people in this country

274
00:18:49.300 --> 00:18:51.740
<v Rick Farley>have not changed very much at all.

275
00:18:53.860 --> 00:18:55.000
<v Rick Farley>So what's the agenda?

276
00:18:57.500 --> 00:19:00.300
<v Rick Farley>It seems to me that there's a number of components of the agenda.

277
00:19:00.300 --> 00:19:01.640
<v Rick Farley>The first has got to be education,

278
00:19:02.740 --> 00:19:05.840
<v Rick Farley>so that there is a true and accurate history of this country

279
00:19:05.840 --> 00:19:06.960
<v Rick Farley>taught in our schools.

280
00:19:07.700 --> 00:19:09.000
<v Rick Farley>It wasn't taught to me.

281
00:19:11.520 --> 00:19:13.400
<v Rick Farley>The second part of it, of course,

282
00:19:13.400 --> 00:19:14.620
<v Rick Farley>is going to be a rights agenda,

283
00:19:15.420 --> 00:19:17.980
<v Rick Farley>which will continue to be pursued in the courts

284
00:19:19.280 --> 00:19:21.300
<v Rick Farley>and in changes to the Constitution,

285
00:19:21.560 --> 00:19:22.560
<v Rick Farley>perhaps with a treaty,

286
00:19:22.640 --> 00:19:25.220
<v Rick Farley>certainly in a debate about a Bill of Rights,

287
00:19:26.020 --> 00:19:29.680
<v Rick Farley>which will accompany the extension of the Republican debate.

288
00:19:31.200 --> 00:19:34.540
<v Rick Farley>And the third component has got to be to redress disadvantage.

289
00:19:37.260 --> 00:19:39.640
<v Rick Farley>But let me make some observations to you

290
00:19:40.300 --> 00:19:43.920
<v Rick Farley>about some of the things that I've come to understand

291
00:19:44.480 --> 00:19:47.020
<v Rick Farley>over the last 10 or 15 years in particular.

292
00:19:49.340 --> 00:19:52.240
<v Rick Farley>The first is, and it's self-evident when you think about it,

293
00:19:52.280 --> 00:19:54.320
<v Rick Farley>that when we're dealing with Aboriginal people,

294
00:19:54.420 --> 00:19:56.280
<v Rick Farley>we're dealing with a different culture.

295
00:19:56.680 --> 00:19:57.840
<v Rick Farley>It's as simple as that.

296
00:19:58.720 --> 00:20:00.280
<v Rick Farley>And the priorities of Aboriginal people,

297
00:20:00.300 --> 00:20:02.520
<v Rick Farley>aren't necessarily going to be our priorities.

298
00:20:02.980 --> 00:20:05.240
<v Rick Farley>Or our priorities certainly may not be theirs.

299
00:20:09.860 --> 00:20:12.140
<v Rick Farley>Gullaroy Unupingu is a senior lawman

300
00:20:12.140 --> 00:20:14.240
<v Rick Farley>in northern Australia, in Arnhem Land.

301
00:20:14.900 --> 00:20:16.500
<v Rick Farley>I had a discussion with him once,

302
00:20:16.640 --> 00:20:18.600
<v Rick Farley>and you know how you have those discussions

303
00:20:18.600 --> 00:20:20.940
<v Rick Farley>and something comes at you totally out of left field,

304
00:20:21.640 --> 00:20:23.680
<v Rick Farley>and you think, wow, I've never really thought of it

305
00:20:23.680 --> 00:20:24.820
<v Rick Farley>in those terms before.

306
00:20:26.120 --> 00:20:27.520
<v Rick Farley>But I was talking to Gullaroy once,

307
00:20:27.620 --> 00:20:29.660
<v Rick Farley>it was during the Native Title debate, and I said to him,

308
00:20:29.660 --> 00:20:30.880
<v Rick Farley>Gullaroy, you're a senior lawman,

309
00:20:31.100 --> 00:20:33.080
<v Rick Farley>it would help if you could release some information

310
00:20:33.660 --> 00:20:34.940
<v Rick Farley>about connection with land,

311
00:20:35.560 --> 00:20:38.040
<v Rick Farley>because out of information will come some better understanding,

312
00:20:38.300 --> 00:20:40.180
<v Rick Farley>out of understanding will come a better debate.

313
00:20:41.460 --> 00:20:43.360
<v Rick Farley>And I thought that was a pretty reasonable proposition

314
00:20:43.360 --> 00:20:44.640
<v Rick Farley>to put from my point of view.

315
00:20:45.020 --> 00:20:47.540
<v Rick Farley>Information equals understanding equals a better debate.

316
00:20:48.640 --> 00:20:51.340
<v Rick Farley>There was a pause, and Gullaroy just looked at me for a while,

317
00:20:51.380 --> 00:20:54.700
<v Rick Farley>and he said, why do you white fellows have to know everything?

318
00:20:57.600 --> 00:20:58.000
<v Speaker 5>Okay?

319
00:20:58.000 --> 00:21:00.400
<v Rick Farley>And that is one of the essential things

320
00:21:00.400 --> 00:21:02.480
<v Rick Farley>that I think we've all got to understand.

321
00:21:03.700 --> 00:21:06.260
<v Rick Farley>One of the biggest cultural hurdles, I think,

322
00:21:06.260 --> 00:21:08.200
<v Rick Farley>that non-Indigenous people have got to jump over

323
00:21:09.100 --> 00:21:13.880
<v Rick Farley>in this whole debate is to accept and to respect something

324
00:21:14.480 --> 00:21:15.920
<v Rick Farley>which we're never going to understand.

325
00:21:18.280 --> 00:21:18.760
<v Rick Farley>APPLAUSE

326
00:21:28.000 --> 00:21:29.240
<v Rick Farley>The second point to ponder.

327
00:21:29.860 --> 00:21:32.880
<v Rick Farley>Public administration in this country is highly centralised.

328
00:21:33.060 --> 00:21:35.420
<v Rick Farley>The way that deals get done and business gets done

329
00:21:35.420 --> 00:21:37.400
<v Rick Farley>is the government sits down with peak councils,

330
00:21:37.480 --> 00:21:40.360
<v Rick Farley>cuts the deal, both sides implement their side of the equation.

331
00:21:41.840 --> 00:21:44.900
<v Rick Farley>And I'd argue that ATSIC is a white-fella attempt

332
00:21:44.900 --> 00:21:49.120
<v Rick Farley>to impose that kind of peak council structure on Aboriginal people.

333
00:21:49.300 --> 00:21:50.440
<v Rick Farley>There's only one problem with that.

334
00:21:50.540 --> 00:21:53.200
<v Rick Farley>Under Aboriginal law, no-one can talk for anyone else's country.

335
00:21:54.020 --> 00:21:57.980
<v Rick Farley>So the prospect of a peak council to represent all Aboriginal people,

336
00:21:57.980 --> 00:22:00.240
<v Rick Farley>is a white-fella concept.

337
00:22:02.040 --> 00:22:05.460
<v Rick Farley>So one of the tensions that exists in this country, in my view,

338
00:22:05.560 --> 00:22:08.420
<v Rick Farley>is the tension between a highly centralised system

339
00:22:08.420 --> 00:22:09.340
<v Rick Farley>of public administration

340
00:22:10.920 --> 00:22:15.440
<v Rick Farley>and the need to deal, certainly with Indigenous issues,

341
00:22:15.580 --> 00:22:17.660
<v Rick Farley>and I'd also argue probably with environment issues

342
00:22:17.660 --> 00:22:18.860
<v Rick Farley>and a range of other issues,

343
00:22:19.100 --> 00:22:22.340
<v Rick Farley>the need to deal with them on a regional or local basis.

344
00:22:23.300 --> 00:22:25.000
<v Rick Farley>And I think that's one of the big challenges

345
00:22:25.000 --> 00:22:26.580
<v Rick Farley>that we've got to deal with.

346
00:22:27.860 --> 00:22:29.500
<v Rick Farley>So coming back to the agenda,

347
00:22:29.680 --> 00:22:31.680
<v Rick Farley>after those sort of wider observations,

348
00:22:32.080 --> 00:22:33.380
<v Rick Farley>what are some other parts of it?

349
00:22:35.760 --> 00:22:38.500
<v Rick Farley>Firstly, I think we've got to regionalise administration

350
00:22:38.500 --> 00:22:39.860
<v Rick Farley>and decision-making.

351
00:22:40.100 --> 00:22:41.020
<v Rick Farley>That's part of it.

352
00:22:42.460 --> 00:22:44.100
<v Rick Farley>Secondly, and at the same time,

353
00:22:44.180 --> 00:22:47.020
<v Rick Farley>we've got to build up skills and capacities within the regions

354
00:22:47.020 --> 00:22:48.680
<v Rick Farley>to be able to deal with that agenda.

355
00:22:51.480 --> 00:22:54.920
<v Rick Farley>Recently established has been an Australian institute...

356
00:22:56.080 --> 00:22:56.560
<v Rick Farley>..a...

357
00:22:56.580 --> 00:22:58.420
<v Rick Farley>..an Australian Indigenous Leadership Centre,

358
00:22:58.560 --> 00:23:01.720
<v Rick Farley>which Mick Dodson is the chair of at the moment.

359
00:23:03.200 --> 00:23:05.580
<v Rick Farley>And that Indigenous Leader Centre

360
00:23:05.580 --> 00:23:10.480
<v Rick Farley>is aiming to build the skills and capacities of Aboriginal people

361
00:23:10.480 --> 00:23:13.780
<v Rick Farley>so they can better respond to the tensions in public administration.

362
00:23:14.580 --> 00:23:18.220
<v Rick Farley>Part of it also, I think, has got to be to build business partnerships,

363
00:23:18.560 --> 00:23:20.160
<v Rick Farley>create Aboriginal businesses,

364
00:23:20.500 --> 00:23:24.040
<v Rick Farley>create employment in regional areas of Australia for Aboriginal people.

365
00:23:26.580 --> 00:23:29.480
<v Rick Farley>Part of it has also got to be that ephemeral thing,

366
00:23:29.520 --> 00:23:30.780
<v Rick Farley>a whole-of-government response.

367
00:23:32.340 --> 00:23:33.680
<v Rick Farley>It's very difficult sometimes.

368
00:23:39.980 --> 00:23:42.420
<v Rick Farley>But in the last analysis, let me put it to you this way.

369
00:23:42.580 --> 00:23:44.960
<v Rick Farley>I think there is a unique opportunity

370
00:23:45.900 --> 00:23:47.460
<v Rick Farley>over the next six months or so,

371
00:23:47.520 --> 00:23:50.120
<v Rick Farley>because at the end of this year, there's going to be a federal election.

372
00:23:51.380 --> 00:23:54.180
<v Rick Farley>And if there's one thing that politicians can do, they can count.

373
00:23:58.620 --> 00:23:59.200
<v Rick Farley>And that's to build a national leadership system.

374
00:23:59.200 --> 00:24:00.260
<v Rick Farley>So I agree with Ron Wilson

375
00:24:00.260 --> 00:24:05.800
<v Rick Farley>that the paralysis that exists is in national leadership.

376
00:24:06.020 --> 00:24:07.600
<v Rick Farley>I don't see it at community level.

377
00:24:07.760 --> 00:24:10.220
<v Rick Farley>I don't see it in all the people who are here tonight.

378
00:24:10.760 --> 00:24:14.660
<v Rick Farley>I don't see it in all of the people who walked over the bridges last year.

379
00:24:15.440 --> 00:24:20.200
<v Rick Farley>I don't see it in the formation of local reconciliation groups

380
00:24:20.200 --> 00:24:21.120
<v Rick Farley>throughout this country.

381
00:24:21.900 --> 00:24:24.500
<v Rick Farley>So I think the real challenge is really with us

382
00:24:24.500 --> 00:24:26.720
<v Rick Farley>over the next six months or so.

383
00:24:26.780 --> 00:24:31.100
<v Rick Farley>It's to firstly accept that politicians rarely lead.

384
00:24:31.280 --> 00:24:31.860
<v Rick Farley>They follow.

385
00:24:32.860 --> 00:24:34.400
<v Rick Farley>They look at the opinion polls.

386
00:24:35.500 --> 00:24:38.100
<v Rick Farley>They get their polling out of marginal seats.

387
00:24:38.360 --> 00:24:40.000
<v Rick Farley>And they see what the issues are,

388
00:24:40.120 --> 00:24:41.500
<v Rick Farley>and then they respond to those issues.

389
00:24:43.240 --> 00:24:45.760
<v Rick Farley>So in that context, the ball's really in our court.

390
00:24:46.620 --> 00:24:48.800
<v Rick Farley>The People's Movement for Reconciliation

391
00:24:48.800 --> 00:24:52.060
<v Rick Farley>has a marvellous opportunity in the coming months

392
00:24:53.300 --> 00:24:54.480
<v Rick Farley>to demand a voice.

393
00:24:54.500 --> 00:24:55.620
<v Rick Farley>And it's to give all of the political parties

394
00:24:55.620 --> 00:24:57.200
<v Rick Farley>some very simple things.

395
00:24:58.000 --> 00:25:01.720
<v Rick Farley>For instance, what is the response of the Labor Party,

396
00:25:01.920 --> 00:25:04.580
<v Rick Farley>the Liberal Party, the National Party, the Democrats,

397
00:25:05.400 --> 00:25:07.880
<v Rick Farley>to the recommendations in the final report

398
00:25:07.880 --> 00:25:10.020
<v Rick Farley>of the Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation?

399
00:25:11.180 --> 00:25:15.360
<v Rick Farley>What is the response of each of the political parties

400
00:25:15.360 --> 00:25:19.100
<v Rick Farley>to the recommendations in Ron's Bringing Them Home report?

401
00:25:21.260 --> 00:25:23.720
<v Rick Farley>Pretty simple questions to put to some politicians.

402
00:25:24.500 --> 00:25:25.480
<v Rick Farley>Over the next little while.

403
00:25:26.040 --> 00:25:28.400
<v Rick Farley>Let me conclude with this very simple thought.

404
00:25:28.540 --> 00:25:31.700
<v Rick Farley>To me, there is no alternative to reconciliation,

405
00:25:31.800 --> 00:25:33.440
<v Rick Farley>because when it comes down to it,

406
00:25:33.500 --> 00:25:35.480
<v Rick Farley>there's only two possibilities in this country.

407
00:25:37.900 --> 00:25:40.140
<v Rick Farley>We develop some greater racial harmony,

408
00:25:40.960 --> 00:25:42.980
<v Rick Farley>or we have a divided nation,

409
00:25:43.780 --> 00:25:46.080
<v Rick Farley>with racial strife and racial tension.

410
00:25:46.860 --> 00:25:50.280
<v Rick Farley>Now, I reject, I absolutely reject the latter outcome.

411
00:25:51.880 --> 00:25:54.480
<v Rick Farley>And that's why I'm committed to the reconciliation process.

412
00:25:54.500 --> 00:25:56.500
<v Rick Farley>That's why so many other Australians

413
00:25:56.500 --> 00:25:58.560
<v Rick Farley>are committed to the reconciliation process.

414
00:26:01.800 --> 00:26:04.420
<v Rick Farley>There is a strange mentality in this country

415
00:26:05.160 --> 00:26:08.140
<v Rick Farley>that regards Aboriginal culture as a threat.

416
00:26:09.040 --> 00:26:10.800
<v Rick Farley>But in fact, it's a gift.

417
00:26:12.360 --> 00:26:14.520
<v Rick Farley>We have the gift in this country

418
00:26:14.520 --> 00:26:18.000
<v Rick Farley>of the oldest surviving culture in the world,

419
00:26:18.180 --> 00:26:20.520
<v Rick Farley>yet we choose to regard it as a threat.

420
00:26:37.140 --> 00:26:38.820
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is Our identity is Our identity is

421
00:26:38.820 --> 00:26:39.480
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

422
00:26:39.480 --> 00:26:39.920
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

423
00:26:39.920 --> 00:26:40.480
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

424
00:26:40.480 --> 00:26:41.240
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

425
00:26:41.240 --> 00:26:41.740
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

426
00:26:41.740 --> 00:26:42.200
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

427
00:26:42.200 --> 00:26:42.360
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

428
00:26:42.360 --> 00:26:42.820
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

429
00:26:42.820 --> 00:26:43.240
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

430
00:26:43.240 --> 00:26:43.760
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

431
00:26:43.760 --> 00:26:43.900
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

432
00:26:43.900 --> 00:26:44.500
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

433
00:26:44.500 --> 00:26:45.100
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

434
00:26:45.100 --> 00:26:45.800
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

435
00:26:45.800 --> 00:26:46.540
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

436
00:26:46.540 --> 00:26:47.500
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

437
00:26:47.500 --> 00:26:52.800
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

438
00:26:52.800 --> 00:26:54.320
<v Rick Farley>Our identity is

439
00:26:54.500 --> 00:27:00.700
<v Rick Farley>have anything to do with it, but there are opportunities now, here, today. And if we

440
00:27:00.700 --> 00:27:06.320
<v Rick Farley>don't seize them, we're leaving the burden to be carried by our kids and our grandkids.

441
00:27:13.960 --> 00:27:20.840
<v Rick Farley>And the final thought is simply this, that it's up to us to decide the kind of country

442
00:27:20.840 --> 00:27:28.460
<v Rick Farley>that we want to live in. It's up to us. It's not up to the politicians. And we have the

443
00:27:28.460 --> 00:27:35.360
<v Rick Farley>capacity to force the politicians to give us the society that we want. We've got a particular

444
00:27:35.360 --> 00:27:41.620
<v Rick Farley>opportunity over the next four to six months, and I hope to goodness we all make the best

445
00:27:41.620 --> 00:27:41.900
<v Rick Farley>of it.

