WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.420
<v Doug McEachern>population and the question of population policy. It's been a commonplace in recent years for people

2
00:00:08.420 --> 00:00:14.760
<v Doug McEachern>to observe that Australia is a population policy free zone. It's an issue that governments may

3
00:00:14.760 --> 00:00:19.680
<v Doug McEachern>occasionally gesture towards but would never want to embrace or would certainly never want

4
00:00:19.680 --> 00:00:25.240
<v Doug McEachern>to encourage a deep public debate about the composition, size and character of our population.

5
00:00:26.160 --> 00:00:30.900
<v Doug McEachern>And looking back at Australia's history, we can take the view that this is a country which has

6
00:00:30.900 --> 00:00:38.400
<v Doug McEachern>either always had a population policy or has never had a population policy. In the always

7
00:00:38.400 --> 00:00:44.700
<v Doug McEachern>population policy line comes from the very act of colonisation, the transplanting of a population

8
00:00:44.700 --> 00:00:48.680
<v Doug McEachern>from one part of the world to another part of the world with the inevitable consequences that it has

9
00:00:48.680 --> 00:00:53.460
<v Doug McEachern>on those who lived there before and on the environment in which they will be.

10
00:00:54.740 --> 00:00:55.220
<v Doug McEachern>So, I'm going to go back to the question of population policy.

11
00:00:55.220 --> 00:01:01.620
<v Doug McEachern>The Federation and the debate surrounding Federation, of course, are linked to the invention of a clear

12
00:01:01.620 --> 00:01:08.400
<v Doug McEachern>statement of a population policy which has in recent years not only fallen from favour but now

13
00:01:08.400 --> 00:01:14.380
<v Doug McEachern>been relegated as something not worthy of note when reflecting back on the history of Federation

14
00:01:14.380 --> 00:01:17.200
<v Doug McEachern>and how Australia came into the world as a nation.

15
00:01:18.960 --> 00:01:24.660
<v Doug McEachern>On the side of the we've never got around to a population policy is the frequent

16
00:01:26.900 --> 00:01:32.780
<v Doug McEachern>call, certainly since the 1890s through to the present day, that we need to have a population policy.

17
00:01:33.700 --> 00:01:39.560
<v Doug McEachern>We need to have a public debate on these questions. So today we've got an opportunity to start

18
00:01:39.560 --> 00:01:45.600
<v Doug McEachern>considering what the framework of an argument about population policy for Australia might be like.

19
00:01:45.800 --> 00:01:53.620
<v Doug McEachern>It's one of the key themes of this Festival of Ideas culminating in the Sunday night session on the 21st century.

20
00:01:53.620 --> 00:02:01.320
<v Doug McEachern>Now to kick us off today we have Alison McKinnon. Alison McKinnon is the Professor of History and Gender Studies

21
00:02:01.320 --> 00:02:06.800
<v Doug McEachern>at the University of South Australia and she is the Foundation Director of the Hawke Institute

22
00:02:06.800 --> 00:02:14.080
<v Doug McEachern>which has played such a significant part in engendering debate about a whole range of sensitive public issues

23
00:02:14.080 --> 00:02:21.260
<v Doug McEachern>in Adelaide with a much wider impact in the nation. And I invite her to open this discussion on Populate or Perish,

24
00:02:21.300 --> 00:02:23.500
<v Doug McEachern>the Population Policy Imperative.

25
00:02:29.480 --> 00:02:36.620
<v Alison McKinnon>Thank you Doug and I'm most delighted to see such a large population here to consider this question.

26
00:02:36.960 --> 00:02:43.520
<v Alison McKinnon>And I think probably I'm going first because I'm a historian and we will start from the past.

27
00:02:43.740 --> 00:02:50.340
<v Alison McKinnon>It's really fascinating that we're here talking about an issue that has been so significant throughout Australian history.

28
00:02:50.520 --> 00:02:53.600
<v Alison McKinnon>Indeed was one of the major questions around about the period of the 19th century.

29
00:02:53.620 --> 00:02:57.920
<v Alison McKinnon>The period of Federation. What sort of policy, what sort of population should we have?

30
00:02:58.060 --> 00:03:06.020
<v Alison McKinnon>And of course as we all know to our sorrow, the White Australia population was, sorry the White Australia policy

31
00:03:06.620 --> 00:03:12.900
<v Alison McKinnon>was a key element of Federation. But we have come a very long way since then.

32
00:03:13.660 --> 00:03:22.840
<v Alison McKinnon>I think that the whole question of population is a really fascinating and difficult one because it's in that area

33
00:03:22.840 --> 00:03:31.380
<v Alison McKinnon>of population policy that we have an intersection now of three major issues in contemporary society.

34
00:03:32.000 --> 00:03:39.380
<v Alison McKinnon>One of those major issues is that of low fertility, particularly in the developed world.

35
00:03:39.480 --> 00:03:44.560
<v Alison McKinnon>Although increasingly in some parts, some I mention, of the developing world.

36
00:03:44.800 --> 00:03:52.000
<v Alison McKinnon>So there's low fertility, increasing movements of people, huge amounts of people movement,

37
00:03:52.000 --> 00:03:59.720
<v Alison McKinnon>immigration across the world and interesting debates therefore as people move of national identity.

38
00:04:00.200 --> 00:04:08.740
<v Alison McKinnon>So we have there in that mix of low fertility, high levels of people movement and questions of national identity,

39
00:04:08.940 --> 00:04:16.140
<v Alison McKinnon>a very, very volatile mix. Hence I think we need to look at this question very carefully.

40
00:04:17.640 --> 00:04:21.980
<v Alison McKinnon>Well as Doug said, over the last few decades most women have been

41
00:04:21.980 --> 00:04:25.700
<v Alison McKinnon>in Western countries have been very wary about population policies.

42
00:04:26.300 --> 00:04:33.140
<v Alison McKinnon>They have been seen as too sensitive, as intruding into people's rights, even into the bedrooms of the nation.

43
00:04:34.160 --> 00:04:37.660
<v Alison McKinnon>We may have had an immigration policy on the one hand.

44
00:04:38.680 --> 00:04:45.320
<v Alison McKinnon>We may have had even the beginnings of an environmental policy, although probably Tim might dispute that.