446
00:28:03.780 --> 00:28:08.860
<v Phillip Adams>Rick Farley, late of the National Farmers Federation, and don't forget to book your

447
00:28:08.860 --> 00:28:16.620
<v Phillip Adams>tickets for the pas de deux from Swan Lake with McGuinness and Pearson. Let us now have

448
00:28:17.520 --> 00:28:20.820
<v Phillip Adams>an African view, an African perspective on this.

449
00:28:20.820 --> 00:28:24.820
<v Phillip Adams>The African perspective on the issue. It comes from a black African, a writer, teacher,

450
00:28:25.120 --> 00:28:30.860
<v Phillip Adams>university administrator, a cultural activist, and a freedom fighter who spent almost 30

451
00:28:30.860 --> 00:28:39.280
<v Phillip Adams>years in exile during the Apartheid era. Professor Mumbulelo Mzami is a visiting scholar at the

452
00:28:39.280 --> 00:28:44.780
<v Phillip Adams>Hawke Institute at the University of South Australia. He was also the first post-Apartheid

453
00:28:44.780 --> 00:28:50.800
<v Phillip Adams>Vice-Chancellor at a South African university. He's had an extraordinary career, and he's

454
00:28:50.800 --> 00:28:54.000
<v Phillip Adams>building

455
00:29:20.800 --> 00:29:21.980
<v Speaker 6>It's amazing.

456
00:29:23.960 --> 00:29:33.540
<v Speaker 6>May I add my voice to those of Sir Ronald and my esteemed panelists

457
00:29:33.540 --> 00:29:38.380
<v Speaker 6>in paying my respects to my hosts.

458
00:29:39.760 --> 00:29:47.160
<v Speaker 6>First, the Ghana people for their graciousness in welcoming us to their land,

459
00:29:47.160 --> 00:29:53.740
<v Speaker 6>in welcoming me in particular into their houses and their hearts,

460
00:29:54.820 --> 00:30:04.860
<v Speaker 6>but also to my co-hosts, the Adelaide Festival of Ideas via Rose White

461
00:30:04.860 --> 00:30:11.360
<v Speaker 6>and the Bob Hawke Institute, whose director is Alison McKinnon.

462
00:30:11.440 --> 00:30:16.020
<v Speaker 6>And of course, through them, my pro-vice-chancellor is here present.

463
00:30:17.560 --> 00:30:19.960
<v Speaker 6>Eleanor Ramsey and Michael Rowan.

464
00:30:24.040 --> 00:30:30.600
<v Speaker 6>I cannot even presume to respond to Sir Ronald or to any of the ideas

465
00:30:30.600 --> 00:30:32.840
<v Speaker 6>that have been floated from my fellow panelists,

466
00:30:33.580 --> 00:30:36.200
<v Speaker 6>because I know nothing of the Australian situation.

467
00:30:36.540 --> 00:30:38.040
<v Speaker 6>So let me address my situation.

468
00:30:38.860 --> 00:30:43.940
<v Speaker 6>There may or may not be parallels in what I'm going to say with your particular situation,

469
00:30:44.160 --> 00:30:47.140
<v Speaker 6>but I will not presume to speak to the Australians.

470
00:30:47.160 --> 00:30:47.600
<v Speaker 6>I will not presume to speak to the Australian situation,

471
00:30:48.060 --> 00:30:49.720
<v Speaker 6>not by any stretch of the imagination.

472
00:30:51.540 --> 00:30:58.160
<v Speaker 6>We argue from the perspective of the African National Government, National Congress,

473
00:30:59.060 --> 00:31:06.580
<v Speaker 6>that reconciliation and transformation should be viewed as interdependent parts

474
00:31:06.580 --> 00:31:11.380
<v Speaker 6>of one unique process of building a new society.

475
00:31:11.800 --> 00:31:17.140
<v Speaker 6>So it's really reconciliation and transformation I want to talk about.

476
00:31:17.160 --> 00:31:18.040
<v Speaker 6>I will talk about that in a moment.

477
00:31:18.700 --> 00:31:23.160
<v Speaker 6>South Africans of different political persuasion have generally accepted that reconciliation

478
00:31:23.160 --> 00:31:29.520
<v Speaker 6>and reconstruction or transformation are the twin pillars on which South African society rests.

479
00:31:31.160 --> 00:31:37.100
<v Speaker 6>The trick, however, is to discover what is involved in bringing about reconciliation and transformation.

480
00:31:37.800 --> 00:31:40.020
<v Speaker 6>What does each task entail?

481
00:31:40.140 --> 00:31:44.760
<v Speaker 6>And can we treat them as separate and distinct, as you seem to be doing?

482
00:31:45.180 --> 00:31:47.140
<v Speaker 6>Can a nation pre-declare its own destiny?

483
00:31:47.160 --> 00:31:51.040
<v Speaker 6>Can we preach reconciliation in the morning and reconstruction in the afternoon?

484
00:31:51.420 --> 00:31:57.600
<v Speaker 6>What are the implications of stressing one aspect to the exclusion of the other?

485
00:31:58.220 --> 00:32:01.060
<v Speaker 6>I think we've heard a great deal about reconciliation.

486
00:32:02.600 --> 00:32:08.040
<v Speaker 6>But in the final analysis, reconciliation on the one hand is diplomatic speak.

487
00:32:09.400 --> 00:32:15.200
<v Speaker 6>Reconciliation is, of course, an expression of solidarity, such as you point out, Sir Ronald.

488
00:32:15.200 --> 00:32:24.080
<v Speaker 6>But it has its rituals, which in essence are about emotionally massaging one another.

489
00:32:25.260 --> 00:32:32.860
<v Speaker 6>It means blowing kisses, embracing all and sundry, and generally bringing people together.

490
00:32:34.540 --> 00:32:39.060
<v Speaker 6>It is inviting your prison warders to your presidential inauguration.

491
00:32:40.580 --> 00:32:45.000
<v Speaker 6>It is drinking tea with the wives of former prime ministers.

492
00:32:45.200 --> 00:32:53.920
<v Speaker 6>And it is also wearing the number five Springbok jersey at the world rugby finals,

493
00:32:54.100 --> 00:32:56.840
<v Speaker 6>even though we don't even understand what rugby is about.

494
00:33:00.960 --> 00:33:04.920
<v Speaker 6>So reconciliation is a worthy goal to pursue in itself.

495
00:33:06.340 --> 00:33:09.980
<v Speaker 6>But reconciliation is also a means to an end.

496
00:33:10.680 --> 00:33:13.900
<v Speaker 6>It provides the necessary space for state intervention

497
00:33:13.900 --> 00:33:15.180
<v Speaker 6>in order to bring about reconciliation.

498
00:33:15.200 --> 00:33:17.560
<v Speaker 6>It is a way to bring about a just social order.

499
00:33:17.680 --> 00:33:20.800
<v Speaker 6>That is, to bring about social transformation.

500
00:33:21.300 --> 00:33:23.780
<v Speaker 6>That, surely, should be its raison d'etre.

501
00:33:25.440 --> 00:33:32.680
<v Speaker 6>So meaningful reconciliation, then, has to be accompanied by some measure of justice.

502
00:33:33.800 --> 00:33:39.080
<v Speaker 6>And justice, we have discovered, can be of two kinds, minimum.

503
00:33:39.820 --> 00:33:44.900
<v Speaker 6>Justice can either be retributive, punitive, if you like,

504
00:33:45.200 --> 00:33:48.560
<v Speaker 6>or it can be restorative.

505
00:33:49.580 --> 00:33:52.540
<v Speaker 6>And redistributive justice is, of course, punitive.

506
00:33:53.100 --> 00:33:58.320
<v Speaker 6>And very, very often, ask many of us who have been to prison on this stage.

507
00:33:58.500 --> 00:34:01.240
<v Speaker 6>It leaves a legacy of bitterness.

508
00:34:03.340 --> 00:34:07.620
<v Speaker 6>Restorative justice, on the other hand, is healing and reconciling.

509
00:34:08.580 --> 00:34:14.280
<v Speaker 6>And South Africa chose to emphasize restorative justice as a path to social reconciliation.

510
00:34:15.260 --> 00:34:22.060
<v Speaker 6>But social reconciliation demands some measure of redistributive justice.

511
00:34:22.340 --> 00:34:26.800
<v Speaker 6>Redistributive justice is, in my view, an important element of restorative justice.

512
00:34:27.660 --> 00:34:33.220
<v Speaker 6>That, however, is still sadly lacking, despite the undertaking by the state

513
00:34:33.220 --> 00:34:38.740
<v Speaker 6>to compensate the victims of apartheid brutality, or simply resisted in some quarters.

514
00:34:38.920 --> 00:34:43.640
<v Speaker 6>I had the privilege in March to meet your Senator Aidan Ridgway,

515
00:34:44.360 --> 00:34:45.180
<v Speaker 6>with the

516
00:34:45.200 --> 00:34:48.320
<v Speaker 6>whom we both addressed the plenary session of the United Nations

517
00:34:48.320 --> 00:34:51.400
<v Speaker 6>and Commission for Human Rights in Geneva,

518
00:34:52.200 --> 00:34:55.460
<v Speaker 6>in preparation for the World Conference Against Racism.

519
00:34:56.280 --> 00:35:01.440
<v Speaker 6>And this is what he had to say, speaking to the plight of indigenous people in this regard,

520
00:35:01.720 --> 00:35:07.700
<v Speaker 6>I think in areas of the world that were settled principally by Europeans.

521
00:35:07.960 --> 00:35:09.160
<v Speaker 6>He says, and I quote,

522
00:35:11.200 --> 00:35:14.200
<v Speaker 6>Non-indigenous Australians are keen to embrace

523
00:35:14.200 --> 00:35:15.820
<v Speaker 6>the rhetoric of reconciliation,

524
00:35:17.360 --> 00:35:21.500
<v Speaker 6>so long as it doesn't require them to take effective action

525
00:35:21.500 --> 00:35:24.200
<v Speaker 6>to share the country's abundant resources.

526
00:35:26.480 --> 00:35:28.120
<v Speaker 6>It's him, not me, okay?

527
00:35:28.200 --> 00:35:29.580
<v Speaker 6>I know nothing about your situation.

528
00:35:30.820 --> 00:35:34.940
<v Speaker 6>Most are not prepared to make any significant adjustments

529
00:35:34.940 --> 00:35:38.260
<v Speaker 6>in how they live or how they see their future.

530
00:35:38.920 --> 00:35:41.920
<v Speaker 6>Few are prepared to really look into themselves,

531
00:35:42.180 --> 00:35:44.180
<v Speaker 6>to challenge their beliefs and beliefs,

532
00:35:44.180 --> 00:35:44.480
<v Speaker 6>to challenge their values,

533
00:35:44.620 --> 00:35:46.560
<v Speaker 6>for fear of what they might find

534
00:35:46.560 --> 00:35:48.940
<v Speaker 6>and what they think they might lose.

535
00:35:57.180 --> 00:36:00.020
<v Speaker 6>But naturally, this rings a bell for me.

536
00:36:00.100 --> 00:36:03.500
<v Speaker 6>It echoes something that I identify with.

537
00:36:03.720 --> 00:36:07.100
<v Speaker 6>Because as with indigenous people in Australia,

538
00:36:08.180 --> 00:36:09.840
<v Speaker 6>and in North and South America,

539
00:36:10.040 --> 00:36:11.540
<v Speaker 6>and everywhere else in the world,

540
00:36:11.680 --> 00:36:14.160
<v Speaker 6>many indigenous Africans feel that they are not alone.

541
00:36:14.160 --> 00:36:15.460
<v Speaker 6>They feel cheated by reconciliation

542
00:36:16.160 --> 00:36:19.120
<v Speaker 6>that brings about little or no transformation.

543
00:36:20.800 --> 00:36:23.740
<v Speaker 6>Africans in South Africa feel increasingly betrayed

544
00:36:23.740 --> 00:36:27.800
<v Speaker 6>by the perceived lack of commitment and insensitivity

545
00:36:27.800 --> 00:36:31.640
<v Speaker 6>of a white community they see as having reneged

546
00:36:31.640 --> 00:36:37.020
<v Speaker 6>on the social contract implicit in the historic compromise we made in 1994.

547
00:36:38.000 --> 00:36:40.180
<v Speaker 6>White South Africans, on the other hand,

548
00:36:40.180 --> 00:36:43.480
<v Speaker 6>feel increasingly gloomy and demotivated

549
00:36:43.480 --> 00:36:46.920
<v Speaker 6>by their perception of increasing marginalization

550
00:36:47.480 --> 00:36:50.540
<v Speaker 6>and of growing accusation of racism against them.

551
00:36:51.620 --> 00:36:53.840
<v Speaker 6>In fact, if you visit South Africa,

552
00:36:53.900 --> 00:36:56.260
<v Speaker 6>those of you who have will have been struck

553
00:36:56.260 --> 00:36:59.920
<v Speaker 6>by something very remarkable in my country.

554
00:37:00.800 --> 00:37:03.380
<v Speaker 6>No one ever supported apartheid.

555
00:37:05.480 --> 00:37:10.060
<v Speaker 6>There is actually, in this form of denial and so on,

556
00:37:10.980 --> 00:37:13.460
<v Speaker 6>a form that reintroduces

557
00:37:13.480 --> 00:37:14.860
<v Speaker 6>and entrenched attitudes of the past.

558
00:37:14.980 --> 00:37:17.640
<v Speaker 6>The racial polarization has the potential

559
00:37:17.640 --> 00:37:20.300
<v Speaker 6>to deteriorate very, very rapidly

560
00:37:20.300 --> 00:37:23.360
<v Speaker 6>if transformation doesn't become the other.

561
00:37:23.400 --> 00:37:26.040
<v Speaker 6>Let me very quickly mention,

562
00:37:27.080 --> 00:37:31.280
<v Speaker 6>in elucidation to some of the things that we heard

563
00:37:31.280 --> 00:37:34.200
<v Speaker 6>relating to the agenda of reconciliation.

564
00:37:34.660 --> 00:37:38.560
<v Speaker 6>I think my colleague Rick tries to point out to this.

565
00:37:39.360 --> 00:37:42.800
<v Speaker 6>In my view, transformation, on the other hand,

566
00:37:44.340 --> 00:37:47.780
<v Speaker 6>as against or in tandem with reconciliation,

567
00:37:48.100 --> 00:37:49.500
<v Speaker 6>is plain speaking.

568
00:37:50.140 --> 00:37:54.180
<v Speaker 6>And very, very often, it is treading on people's corns.

569
00:37:54.360 --> 00:37:56.880
<v Speaker 6>And quite frankly, it is kicking bombs.

570
00:38:00.940 --> 00:38:03.400
<v Speaker 6>Transformation requires, I think,

571
00:38:05.980 --> 00:38:09.320
<v Speaker 6>a multifaceted approach, as has been pointed out.

572
00:38:10.260 --> 00:38:12.140
<v Speaker 6>Transformation basically is,

573
00:38:13.960 --> 00:38:15.940
<v Speaker 6>reconstruction, social reconstruction,

574
00:38:16.080 --> 00:38:18.300
<v Speaker 6>from the ravages of colonialism,

575
00:38:18.380 --> 00:38:20.120
<v Speaker 6>segregation, and apartheid.

576
00:38:20.540 --> 00:38:22.280
<v Speaker 6>But viewed holistically,

577
00:38:22.540 --> 00:38:26.120
<v Speaker 6>it is a gradual process by which change can be brought about

578
00:38:26.120 --> 00:38:29.800
<v Speaker 6>from the prevailing exclusive political, economic,

579
00:38:29.880 --> 00:38:31.360
<v Speaker 6>and social order

580
00:38:31.360 --> 00:38:34.620
<v Speaker 6>to a new inclusive social order.

581
00:38:34.760 --> 00:38:37.460
<v Speaker 6>It is, if you like, a systematic process

582
00:38:37.460 --> 00:38:39.440
<v Speaker 6>and not a single event.

583
00:38:39.820 --> 00:38:43.460
<v Speaker 6>And it consists of a program of action,

584
00:38:43.460 --> 00:38:47.680
<v Speaker 6>that will be capable of generating quantifiable results

585
00:38:47.680 --> 00:38:50.560
<v Speaker 6>and qualitative changes in people's lives.

586
00:38:50.700 --> 00:38:51.720
<v Speaker 6>In the main, therefore,

587
00:38:51.880 --> 00:38:55.420
<v Speaker 6>the beneficiaries of such an exercise will be the victims

588
00:38:55.420 --> 00:38:57.700
<v Speaker 6>and not the perpetrators of oppression,

589
00:38:58.040 --> 00:38:59.720
<v Speaker 6>of exploitation, and domination,

590
00:39:00.020 --> 00:39:02.380
<v Speaker 6>who have moral claims on society

591
00:39:02.380 --> 00:39:05.300
<v Speaker 6>for moral, for material compensation

592
00:39:05.300 --> 00:39:07.420
<v Speaker 6>in one form or the other.

593
00:39:08.420 --> 00:39:11.120
<v Speaker 6>Now, three things happen here.

594
00:39:11.240 --> 00:39:13.300
<v Speaker 6>First, on the political arena.

595
00:39:13.300 --> 00:39:15.900
<v Speaker 6>Because I think in the political arena,

596
00:39:16.100 --> 00:39:18.100
<v Speaker 6>transformation involves creating

597
00:39:18.100 --> 00:39:20.620
<v Speaker 6>a qualitatively new nation

598
00:39:20.620 --> 00:39:23.540
<v Speaker 6>that subscribes to the tenets of democracy,

599
00:39:23.980 --> 00:39:26.160
<v Speaker 6>non-sexism, non-racism,

600
00:39:26.260 --> 00:39:29.260
<v Speaker 6>and non-discrimination in every other sphere.