45
00:04:45.520 --> 00:04:49.840
<v Alison McKinnon>But the thought of a population policy which brings together all these elements

46
00:04:49.840 --> 00:04:52.520
<v Alison McKinnon>has been seen as thoroughly tricky.

47
00:04:53.820 --> 00:05:00.020
<v Alison McKinnon>It was suggested some time ago as labour policy by the courageous Barry Jones.

48
00:05:00.600 --> 00:05:09.300
<v Alison McKinnon>But his suggestions attracted almost as much ridicule as his recently released diagram about Knowledge Nation.

49
00:05:11.480 --> 00:05:16.340
<v Alison McKinnon>The term, I'm a historian of women's lives.

50
00:05:16.640 --> 00:05:19.820
<v Alison McKinnon>And I have to say, the term population policy is a very, very important term.

51
00:05:19.840 --> 00:05:23.480
<v Alison McKinnon>And I think it's important to note that the term population policy has had rather sinister overtones for women.

52
00:05:23.600 --> 00:05:27.220
<v Alison McKinnon>As it's usually meant, have more babies.

53
00:05:28.760 --> 00:05:32.100
<v Alison McKinnon>Or put it in other terms, nation building.

54
00:05:32.380 --> 00:05:37.200
<v Alison McKinnon>This term nation building is another one that many women might well be suspicious of.

55
00:05:37.300 --> 00:05:44.640
<v Alison McKinnon>To historians, nation building conjures up men going up and fighting, going off and fighting, women having more babies.

56
00:05:45.820 --> 00:05:49.160
<v Alison McKinnon>And it's always had equally sinister racial overtones.

57
00:05:49.840 --> 00:05:56.080
<v Alison McKinnon>From the well-known white Australia policy to the fact that it has been white births that have been encouraged

58
00:05:56.080 --> 00:06:01.440
<v Alison McKinnon>while those of the indigenous population have for most of our time been discouraged.

59
00:06:02.000 --> 00:06:08.100
<v Alison McKinnon>Throughout most of Australia's history, women, white women in particular, have been constantly urged to have more babies

60
00:06:08.100 --> 00:06:15.520
<v Alison McKinnon>apart from the short period of the baby boom, 1946 to 61, when they seemed to need no urging.

61
00:06:16.260 --> 00:06:18.740
<v Alison McKinnon>But that boom, as we have now seen,

62
00:06:19.840 --> 00:06:27.860
<v Alison McKinnon>was in fact a peculiar little blip in the general sort of downturn of fertility since the 1880s.

63
00:06:30.260 --> 00:06:35.640
<v Alison McKinnon>Fertility now has fallen below replacement level and has been for 20 years.

64
00:06:35.900 --> 00:06:44.260
<v Alison McKinnon>As many of you will be aware, the average birth rate of 1.76 children per woman is well below replacement.

65
00:06:45.560 --> 00:06:48.300
<v Alison McKinnon>It's actually 1.65 in cities,

66
00:06:48.300 --> 00:06:55.160
<v Alison McKinnon>and some demographers predict that it will fall to 1.5 by 2050.

67
00:06:56.000 --> 00:06:57.320
<v Alison McKinnon>Now does this matter?

68
00:06:58.400 --> 00:07:01.140
<v Alison McKinnon>This of course is the heart of the issue.

69
00:07:01.220 --> 00:07:01.820
<v Alison McKinnon>Does it matter?

70
00:07:02.280 --> 00:07:05.280
<v Alison McKinnon>But just before we come back to whether it matters,

71
00:07:06.900 --> 00:07:08.720
<v Alison McKinnon>let's look at what happened in the past,

72
00:07:08.880 --> 00:07:11.740
<v Alison McKinnon>when indeed there were those same fears.

73
00:07:11.920 --> 00:07:17.160
<v Alison McKinnon>It is a constant in Western societies, this fear of fertility decline.

74
00:07:17.160 --> 00:07:24.460
<v Alison McKinnon>Or to be specific, fear of fertility decline in certain groups of people, not in others.

75
00:07:26.900 --> 00:07:32.240
<v Alison McKinnon>After the 1903 Royal Commission entered the decline in the birth rate,

76
00:07:32.480 --> 00:07:39.900
<v Alison McKinnon>women were accused of selfishness, self-indulgence, seeking pleasure rather than enjoying maternity.

77
00:07:40.460 --> 00:07:45.620
<v Alison McKinnon>Access to any form of family limitation, I have to say it was pretty primitive then,

78
00:07:45.620 --> 00:07:47.100
<v Alison McKinnon>was restricted.

79
00:07:48.040 --> 00:07:53.000
<v Alison McKinnon>And access to any chemical agents which might bring about abortions were cut back.

80
00:07:53.360 --> 00:07:58.960
<v Alison McKinnon>So there was a terrific fear at that time, women restricting their fertility.

81
00:07:59.640 --> 00:08:04.900
<v Alison McKinnon>And there have been several measures throughout the early part of the century.

82
00:08:04.940 --> 00:08:09.500
<v Alison McKinnon>The 1912 baby bonus to encourage women to have more babies.

83
00:08:11.000 --> 00:08:14.620
<v Alison McKinnon>And that was even at the time extended to unwedding.

84
00:08:15.620 --> 00:08:19.020
<v Alison McKinnon>And the idea of having more mothers, which was quite an extraordinary element

85
00:08:19.020 --> 00:08:21.800
<v Alison McKinnon>for the thinking of society at that time.

86
00:08:22.880 --> 00:08:32.240
<v Alison McKinnon>In 1946, the influential eugenicist, Victor Wallace, argued strongly in his book,

87
00:08:32.340 --> 00:08:35.920
<v Alison McKinnon>Women and Children First, for a whole raft of government interventions

88
00:08:35.920 --> 00:08:38.280
<v Alison McKinnon>to stimulate the white Australian birth rate.

89
00:08:39.480 --> 00:08:45.280
<v Alison McKinnon>He cited very approvingly the initiatives of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet

90
00:08:45.620 --> 00:08:50.560
<v Alison McKinnon>and the USSR, which paid state allowances to mothers of large families.

91
00:08:52.620 --> 00:08:53.980
<v Alison McKinnon>And awarded motherhood medals.

92
00:08:55.620 --> 00:08:57.780
<v Alison McKinnon>The orders of the glory of motherhood.

93
00:08:58.620 --> 00:09:00.900
<v Alison McKinnon>And the honorary title of mother heroine.

94
00:09:03.780 --> 00:09:09.060
<v Alison McKinnon>He did also suggest attracting immigrants from Britain and Scandinavia.

95
00:09:09.280 --> 00:09:12.600
<v Alison McKinnon>But feared there might not be enough surplus population.

96
00:09:14.060 --> 00:09:15.240
<v Alison McKinnon>Well, he said,

97
00:09:15.620 --> 00:09:18.280
<v Alison McKinnon>the surplus population exists in Southern Europe,

98
00:09:18.400 --> 00:09:22.880
<v Alison McKinnon>a part of the world from which quite definitely the most suitable immigrants are not obtained.

99
00:09:25.140 --> 00:09:29.420
<v Alison McKinnon>Well, of course, it's very typical of the Anglo-centric thinking of the time.

100
00:09:29.540 --> 00:09:31.000
<v Alison McKinnon>And of course, he was totally wrong.

101
00:09:31.360 --> 00:09:34.720
<v Alison McKinnon>And needless to say, many population forecasters are wrong.

102
00:09:36.320 --> 00:09:38.320
<v Alison McKinnon>Demographers didn't predict the baby boom.

103
00:09:39.060 --> 00:09:40.160
<v Alison McKinnon>They got that wrong.

104
00:09:41.100 --> 00:09:43.260
<v Alison McKinnon>Well, there were few heroine mothers.

105
00:09:43.260 --> 00:09:51.000
<v Alison McKinnon>Although I must admit there is one who's a regular columnist in the Australian op-ed pages that some of you might well read.

106
00:09:51.920 --> 00:09:57.940
<v Alison McKinnon>But immigration, rather than urging mothers to have more babies, became the order of the day for nation building.

107
00:09:58.460 --> 00:10:02.580
<v Alison McKinnon>So then it's not surprising that women are a little wary of population policies.

108
00:10:03.560 --> 00:10:08.800
<v Alison McKinnon>We might ask ourselves, as a population policy-gator, back to the kitchen, girls.

109
00:10:09.500 --> 00:10:11.700
<v Alison McKinnon>If the birth rates continue to decline.

110
00:10:11.700 --> 00:10:16.660
<v Alison McKinnon>But they are not, of course, yet at the level of countries like Spain, Italy and Japan,

111
00:10:17.000 --> 00:10:20.700
<v Alison McKinnon>where the replacement rate is down to 1.2.

112
00:10:21.760 --> 00:10:27.080
<v Alison McKinnon>No doubt we all remember the fuss when the then Premier of Victoria, Jeff Kennett,

113
00:10:27.160 --> 00:10:32.260
<v Alison McKinnon>chose to make certain remarks about falling fertility at an elite Melbourne girls' school.

114
00:10:32.880 --> 00:10:37.560
<v Alison McKinnon>This was very much interpreted as a little message for the girls.

115
00:10:37.900 --> 00:10:41.400
<v Alison McKinnon>But there's a lot more I'd like to say here about why.

116
00:10:41.700 --> 00:10:42.880
<v Alison McKinnon>Why that's happening.

117
00:10:42.960 --> 00:10:46.980
<v Alison McKinnon>But I'm going to talk about that in tomorrow's panel on gender and the population policy debate.

118
00:10:47.280 --> 00:10:49.700
<v Alison McKinnon>But just to come back to the question about falling fertility.

119
00:10:50.040 --> 00:10:50.980
<v Alison McKinnon>Does it matter?

120
00:10:52.020 --> 00:10:54.440
<v Alison McKinnon>Well, yes, I think it does matter, actually.

121
00:10:55.040 --> 00:11:01.960
<v Alison McKinnon>As our population actually declines, or fertility declines, the population isn't yet declining,

122
00:11:02.620 --> 00:11:06.920
<v Alison McKinnon>we'll have to either embrace a small and rapidly ageing population.

123
00:11:08.220 --> 00:11:11.160
<v Alison McKinnon>Indeed, we're facing that in South Australia right now.

124
00:11:11.160 --> 00:11:14.960
<v Alison McKinnon>We have the most ageing and shrinking population of any Australian state.

125
00:11:16.420 --> 00:11:22.000
<v Alison McKinnon>Or else we're going to have to increase immigration to much higher levels than we have now.

126
00:11:23.120 --> 00:11:26.220
<v Alison McKinnon>Now, many of us would favour that.

127
00:11:26.460 --> 00:11:29.400
<v Alison McKinnon>Indeed, we are a country based around immigration.

128
00:11:29.900 --> 00:11:32.640
<v Alison McKinnon>A quarter of us probably were born elsewhere.

129
00:11:33.100 --> 00:11:38.980
<v Alison McKinnon>But if we increase the numbers of immigrants at vastly larger numbers,

130
00:11:38.980 --> 00:11:45.200
<v Alison McKinnon>we are also going to have to make sure we have all the policies in place to ensure social cohesion.

131
00:11:46.520 --> 00:11:52.040
<v Alison McKinnon>Because we have seen in other parts of the world where immigration increases very rapidly,

132
00:11:52.240 --> 00:12:00.680
<v Alison McKinnon>that sometimes those countries don't deal with bringing those people into full citizenship rapidly enough.

133
00:12:02.380 --> 00:12:05.500
<v Alison McKinnon>Who will these increasing numbers of immigrants be?

134
00:12:05.660 --> 00:12:06.680
<v Alison McKinnon>Where will they come from?

135
00:12:06.820 --> 00:12:08.840
<v Alison McKinnon>There's going to be extreme competition.

136
00:12:08.980 --> 00:12:10.660
<v Alison McKinnon>There's going to be a lot of competition for skilled immigrants.

137
00:12:11.680 --> 00:12:17.060
<v Alison McKinnon>All around the world in Western countries where population numbers are declining.

138
00:12:18.500 --> 00:12:27.160
<v Alison McKinnon>Yet, curiously, we're making things as difficult as possible for many skilled asylum seekers reaching our shores

139
00:12:27.160 --> 00:12:30.660
<v Alison McKinnon>who could make major contributions to our society.