601
00:39:33.680 --> 00:39:35.440
<v Speaker 6>Yet, yet,

602
00:39:37.020 --> 00:39:41.700
<v Speaker 6>significant as the political changes that have occurred are

603
00:39:41.700 --> 00:39:42.880
<v Speaker 6>in their own right,

604
00:39:43.300 --> 00:39:46.140
<v Speaker 6>it is more useful, I think,

605
00:39:46.140 --> 00:39:47.180
<v Speaker 6>and less misleading,

606
00:39:47.320 --> 00:39:49.840
<v Speaker 6>to view political transformation,

607
00:39:50.160 --> 00:39:50.960
<v Speaker 6>like reconciliation,

608
00:39:52.300 --> 00:39:53.360
<v Speaker 6>as a means to an end.

609
00:39:53.920 --> 00:39:57.640
<v Speaker 6>Or else, one easily comes to mistake

610
00:39:57.640 --> 00:40:00.320
<v Speaker 6>the trappings of power for its substance.

611
00:40:01.680 --> 00:40:03.480
<v Speaker 6>Changes in the political lot

612
00:40:03.480 --> 00:40:05.140
<v Speaker 6>of the previously disenfranchised

613
00:40:05.140 --> 00:40:06.580
<v Speaker 6>are thus necessary,

614
00:40:06.620 --> 00:40:09.340
<v Speaker 6>but not sufficient conditions for transformation,

615
00:40:10.300 --> 00:40:11.100
<v Speaker 6>holistically conceived.

616
00:40:11.360 --> 00:40:13.160
<v Speaker 6>So you can have more and more,

617
00:40:13.300 --> 00:40:14.900
<v Speaker 6>more aborigines in your senate,

618
00:40:15.120 --> 00:40:15.620
<v Speaker 6>and so on.

619
00:40:16.060 --> 00:40:18.400
<v Speaker 6>It could actually be window dressing,

620
00:40:18.640 --> 00:40:20.240
<v Speaker 6>not necessarily transformation.

621
00:40:21.160 --> 00:40:22.480
<v Speaker 6>That's what I'm talking about.

622
00:40:22.940 --> 00:40:25.020
<v Speaker 6>The powers of transformation lie

623
00:40:25.020 --> 00:40:26.420
<v Speaker 6>in the economic sphere.

624
00:40:28.140 --> 00:40:30.440
<v Speaker 6>Economically, transformation is redress

625
00:40:30.440 --> 00:40:32.760
<v Speaker 6>and progress that occur usually

626
00:40:32.760 --> 00:40:35.420
<v Speaker 6>in two largely overlapping phases.

627
00:40:35.700 --> 00:40:36.720
<v Speaker 6>In its initial phase,

628
00:40:36.900 --> 00:40:39.020
<v Speaker 6>and to kickstart the process,

629
00:40:39.180 --> 00:40:40.620
<v Speaker 6>you can't run away from this,

630
00:40:40.840 --> 00:40:42.640
<v Speaker 6>economic transformation,

631
00:40:42.640 --> 00:40:45.640
<v Speaker 6>requires some measure of redress

632
00:40:45.640 --> 00:40:48.060
<v Speaker 6>to level the playing fields

633
00:40:48.640 --> 00:40:52.060
<v Speaker 6>in accordance with some demographically balancing act,

634
00:40:52.200 --> 00:40:55.460
<v Speaker 6>and to bring about institutional representivity

635
00:40:55.460 --> 00:40:57.800
<v Speaker 6>and fairer competition between people,

636
00:40:57.960 --> 00:40:59.980
<v Speaker 6>regardless of their privileged

637
00:40:59.980 --> 00:41:02.320
<v Speaker 6>or underprivileged status at birth.

638
00:41:03.680 --> 00:41:06.180
<v Speaker 6>This early phase is also essential, of course,

639
00:41:06.200 --> 00:41:08.140
<v Speaker 6>to bring about comparable standards of living

640
00:41:08.140 --> 00:41:09.960
<v Speaker 6>for people from disadvantaged

641
00:41:09.960 --> 00:41:11.720
<v Speaker 6>and advantaged backgrounds alike.

642
00:41:12.780 --> 00:41:16.800
<v Speaker 6>Redress and progress can only be accomplished,

643
00:41:16.880 --> 00:41:20.680
<v Speaker 6>however, through applying some remedial formula,

644
00:41:20.940 --> 00:41:23.000
<v Speaker 6>such as affirmative action.

645
00:41:23.320 --> 00:41:25.280
<v Speaker 6>The privileging, that is,

646
00:41:25.400 --> 00:41:28.080
<v Speaker 6>of groups previously underrepresented

647
00:41:28.080 --> 00:41:31.740
<v Speaker 6>and discriminated against by reason of their race,

648
00:41:31.740 --> 00:41:35.220
<v Speaker 6>class, color, sex, gender, religion, you name it.

649
00:41:37.220 --> 00:41:39.400
<v Speaker 6>Sequentially, but sometimes simultaneously,

650
00:41:39.880 --> 00:41:41.700
<v Speaker 6>with addressing the legacy of the aborigines,

651
00:41:41.700 --> 00:41:42.080
<v Speaker 6>the past,

652
00:41:42.240 --> 00:41:46.260
<v Speaker 6>transformation also proceeds from providing equal opportunity.

653
00:41:47.700 --> 00:41:49.280
<v Speaker 6>Equal opportunity to every citizen,

654
00:41:49.360 --> 00:41:51.460
<v Speaker 6>regardless of social status or origin.

655
00:41:52.740 --> 00:41:55.340
<v Speaker 6>But whether in its affirmative action

656
00:41:55.340 --> 00:41:57.380
<v Speaker 6>or equal opportunity phase,

657
00:41:57.660 --> 00:42:00.140
<v Speaker 6>economic transformation, of course,

658
00:42:00.240 --> 00:42:03.500
<v Speaker 6>can only occur when economic growth is commensurate

659
00:42:03.500 --> 00:42:06.260
<v Speaker 6>with economic opportunity that must be provided.

660
00:42:07.700 --> 00:42:10.760
<v Speaker 6>There are other indicators of,

661
00:42:10.760 --> 00:42:13.680
<v Speaker 6>and other dimensions to transformation I could go on.

662
00:42:14.000 --> 00:42:15.360
<v Speaker 6>But I want to end with one,

663
00:42:15.440 --> 00:42:16.460
<v Speaker 6>which is also significant,

664
00:42:17.660 --> 00:42:20.120
<v Speaker 6>insofar as I have been conversing

665
00:42:20.120 --> 00:42:22.980
<v Speaker 6>with my other co-hosts of the Aboriginal Research Institute

666
00:42:22.980 --> 00:42:27.660
<v Speaker 6>and many of the Ghana elders as well.

667
00:42:28.380 --> 00:42:31.920
<v Speaker 6>Because I think transformation also has a cultural dimension,

668
00:42:32.320 --> 00:42:33.560
<v Speaker 6>cultural transformation.

669
00:42:34.420 --> 00:42:36.300
<v Speaker 6>And in the sphere of culture,

670
00:42:36.520 --> 00:42:40.000
<v Speaker 6>taken broadly to encompass national norms,

671
00:42:40.120 --> 00:42:40.440
<v Speaker 6>values,

672
00:42:40.760 --> 00:42:41.200
<v Speaker 6>and standards,

673
00:42:41.400 --> 00:42:43.480
<v Speaker 6>as well as diverse lifestyles,

674
00:42:43.480 --> 00:42:43.860
<v Speaker 6>traditions,

675
00:42:44.020 --> 00:42:44.420
<v Speaker 6>customs,

676
00:42:44.540 --> 00:42:44.920
<v Speaker 6>et cetera.

677
00:42:45.540 --> 00:42:51.920
<v Speaker 6>Transformation takes the form of cultivating a new human rights culture.

678
00:42:52.540 --> 00:42:55.020
<v Speaker 6>And that is a new human rights culture

679
00:42:55.020 --> 00:42:57.820
<v Speaker 6>that is going to take its inspiration

680
00:42:57.820 --> 00:43:01.620
<v Speaker 6>from the unfolding culture of liberation.

681
00:43:02.520 --> 00:43:06.340
<v Speaker 6>It assumes elements of reclamation and celebration

682
00:43:06.340 --> 00:43:10.080
<v Speaker 6>that reintegrate alienated South Africans

683
00:43:10.080 --> 00:43:10.780
<v Speaker 6>and the Black Americans in our country,

684
00:43:10.860 --> 00:43:11.360
<v Speaker 6>for example,

685
00:43:11.360 --> 00:43:14.660
<v Speaker 6>to their culture and to their human stories.

686
00:43:15.060 --> 00:43:17.160
<v Speaker 6>It provides education.

687
00:43:17.240 --> 00:43:18.440
<v Speaker 6>You talk to education,

688
00:43:19.300 --> 00:43:22.480
<v Speaker 6>but it provides education for transformation,

689
00:43:22.920 --> 00:43:24.700
<v Speaker 6>education for liberation.

690
00:43:25.060 --> 00:43:28.600
<v Speaker 6>And it is education that decolonizes the mind.

691
00:43:28.880 --> 00:43:32.020
<v Speaker 6>It will decolonize the mind of both the colonizer

692
00:43:32.020 --> 00:43:33.640
<v Speaker 6>and the colonized.

693
00:43:40.080 --> 00:43:46.200
<v Speaker 6>In other words, it will counter mental enslavement

694
00:43:46.200 --> 00:43:51.800
<v Speaker 6>at the same time as it counters cultural imperialism and ethnocentrism.

695
00:43:52.540 --> 00:43:59.420
<v Speaker 6>It is also always about redefining the new parameters of nationhood.

696
00:44:00.380 --> 00:44:05.320
<v Speaker 6>For every South African, for example, in ways that create a wider sense of belonging,

697
00:44:05.320 --> 00:44:11.100
<v Speaker 6>while at the same time validating each person's identity, dignity, and humanity.

698
00:44:12.160 --> 00:44:17.140
<v Speaker 6>So the new patriotic culture thus cultivated, and I saw the beginnings of it.

699
00:44:17.200 --> 00:44:21.800
<v Speaker 6>Many of us were riveted to our TV sets,

700
00:44:21.960 --> 00:44:25.660
<v Speaker 6>watching the opening and the closing ceremonies of your Olympics.

701
00:44:25.880 --> 00:44:27.620
<v Speaker 6>We saw the beginnings of it.

702
00:44:27.660 --> 00:44:32.540
<v Speaker 6>That was the one factor which caught the international media last year.

703
00:44:32.880 --> 00:44:34.520
<v Speaker 6>Guess what the second one was?

704
00:44:35.320 --> 00:44:37.540
<v Speaker 6>Your Prime Minister refusing to apologise.

705
00:44:38.120 --> 00:44:41.820
<v Speaker 6>The other one, of course that's a constant, is the Pauline Hanson factor.

706
00:44:42.920 --> 00:44:50.940
<v Speaker 6>Transformation then is a holistic process that encompasses not only political gains but also material progress

707
00:44:50.940 --> 00:44:54.040
<v Speaker 6>and other improvements in people's lives.

708
00:44:54.240 --> 00:44:58.860
<v Speaker 6>I'm trying to suggest that reconciliation can be seen in some respects

709
00:44:59.600 --> 00:45:03.040
<v Speaker 6>as a honeymoon period we must all go through.

710
00:45:03.040 --> 00:45:08.160
<v Speaker 6>But honeymoons, unlike diamonds, are not forever.

711
00:45:36.120 --> 00:45:37.520
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, Balelo.

712
00:45:37.720 --> 00:45:40.920
<v Phillip Adams>Now to the fourth and final member of our panel.

713
00:45:41.720 --> 00:45:45.820
<v Phillip Adams>Jacob Rumbiak is as well-known and respected in Jakarta

714
00:45:45.820 --> 00:45:47.900
<v Phillip Adams>as he is in West Papua.

715
00:45:48.020 --> 00:45:52.380
<v Phillip Adams>Why? Because he was a very successful soccer player

716
00:45:52.380 --> 00:45:57.680
<v Phillip Adams>and, in fact, helped win the Asian Championship Cup

717
00:45:57.680 --> 00:46:00.000
<v Phillip Adams>for Indonesia in 1984.

718
00:46:00.060 --> 00:46:03.020
<v Phillip Adams>But his popularity on the soccer field

719
00:46:03.020 --> 00:46:05.100
<v Phillip Adams>did not prevent him from being arrested

720
00:46:05.100 --> 00:46:08.220
<v Phillip Adams>on subversion charges by the Indonesians

721
00:46:08.220 --> 00:46:13.420
<v Phillip Adams>and spending ten years in various Indonesian prisons.

722
00:46:14.360 --> 00:46:17.640
<v Phillip Adams>In one, five years on death row,

723
00:46:17.780 --> 00:46:20.180
<v Phillip Adams>where he completed a theology degree.

724
00:46:21.040 --> 00:46:24.400
<v Phillip Adams>In another, two, in a stone-walled cell

725
00:46:24.400 --> 00:46:26.720
<v Phillip Adams>at the top of a 30-foot tower.

726
00:46:27.700 --> 00:46:32.080
<v Phillip Adams>And then he spent ten months in prison with Zanana Guzman.

727
00:46:32.300 --> 00:46:33.000
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you.

728
00:46:33.020 --> 00:46:36.620
<v Phillip Adams>His torture, his deprivation and internment

729
00:46:36.620 --> 00:46:38.800
<v Phillip Adams>mirrors the past and present circumstances

730
00:46:38.800 --> 00:46:41.120
<v Phillip Adams>of thousands of other West Papuans.

731
00:46:41.240 --> 00:46:44.540
<v Phillip Adams>And it has to be said that, to a large extent,

732
00:46:45.280 --> 00:46:48.140
<v Phillip Adams>events in East Timor have eclipsed,

733
00:46:48.140 --> 00:46:49.740
<v Phillip Adams>for us and the rest of the world,

734
00:46:51.040 --> 00:46:53.900
<v Phillip Adams>the horrible goings-on in West Papua.

735
00:46:54.020 --> 00:46:55.420
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you.

736
00:47:00.880 --> 00:47:02.720
<v Phillip Adams>In which Australia,

737
00:47:03.020 --> 00:47:04.480
<v Phillip Adams>is equally complicit?

738
00:47:04.620 --> 00:47:06.620
<v Phillip Adams>Ladies and gentlemen, Jacob Rumbiak.

739
00:47:17.260 --> 00:47:21.020
<v Speaker 7>Thank you very much for giving me

740
00:47:21.020 --> 00:47:25.680
<v Speaker 7>a beautiful opportunity to talk to you.

741
00:47:26.880 --> 00:47:29.900
<v Speaker 7>But particularly, thank you very much

742
00:47:29.900 --> 00:47:32.020
<v Speaker 7>for Indigenous Aboriginals.

743
00:47:37.820 --> 00:47:48.760
<v Speaker 7>Our

744
00:47:53.920 --> 00:47:57.200
<v Speaker 7>So I think I feel strong for talking tonight.

745
00:48:01.340 --> 00:48:12.840
<v Speaker 7>I think when I hear my friend, my brother and sister from Aboriginal, but also from Africa,

746
00:48:12.840 --> 00:48:24.820
<v Speaker 7>they talk more and they give beautiful idea about how to solve this problem in here.

747
00:48:25.180 --> 00:48:36.200
<v Speaker 7>And I believe all of us, we agree for concern about how we solve this problem together

748
00:48:37.140 --> 00:48:38.020
<v Speaker 7>because

749
00:48:42.340 --> 00:48:42.760
<v Speaker 7>we have

750
00:48:42.840 --> 00:48:57.840
<v Speaker 7>I mean we have responsible for look after our world because I believe all of us become part of the world.

751
00:48:58.160 --> 00:49:12.820
<v Speaker 7>So we agree for look after each other and we want to recognize who we recognize each other.

752
00:49:12.820 --> 00:49:13.020
<v Speaker 7>So we agree for look after each other.

753
00:49:13.220 --> 00:49:16.100
<v Speaker 7>So we agree for look after each other.

754
00:49:16.100 --> 00:49:20.580
<v Speaker 7>In West Papua, we have the same problem as the Australia Aboriginals.

755
00:49:22.340 --> 00:49:33.920
<v Speaker 7>Foreigners have taken our land, but I see in Australia there is big awareness of the problem now.

756
00:49:35.360 --> 00:49:40.940
<v Speaker 7>White people and Aboriginals are working hard

757
00:49:40.940 --> 00:49:44.000
<v Speaker 7>for a solution.

758
00:49:46.300 --> 00:49:57.160
<v Speaker 7>When I live in here and I try for, you know, I try for learn more about what happened in here.

759
00:49:57.880 --> 00:50:04.560
<v Speaker 7>And I look like awareness.

760
00:50:06.460 --> 00:50:07.200
<v Speaker 7>Also,

761
00:50:11.000 --> 00:50:17.780
<v Speaker 7>white Australia, white man and Aboriginals, they talking about what happened in here.

762
00:50:18.500 --> 00:50:21.920
<v Speaker 7>But I look difficult in solution.

763
00:50:24.800 --> 00:50:35.020
<v Speaker 7>I don't know, maybe I false, but when I've been in here for 20 months and I try for look what happened.

764
00:50:35.140 --> 00:50:38.520
<v Speaker 7>But I think difficult in solution.

765
00:50:41.500 --> 00:50:57.600
<v Speaker 7>So my opinion or my idea is after awareness and we must make strong, I mean we must grow something true in, you know, grassroots.

766
00:50:59.680 --> 00:51:03.740
<v Speaker 7>And our awareness in up to.

767
00:51:06.060 --> 00:51:07.740
<v Speaker 7>Because when,

768
00:51:09.580 --> 00:51:11.200
<v Speaker 7>we awareness only.

769
00:51:12.980 --> 00:51:24.240
<v Speaker 7>But we have a big support for, you know, always talking to government and we talk about how government must change policy.

770
00:51:24.900 --> 00:51:26.720
<v Speaker 7>I think difficult.

771
00:51:27.000 --> 00:51:38.500
<v Speaker 7>But when we have a big support from grassroots and after it, awareness up and all of them have, you know, understanding.

772
00:51:38.520 --> 00:51:45.920
<v Speaker 7>And I think maybe easy for the make decision.