140
00:12:32.140 --> 00:12:36.400
<v Alison McKinnon>So I guess I'd have to place myself as a moderate

141
00:12:36.400 --> 00:12:39.400
<v Alison McKinnon>in terms of all this population numbers debate.

142
00:12:39.520 --> 00:12:45.440
<v Alison McKinnon>I want to throw my opinion out here for discussion as I'm sure my fellow panellists will.

143
00:12:47.360 --> 00:12:53.380
<v Alison McKinnon>I don't agree with the position of some environmentalists, perhaps Tim is one,

144
00:12:53.520 --> 00:13:00.160
<v Alison McKinnon>who urge a very small population in the light of our fragile environment.

145
00:13:00.900 --> 00:13:04.800
<v Alison McKinnon>Nor do I agree with bodies such as the Business Council of Australia

146
00:13:04.800 --> 00:13:06.380
<v Alison McKinnon>which are pushing for really small populations.

147
00:13:06.380 --> 00:13:12.360
<v Alison McKinnon>Really large population increases of the measure of say 45 million or more.

148
00:13:12.740 --> 00:13:18.500
<v Alison McKinnon>I think that we're aiming for a kind of middle road of around 23 million

149
00:13:18.500 --> 00:13:23.680
<v Alison McKinnon>and that might achieve a population with a reasonable age structure,

150
00:13:23.900 --> 00:13:28.160
<v Alison McKinnon>a manageable immigration policy and environmental sustainability.

151
00:13:29.100 --> 00:13:32.000
<v Alison McKinnon>Although the latter will have to be very carefully managed.

152
00:13:32.120 --> 00:13:34.840
<v Alison McKinnon>I'm sure that will be very much part of our debate here.

153
00:13:36.380 --> 00:13:38.260
<v Alison McKinnon>So where are women in this equation?

154
00:13:39.120 --> 00:13:46.940
<v Alison McKinnon>I started off with that concern about population policies often having very specific meanings for women.

155
00:13:49.020 --> 00:13:57.400
<v Alison McKinnon>Part of our population policy I believe should include a range of innovative labour market solutions

156
00:13:58.380 --> 00:14:06.060
<v Alison McKinnon>which allow women who wish to combine motherhood with a job or with a career,

157
00:14:06.380 --> 00:14:07.760
<v Alison McKinnon>to do so.

158
00:14:09.080 --> 00:14:17.520
<v Alison McKinnon>As evidence from all around the world shows that if women are not able to combine the two,

159
00:14:17.740 --> 00:14:22.420
<v Alison McKinnon>they'll vote with their feet or their wombs you might say, and not have children.

160
00:14:23.060 --> 00:14:26.940
<v Alison McKinnon>And this is very much the pattern in countries like Italy

161
00:14:26.940 --> 00:14:32.220
<v Alison McKinnon>where there's little access to part-time work or to gender equity in the workplace.

162
00:14:32.940 --> 00:14:36.260
<v Alison McKinnon>Now I'm not arguing this because I'm a pro-natalist,

163
00:14:36.260 --> 00:14:38.980
<v Alison McKinnon>and I think we should be urging women to have more babies.

164
00:14:39.100 --> 00:14:39.940
<v Alison McKinnon>Far from it.

165
00:14:40.400 --> 00:14:44.200
<v Alison McKinnon>But I am concerned that there are many young women

166
00:14:45.160 --> 00:14:50.740
<v Alison McKinnon>who would perhaps like to have children or like to have more than one child

167
00:14:51.260 --> 00:14:58.360
<v Alison McKinnon>who find the pressures of a combination of work and family just too difficult in our society.

168
00:14:59.080 --> 00:15:03.160
<v Alison McKinnon>And there'll be more of that I'm sure in our gender and population panel tomorrow.

169
00:15:03.980 --> 00:15:05.380
<v Alison McKinnon>So I'm just saying,

170
00:15:05.380 --> 00:15:10.820
<v Alison McKinnon>let's bring all these elements back into the population policy debate

171
00:15:10.820 --> 00:15:16.160
<v Alison McKinnon>but in ways that are suited to the 21st century rather than the 19th.

172
00:15:16.180 --> 00:15:17.020
<v Alison McKinnon>Thank you.

173
00:15:19.640 --> 00:15:25.660
<v Doug McEachern>Thank you Alison.

174
00:15:26.360 --> 00:15:29.120
<v Doug McEachern>Our next speaker will be Fran Boehm

175
00:15:29.120 --> 00:15:32.800
<v Doug McEachern>who is head of the Department and Professor of Public Health at Flinders University.

176
00:15:33.700 --> 00:15:35.360
<v Doug McEachern>Fran has published a book called,

177
00:15:35.380 --> 00:15:39.440
<v Doug McEachern>Published extensively on a whole range of issues about the quality of life

178
00:15:39.440 --> 00:15:42.640
<v Doug McEachern>and the way in which the health system works

179
00:15:42.640 --> 00:15:47.220
<v Doug McEachern>and the distribution of the benefits or the limitations on access to that health system.

180
00:15:47.480 --> 00:15:50.800
<v Doug McEachern>And she has been an exemplary public intellectual in this particular role

181
00:15:51.460 --> 00:15:57.420
<v Doug McEachern>making quite clear the costs of various policy changes introduced by governments over a number of years.

182
00:15:57.700 --> 00:16:00.220
<v Doug McEachern>I'd like to invite her now to talk on this topic.

183
00:16:06.540 --> 00:16:08.760
<v Fran Baum>Thanks Doug and good morning everybody.

184
00:16:08.920 --> 00:16:11.560
<v Fran Baum>It's just fantastic to see so many of you here.

185
00:16:11.680 --> 00:16:13.220
<v Fran Baum>That's really, really wonderful.

186
00:16:14.580 --> 00:16:18.900
<v Fran Baum>I think there are a few other issues that really raise such strong opinions

187
00:16:18.900 --> 00:16:21.820
<v Fran Baum>as those that come up when we talk about population.

188
00:16:22.220 --> 00:16:27.220
<v Fran Baum>And I guess that isn't surprising because at the very heart of it are issues of life and death

189
00:16:27.220 --> 00:16:29.060
<v Fran Baum>and that gets us all going.

190
00:16:29.880 --> 00:16:34.660
<v Fran Baum>And it certainly hooks into our deepest prejudice when we start talking about population.

191
00:16:34.660 --> 00:16:40.400
<v Fran Baum>I think images abound of the hordes from Asia and Africa overrunning us,

192
00:16:40.400 --> 00:16:44.660
<v Fran Baum>of breeding masses in third world countries ensuring that our environment deteriorates

193
00:16:45.260 --> 00:16:49.100
<v Fran Baum>through their overpopulation as it is so often presented.

194
00:16:49.620 --> 00:16:54.200
<v Fran Baum>So it's very hard to consider this question of populating or perishing

195
00:16:54.200 --> 00:16:57.040
<v Fran Baum>without entering the realm of moral panics.

196
00:16:57.080 --> 00:17:01.020
<v Fran Baum>And I'm sure they're going to happen in the debates at this festival over the next few days.

197
00:17:01.300 --> 00:17:04.640
<v Fran Baum>So what I'd like to do is first of all just have a look at some of the issues

198
00:17:04.660 --> 00:17:05.960
<v Fran Baum>that have aroused some of those moral panics.

199
00:17:06.360 --> 00:17:10.960
<v Fran Baum>And then I'd like to argue that for me the issue isn't so much about population

200
00:17:10.960 --> 00:17:14.780
<v Fran Baum>or the exact number of people we had but how much we all consume

201
00:17:14.780 --> 00:17:16.480
<v Fran Baum>and that that's the critical issue.

202
00:17:16.720 --> 00:17:17.780
<v Fran Baum>And I'll argue that.

203
00:17:18.180 --> 00:17:23.640
<v Fran Baum>One of the first issues that very easily comes up and has been lurking in the corner of this debate

204
00:17:23.640 --> 00:17:25.800
<v Fran Baum>is the eugenics argument.

205
00:17:26.160 --> 00:17:31.540
<v Fran Baum>And we saw this very clearly in both Australia and Britain in the early part of the 20th century

206
00:17:31.540 --> 00:17:34.080
<v Fran Baum>when both countries held rule commissions

207
00:17:34.660 --> 00:17:38.380
<v Fran Baum>and the question of what then was seen as concern about falling fertility,

208
00:17:38.740 --> 00:17:40.520
<v Fran Baum>particularly in the 1930s.

209
00:17:40.880 --> 00:17:45.640
<v Fran Baum>And the concern was expressed that the lower classes were outbreeding the higher classes.

210
00:17:45.920 --> 00:17:50.400
<v Fran Baum>And it was feared that this would lead to an overall reduction in the intelligence of the population

211
00:17:50.400 --> 00:17:53.880
<v Fran Baum>without any scientific foundation to that argument.

212
00:17:54.340 --> 00:17:59.080
<v Fran Baum>In the US we've seen similar genetic fears over the fact that African Americans

213
00:17:59.080 --> 00:18:01.980
<v Fran Baum>have a higher fertility rate than Anglo-Celtic Americans.

214
00:18:02.600 --> 00:18:04.560
<v Fran Baum>And in Singapore, for instance,

215
00:18:04.660 --> 00:18:08.480
<v Fran Baum>incentives have been offered to female graduates to encourage them to have children

216
00:18:08.480 --> 00:18:13.340
<v Fran Baum>on the belief that that would increase the overall intelligence level of the population.

217
00:18:13.780 --> 00:18:17.500
<v Fran Baum>So that eugenics strain has been very strong in these debates.

218
00:18:18.620 --> 00:18:20.740
<v Fran Baum>Similarly with the whole migration debate,

219
00:18:21.040 --> 00:18:24.880
<v Fran Baum>it's been full of moral panics and we've seen that in Australia in the last years.

220
00:18:25.200 --> 00:18:29.600
<v Fran Baum>The treatment of refugees in Australia through their incarceration in refugee camps

221
00:18:29.600 --> 00:18:32.520
<v Fran Baum>in remote and inhospitable areas of Australia

222
00:18:32.520 --> 00:18:34.640
<v Fran Baum>I think is fueled by fear.

223
00:18:34.660 --> 00:18:36.500
<v Fran Baum>Fears of the hordes overrunning us,

224
00:18:36.640 --> 00:18:38.940
<v Fran Baum>of the unknown seeking to rip us off,

225
00:18:39.040 --> 00:18:39.900
<v Fran Baum>take our benefits,

226
00:18:40.220 --> 00:18:42.780
<v Fran Baum>jump ahead of us in the queue for life's resources,

227
00:18:43.060 --> 00:18:44.980
<v Fran Baum>whether that's jobs, houses or education.

228
00:18:45.720 --> 00:18:49.280
<v Fran Baum>And I think it's astounding that in the 21st century in Australia

229
00:18:49.280 --> 00:18:52.860
<v Fran Baum>we have political leaders who can so readily pursue policies

230
00:18:52.860 --> 00:18:55.840
<v Fran Baum>contrary to UN conventions on the treatment of refugees.

231
00:19:00.320 --> 00:19:03.220
<v Fran Baum>But in having said that about our leaders,

232
00:19:03.340 --> 00:19:04.640
<v Fran Baum>we have to recognize that it is

233
00:19:04.660 --> 00:19:05.940
<v Fran Baum>popular with the voters.

234
00:19:06.240 --> 00:19:08.060
<v Fran Baum>Lock them up and throw away the key

235
00:19:08.060 --> 00:19:11.280
<v Fran Baum>is the next best option to sending them back where they come from.

236
00:19:11.900 --> 00:19:16.540
<v Fran Baum>And migration has traditionally been an important tool of population policy for Australia

237
00:19:16.540 --> 00:19:19.100
<v Fran Baum>and it will continue to be so in the future.

238
00:19:19.280 --> 00:19:23.620
<v Fran Baum>And better public policy would result if there were less moral panic about those issues

239
00:19:23.620 --> 00:19:27.340
<v Fran Baum>from the population, from politicians and sections of the public.

240
00:19:27.500 --> 00:19:28.840
<v Fran Baum>But again, another moral panic.

241
00:19:29.560 --> 00:19:32.960
<v Fran Baum>And fertility, as Alison's already said, is another area

242
00:19:32.960 --> 00:19:35.620
<v Fran Baum>where it's full of moral imperatives.