773
00:51:46.240 --> 00:51:47.780
<v Speaker 7>I mean solution.

774
00:51:48.140 --> 00:51:50.380
<v Speaker 7>Because I look difficult in solution.

775
00:52:00.880 --> 00:52:05.940
<v Speaker 7>But seriously, reconciliation will be difficult.

776
00:52:05.940 --> 00:52:12.640
<v Speaker 7>If white people don't develop big understanding of Aboriginal land all the time.

777
00:52:12.780 --> 00:52:15.940
<v Speaker 7>The Aboriginals are looking at their land.

778
00:52:17.400 --> 00:52:22.280
<v Speaker 7>Melanesian West Papua like me and Aboriginals have similar understanding.

779
00:52:23.520 --> 00:52:26.560
<v Speaker 7>It is called customary ownership.

780
00:52:27.380 --> 00:52:28.580
<v Speaker 7>It is law.

781
00:52:29.380 --> 00:52:35.920
<v Speaker 7>It means a group, not an individual, on, on, on land.

782
00:52:35.920 --> 00:52:40.320
<v Speaker 7>We don't have private ownership.

783
00:52:41.080 --> 00:52:44.680
<v Speaker 7>Non-Melanesian don't like customary ownership.

784
00:52:45.140 --> 00:52:54.280
<v Speaker 7>Because it makes it more difficult to buy the land and develop it for farming, tourism and mining.

785
00:52:55.380 --> 00:53:05.900
<v Speaker 7>Some countries in Pacific like Fiji and PNG are the last countries in the world to have customary law of land.

786
00:53:05.900 --> 00:53:06.400
<v Speaker 7>They are the last countries to have customary ownership of their land.

787
00:53:07.000 --> 00:53:18.220
<v Speaker 7>But I have heard that the Australian government is surveying their land in PNG with airplanes, mapping the land.

788
00:53:18.980 --> 00:53:24.320
<v Speaker 7>This is a tool for changing customary ownership of land.

789
00:53:25.140 --> 00:53:28.980
<v Speaker 7>The Australian government call this foreign aid.

790
00:53:31.060 --> 00:53:35.880
<v Speaker 7>But by surveying the land, it is helping the progress of the land.

791
00:53:35.900 --> 00:53:40.640
<v Speaker 7>It is a process of over, over turning customary land law.

792
00:53:41.520 --> 00:53:45.760
<v Speaker 7>In West Papua, we have a big problem about land too.

793
00:53:46.540 --> 00:53:51.660
<v Speaker 7>Because the Indonesian government says it is owns all our land.

794
00:53:51.980 --> 00:53:54.340
<v Speaker 7>This is Indonesian law about land.

795
00:53:56.040 --> 00:54:02.720
<v Speaker 7>So, when I try for, you know, make, compare, study, I look similar.

796
00:54:04.360 --> 00:54:14.140
<v Speaker 7>So, for, I mean, this is my idea, like talking, difficult in solution.

797
00:54:15.240 --> 00:54:26.140
<v Speaker 7>But I believe tonight, all of us in here, by Edelight Festival of Idea,

798
00:54:26.340 --> 00:54:32.700
<v Speaker 7>we want to concern about the land.

799
00:54:32.700 --> 00:54:34.980
<v Speaker 7>We want to talk about what we're talking tonight.

800
00:54:36.760 --> 00:54:42.480
<v Speaker 7>Because when we want to reconciliation, and we want to something success tomorrow,

801
00:54:42.820 --> 00:54:45.060
<v Speaker 7>tonight, we must make decision.

802
00:54:46.720 --> 00:55:00.140
<v Speaker 7>And I believe all of us concern, and all of us have big responsible for work together,

803
00:55:00.240 --> 00:55:02.320
<v Speaker 7>for solve this problem.

804
00:55:02.700 --> 00:55:03.540
<v Speaker 7>And I believe we can solve this problem by peaceful resolution.

805
00:55:03.860 --> 00:55:04.820
<v Speaker 7>Thank you very much.

806
00:55:15.780 --> 00:55:28.240
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, Jacob.

807
00:55:28.580 --> 00:55:29.420
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, Jackie.

808
00:55:30.040 --> 00:55:31.140
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, Balela.

809
00:55:31.140 --> 00:55:32.260
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, Rick.

810
00:55:32.380 --> 00:55:34.960
<v Phillip Adams>And most of all, thank you, Sir Ronald Wilson.

811
00:55:35.700 --> 00:55:38.440
<v Phillip Adams>We shall now break for 15 or so minutes.

812
00:55:38.940 --> 00:55:41.480
<v Phillip Adams>Return promptly, if you please.

813
00:55:41.580 --> 00:55:45.360
<v Phillip Adams>And we will have about 20 minutes of questions from the floor.

814
00:55:45.560 --> 00:55:46.360
<v Phillip Adams>Thanks very much.

815
00:55:53.160 --> 00:55:58.020
<v Phillip Adams>Welcome back to the Adelaide Town Hall, to the Festival of Ideas.

816
00:55:58.260 --> 00:56:01.120
<v Phillip Adams>Our discussion continues on the issue of land.

817
00:56:01.140 --> 00:56:01.700
<v Phillip Adams>We have a moment of reconciliation.

818
00:56:02.360 --> 00:56:05.160
<v Phillip Adams>And now we open up to the audience.

819
00:56:05.640 --> 00:56:11.040
<v Phillip Adams>We have an upper house upstairs there with one microphone, and the House of Reps down here.

820
00:56:11.300 --> 00:56:15.660
<v Phillip Adams>And I ask you to hurl yourself at those microphones as rapidly as possible.

821
00:56:15.920 --> 00:56:17.440
<v Phillip Adams>Now, I know it's a daunting prospect.

822
00:56:17.740 --> 00:56:19.540
<v Phillip Adams>It's a big hall, and it's getting late.

823
00:56:19.660 --> 00:56:28.080
<v Phillip Adams>But please, this is the one chance you'll have to talk to this extraordinary group of highly talented human beings.

824
00:56:28.300 --> 00:56:30.200
<v Phillip Adams>Sir, it's no good waving at me.

825
00:56:30.200 --> 00:56:31.280
<v Phillip Adams>You've got to go to the microphone.

826
00:56:33.740 --> 00:56:35.260
<v Phillip Adams>Address it sternly.

827
00:56:36.540 --> 00:56:40.120
<v Phillip Adams>And if you could start sort of forming long queues around the block.

828
00:56:41.180 --> 00:56:46.300
<v Audience>I have a question I'd like to direct to Rick Farley, principally because I think he's a doer.

829
00:56:46.500 --> 00:56:53.400
<v Audience>And he's put forward some ideas tonight that I think everyone here, that we're here for a reason, we'd like to do something.

830
00:56:53.700 --> 00:57:00.180
<v Audience>And 400,000 other people have walked across bridges in a display of frustration, I suppose.

831
00:57:00.180 --> 00:57:11.180
<v Audience>What I'd like to put forward or ask is, is there any way that we can harness the goodwill that's here while there's some political sensitivity in the system?

832
00:57:11.460 --> 00:57:28.640
<v Audience>And be it a phone-in or something of that sort where the question be raised publicly that people are dissatisfied with the lack of paralysis in the system from the recommendations of the Reconciliation Council?

833
00:57:28.800 --> 00:57:29.920
<v Audience>What's before?

834
00:57:29.920 --> 00:57:30.160
<v Audience>What's after?

835
00:57:30.180 --> 00:57:30.680
<v Audience>What's before parliament?

836
00:57:30.860 --> 00:57:31.860
<v Audience>Nothing being done?

837
00:57:32.100 --> 00:57:44.560
<v Audience>Is there any way that we could either put a public telephone poll in where if there were 400,000 respondents like walking across the bridge, that would certainly put some political heat in the system?

838
00:57:47.800 --> 00:57:48.360
<v Rick Farley>Okay.

839
00:57:50.320 --> 00:57:53.780
<v Rick Farley>Firstly, I love the analogy of reconciliation as a honeymoon.

840
00:57:54.920 --> 00:57:58.380
<v Rick Farley>And then you get down to the hard yards of making the marriage work.

841
00:57:58.380 --> 00:58:01.020
<v Rick Farley>I mean, to me, that's about where we are today.

842
00:58:01.340 --> 00:58:06.580
<v Rick Farley>There's been this intellectual honeymoon, if you like, with reconciliation.

843
00:58:06.820 --> 00:58:28.360
<v Rick Farley>But the real challenge before all of us is to harness that degree of public opinion that we've seen over the last 12 to 18 months in particular, that developed over the 10-year life of the Council for Reconciliation, and turn that into action which will materially change the living system.

844
00:58:29.720 --> 00:58:31.000
<v Rick Farley>And that's what we're going to do in the next 10 years or so.

845
00:58:31.000 --> 00:58:32.180
<v Rick Farley>And that is the equation today.

846
00:58:32.980 --> 00:58:36.860
<v Rick Farley>Now, there's obviously an opportunity with the federal election coming up.

847
00:58:38.500 --> 00:58:56.040
<v Rick Farley>To me, the most effective thing that individuals can do is simply to write a letter to their local member of parliament and ask them the questions about, you know, where is the response to the recommendations in the Council's final report?

848
00:58:56.280 --> 00:58:58.340
<v Rick Farley>Where is the response of that?

849
00:58:58.340 --> 00:59:04.240
<v Rick Farley>their party to the recommendations in the Bringing Them Home report and put the wood on them. And I

850
00:59:04.240 --> 00:59:10.800
<v Rick Farley>can tell you, and I'm sure others who are involved in politics in this audience would agree, that if

851
00:59:10.800 --> 00:59:17.740
<v Rick Farley>a local member gets 50 letters in a day, signed addresses from people within his electorate,

852
00:59:18.560 --> 00:59:27.200
<v Rick Farley>it scares the living. It scares them a lot. What was the word you were searching for there?

853
00:59:30.520 --> 00:59:36.100
<v Rick Farley>So that's one level of activity. The second level of activity, if it could be achieved,

854
00:59:36.340 --> 00:59:44.720
<v Rick Farley>would be to get one of the large media organisations to look at the impact that

855
00:59:44.720 --> 00:59:52.700
<v Rick Farley>reconciliation issues are having in the election campaign. And if they were prepared to do that

856
00:59:52.700 --> 00:59:56.900
<v Rick Farley>sort of polling, whether it's a phone polling or part of the regular polling that's done for

857
00:59:56.900 --> 00:59:58.120
<v Rick Farley>NewsPoll or Solwick,

858
00:59:58.340 --> 01:00:07.000
<v Rick Farley>or whatever, I think that would also assist the process. But the final equation is that it's not

859
01:00:07.000 --> 01:00:12.960
<v Rick Farley>good enough to sit there or to come to something like this tonight. And I applaud you for coming

860
01:00:12.960 --> 01:00:19.040
<v Rick Farley>tonight. I applaud you for coming. But it's not enough to get that degree of intellectual

861
01:00:19.040 --> 01:00:25.200
<v Rick Farley>self-satisfaction out of what you're doing. We've got to translate that into political action,

862
01:00:25.380 --> 01:00:27.660
<v Rick Farley>which will then result in

863
01:00:28.340 --> 01:00:32.160
<v Rick Farley>benefits in the material living circumstances of Aboriginal people.

864
01:00:38.700 --> 01:00:44.600
<v Phillip Adams>Would anyone else on the panel like to suggest methods of turbocharging this issue?

865
01:00:45.920 --> 01:00:48.020
<v Phillip Adams>Or will we move on to the next question?

866
01:00:49.700 --> 01:00:53.480
<v Phillip Adams>I think we'll take a question from the Senate, the Upper House.

867
01:00:55.720 --> 01:00:58.220
<v Audience>Hello. My name is...

868
01:00:59.100 --> 01:00:59.840
<v Audience>Georgina Williams.

869
01:01:01.140 --> 01:01:02.160
<v Audience>Ngankiburka Ganiata.

870
01:01:02.980 --> 01:01:04.280
<v Audience>Family clan of the Williams.

871
01:01:06.020 --> 01:01:08.640
<v Audience>And a very hard worker at the grassroots.

872
01:01:08.840 --> 01:01:11.320
<v Audience>And the first thing that happens to me in places like this

873
01:01:11.320 --> 01:01:16.380
<v Audience>is that my heart beats a hundred times more rapidly than any other time because

874
01:01:16.380 --> 01:01:22.800
<v Audience>I have to first of all address the jargon, the language use that I'm not used to using.

875
01:01:23.780 --> 01:01:27.700
<v Audience>So that's sort of a separation mark.

876
01:01:28.340 --> 01:01:29.540
<v Audience>Between me and you.

877
01:01:31.240 --> 01:01:39.200
<v Audience>But I'd like to thank, first of all, Sir Ronald for the things he said in the opening.

878
01:01:39.840 --> 01:01:40.820
<v Audience>And I would also...

879
01:01:42.200 --> 01:01:51.420
<v Audience>Ngankiburka is actually the Kaurna language returning to the people, meaning senior female person of the Kaurna lands.

880
01:01:52.500 --> 01:01:57.480
<v Audience>My place, Patpanga, is Willunga, Oldinga.

881
01:01:59.400 --> 01:02:01.060
<v Audience>Ngankiparinga, which is the Ongaparinga.

882
01:02:01.440 --> 01:02:02.840
<v Audience>I work with all the councils.

883
01:02:03.620 --> 01:02:11.980
<v Audience>And I would like to first of all say thank you to the Federated Farmer, which nearly knocked me off my chair listening to him talk like that.

884
01:02:12.020 --> 01:02:17.540
<v Audience>I thought that he was the right wing and enemy as far as I could tell and hear from other people.

885
01:02:18.520 --> 01:02:21.900
<v Audience>And to hear him speak in the way that he did was quite a surprise to me.

886
01:02:22.000 --> 01:02:26.580
<v Audience>And I was looking outside for him, but I'm a bit blind and I can't see what you look like from here.

887
01:02:26.720 --> 01:02:27.100
<v Audience>Yeah.

888
01:02:27.480 --> 01:02:30.280
<v Audience>And I couldn't see you anywhere out there to come and tell you.

889
01:02:30.740 --> 01:02:32.700
<v Audience>And thank you for the things you said.

890
01:02:32.820 --> 01:02:46.540
<v Audience>Because as a grassroots ordinary Nunga person, female, I face all of the impacts of trying to do something.

891
01:02:47.460 --> 01:02:51.840
<v Audience>To actually be the action in your life.

892
01:02:52.700 --> 01:02:54.820
<v Audience>And there is a place called Waraparinga.

893
01:02:54.880 --> 01:02:55.780
<v Audience>And again, I'm going to...

894
01:02:55.780 --> 01:02:57.460
<v Audience>I don't know whether this is a question or I'm telling you.

895
01:02:57.480 --> 01:02:58.100
<v Audience>I'm telling you something here.

896
01:02:59.780 --> 01:03:01.760
<v Audience>Or advertising or whatever I'm doing.

897
01:03:01.880 --> 01:03:10.800
<v Audience>But anyway, I'm doing what you're talking about in addressing the situation with action rather than with rhetoric.

898
01:03:11.000 --> 01:03:13.020
<v Audience>Which is why my heart pounds like a dozen.

899
01:03:13.020 --> 01:03:21.940
<v Audience>I get up here and I have to try to find the words to speak to you and to not only to you but all the others who are listening in the exchange between us.

900
01:03:23.220 --> 01:03:27.460
<v Audience>So what I'm saying is that in the action, for all of those who are sitting in the room,

901
01:03:27.460 --> 01:03:40.340
<v Audience>in this hall tonight, I would like to say there is ways of exchanging with each other that's not only using your platforms but are using ours as well.

902
01:03:40.700 --> 01:03:50.620
<v Audience>And at Waraparinga, which is for people in Adelaide who know the place, is the triangle of Marion Road, Sturt Road, South Road.

903
01:03:51.460 --> 01:03:53.200
<v Audience>And down in there is a little oasis.

904
01:03:53.580 --> 01:03:57.440
<v Audience>In this little oasis, once a month on the rise of the sun, there's a little oasis.

905
01:03:57.440 --> 01:04:06.280
<v Audience>And so the full moon, we meet together, people, and that I'm here actually doing tonight is to say that the full moon you need to know about,

906
01:04:06.500 --> 01:04:09.080
<v Audience>you have to come when the full moon is on.

907
01:04:09.240 --> 01:04:16.500
<v Audience>And what we do is we meet and exchange in the spirit of humanity in this reconciliation process around the fire,

908
01:04:17.440 --> 01:04:23.700
<v Audience>which is our venue of exchange and not yours up there, which scares me.

909
01:04:23.860 --> 01:04:27.180
<v Audience>And down there, what we do is we say,

910
01:04:27.440 --> 01:04:31.240
<v Audience>to one another, I meet and greet you in the spirit of humanity.

911
01:04:32.020 --> 01:04:34.240
<v Audience>And from there, we exchange with one another.

912
01:04:34.440 --> 01:04:40.180
<v Audience>And we bring something to share, to eat, a food that sustains our lives, all of us.

913
01:04:40.340 --> 01:04:43.760
<v Audience>So these are practical things that are happening in this place.

914
01:04:43.980 --> 01:04:51.800
<v Audience>But you have to know when the full moon is on because that is your organic relationship to the earth and to all the environment of the earth.

915
01:04:51.880 --> 01:04:56.840
<v Audience>And every single thing that you are in academic ways talking about,

916
01:04:56.840 --> 01:04:57.720
<v Audience>you are talking about doing.

917
01:04:58.220 --> 01:05:01.100
<v Audience>So here we can meet with everyone.

918
01:05:02.280 --> 01:05:04.340
<v Audience>That's why I'm up here saying these things tonight.

919
01:05:04.560 --> 01:05:08.120
<v Audience>So you can decide whether I'm asking you a question or not.

920
01:05:08.480 --> 01:05:09.880
<v Audience>I won't decide that.