243
00:19:35.900 --> 00:19:40.720
<v Fran Baum>The dictate to have children has traditionally been a crucial message in a pro-natalist society.

244
00:19:41.360 --> 00:19:44.180
<v Fran Baum>But of course that was only the case if you're in a stable,

245
00:19:44.340 --> 00:19:48.240
<v Fran Baum>two-parent, heterosexual couple who could afford to support children.

246
00:19:48.620 --> 00:19:52.440
<v Fran Baum>Beyond that, there are many mixed messages about fertility and parenthood.

247
00:19:52.620 --> 00:19:55.780
<v Fran Baum>Just to give you some examples, I mean, I noticed the two-edged sword

248
00:19:55.780 --> 00:19:58.620
<v Fran Baum>as a person who has chosen not to have any birth children.

249
00:19:59.220 --> 00:20:02.900
<v Fran Baum>Parents generally let you know that you're missing out on one of the best experiences

250
00:20:02.960 --> 00:20:03.660
<v Fran Baum>in life.

251
00:20:04.240 --> 00:20:08.760
<v Fran Baum>There's often a sort of sanctimoniousness about that they've meant sacrifices

252
00:20:08.760 --> 00:20:11.640
<v Fran Baum>but they've been worth every sacrifice I have made.

253
00:20:12.500 --> 00:20:15.060
<v Fran Baum>But then there's another element to their reaction,

254
00:20:15.260 --> 00:20:18.400
<v Fran Baum>a sort of resentment that I feel that I've been a draft dodger.

255
00:20:18.460 --> 00:20:21.660
<v Fran Baum>I haven't quite done my duty or my bit in not being a parent.

256
00:20:22.020 --> 00:20:23.540
<v Fran Baum>I've escaped the penalties.

257
00:20:24.340 --> 00:20:28.820
<v Fran Baum>But then there are the parents who, as the conversation continues, eventually say,

258
00:20:29.000 --> 00:20:31.200
<v Fran Baum>well, I can understand your decision.

259
00:20:31.420 --> 00:20:32.400
<v Fran Baum>Don't get me wrong.

260
00:20:32.520 --> 00:20:32.940
<v Fran Baum>I love my children.

261
00:20:32.960 --> 00:20:36.940
<v Fran Baum>But if I had my time again, I would think twice about having them.

262
00:20:37.060 --> 00:20:37.900
<v Fran Baum>Have you heard that one?

263
00:20:38.560 --> 00:20:42.420
<v Fran Baum>And in fact, many people these days, for the reasons Alison's talked about,

264
00:20:42.520 --> 00:20:44.340
<v Fran Baum>are thinking twice about having children.

265
00:20:44.580 --> 00:20:49.240
<v Fran Baum>And that's why many are having less children or not choosing to have them at all.

266
00:20:50.020 --> 00:20:52.900
<v Fran Baum>So let's think about the future of South Australia.

267
00:20:53.160 --> 00:20:56.660
<v Fran Baum>Now, we've thought about some of the moral panics behind this debate.

268
00:20:57.240 --> 00:20:59.460
<v Fran Baum>What should our population future be?

269
00:20:59.720 --> 00:21:00.960
<v Fran Baum>Should we populate more?

270
00:21:00.960 --> 00:21:03.160
<v Fran Baum>If we don't, will we perish?

271
00:21:03.720 --> 00:21:07.480
<v Fran Baum>Or does the route of populating more inevitably lead to our demise?

272
00:21:08.200 --> 00:21:10.900
<v Fran Baum>And what if we say, well, we do want an increased population?

273
00:21:11.520 --> 00:21:12.900
<v Fran Baum>How could we bring that about?

274
00:21:13.080 --> 00:21:13.880
<v Fran Baum>How would we do it?

275
00:21:14.760 --> 00:21:20.120
<v Fran Baum>Well, at the moment, there's about 1.5 million of us, and 1.1 of us live in Adelaide.

276
00:21:20.160 --> 00:21:23.740
<v Fran Baum>And I think we're one of the most urbanized societies on earth, probably.

277
00:21:24.120 --> 00:21:28.920
<v Fran Baum>And our population will go on increasing slightly till about for the next 20 years.

278
00:21:29.120 --> 00:21:30.700
<v Fran Baum>And then it will begin to decline.

279
00:21:30.700 --> 00:21:34.920
<v Fran Baum>So that by mid-century, there will be something like 1.4 million.

280
00:21:35.000 --> 00:21:37.880
<v Fran Baum>So we'll have dropped by something like just under 100,000.

281
00:21:38.960 --> 00:21:42.900
<v Fran Baum>Now, if we wanted to increase our population, we could do that by increasing fertility,

282
00:21:43.820 --> 00:21:47.700
<v Fran Baum>decreasing death rates, or increasing inward migration.

283
00:21:48.340 --> 00:21:49.460
<v Fran Baum>But what do we want?

284
00:21:49.580 --> 00:21:50.300
<v Fran Baum>What are the future?

285
00:21:50.580 --> 00:21:56.260
<v Fran Baum>And just what I want to do is look at the sort of option of declining population

286
00:21:56.260 --> 00:22:00.620
<v Fran Baum>and then look at an alternative option that I think is probably preferable.

287
00:22:01.060 --> 00:22:05.780
<v Fran Baum>So if our current trends continue, we'll have a slow decline over the next century.

288
00:22:06.080 --> 00:22:10.200
<v Fran Baum>So what would it be like living in a South Australia where we're on average getting older,

289
00:22:10.400 --> 00:22:12.580
<v Fran Baum>where there are less and less people under 25?

290
00:22:12.920 --> 00:22:16.940
<v Fran Baum>And I do remark it might be like being at the Festival of Ideas.

291
00:22:17.040 --> 00:22:19.040
<v Fran Baum>How many people here are under 25?

292
00:22:20.340 --> 00:22:20.780
<v Fran Baum>Okay.

293
00:22:21.120 --> 00:22:25.180
<v Fran Baum>I think you're not represented as much as you are in the general population,

294
00:22:25.380 --> 00:22:26.780
<v Fran Baum>but well done for being here.

295
00:22:26.860 --> 00:22:29.340
<v Fran Baum>And maybe you could bring some of your friends on the next few days.

296
00:22:29.460 --> 00:22:29.880
<v Fran Baum>.

297
00:22:29.880 --> 00:22:30.680
<v Fran Baum>.

298
00:22:30.700 --> 00:22:35.940
<v Fran Baum>Now, this is a situation that would be quite new to human experience to have an aging population.

299
00:22:36.440 --> 00:22:40.520
<v Fran Baum>In the past, population decline has tended to happen because of catastrophic events

300
00:22:40.520 --> 00:22:44.560
<v Fran Baum>such as earthquakes, volcanoes, or the onset of infectious diseases

301
00:22:44.560 --> 00:22:46.440
<v Fran Baum>such as the Black Death in the Middle Ages.

302
00:22:46.900 --> 00:22:50.200
<v Fran Baum>Now, my gut reaction is that it won't be a very exciting place to be.

303
00:22:50.480 --> 00:22:55.020
<v Fran Baum>Older people tend to be less innovative, more conservative, and less prone to risk-taking.

304
00:22:55.780 --> 00:22:56.920
<v Fran Baum>I'm being ageist.

305
00:22:56.960 --> 00:22:58.260
<v Fran Baum>I'm sorry, but that's what I think.

306
00:22:58.260 --> 00:23:00.500
<v Fran Baum>What would this mean for our economy?

307
00:23:00.780 --> 00:23:02.320
<v Fran Baum>What would it mean for our art scene?

308
00:23:02.600 --> 00:23:05.680
<v Fran Baum>A geriatric fringe festival might not be quite the same.

309
00:23:05.980 --> 00:23:06.420
<v Fran Baum>.

310
00:23:06.420 --> 00:23:10.420
<v Fran Baum>There would be less crime, as most people who commit crime are young.

311
00:23:10.540 --> 00:23:11.580
<v Fran Baum>Or would that be?

312
00:23:11.740 --> 00:23:15.940
<v Fran Baum>We might be able to close a prison or two because most of our prison population is under 25.

313
00:23:16.780 --> 00:23:20.160
<v Fran Baum>Some people suggested an aging population would mean a sicker population

314
00:23:20.160 --> 00:23:22.140
<v Fran Baum>because they'd use more health services.

315
00:23:22.440 --> 00:23:23.940
<v Fran Baum>But I don't know that that's the case.

316
00:23:24.200 --> 00:23:27.280
<v Fran Baum>Us baby boomers may turn out to be healthy as we age,

317
00:23:27.280 --> 00:23:31.760
<v Fran Baum>and in any case, most of us are heavy users of health services in our last year of life,

318
00:23:31.920 --> 00:23:33.480
<v Fran Baum>whether that's when we're 60 or 90.

319
00:23:34.420 --> 00:23:38.000
<v Fran Baum>And I think an aging South Australia would probably face a skills crisis,

320
00:23:38.260 --> 00:23:41.780
<v Fran Baum>particularly in the IT sector, because it's young people who gain the new skills,

321
00:23:41.940 --> 00:23:42.760
<v Fran Baum>the cutting-edge skills.

322
00:23:43.460 --> 00:23:47.460
<v Fran Baum>And while it's true that older people are less productive in the conventional economic sense

323
00:23:47.460 --> 00:23:49.600
<v Fran Baum>in terms of their contribution to the GMP,

324
00:23:49.940 --> 00:23:53.660
<v Fran Baum>things might change if we count their voluntary work, caring for grandchildren,

325
00:23:53.960 --> 00:23:55.560
<v Fran Baum>contribution to community life.

326
00:23:55.560 --> 00:24:01.920
<v Fran Baum>A positive aging scenario might be that South Australia could lead the world in terms of slow culture.

327
00:24:02.100 --> 00:24:08.620
<v Fran Baum>We'd concentrate on slow food, enhance our already world-class reputation for fine wines and foods.

328
00:24:08.840 --> 00:24:10.960
<v Fran Baum>Perhaps we could ban all fast food outlets.

329
00:24:11.900 --> 00:24:14.480
<v Fran Baum>We'd cultivate people like that.

330
00:24:16.220 --> 00:24:21.920
<v Fran Baum>We'd cultivate a slow pace of life, reduce working hours, increase the intensity of community life,

331
00:24:22.220 --> 00:24:25.540
<v Fran Baum>develop backyard gardens, cultivate arrangements,

332
00:24:25.540 --> 00:24:26.060
<v Fran Baum>and change of crops.

333
00:24:26.280 --> 00:24:29.800
<v Fran Baum>It occurred to me we could have dope for all for aging baby boomers.

334
00:24:31.820 --> 00:24:34.440
<v Fran Baum>But overall, I'm not sure it's that attractive.

335
00:24:35.360 --> 00:24:39.100
<v Fran Baum>And at the moment, I suppose it seems the most likely option.

336
00:24:39.500 --> 00:24:46.440
<v Fran Baum>But what would happen if a South Australian government really wanted to decide that

337
00:24:46.440 --> 00:24:48.380
<v Fran Baum>they wanted to increase the population?

338
00:24:48.640 --> 00:24:49.820
<v Fran Baum>How might we go about that?

339
00:24:50.220 --> 00:24:52.740
<v Fran Baum>Well, one thing you might want to do is increase fertility.

340
00:24:53.320 --> 00:24:55.480
<v Fran Baum>And the way that you might want to do that was by

341
00:24:55.540 --> 00:24:57.760
<v Fran Baum>making it more attractive for people to have children.

342
00:24:58.240 --> 00:25:02.320
<v Fran Baum>And I think you'd have to provide subsidies to people might be one possibility

343
00:25:02.320 --> 00:25:04.400
<v Fran Baum>to give an incentive for childbearing.

344
00:25:04.660 --> 00:25:08.480
<v Fran Baum>We'd certainly have to improve the social goods that people need to raise children.

345
00:25:08.700 --> 00:25:12.880
<v Fran Baum>Better childcare centres, stronger communities that are supportive of parents,

346
00:25:13.140 --> 00:25:16.960
<v Fran Baum>with lots of public space where people can gain social support and interact,

347
00:25:17.340 --> 00:25:22.740
<v Fran Baum>better parental leave positions, provisions, and world-class public schools,

348
00:25:22.980 --> 00:25:25.520
<v Fran Baum>and much more flexible working around that.