921
01:05:10.080 --> 01:05:18.920
<v Audience>What I'm saying is I would like for everyone to know that this organic relationship between us and the planet earth,

922
01:05:19.020 --> 01:05:24.740
<v Audience>our mother and our responsibility to take care of her,

923
01:05:24.820 --> 01:05:26.420
<v Audience>the beautiful green mantle,

924
01:05:26.840 --> 01:05:27.760
<v Audience>of our mother earth,

925
01:05:27.880 --> 01:05:36.260
<v Audience>and not to continue to separate ourselves from that with economics of sustainability and so on and so forth,

926
01:05:36.320 --> 01:05:39.640
<v Audience>many of the things that I don't really fully understand.

927
01:05:39.660 --> 01:05:49.160
<v Audience>As many of our aboriginal peoples right across the whole of the country speak often into their bottles of despair about.

928
01:05:49.920 --> 01:05:56.380
<v Audience>And then paint beautiful art for you to put on your walls.

929
01:05:56.840 --> 01:05:58.160
<v Audience>Which actually came from our body.

930
01:05:58.420 --> 01:06:01.900
<v Audience>And on that note, since I've got grandchildren here with me tonight,

931
01:06:01.980 --> 01:06:03.800
<v Audience>and I'm the only one that looks like that, I have them,

932
01:06:03.860 --> 01:06:06.560
<v Audience>carrying on with my own culture, I've got to go.

933
01:06:06.820 --> 01:06:09.200
<v Audience>So whether that's a question or not, good night.

934
01:06:19.800 --> 01:06:25.760
<v Phillip Adams>Well that's as good a flow of rhetoric as I've heard in a long time.

935
01:06:25.760 --> 01:06:27.700
<v Phillip Adams>You found your words.

936
01:06:27.740 --> 01:06:30.360
<v Phillip Adams>Not a question, but a wonderful statement.

937
01:06:31.080 --> 01:06:33.760
<v Phillip Adams>To the lower house, to the House of Reps, sir, your turn.

938
01:06:34.660 --> 01:06:36.920
<v Speaker 5>It is daunting to ask a question.

939
01:06:37.120 --> 01:06:41.520
<v Speaker 5>And it's all the more daunting as a Jewish man to have behind me in the queue,

940
01:06:41.720 --> 01:06:45.060
<v Speaker 5>a Holocaust denier from the Australia Institute.

941
01:06:45.220 --> 01:06:50.160
<v Speaker 5>I wish you'd just step back so I could stand in certain freedom.

942
01:06:51.920 --> 01:06:52.960
<v Speaker 5>Look, the...

943
01:06:59.160 --> 01:07:02.220
<v Phillip Adams>You have our sympathy, but proceed.

944
01:07:03.140 --> 01:07:11.360
<v Speaker 5>The suffering of the Aboriginal people over the years is something that my family observed

945
01:07:11.360 --> 01:07:17.200
<v Speaker 5>since 1939 when they came to Australia, fleeing Europe.

946
01:07:17.700 --> 01:07:25.080
<v Speaker 5>And what strikes me is that somebody saying sorry at any time, whether it's now or in the future,

947
01:07:25.080 --> 01:07:33.280
<v Speaker 5>will not overcome the ingrained low self-esteem and shame and toxic shame

948
01:07:34.080 --> 01:07:39.400
<v Speaker 5>that we see exhibited by our Indigenous people whenever we look.

949
01:07:39.580 --> 01:07:44.680
<v Speaker 5>I've seldom been able to make eye contact with an Aboriginal man or woman.

950
01:07:44.920 --> 01:07:51.840
<v Speaker 5>And intuitively, I believe this results from the low self-esteem and various forms of shame.

951
01:07:52.220 --> 01:07:54.560
<v Speaker 5>And we have this 2% of the population.

952
01:07:54.560 --> 01:07:55.060
<v Speaker 5>And we have this 2% of the population.

953
01:07:55.080 --> 01:07:57.180
<v Speaker 5>And we have this 2% of the population suffering what is almost a disease.

954
01:07:58.900 --> 01:08:05.260
<v Speaker 5>Now, I believe that the reparation required involves much more than just saying sorry

955
01:08:06.080 --> 01:08:10.140
<v Speaker 5>or financial reparation, because the suffering of the stolen generation

956
01:08:10.140 --> 01:08:17.420
<v Speaker 5>and virtually all Aborigine people is something much more endemic and deeply rooted.

957
01:08:17.680 --> 01:08:21.740
<v Speaker 5>And when you've been in a...

958
01:08:22.600 --> 01:08:25.060
<v Speaker 5>When you're part of society that is so...

959
01:08:25.060 --> 01:08:31.820
<v Speaker 5>So, negated and pushed back, for the people who are still living and have life now,

960
01:08:31.960 --> 01:08:36.680
<v Speaker 5>to overcome this toxic shame and low self-esteem and self-loathing,

961
01:08:37.640 --> 01:08:41.200
<v Speaker 5>it's a much bigger problem than people seem to have addressed today.

962
01:08:41.340 --> 01:08:45.060
<v Speaker 5>And I was wondering if the panel agrees with me or not.

963
01:08:45.640 --> 01:08:50.860
<v Speaker 5>And I also just find it despicable that standing behind me is this Holocaust denier.

964
01:08:50.980 --> 01:08:54.020
<v Speaker 5>I can't believe that this has happened to me tonight.

965
01:08:55.480 --> 01:08:58.300
<v Phillip Adams>Jackie, would you like to be the first to respond to this?

966
01:09:01.760 --> 01:09:05.240
<v Marcia Langton>Thank you to the gentleman for his question.

967
01:09:05.840 --> 01:09:13.520
<v Marcia Langton>I think what Rick said earlier about the hopelessness that most of our people feel that we're in,

968
01:09:13.520 --> 01:09:21.840
<v Marcia Langton>in terms of lack of education, of access to services, of unemployment,

969
01:09:22.500 --> 01:09:24.640
<v Marcia Langton>which is so high in our community,

970
01:09:24.640 --> 01:09:32.420
<v Marcia Langton>it would probably be well and truly up to the 80, 90%.

971
01:09:32.420 --> 01:09:40.720
<v Marcia Langton>It's very disguised by CDEP projects that ATSIC funds in our communities.

972
01:09:41.400 --> 01:09:47.540
<v Marcia Langton>I might just express to you that the inability of Aboriginal people...

973
01:09:47.540 --> 01:09:50.940
<v Marcia Langton>You talked about the inability to look someone in the eye.

974
01:09:51.640 --> 01:09:53.100
<v Marcia Langton>It is a very cultural thing,

975
01:09:53.100 --> 01:09:58.920
<v Marcia Langton>that Aboriginal people don't take it on to look people straight in the eye.

976
01:09:59.060 --> 01:10:02.740
<v Marcia Langton>It's about movement, it's about body language.

977
01:10:03.080 --> 01:10:14.640
<v Marcia Langton>Those of us, of course, who are urbanised and skilled in Western kind of dichotomy

978
01:10:14.640 --> 01:10:21.160
<v Marcia Langton>and ways of communication obviously feel much more comfortable

979
01:10:21.160 --> 01:10:23.080
<v Marcia Langton>about looking somebody in the eye.

980
01:10:23.100 --> 01:10:29.420
<v Marcia Langton>Although, usually when I first meet a person, I don't look them in the eye, still.

981
01:10:29.700 --> 01:10:33.020
<v Marcia Langton>I have to wait until I feel comfortable with that person.

982
01:10:33.600 --> 01:10:39.440
<v Marcia Langton>So, please don't feel bad that people, Indigenous people won't look you in the eye.

983
01:10:39.620 --> 01:10:40.720
<v Marcia Langton>It's not a sign of disrespect.

984
01:10:41.280 --> 01:10:47.920
<v Marcia Langton>It's a sign of not shaking hands doesn't automatically come to us as well.

985
01:10:49.300 --> 01:10:52.460
<v Marcia Langton>In response to your question, I think,

986
01:10:53.680 --> 01:10:58.880
<v Marcia Langton>certainly in the last few weeks, it's been a nightmare for our community.

987
01:10:59.340 --> 01:11:04.160
<v Marcia Langton>How we're able to get through that has been very difficult.

988
01:11:04.420 --> 01:11:07.780
<v Marcia Langton>It's been Aboriginal women who have been speaking out about this problem

989
01:11:07.780 --> 01:11:09.860
<v Marcia Langton>and Aboriginal women only.

990
01:11:09.920 --> 01:11:13.560
<v Marcia Langton>I haven't heard too much response from Aboriginal men,

991
01:11:13.840 --> 01:11:19.940
<v Marcia Langton>from white men or white women, maybe one or two.

992
01:11:20.100 --> 01:11:23.080
<v Marcia Langton>So, therefore, we are bearing the whole burden.

993
01:11:23.080 --> 01:11:24.980
<v Marcia Langton>We're bearing the whole huge burden upon this ourselves.

994
01:11:26.640 --> 01:11:28.280
<v Marcia Langton>We're saying that's not reconciliation.

995
01:11:28.780 --> 01:11:30.080
<v Marcia Langton>That's not what we're all about.

996
01:11:30.640 --> 01:11:35.980
<v Marcia Langton>It's about all of us taking responsibility and doing something for it.

997
01:11:36.880 --> 01:11:39.160
<v Marcia Langton>I'm not sure that I answered your question

998
01:11:39.160 --> 01:11:43.840
<v Marcia Langton>and I'm sorry that you have had to feel uncomfortable here tonight.

999
01:11:46.200 --> 01:11:49.960
<v Marcia Langton>And certainly we know that, I know that when I speak to an audience,

1000
01:11:50.120 --> 01:11:52.180
<v Marcia Langton>I know that everyone here is not going to be converted.

1001
01:11:52.180 --> 01:11:54.940
<v Marcia Langton>We're not going to be thinking about reconciliation

1002
01:11:54.940 --> 01:11:57.860
<v Marcia Langton>as a positive and a very constructive force

1003
01:11:57.860 --> 01:12:02.800
<v Marcia Langton>in which we can move this nation forward in terms of its identity.

1004
01:12:03.260 --> 01:12:06.820
<v Marcia Langton>So that's the great challenge for us.

1005
01:12:07.360 --> 01:12:13.420
<v Marcia Langton>In our country, as the First Nation status people,

1006
01:12:14.180 --> 01:12:17.380
<v Marcia Langton>I think it is high time we deserved a bit of recognition

1007
01:12:18.060 --> 01:12:19.660
<v Marcia Langton>and a bit of respect.

1008
01:12:20.200 --> 01:12:22.000
<v Marcia Langton>That has been long coming.

1009
01:12:22.180 --> 01:12:26.900
<v Marcia Langton>It's been something that we've always searched for.

1010
01:12:28.020 --> 01:12:34.760
<v Marcia Langton>But, of course, without our rights agenda not being taken on board properly,

1011
01:12:34.920 --> 01:12:37.360
<v Marcia Langton>we will have to keep fighting this.

1012
01:12:37.640 --> 01:12:44.280
<v Marcia Langton>And I do support what Rick said in terms of this being a honeymoon period.

1013
01:12:44.980 --> 01:12:49.440
<v Marcia Langton>I think probably for me, when I'm asked a question about where to next

1014
01:12:49.440 --> 01:12:51.180
<v Marcia Langton>for the next generation,

1015
01:12:51.340 --> 01:12:53.980
<v Marcia Langton>I'm going to say, well, the honeymoon's over.

1016
01:12:54.520 --> 01:13:00.840
<v Marcia Langton>Let's start the marriage, if there is a marriage to be had.

1017
01:13:01.000 --> 01:13:04.640
<v Marcia Langton>And I think and I hope and I pray that there is one,

1018
01:13:04.740 --> 01:13:06.900
<v Marcia Langton>because without that hope in my heart,

1019
01:13:07.020 --> 01:13:11.520
<v Marcia Langton>I despair for my people and for future generations.

1020
01:13:22.140 --> 01:13:27.120
<v Phillip Adams>The questioner, as I recall, talked of toxic shame.

1021
01:13:28.780 --> 01:13:32.520
<v Phillip Adams>I make no secret of bias, my bias.

1022
01:13:33.340 --> 01:13:34.680
<v Phillip Adams>It gets me into a bit of trouble sometimes.

1023
01:13:35.880 --> 01:13:38.960
<v Phillip Adams>But the word toxic resonates at the moment

1024
01:13:38.960 --> 01:13:41.400
<v Phillip Adams>because I've had correspondence with the next gentleman

1025
01:13:41.400 --> 01:13:44.440
<v Phillip Adams>and accused him of publishing toxic sludge.

1026
01:13:44.880 --> 01:13:46.840
<v Phillip Adams>Because, unless I'm very much mistaken,

1027
01:13:47.100 --> 01:13:50.580
<v Phillip Adams>you are from the Adelaide Institute and your name is Frederick Tobin.

1028
01:13:50.580 --> 01:13:52.020
<v Phillip Adams>Sir, what is your question?

1029
01:13:52.420 --> 01:13:55.840
<v Audience>I thank you for your lovely introduction.

1030
01:13:56.160 --> 01:14:01.060
<v Audience>The gentleman who preceded me, I am reminded now,

1031
01:14:01.200 --> 01:14:06.980
<v Audience>we were together fighting fires as students many years ago

1032
01:14:07.580 --> 01:14:08.880
<v Audience>when I was at Melbourne University.

1033
01:14:09.120 --> 01:14:10.920
<v Audience>So it's the first time I've ever met him again.

1034
01:14:11.580 --> 01:14:16.820
<v Audience>And it's embarrassed me to be hearing this

1035
01:14:17.580 --> 01:14:19.780
<v Audience>without my being given a right of reply.

1036
01:14:20.580 --> 01:14:22.700
<v Phillip Adams>Well, you've been given it now. What is your question?

1037
01:14:22.760 --> 01:14:26.180
<v Audience>I would like to ask the panel, in particular Sir Ronald,

1038
01:14:27.280 --> 01:14:32.440
<v Audience>what chance there is of the provisional Aboriginal government

1039
01:14:33.980 --> 01:14:35.780
<v Audience>succeeding in the future

1040
01:14:35.780 --> 01:14:41.120
<v Audience>in establishing a pure Aboriginal nation in Australia?

1041
01:14:47.660 --> 01:14:50.480
<v Speaker 11>Would any other member of the panel like to start?

1042
01:14:53.400 --> 01:14:57.500
<v Speaker 11>You're asking me to look in a crystal ball.

1043
01:14:57.760 --> 01:15:00.680
<v Speaker 11>I could see the glimmer of hope

1044
01:15:00.680 --> 01:15:07.260
<v Speaker 11>when we can get serious negotiations going on around the table

1045
01:15:07.260 --> 01:15:14.340
<v Speaker 11>between Indigenous leaders and the political leaders of this nation.

1046
01:15:14.600 --> 01:15:19.880
<v Speaker 11>It seems to me that we have to envisage that kind of

1047
01:15:19.880 --> 01:15:24.620
<v Speaker 11>meeting point in order to bring these objectives,

1048
01:15:24.800 --> 01:15:28.420
<v Speaker 11>such as the one you've mentioned, down out of the sky

1049
01:15:28.420 --> 01:15:35.480
<v Speaker 11>and really examine how it can be moved forward towards realisation.

1050
01:15:37.680 --> 01:15:41.080
<v Phillip Adams>Any other comments? Rick, would you like to pick this one up?

1051
01:15:41.540 --> 01:15:43.580
<v Rick Farley>A couple of quick things.

1052
01:15:46.920 --> 01:15:49.700
<v Rick Farley>First of all, I think people need to understand

1053
01:15:49.880 --> 01:15:52.580
<v Rick Farley>what the Mabo judgment really meant,

1054
01:15:52.700 --> 01:15:57.400
<v Rick Farley>because in that judgment, the High Court recognised

1055
01:15:57.400 --> 01:16:02.000
<v Rick Farley>a functioning system of Indigenous law in this country.

1056
01:16:02.520 --> 01:16:03.920
<v Rick Farley>And that's really what it did.

1057
01:16:03.980 --> 01:16:08.580
<v Rick Farley>It recognised a functioning system of Indigenous law

1058
01:16:08.580 --> 01:16:11.320
<v Rick Farley>with residual property rights, which they called native title.

1059
01:16:12.460 --> 01:16:15.980
<v Rick Farley>So one of the great challenges for the legal profession,

1060
01:16:16.200 --> 01:16:17.660
<v Rick Farley>and indeed for the whole community now,

1061
01:16:17.660 --> 01:16:21.060
<v Rick Farley>is how those two systems of law fit together.

1062
01:16:21.280 --> 01:16:22.920
<v Rick Farley>So that's one comment.

1063
01:16:23.080 --> 01:16:30.140
<v Rick Farley>There is a legal basis now to rights for Aboriginal people,

1064
01:16:30.260 --> 01:16:31.920
<v Rick Farley>recognised by our courts.

1065
01:16:36.500 --> 01:16:41.320
<v Rick Farley>The second point is that I have never heard any Aboriginal person

1066
01:16:43.860 --> 01:16:46.640
<v Rick Farley>say that they want to be separate from the rest of Australia.

1067
01:16:46.640 --> 01:16:51.640
<v Rick Farley>Every Aboriginal person that I've dealt with has said,

1068
01:16:51.680 --> 01:16:53.920
<v Rick Farley>we want to be part of Australia,

1069
01:16:54.160 --> 01:16:59.180
<v Rick Farley>but we don't want to be lumped together into this homogenous mass,

1070
01:17:00.900 --> 01:17:02.160
<v Rick Farley>like everyone else.

1071
01:17:02.200 --> 01:17:06.320
<v Rick Farley>We want respect for our separate culture and our separate law,

1072
01:17:06.540 --> 01:17:09.620
<v Rick Farley>which has been recognised by the whitefella common law.

1073
01:17:10.200 --> 01:17:13.820
<v Rick Farley>So it's not a question of separateness in that sense.

1074
01:17:14.000 --> 01:17:15.260
<v Rick Farley>It's a question of...

1075
01:17:17.380 --> 01:17:22.640
<v Rick Farley>Aboriginal people wanting to share the country.

1076
01:17:22.900 --> 01:17:27.940
<v Rick Farley>And all I've ever heard Aboriginal people say is,

1077
01:17:28.000 --> 01:17:29.640
<v Rick Farley>it would be nice if we were asked.

1078
01:17:30.660 --> 01:17:32.580
<v Rick Farley>It would be nice if we were asked.

1079
01:17:41.040 --> 01:17:43.820
<v Phillip Adams>It's question time at the Adelaide Town Hall.

1080
01:17:43.920 --> 01:17:45.540
<v Phillip Adams>We're combining the reps in the Senate.

1081
01:17:45.540 --> 01:17:48.080
<v Phillip Adams>Is there another question from the upper house?

1082
01:17:48.160 --> 01:17:48.420
<v Phillip Adams>Yes.

1083
01:17:49.880 --> 01:17:50.440
<v Audience>Hello.

1084
01:17:50.700 --> 01:17:52.420
<v Audience>My name is Freya Debiol,

1085
01:17:52.560 --> 01:17:55.860
<v Audience>and I've been committed to reconciliation here in Adelaide.

1086
01:17:55.940 --> 01:17:59.900
<v Audience>And I just wanted to say I acknowledge that I'm on Kaurna land,

1087
01:18:00.180 --> 01:18:04.740
<v Audience>and I wanted to thank the festival for bringing in the international speakers

1088
01:18:04.740 --> 01:18:09.240
<v Audience>to bring a view about our local issues with reconciliation here.

1089
01:18:09.440 --> 01:18:14.380
<v Audience>And I wanted to say that I recognise in Mbulilo a fellow revolutionary,

1090
01:18:14.480 --> 01:18:15.520
<v Audience>though he didn't speak.

1091
01:18:15.540 --> 01:18:16.500
<v Audience>He didn't use that word.

1092
01:18:16.680 --> 01:18:18.800
<v Audience>And I found his challenge really interesting.

1093
01:18:19.200 --> 01:18:25.500
<v Audience>And what occurred to me as I listened to him and our speaker from West Papua

1094
01:18:25.500 --> 01:18:29.240
<v Audience>is that one of the things that we have to deal with

1095
01:18:29.240 --> 01:18:31.900
<v Audience>is the fact that we're living in the context of globalisation.

1096
01:18:32.300 --> 01:18:35.300
<v Audience>And when we talk about Indigenous people's rights in this country,

1097
01:18:35.500 --> 01:18:39.140
<v Audience>we also have to acknowledge that other people's rights are being taken away

1098
01:18:39.140 --> 01:18:44.520
<v Audience>and that maybe we need not only to fight at the local level for Indigenous people's rights,

1099
01:18:44.520 --> 01:18:46.080
<v Audience>but we need to make connections,

1100
01:18:46.220 --> 01:18:49.020
<v Audience>because women's rights are not respected in this country.

1101
01:18:49.240 --> 01:18:52.360
<v Audience>We have asylum seekers who are called illegals

1102
01:18:52.360 --> 01:18:56.560
<v Audience>and stigmatised in a shocking manner.

1103
01:18:56.800 --> 01:18:59.260
<v Audience>And I just wonder what the panel might say about that.

1104
01:19:00.760 --> 01:19:06.100
<v Phillip Adams>Who would like to respond to these related, interrelated issues?

1105
01:19:10.520 --> 01:19:14.420
<v Speaker 6>I think that's a very, very significant point.

1106
01:19:14.520 --> 01:19:15.420
<v Speaker 6>That's been made.

1107
01:19:15.680 --> 01:19:24.460
<v Speaker 6>And in my mind relates to something that Rick was trying to share with me also behind,

1108
01:19:24.800 --> 01:19:32.260
<v Speaker 6>in terms of making the particular alliances that need to be made.

1109
01:19:33.100 --> 01:19:37.480
<v Speaker 6>If I may speak with regard to the South African position, for example,

1110
01:19:38.560 --> 01:19:44.500
<v Speaker 6>there is clearly no doubt in my mind that women in the context of the South African

1111
01:19:44.500 --> 01:19:49.380
<v Speaker 6>struggle are the sheroes of continuance,

1112
01:19:50.500 --> 01:19:58.380
<v Speaker 6>who sustain life, making sure life continues from one era to the next.

1113
01:19:59.520 --> 01:20:07.680
<v Speaker 6>Their disempowerment actually translates into the nation's disempowerment.

1114
01:20:08.500 --> 01:20:11.440
<v Speaker 6>In areas of the land from which I am sprung,

1115
01:20:12.500 --> 01:20:14.340
<v Speaker 6>there are in fact no maids.

1116
01:20:14.500 --> 01:20:20.400
<v Speaker 6>The maids were swallowed by the gold mines, for example.

1117
01:20:20.640 --> 01:20:27.100
<v Speaker 6>And sustenance, continuance, remains with the women.

1118
01:20:27.620 --> 01:20:34.100
<v Speaker 6>And so one can talk to other constituencies that are similarly marginalised,

1119
01:20:36.260 --> 01:20:37.800
<v Speaker 6>downtrodden and so on.

1120
01:20:37.920 --> 01:20:44.380
<v Speaker 6>But we must also remember that there are ever so many people

1121
01:20:44.380 --> 01:20:44.480
<v Speaker 6>on the planet,

1122
01:20:44.500 --> 01:20:47.360
<v Speaker 6>and I'm sorry because I'm still an unreconstructed Marxist,

1123
01:20:47.520 --> 01:20:49.240
<v Speaker 6>there are some people

1124
01:20:53.420 --> 01:20:58.040
<v Speaker 6>willing to commit class suicide, in a manner of speaking.

1125
01:20:58.380 --> 01:21:06.700
<v Speaker 6>And therefore, you do not only define alliances within your own class situation also.

1126
01:21:06.900 --> 01:21:09.820
<v Speaker 6>There are alliances we are making across classes as well.

1127
01:21:10.040 --> 01:21:13.120
<v Speaker 6>And for that reason, I really wouldn't poo-poo

1128
01:21:13.120 --> 01:21:15.060
<v Speaker 6>the intellectuals who are here,

1129
01:21:15.160 --> 01:21:19.340
<v Speaker 6>attempting also to understand their roles from their own position,

1130
01:21:19.480 --> 01:21:22.960
<v Speaker 6>in order to be able to link particularly with the rest.

1131
01:21:23.740 --> 01:21:25.820
<v Speaker 6>So in the final analysis, I think,

1132
01:21:25.940 --> 01:21:28.740
<v Speaker 6>at least this is what we are learning in South Africa,

1133
01:21:28.900 --> 01:21:34.200
<v Speaker 6>that South Africa belongs to all who live in it,

1134
01:21:34.280 --> 01:21:35.760
<v Speaker 6>black and white.

1135
01:21:35.980 --> 01:21:41.220
<v Speaker 6>And those were the words of the Freedom Charter,

1136
01:21:41.280 --> 01:21:42.760
<v Speaker 6>the blueprint for change.

1137
01:21:43.120 --> 01:21:44.600
<v Speaker 6>And I think that is what we are learning in the African National Congress.

1138
01:21:44.820 --> 01:21:49.040
<v Speaker 6>And I dare say that what the aborigines want to tell you

1139
01:21:50.120 --> 01:21:53.300
<v Speaker 6>is that Australia belongs to all who live in it,

1140
01:21:53.420 --> 01:21:54.540
<v Speaker 6>black and white.

1141
01:21:55.440 --> 01:22:01.040
<v Speaker 6>I think also what we want to say is that in the final analysis,

1142
01:22:01.140 --> 01:22:03.820
<v Speaker 6>not even ourselves, not you and so on,

1143
01:22:03.900 --> 01:22:05.060
<v Speaker 6>depending on your positions,

1144
01:22:06.400 --> 01:22:10.800
<v Speaker 6>has monopoly to truth and beauty,

1145
01:22:10.800 --> 01:22:15.940
<v Speaker 6>because there is room for us all at the rendezvous of victory.

1146
01:22:16.440 --> 01:22:19.340
<v Speaker 6>And that's validating our common humanity.

1147
01:22:20.620 --> 01:22:25.840
<v Speaker 6>So I appreciate that Alliance-building contribution and comments.

1148
01:22:32.940 --> 01:22:35.900
<v Phillip Adams>Another question from the lower house.

1149
01:22:36.220 --> 01:22:36.740
<v Audience>Thank you.

1150
01:22:42.080 --> 01:22:43.660
<v Audience>But I've got a question.

1151
01:22:43.820 --> 01:22:46.740
<v Audience>I'd like to go straight to the point, I think.

1152
01:22:48.020 --> 01:22:49.740
<v Audience>Before I do that, the man in the dark suit,

1153
01:22:49.940 --> 01:22:51.340
<v Audience>there's a bit of an answer for him too.

1154
01:22:51.620 --> 01:22:53.860
<v Audience>There are many nations, hundreds of nations here,

1155
01:22:53.880 --> 01:22:55.160
<v Audience>and they've been here for a long, long time.

1156
01:22:55.700 --> 01:22:57.240
<v Audience>So I needn't worry about when they're going to come.

1157
01:22:57.340 --> 01:22:57.960
<v Audience>We're still here.

1158
01:22:59.900 --> 01:23:01.260
<v Audience>But cut to the chase.

1159
01:23:03.480 --> 01:23:06.800
<v Audience>My brothers from Melanesia and from Africa

1160
01:23:06.800 --> 01:23:08.040
<v Audience>have hit it on the head.

1161
01:23:08.040 --> 01:23:11.020
<v Audience>It's about land and it's about economics.

1162
01:23:12.520 --> 01:23:15.140
<v Audience>And I'd like to ask those in the dominant society

1163
01:23:15.140 --> 01:23:17.820
<v Audience>how they think they're going to deconstruct

1164
01:23:17.820 --> 01:23:20.920
<v Audience>and then reconstruct this country in such a way

1165
01:23:20.920 --> 01:23:24.140
<v Audience>that we can get justice over land and economics.

1166
01:23:25.100 --> 01:23:28.620
<v Audience>And another question following that is that also

1167
01:23:28.620 --> 01:23:34.660
<v Audience>the only suggestion of an economic solution to your problem

1168
01:23:35.800 --> 01:23:37.580
<v Audience>that I've heard is,

1169
01:23:38.060 --> 01:23:41.220
<v Audience>as has been put forward by NAO, which is now NACCHO,

1170
01:23:41.320 --> 01:23:44.200
<v Audience>many years ago, of which I was proud to be a member,

1171
01:23:44.860 --> 01:23:45.600
<v Audience>an executive member,

1172
01:23:46.060 --> 01:23:47.780
<v Audience>that we had a philosophy called pay the rent.

1173
01:23:48.200 --> 01:23:51.820
<v Audience>And I have yet to hear another proposition that comes near it.

1174
01:23:52.240 --> 01:23:53.900
<v Audience>So could I just ask the two questions?

1175
01:23:53.940 --> 01:23:57.600
<v Audience>How is the dominant society going to change itself

1176
01:23:58.480 --> 01:23:59.880
<v Audience>about land and economics?

1177
01:24:00.760 --> 01:24:03.040
<v Audience>And secondly, as a writer to that,

1178
01:24:03.180 --> 01:24:05.920
<v Audience>is there anything better than pay the rent that's been proposed already?

1179
01:24:08.200 --> 01:24:08.940
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you.

1180
01:24:11.080 --> 01:24:12.940
<v Phillip Adams>Ronald, paying the rent.

1181
01:24:14.360 --> 01:24:16.300
<v Speaker 11>The first question,

1182
01:24:17.760 --> 01:24:23.040
<v Speaker 11>I think I pick up the statement by my brother here

1183
01:24:23.040 --> 01:24:25.520
<v Speaker 11>that the land belongs to all of us.

1184
01:24:26.240 --> 01:24:30.540
<v Speaker 11>And I see the only way forward in terms of justice

1185
01:24:30.540 --> 01:24:34.640
<v Speaker 11>in relation to land between the races in Australia

1186
01:24:35.420 --> 01:24:36.520
<v Speaker 11>is in terms of

1187
01:24:36.520 --> 01:24:38.020
<v Speaker 11>a share of land.

1188
01:24:38.040 --> 01:24:38.620
<v Speaker 11>A shared relationship,

1189
01:24:39.520 --> 01:24:43.600
<v Speaker 11>which may well be furthered in a practical sense

1190
01:24:44.160 --> 01:24:46.320
<v Speaker 11>through the development of partnerships

1191
01:24:47.040 --> 01:24:50.160
<v Speaker 11>in business enterprises focused on the land.

1192
01:24:50.460 --> 01:24:56.160
<v Speaker 11>That seems to me to be one way of bridging the gap.

1193
01:24:56.640 --> 01:25:00.080
<v Speaker 11>I forget what the second question was.

1194
01:25:01.000 --> 01:25:03.500
<v Phillip Adams>The notion of paying the rent, Ronald.

1195
01:25:04.520 --> 01:25:04.720
<v Speaker 11>Yes.

1196
01:25:05.520 --> 01:25:06.320
<v Speaker 11>That was...

1197
01:25:08.040 --> 01:25:12.840
<v Speaker 11>a concept that was run years ago

1198
01:25:12.840 --> 01:25:17.860
<v Speaker 11>and attracted the loyalty of quite a lot of Australians.

1199
01:25:18.140 --> 01:25:21.660
<v Speaker 11>But it lacked a method of fulfilment.

1200
01:25:23.000 --> 01:25:28.940
<v Speaker 11>How do you go about a scheme to pay the rent?

1201
01:25:30.520 --> 01:25:32.400
<v Speaker 11>I remember churches, for example,

1202
01:25:32.400 --> 01:25:37.460
<v Speaker 11>were challenged to pay the rent on the land on which they're

1203
01:25:37.460 --> 01:25:38.060
<v Speaker 11>building.

1204
01:25:38.220 --> 01:25:39.160
<v Speaker 11>And I think that was the reason why the buildings were constructed

1205
01:25:39.160 --> 01:25:50.360
<v Speaker 11>by making an appropriate contribution to the betterment of the quality of life

1206
01:25:50.360 --> 01:25:51.620
<v Speaker 11>for Aboriginal people.

1207
01:25:51.960 --> 01:25:58.740
<v Speaker 11>But I think it founded because it was like streams going into a desert.

1208
01:25:58.920 --> 01:26:06.480
<v Speaker 11>There wasn't the opportunity taken to really develop a...

1209
01:26:06.480 --> 01:26:06.660
<v Speaker 11>...a...

1210
01:26:07.460 --> 01:26:15.500
<v Speaker 11>...a union of these forces that would really then carry tangible outcomes in its wake.

1211
01:26:16.060 --> 01:26:18.160
<v Phillip Adams>Rick, it's a tough, unsentimental question.

1212
01:26:18.320 --> 01:26:20.040
<v Phillip Adams>Do you have a tough answer for it?

1213
01:26:20.540 --> 01:26:22.660
<v Rick Farley>I don't think there's any simple answer to it.

1214
01:26:22.720 --> 01:26:27.220
<v Rick Farley>The only thing that I can point to is, from my own experience,

1215
01:26:27.340 --> 01:26:31.080
<v Rick Farley>was the agreement that we managed to put together on Cape York

1216
01:26:31.080 --> 01:26:36.420
<v Rick Farley>between pastoralists, Aboriginal people and the environment movement.

1217
01:26:37.460 --> 01:26:41.140
<v Rick Farley>Where people sat down and talked about what land use should be,

1218
01:26:42.900 --> 01:26:48.560
<v Rick Farley>protecting cultural areas, providing access for Aboriginal people on to country,

1219
01:26:50.620 --> 01:26:56.480
<v Rick Farley>developing shared business arrangements and also protecting high...

1220
01:26:56.480 --> 01:27:00.780
<v Rick Farley>...or areas of high natural environmental values as well.

1221
01:27:01.600 --> 01:27:06.080
<v Rick Farley>Interestingly, that agreement was first put together, I think, in 1996.

1222
01:27:07.460 --> 01:27:11.220
<v Rick Farley>And despite all the ups and downs of, you know, different court decisions,

1223
01:27:12.980 --> 01:27:15.480
<v Rick Farley>the change in government in Queensland,

1224
01:27:16.800 --> 01:27:21.120
<v Rick Farley>when Premier Borbidge initially supported the agreement and then walked away from it,

1225
01:27:21.160 --> 01:27:24.460
<v Rick Farley>the current Premier, Beattie, has picked that up again.

1226
01:27:27.040 --> 01:27:31.880
<v Rick Farley>So, it's probably the most difficult question there is because, you know...

1227
01:27:32.460 --> 01:27:37.340
<v Rick Farley>But the only way that I can approach it is to say that, in the last analysis,

1228
01:27:38.780 --> 01:27:41.840
<v Rick Farley>the land is really all we've got.

1229
01:27:42.000 --> 01:27:45.140
<v Rick Farley>I mean, the land, in Aboriginal terms, is mother.

1230
01:27:46.320 --> 01:27:51.000
<v Rick Farley>And I think there's a lot of people in the environment movement and, you know,

1231
01:27:51.020 --> 01:27:54.380
<v Rick Farley>perhaps surprisingly, a lot of farmers who would also embrace that concept.

1232
01:27:55.660 --> 01:28:00.020
<v Rick Farley>So, I think the challenge for all of us is to do two things.

1233
01:28:00.120 --> 01:28:06.980
<v Rick Farley>One, to make sure that we care for country because it's the country that gives us everything.

1234
01:28:07.700 --> 01:28:11.060
<v Rick Farley>And then secondly, we've got to, as Sir Ronald said,

1235
01:28:11.240 --> 01:28:16.780
<v Rick Farley>we've got to develop partnerships and agreements about how the country is cared for

1236
01:28:17.400 --> 01:28:24.820
<v Rick Farley>and how its benefits or the gifts that it gives us are distributed equally

1237
01:28:26.060 --> 01:28:28.120
<v Rick Farley>to all of those who have an interest in it.

1238
01:28:28.220 --> 01:28:30.480
<v Rick Farley>Now, we're struggling with it on Cape York.

1239
01:28:32.460 --> 01:28:35.640
<v Rick Farley>It looks as if there is going to be further progress.

1240
01:28:35.640 --> 01:28:39.300
<v Rick Farley>Well, the agreement is held together now for five years

1241
01:28:39.300 --> 01:28:42.420
<v Rick Farley>and Premier Beattie is giving it new life at the moment.

1242
01:28:42.680 --> 01:28:45.620
<v Rick Farley>I think what happens on Cape York, you know,

1243
01:28:45.620 --> 01:28:48.560
<v Rick Farley>well could be a very interesting model for the rest of Australia.

1244
01:28:55.040 --> 01:28:59.640
<v Phillip Adams>You're at the Festival of Ideas at the Adelaide Town Hall.

1245
01:28:59.800 --> 01:29:03.160
<v Phillip Adams>The issue, reconciliation and paralysis,

1246
01:29:04.020 --> 01:29:05.560
<v Phillip Adams>to which, Sir Ronald,

1247
01:29:05.640 --> 01:29:08.100
<v Phillip Adams>Sir Ronald Wilson insisted we add a question mark.

1248
01:29:08.380 --> 01:29:12.660
<v Phillip Adams>And the next question pertaining to this question comes from the balcony.

1249
01:29:14.580 --> 01:29:15.220
<v Speaker 4>Hello.

1250
01:29:15.340 --> 01:29:18.260
<v Speaker 4>I'd hoped not to speak after such knowledgeable people.

1251
01:29:18.820 --> 01:29:21.180
<v Speaker 4>I fear I'll look like an idiot.

1252
01:29:21.460 --> 01:29:29.300
<v Speaker 4>But I just wanted to respond to the concept of reconciliation and paralysis.

1253
01:29:29.700 --> 01:29:34.260
<v Speaker 4>And it's been sort of widely maybe conferred that

1254
01:29:35.640 --> 01:29:38.660
<v Speaker 4>the paralysis is perhaps on a parliamentary level at the moment

1255
01:29:38.660 --> 01:29:45.280
<v Speaker 4>and that it's doing quite well at a community level.

1256
01:29:45.640 --> 01:29:51.620
<v Speaker 4>I just wanted to say that we need to empower the parliamentary figures

1257
01:29:52.560 --> 01:29:54.520
<v Speaker 4>to be able to make the changes.

1258
01:29:55.280 --> 01:29:58.320
<v Speaker 4>If we're looking to them as leaders, well, they've never really led

1259
01:29:58.320 --> 01:29:59.920
<v Speaker 4>and that's for us to do.

1260
01:30:00.280 --> 01:30:02.060
<v Speaker 4>And we need to keep doing that.

1261
01:30:02.780 --> 01:30:04.640
<v Speaker 4>We really need to take this on.

1262
01:30:05.280 --> 01:30:08.800
<v Speaker 4>We're talking about a cultural marriage, I believe,

1263
01:30:09.000 --> 01:30:12.800
<v Speaker 4>and that means that it's to do with culture and not politics.

1264
01:30:13.120 --> 01:30:14.220
<v Speaker 4>And we're the culture.

1265
01:30:14.880 --> 01:30:16.580
<v Speaker 4>And we need to take that on.

1266
01:30:16.680 --> 01:30:20.480
<v Speaker 4>So I fear I have looked like an idiot.

1267
01:30:20.480 --> 01:30:22.700
<v Phillip Adams>You've made a very good statement and I thank you for it.

1268
01:30:28.060 --> 01:30:28.500
<v Phillip Adams>Madam.

1269
01:30:29.800 --> 01:30:32.800
<v Audience>I'd like to thank everyone up there

1270
01:30:32.800 --> 01:30:36.100
<v Audience>because I've learnt a bit more about reconciliation.

1271
01:30:36.100 --> 01:30:37.960
<v Phillip Adams>Can you be a bit closer to the microphone, please?

1272
01:30:39.280 --> 01:30:42.640
<v Audience>I've learnt heaps of stuff about reconciliation and stuff.

1273
01:30:43.360 --> 01:30:48.320
<v Audience>And I hope that my generation can take it to the next level.

1274
01:30:48.560 --> 01:30:49.300
<v Audience>Thank you.

1275
01:30:50.360 --> 01:30:50.920
<v Audience>APPLAUSE

1276
01:30:58.080 --> 01:30:59.600
<v Phillip Adams>Back to the gods.

1277
01:31:01.300 --> 01:31:02.700
<v Audience>My name is Jane.

1278
01:31:02.780 --> 01:31:03.020
<v Audience>I'm Jane Wilson.

1279
01:31:03.440 --> 01:31:06.040
<v Audience>I want to acknowledge that I'm on Kaurna land.

1280
01:31:06.440 --> 01:31:10.260
<v Audience>But at the moment I'm particularly concerned for the Narendra,

1281
01:31:10.500 --> 01:31:12.080
<v Audience>the people around the Koran.

1282
01:31:12.380 --> 01:31:14.440
<v Audience>And I'm collecting...

1283
01:31:16.240 --> 01:31:20.400
<v Audience>I'm going around with a petition for a reconciliation ferry.

1284
01:31:20.740 --> 01:31:23.620
<v Audience>But I want to ask the panel...

1285
01:31:23.620 --> 01:31:25.800
<v Audience>This is, for those who don't know,

1286
01:31:27.320 --> 01:31:32.180
<v Audience>a ferry from Clayton Island to Hindmarsh Island,

1287
01:31:32.180 --> 01:31:33.080
<v Audience>to Kummerang,

1288
01:31:33.140 --> 01:31:35.780
<v Audience>because the old ferry has gone

1289
01:31:35.780 --> 01:31:38.420
<v Audience>now that the new bridge has been built.

1290
01:31:39.180 --> 01:31:41.640
<v Audience>And the Narendra do not want to use the bridge.

1291
01:31:41.880 --> 01:31:44.620
<v Audience>And of course there might be an accident on the bridge.

1292
01:31:44.820 --> 01:31:50.560
<v Audience>And many families like mine will greatly miss a ferry

1293
01:31:50.560 --> 01:31:52.180
<v Audience>when they go for their summer holidays

1294
01:31:52.180 --> 01:31:56.700
<v Audience>because my grandchildren like to stay on it for several turns.

1295
01:31:57.140 --> 01:32:00.320
<v Audience>But I am aware that a petition...

1296
01:32:01.040 --> 01:32:04.720
<v Audience>So many petitions get presented in Parliament

1297
01:32:04.720 --> 01:32:07.000
<v Audience>and nothing happens to them.

1298
01:32:07.280 --> 01:32:10.400
<v Audience>And I would like the panel's advice,

1299
01:32:10.620 --> 01:32:15.240
<v Audience>because to me a ferry is such a small thing,

1300
01:32:15.420 --> 01:32:18.220
<v Audience>and yet it would mean a terrific lot to the Narendra people.

1301
01:32:18.480 --> 01:32:20.540
<v Audience>It would give employment to them.

1302
01:32:20.600 --> 01:32:25.440
<v Audience>We could have a cross-cultural education experience there,

1303
01:32:25.600 --> 01:32:28.600
<v Audience>which if it was run by Tom Trevorrow

1304
01:32:28.600 --> 01:32:30.300
<v Audience>and like his camp, Kaurna,

1305
01:32:30.320 --> 01:32:34.080
<v Audience>the Kurung experiences would turn people round

1306
01:32:34.080 --> 01:32:35.440
<v Audience>like it turned me round.

1307
01:32:35.720 --> 01:32:38.340
<v Audience>But, you know, maybe we get 5,000,

1308
01:32:38.360 --> 01:32:40.760
<v Audience>maybe we get 10,000, and it isn't enough.

1309
01:32:41.020 --> 01:32:43.040
<v Audience>What else can we do?

1310
01:32:46.440 --> 01:32:47.640
<v Phillip Adams>I've always...

1311
01:32:49.120 --> 01:32:52.140
<v Phillip Adams>I've always regarded sending petitions to Parliament

1312
01:32:52.140 --> 01:32:54.580
<v Phillip Adams>as being as useless as sending prayers to heaven.

1313
01:32:55.000 --> 01:32:58.440
<v Phillip Adams>I think Rick's right that letters to politicians

1314
01:32:58.440 --> 01:32:59.900
<v Phillip Adams>are still the most potent

1315
01:33:00.320 --> 01:33:00.800
<v Phillip Adams>and most effective mechanism,

1316
01:33:00.860 --> 01:33:03.260
<v Phillip Adams>particularly at and around election times,

1317
01:33:03.420 --> 01:33:04.720
<v Phillip Adams>when, oddly enough, they're read.

1318
01:33:05.080 --> 01:33:07.400
<v Phillip Adams>Any other way of launching a ferry, Jackie?

1319
01:33:08.880 --> 01:33:11.140
<v Marcia Langton>I think it's a great idea

1320
01:33:11.140 --> 01:33:14.900
<v Marcia Langton>to allow the Nununjerri people

1321
01:33:14.900 --> 01:33:19.460
<v Marcia Langton>still to navigate and pass through the waterways

1322
01:33:19.460 --> 01:33:21.440
<v Marcia Langton>and not use the bridge.

1323
01:33:21.640 --> 01:33:24.900
<v Marcia Langton>I suspect it's a boycott of the bridge.

1324
01:33:25.100 --> 01:33:27.200
<v Marcia Langton>Am I right in saying that?

1325
01:33:28.980 --> 01:33:29.540
<v Marcia Langton>Yes.

1326
01:33:29.540 --> 01:33:30.120
<v Marcia Langton>Yes, OK.

1327
01:33:31.200 --> 01:33:34.120
<v Marcia Langton>And I think that's a very honourable thing to do

1328
01:33:34.120 --> 01:33:37.340
<v Marcia Langton>in terms of what has been done here

1329
01:33:38.580 --> 01:33:40.640
<v Marcia Langton>to...about the cultural heritage

1330
01:33:40.640 --> 01:33:44.220
<v Marcia Langton>and protection of sacred sites,

1331
01:33:44.340 --> 01:33:45.720
<v Marcia Langton>not only here in this state,

1332
01:33:45.800 --> 01:33:47.720
<v Marcia Langton>but, of course, elsewhere in the country.

1333
01:33:50.220 --> 01:33:50.780
<v Marcia Langton>I...

1334
01:33:51.680 --> 01:33:53.140
<v Marcia Langton>Apart from what Philip said,

1335
01:33:53.420 --> 01:33:56.300
<v Marcia Langton>I don't have any sort of fast ways

1336
01:33:56.300 --> 01:33:58.800
<v Marcia Langton>of how to proceed with that.

1337
01:33:59.540 --> 01:34:00.940
<v Marcia Langton>Just to say thank you

1338
01:34:00.940 --> 01:34:05.820
<v Marcia Langton>and to thank the very generous non-Indigenous people

1339
01:34:05.820 --> 01:34:06.880
<v Marcia Langton>in this country

1340
01:34:07.540 --> 01:34:09.360
<v Marcia Langton>for the amount of work that they do too

1341
01:34:09.360 --> 01:34:12.440
<v Marcia Langton>in terms of working alongside, supporting

1342
01:34:12.440 --> 01:34:15.540
<v Marcia Langton>and aiding and abetting Indigenous peoples

1343
01:34:16.180 --> 01:34:16.960
<v Marcia Langton>in their struggles.

1344
01:34:17.320 --> 01:34:18.900
<v Marcia Langton>Prior to colonial times,

1345
01:34:19.080 --> 01:34:21.020
<v Marcia Langton>we had maybe a few dissident voices.

1346
01:34:21.480 --> 01:34:25.540
<v Marcia Langton>Now we have, I believe, thousands and thousands,

1347
01:34:25.620 --> 01:34:27.180
<v Marcia Langton>if not millions, of people

1348
01:34:27.180 --> 01:34:29.520
<v Marcia Langton>who will stand alongside Indigenous people

1349
01:34:30.180 --> 01:34:31.140
<v Marcia Langton>and work with them.

1350
01:34:31.200 --> 01:34:32.700
<v Marcia Langton>That surely is reconciliation.

1351
01:34:33.260 --> 01:34:36.160
<v Marcia Langton>I just want to respond to the young lady

1352
01:34:36.160 --> 01:34:39.620
<v Marcia Langton>from the last question last time.

1353
01:34:39.760 --> 01:34:41.260
<v Marcia Langton>I'd just like to say to you

1354
01:34:41.260 --> 01:34:43.720
<v Marcia Langton>that the Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation

1355
01:34:43.720 --> 01:34:45.700
<v Marcia Langton>conducted some social research.

1356
01:34:46.160 --> 01:34:48.420
<v Marcia Langton>We found that the people most...

1357
01:34:49.180 --> 01:34:50.920
<v Marcia Langton>most hopeful about reconciliation

1358
01:34:50.920 --> 01:34:52.320
<v Marcia Langton>and moving it forward

1359
01:34:52.320 --> 01:34:55.280
<v Marcia Langton>are the people between the ages of 18 and 25.

1360
01:34:55.820 --> 01:34:57.160
<v Marcia Langton>That's what gives me great hope

1361
01:34:57.180 --> 01:34:58.000
<v Marcia Langton>for the future,

1362
01:34:58.160 --> 01:35:00.180
<v Marcia Langton>because it will be people of that generation

1363
01:35:00.180 --> 01:35:01.760
<v Marcia Langton>who will get to understand,

1364
01:35:01.980 --> 01:35:05.360
<v Marcia Langton>hopefully get to know the real history of our country

1365
01:35:05.360 --> 01:35:06.660
<v Marcia Langton>and to move it along.

1366
01:35:07.640 --> 01:35:09.180
<v Marcia Langton>Unfortunately, it's the over-60s

1367
01:35:09.700 --> 01:35:11.080
<v Marcia Langton>that we have a huge problem with.

1368
01:35:11.260 --> 01:35:12.880
<v Marcia Langton>I'm not saying I've met some wonderful

1369
01:35:13.280 --> 01:35:15.080
<v Marcia Langton>70- and 80-year-old radicals

1370
01:35:15.480 --> 01:35:16.560
<v Marcia Langton>in my time,

1371
01:35:16.680 --> 01:35:20.080
<v Marcia Langton>but, you know, in the truest sense of the word,

1372
01:35:20.960 --> 01:35:22.160
<v Marcia Langton>it's the younger generation

1373
01:35:22.160 --> 01:35:23.520
<v Marcia Langton>who are going to take it forward.

1374
01:35:23.900 --> 01:35:24.860
<v Marcia Langton>That's why I'm hopeful.

1375
01:35:25.100 --> 01:35:26.640
<v Phillip Adams>I'm deeply insulted by that, Jackie.

1376
01:35:26.640 --> 01:35:27.440
<v Marcia Langton>I'm sorry, Philip.

1377
01:35:27.820 --> 01:35:29.140
<v Marcia Langton>I thought you were 59.

1378
01:35:31.640 --> 01:35:33.260
<v Phillip Adams>It's my 62nd birthday today.

1379
01:35:33.500 --> 01:35:34.880
<v Phillip Adams>Rick Farley, your turn.

1380
01:35:35.180 --> 01:35:37.200
<v Rick Farley>Just a very quick comment.

1381
01:35:38.760 --> 01:35:40.920
<v Rick Farley>I ran across a very interesting organisation

1382
01:35:40.920 --> 01:35:43.260
<v Rick Farley>the other day called the Bush Heritage Trust,

1383
01:35:43.520 --> 01:35:46.420
<v Rick Farley>and they want to ensure

1384
01:35:46.420 --> 01:35:50.540
<v Rick Farley>that environmentally significant areas of country

1385
01:35:50.540 --> 01:35:51.180
<v Rick Farley>are protected.

1386
01:35:52.180 --> 01:35:54.380
<v Rick Farley>Now, they started off talking to politicians

1387
01:35:54.380 --> 01:35:56.000
<v Rick Farley>and doing all of that stuff,

1388
01:35:56.000 --> 01:35:57.520
<v Rick Farley>but they came up with a very simple approach,

1389
01:35:57.700 --> 01:35:59.680
<v Rick Farley>which they're putting into practice now,

1390
01:35:59.820 --> 01:36:01.660
<v Rick Farley>and that is they simply go out and raise money

1391
01:36:01.660 --> 01:36:02.460
<v Rick Farley>and they do it themselves.

1392
01:36:03.320 --> 01:36:04.560
<v Rick Farley>They buy the country.

1393
01:36:05.560 --> 01:36:07.980
<v Rick Farley>So, you know, the suggestion I'd make to you is,

1394
01:36:08.760 --> 01:36:10.800
<v Rick Farley>instead of relying on petitions,

1395
01:36:10.980 --> 01:36:13.700
<v Rick Farley>you know, I'd be thinking about the capacity

1396
01:36:13.700 --> 01:36:16.540
<v Rick Farley>to raise money to buy your own ferry.

1397
01:36:16.680 --> 01:36:17.460
<v Rick Farley>Just do it yourself.

1398
01:36:17.680 --> 01:36:18.760
<v Rick Farley>Don't wait for the politicians.

1399
01:36:26.760 --> 01:36:28.000
<v Phillip Adams>Madam, your turn.

1400
01:36:28.240 --> 01:36:28.840
<v Audience>Thank you.

1401
01:36:29.300 --> 01:36:33.720
<v Audience>I would like to, first of all, express a personal desire

1402
01:36:33.720 --> 01:36:35.660
<v Audience>and also ask a question.

1403
01:36:36.000 --> 01:36:41.420
<v Audience>And my personal desire is to see Aboriginal leaders

1404
01:36:41.420 --> 01:36:43.700
<v Audience>who have demonstrated such wonderful compassion

1405
01:36:43.700 --> 01:36:47.020
<v Audience>and intelligence in leading their own people

1406
01:36:47.020 --> 01:36:50.320
<v Audience>now come up and lead all of Australia

1407
01:36:51.000 --> 01:36:53.780
<v Audience>as Treasurer, as Minister for Immigration,

1408
01:36:54.520 --> 01:36:55.220
<v Audience>as...

1409
01:36:56.120 --> 01:36:56.680
<v Audience>..the...

1410
01:36:57.840 --> 01:36:58.820
<v Audience>Excuse me.

1411
01:37:01.180 --> 01:37:05.580
<v Audience>..as the Commissioner for the Office for the Status of Women

1412
01:37:05.580 --> 01:37:06.500
<v Audience>and so on,

1413
01:37:06.560 --> 01:37:09.440
<v Audience>sort out problems that we have with detention centres,

1414
01:37:09.740 --> 01:37:10.500
<v Audience>with asylum,

1415
01:37:10.640 --> 01:37:13.640
<v Audience>for the big problems that are addressing us as a country

1416
01:37:13.640 --> 01:37:17.800
<v Audience>and, you know, are addressing indeed the entire world.

1417
01:37:18.500 --> 01:37:22.220
<v Audience>My question is, to seek clarification,

1418
01:37:23.480 --> 01:37:25.980
<v Audience>I am wondering if I'm getting a...

1419
01:37:26.000 --> 01:37:26.860
<v Audience>..a mistaken impression.

1420
01:37:27.680 --> 01:37:30.840
<v Audience>Is this something that Aboriginal people want to do?

1421
01:37:31.300 --> 01:37:34.480
<v Audience>And if it is something that Aboriginal people do want to do,

1422
01:37:35.620 --> 01:37:36.840
<v Audience>how can that be done?

1423
01:37:37.080 --> 01:37:39.880
<v Audience>I noticed that one of the speakers mentioned affirmative action

1424
01:37:39.880 --> 01:37:41.200
<v Audience>as a possibility,

1425
01:37:41.460 --> 01:37:45.140
<v Audience>but presently there seems to be a big gap

1426
01:37:46.460 --> 01:37:48.700
<v Audience>now for something like that to be possible.

1427
01:37:48.860 --> 01:37:51.880
<v Audience>And indeed, it would be nice to see an Aboriginal person indeed

1428
01:37:51.880 --> 01:37:54.480
<v Audience>lead the country at some point, but I guess that...

1429
01:37:55.040 --> 01:37:57.080
<v Audience>..that we haven't seen a woman lead it yet,

1430
01:37:57.120 --> 01:37:58.880
<v Audience>so perhaps that won't happen in my lifetime.

1431
01:37:59.560 --> 01:38:01.000
<v Phillip Adams>Jackie, what thinkest thou?

1432
01:38:02.420 --> 01:38:05.780
<v Marcia Langton>In our country, we've only had two senators.

1433
01:38:05.940 --> 01:38:07.220
<v Marcia Langton>Both have been male.

1434
01:38:07.520 --> 01:38:13.340
<v Marcia Langton>We have had a couple of representatives in the States.

1435
01:38:13.940 --> 01:38:15.700
<v Marcia Langton>We have Carol Martin now,

1436
01:38:15.760 --> 01:38:19.600
<v Marcia Langton>who's the member... ALP member up in Broome.

1437
01:38:19.820 --> 01:38:22.920
<v Marcia Langton>So, obviously, we are still very much lagging behind

1438
01:38:22.920 --> 01:38:24.120
<v Marcia Langton>in terms of...

1439
01:38:25.900 --> 01:38:29.320
<v Marcia Langton>..political representation in parliaments of any sort.

1440
01:38:29.520 --> 01:38:32.420
<v Marcia Langton>We have a number of... Not too many, though.

1441
01:38:32.620 --> 01:38:37.000
<v Marcia Langton>..people in local government as well.

1442
01:38:37.540 --> 01:38:41.520
<v Marcia Langton>It's just that the Council last time

1443
01:38:41.520 --> 01:38:44.020
<v Marcia Langton>had really argued for dedicated seats in parliament,

1444
01:38:44.240 --> 01:38:46.760
<v Marcia Langton>much like akin to the...

1445
01:38:48.620 --> 01:38:51.040
<v Marcia Langton>..the Eitiruowa, the Maori situation.

1446
01:38:52.060 --> 01:38:54.440
<v Marcia Langton>Of course, that was like...

1447
01:38:54.440 --> 01:38:54.460
<v Marcia Langton>..the...

1448
01:38:54.480 --> 01:38:55.160
<v Marcia Langton>..like knocking...

1449
01:38:55.160 --> 01:38:57.580
<v Marcia Langton>..knocking heads on a brick wall.

1450
01:38:58.480 --> 01:38:59.040
<v Marcia Langton>I think it's...

1451
01:38:59.040 --> 01:39:02.140
<v Marcia Langton>Until the political parties themselves

1452
01:39:02.140 --> 01:39:04.740
<v Marcia Langton>see the absolute value

1453
01:39:05.480 --> 01:39:08.840
<v Marcia Langton>in having Indigenous people within their own party structure,

1454
01:39:09.060 --> 01:39:11.400
<v Marcia Langton>within their own systems and within parliament,

1455
01:39:11.560 --> 01:39:13.600
<v Marcia Langton>we're not going to hope to change it.

1456
01:39:13.720 --> 01:39:16.500
<v Marcia Langton>And not to offer us, as I have been done,

1457
01:39:16.680 --> 01:39:18.980
<v Marcia Langton>a seat that is unwinnable

1458
01:39:19.620 --> 01:39:20.560
<v Marcia Langton>in a...

1459
01:39:20.560 --> 01:39:22.880
<v Marcia Langton>..in a party in Queensland,

1460
01:39:22.960 --> 01:39:23.940
<v Marcia Langton>um...

1461
01:39:24.480 --> 01:39:24.560
<v Marcia Langton>..in a country where we're not going to be able to do that.

1462
01:39:24.560 --> 01:39:25.300
<v Marcia Langton>I don't want that.

1463
01:39:25.360 --> 01:39:25.860
<v Marcia Langton>You know?

1464
01:39:25.960 --> 01:39:27.480
<v Marcia Langton>I want a safe seat.

1465
01:39:27.920 --> 01:39:30.180
<v Marcia Langton>Because I don't want to be wasting my time anymore,

1466
01:39:30.280 --> 01:39:31.380
<v Marcia Langton>three years of my life,

1467
01:39:31.500 --> 01:39:33.740
<v Marcia Langton>with campaigning for nothing.

1468
01:39:33.880 --> 01:39:37.060
<v Marcia Langton>So until political parties get really fair dinkum

1469
01:39:37.060 --> 01:39:38.340
<v Marcia Langton>about, um...

1470
01:39:39.320 --> 01:39:43.180
<v Marcia Langton>..looking at ways in which they can incorporate Indigenous people

1471
01:39:43.180 --> 01:39:45.040
<v Marcia Langton>throughout, um...

1472
01:39:45.040 --> 01:39:46.300
<v Marcia Langton>..their political ranks,

1473
01:39:46.520 --> 01:39:48.360
<v Marcia Langton>then we still sit...

1474
01:39:49.660 --> 01:39:51.140
<v Marcia Langton>..sit on the edges.

1475
01:39:51.140 --> 01:39:55.440
<v Marcia Langton>We're still very much the fringe dwellers in our society.

1476
01:39:55.660 --> 01:39:58.440
<v Marcia Langton>And I would love to see, before I die,

1477
01:39:58.680 --> 01:40:01.220
<v Marcia Langton>an Aboriginal woman even in the federal parliament.

1478
01:40:01.500 --> 01:40:02.720
<v Marcia Langton>That's how bad it is.

1479
01:40:02.920 --> 01:40:06.020
<v Marcia Langton>And I'm not planning to leave this earth for another 40 years or so.

1480
01:40:06.960 --> 01:40:08.280
<v Marcia Langton>So it better happen quick.

1481
01:40:11.920 --> 01:40:18.260
<v Phillip Adams>I've just been advised by the management of the Adelaide Town Hall

1482
01:40:18.260 --> 01:40:20.760
<v Phillip Adams>that they have a midnight booking for community singing.

1483
01:40:21.340 --> 01:40:24.320
<v Phillip Adams>And they have to power the organ up, so we've got to go.

1484
01:40:24.740 --> 01:40:26.740
<v Phillip Adams>So one final question.

1485
01:40:26.880 --> 01:40:27.160
<v Phillip Adams>Sir?

1486
01:40:29.440 --> 01:40:30.780
<v Speaker 17>I'm sorry about this.

1487
01:40:31.000 --> 01:40:34.500
<v Speaker 17>I do abhor people who are asked for a question

1488
01:40:34.500 --> 01:40:35.760
<v Speaker 17>and they get up and make a statement.

1489
01:40:36.060 --> 01:40:38.160
<v Speaker 17>I'm afraid I'll have to make a statement first.

1490
01:40:38.500 --> 01:40:40.260
<v Phillip Adams>You don't feel like sitting down now, do you?

1491
01:40:40.520 --> 01:40:41.800
<v Speaker 17>No. No, thank you.

1492
01:40:41.920 --> 01:40:43.540
<v Speaker 17>I'll have to go on with this.

1493
01:40:43.780 --> 01:40:47.520
<v Speaker 17>But I usually don't get up like this

1494
01:40:47.520 --> 01:40:50.740
<v Speaker 17>because it's a very difficult thing to talk to people about.

1495
01:40:50.740 --> 01:40:51.680
<v Speaker 17>I'm afraid I'll have to go off the cuff.

1496
01:40:51.860 --> 01:40:54.840
<v Speaker 17>But when I was emboldened by this young man

1497
01:40:54.840 --> 01:40:56.900
<v Speaker 17>who got up and talked about land rent,

1498
01:40:57.860 --> 01:41:02.740
<v Speaker 17>and I realised there is a very simple way of doing all this business,

1499
01:41:02.860 --> 01:41:04.520
<v Speaker 17>and I'm going to ask you a question in a minute,

1500
01:41:05.300 --> 01:41:08.600
<v Speaker 17>but I realised there's a story about a man

1501
01:41:08.600 --> 01:41:10.520
<v Speaker 17>who was walking across a field in England.

1502
01:41:11.260 --> 01:41:12.780
<v Speaker 17>And someone came up and said,

1503
01:41:12.940 --> 01:41:17.420
<v Speaker 17>hey, you're trespassing here, this is my land, and you get off.

1504
01:41:17.620 --> 01:41:20.320
<v Speaker 17>And he said, how does it become your land?

1505
01:41:20.740 --> 01:41:23.180
<v Speaker 17>He said, well, my great-great-grandfather

1506
01:41:23.180 --> 01:41:25.360
<v Speaker 17>fought with William the Conqueror,

1507
01:41:25.360 --> 01:41:27.560
<v Speaker 17>and he fought here and fought for this land,

1508
01:41:27.660 --> 01:41:29.280
<v Speaker 17>and he said, and that's how I own it.

1509
01:41:29.660 --> 01:41:31.960
<v Speaker 17>The man said, well, if that's the way you get tied to the land,

1510
01:41:32.000 --> 01:41:35.940
<v Speaker 17>he said, take off your coat, he said, and I'll fight you for it.

1511
01:41:36.480 --> 01:41:39.480
<v Speaker 17>That might be a funny statement,

1512
01:41:39.540 --> 01:41:40.760
<v Speaker 17>but this is exactly...

1513
01:41:40.760 --> 01:41:45.360
<v Speaker 17>When the British came out here, when they settled South Australia,

1514
01:41:45.580 --> 01:41:48.700
<v Speaker 17>they were told not to take the land from the Aborigines,

1515
01:41:49.400 --> 01:41:50.720
<v Speaker 17>but to bring it back.

1516
01:41:50.740 --> 01:41:51.480
<v Speaker 17>They were told to buy it from them,

1517
01:41:52.100 --> 01:41:54.140
<v Speaker 17>and if they didn't want to sell it,

1518
01:41:54.180 --> 01:41:58.660
<v Speaker 17>they were not supposed to take it from them.

1519
01:41:58.780 --> 01:42:02.660
<v Speaker 17>But if they weren't using the land, or if they weren't enjoying it,

1520
01:42:02.800 --> 01:42:04.260
<v Speaker 17>well, then it was OK to buy it.

1521
01:42:04.320 --> 01:42:07.840
<v Speaker 17>Well, this is the terrible sin we committed

1522
01:42:07.840 --> 01:42:10.740
<v Speaker 17>when we sold the land into private enterprise.

1523
01:42:11.160 --> 01:42:13.060
<v Speaker 17>Now, there's a...

1524
01:42:15.340 --> 01:42:17.040
<v Phillip Adams>Is there a question here, sir?

1525
01:42:17.080 --> 01:42:19.880
<v Speaker 17>Yes, I will. I'm sorry about this, sir.

1526
01:42:21.000 --> 01:42:22.360
<v Speaker 17>But I have to...

1527
01:42:22.360 --> 01:42:24.260
<v Speaker 17>Now I've started, I must finish.

1528
01:42:25.660 --> 01:42:27.580
<v Phillip Adams>All those in favour of him finishing.

1529
01:42:30.600 --> 01:42:32.380
<v Phillip Adams>You've won the vote. It's OK.

1530
01:42:32.740 --> 01:42:36.360
<v Speaker 17>Well, now I've lost the thread now, so...

1531
01:42:36.360 --> 01:42:37.580
<v Speaker 17>It's your fault.

1532
01:42:38.880 --> 01:42:39.880
<v Speaker 17>There is...

1533
01:42:42.480 --> 01:42:43.520
<v Speaker 17>When they...

1534
01:42:43.520 --> 01:42:48.480
<v Speaker 17>And, of course, I saw that Samuel Harris had a thing in the paper once,

1535
01:42:48.540 --> 01:42:49.240
<v Speaker 17>an article,

1536
01:42:49.240 --> 01:42:51.940
<v Speaker 17>about 25 years ago when they came here

1537
01:42:51.940 --> 01:42:54.060
<v Speaker 17>and they talked about selling the land,

1538
01:42:54.140 --> 01:42:55.460
<v Speaker 17>the Aborigines will sell it.

1539
01:42:55.500 --> 01:42:58.300
<v Speaker 17>Well, the Aborigines had no more right to sell the land

1540
01:42:58.300 --> 01:43:00.060
<v Speaker 17>than anyone else has to sell it.

1541
01:43:00.540 --> 01:43:04.240
<v Speaker 17>No one generation should sell the land in perpetuity.

1542
01:43:05.140 --> 01:43:07.240
<v Speaker 17>Now, if you're a Christian, you can find...

1543
01:43:07.240 --> 01:43:10.440
<v Phillip Adams>I think your career in real estate sits oddly with this statement.

1544
01:43:12.160 --> 01:43:15.260
<v Speaker 17>As a matter of fact, the real estate people are against me, of course.

1545
01:43:15.680 --> 01:43:17.060
<v Speaker 17>That's why I don't get anywhere.

1546
01:43:17.800 --> 01:43:18.280
<v Speaker 17>But...

1547
01:43:18.960 --> 01:43:22.180
<v Speaker 17>There was a man, an economist...

1548
01:43:22.180 --> 01:43:24.280
<v Speaker 17>Oh, incidentally, the whole world...

1549
01:43:25.280 --> 01:43:28.180
<v Phillip Adams>Ladies and gentlemen, sorry, we have to wind it up.

1550
01:43:28.500 --> 01:43:30.260
<v Speaker 17>Give me one minute more.

1551
01:43:30.260 --> 01:43:32.140
<v Phillip Adams>Come round and tell us about it later privately.

1552
01:43:32.320 --> 01:43:34.740
<v Speaker 17>No, look, I must make my punchline.

1553
01:43:35.600 --> 01:43:36.880
<v Speaker 17>Oh, there's a punchline.

1554
01:43:37.240 --> 01:43:41.200
<v Speaker 17>Yes, the whole world is owned by 5% of the people.

1555
01:43:41.640 --> 01:43:44.080
<v Speaker 17>And there's no valid title to land.

1556
01:43:44.400 --> 01:43:45.940
<v Speaker 17>It's unconstitutional.

1557
01:43:46.260 --> 01:43:48.180
<v Speaker 17>And there was a man in America,

1558
01:43:48.280 --> 01:43:50.400
<v Speaker 17>Henry George, 150 years ago,

1559
01:43:50.500 --> 01:43:53.820
<v Speaker 17>who wrote a book and explained exactly how you could cure.

1560
01:43:53.960 --> 01:43:56.920
<v Speaker 17>Now, I think if all these gentlemen who are in Parliament...

1561
01:43:56.920 --> 01:43:58.560
<v Speaker 17>Thank you very much for the Boyer Lecture.

1562
01:43:58.640 --> 01:43:59.620
<v Speaker 17>Ladies and gentlemen...

1563
01:43:59.620 --> 01:44:00.360
<v Speaker 17>They could cure it in no time.

1564
01:44:00.620 --> 01:44:01.820
<v Phillip Adams>We have to wind it up.

1565
01:44:03.220 --> 01:44:03.660
<v Phillip Adams>APPLAUSE

1566
01:44:10.220 --> 01:44:12.300
<v Phillip Adams>And, look, thank you.

1567
01:44:12.300 --> 01:44:13.240
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, Sir Ronald.

1568
01:44:13.360 --> 01:44:14.040
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, panel.

1569
01:44:14.180 --> 01:44:15.140
<v Phillip Adams>You've all been marvellous.

1570
01:44:15.160 --> 01:44:16.280
<v Phillip Adams>Thank you, audience, for coming.

1571
01:44:16.420 --> 01:44:18.260
<v Phillip Adams>And have a great time at the...

1572
01:44:18.260 --> 01:44:19.500
<v Phillip Adams>The Festival of Ideas.

1573
01:44:19.960 --> 01:44:20.460
<v Phillip Adams>APPLAUSE