349
00:25:25.540 --> 00:25:27.800
<v Fran Baum>So without

350
00:25:41.560 --> 00:25:43.780
<v Fran Baum>if they came from countries with a lower standard of living.

351
00:25:44.200 --> 00:25:47.780
<v Fran Baum>And there are certainly more people applying to live in Australia than we currently accept.

352
00:25:48.320 --> 00:25:52.740
<v Fran Baum>The advantage is that we could attract bright young people in their mid to late 20s

353
00:25:52.740 --> 00:25:57.840
<v Fran Baum>who have the skills that we need, and we wouldn't even have to pay for the education to provide those skills.

354
00:25:58.760 --> 00:26:03.940
<v Fran Baum>But the difficulty might be keeping people away from the bright lights of Sydney and Melbourne once they get here.

355
00:26:04.240 --> 00:26:08.960
<v Fran Baum>So the challenge would be to make Adelaide a cool place that young people not just wanted to stay in,

356
00:26:08.960 --> 00:26:13.500
<v Fran Baum>but more positively, young people from interstate and South Australia wanted to come too.

357
00:26:14.220 --> 00:26:18.440
<v Fran Baum>And as far as I know, the last time that really happened was when Don Dunstan was in power.

358
00:26:18.600 --> 00:26:21.440
<v Fran Baum>And South Australia was the progressive state.

359
00:26:21.700 --> 00:26:26.720
<v Fran Baum>The place was changing fast, and young people from across Australia wanted to get in on the act.

360
00:26:27.120 --> 00:26:34.420
<v Fran Baum>So if we do want to increase our population a little, how can we recreate that sense of progress and excitement and change?

361
00:26:35.020 --> 00:26:38.660
<v Fran Baum>And I suggest that the way we might want to do that is by saying,

362
00:26:38.660 --> 00:26:43.940
<v Fran Baum>well, we could have a moderate increase in population if we learn to cut consumption of non-renewable resources.

363
00:26:44.680 --> 00:26:47.880
<v Fran Baum>So if we keep consuming, we will perish.

364
00:26:48.500 --> 00:26:54.400
<v Fran Baum>And I ask whether we could become the eco-state to which people around the world might flock.

365
00:26:54.720 --> 00:26:58.100
<v Fran Baum>And I'll just finish by making some comments about that.

366
00:26:58.640 --> 00:27:05.500
<v Fran Baum>We know that the ecological footstep of the average South Australian is far greater than at least four-fifths of the world's population.

367
00:27:06.520 --> 00:27:08.600
<v Fran Baum>Adelaide is a very sprawly and a very...

368
00:27:08.600 --> 00:27:08.640
<v Fran Baum>The ecological footstep of the average South Australian is far greater than at least four-fifths of the world's population.

369
00:27:08.660 --> 00:27:38.620
<v Fran Baum>And I ask whether we could make the ecological footstep of the average South Australian is far greater than at least four-fifths of the world's population.

370
00:27:48.260 --> 00:27:58.880
<v Fran Baum>So we could have a range of such ecological solutions.

371
00:27:59.120 --> 00:28:03.280
<v Fran Baum>We could develop model ecological industries and export our expertise.

372
00:28:03.800 --> 00:28:07.700
<v Fran Baum>Our tradition of radical and progressive social reform in South Australia

373
00:28:07.700 --> 00:28:08.640
<v Fran Baum>suggests that we need to build a more sustainable and sustainable economy.

374
00:28:08.640 --> 00:28:12.020
<v Fran Baum>that if any state is going to be able to be the ecological state,

375
00:28:12.180 --> 00:28:13.480
<v Fran Baum>then it should be South Australia.

376
00:28:14.440 --> 00:28:17.020
<v Fran Baum>Reducing our ecological footprint is quite possible

377
00:28:17.020 --> 00:28:19.300
<v Fran Baum>as long as there is the political will,

378
00:28:19.460 --> 00:28:20.840
<v Fran Baum>and I don't see that at the moment,

379
00:28:21.000 --> 00:28:22.760
<v Fran Baum>and popular support for it.

380
00:28:23.200 --> 00:28:24.800
<v Fran Baum>If we were able to do it,

381
00:28:24.840 --> 00:28:27.880
<v Fran Baum>then South Australia would once again be known for something positive.

382
00:28:28.240 --> 00:28:29.940
<v Fran Baum>Our energy-efficient industries,

383
00:28:30.780 --> 00:28:33.560
<v Fran Baum>our beautiful environment would be being enhanced.

384
00:28:33.900 --> 00:28:35.760
<v Fran Baum>Our stunning metropolitan coast,

385
00:28:35.760 --> 00:28:40.040
<v Fran Baum>coast restored from the vandals of the late 1990s and early 20th century.

386
00:28:40.200 --> 00:28:43.140
<v Fran Baum>If you want to see the vandalism, go to Glenelg and West Beach.

387
00:28:43.360 --> 00:28:44.860
<v Fran Baum>There's plenty of evidence of it there.

388
00:28:45.460 --> 00:28:49.160
<v Fran Baum>We'd have the smallest ecological footprint in the developed world.

389
00:28:49.480 --> 00:28:50.800
<v Fran Baum>We'd be known for it.

390
00:28:50.840 --> 00:28:51.980
<v Fran Baum>We'd be proud of it.

391
00:28:52.220 --> 00:28:55.260
<v Fran Baum>And just as people in the 1970s knew South Australia

392
00:28:55.260 --> 00:28:58.660
<v Fran Baum>stood for something positive, for excitement and change,

393
00:28:59.020 --> 00:29:01.380
<v Fran Baum>so could the South Australia of 2020.

394
00:29:02.080 --> 00:29:05.520
<v Fran Baum>If only we had the sense to increase our population

395
00:29:05.520 --> 00:29:05.740
<v Fran Baum>and increase our energy-efficient industries,

396
00:29:05.760 --> 00:29:06.300
<v Fran Baum>to increase our consumption a little,

397
00:29:06.460 --> 00:29:08.820
<v Fran Baum>but at the same time to reduce consumption

398
00:29:08.820 --> 00:29:12.080
<v Fran Baum>and make our state the ecological state.

399
00:29:12.320 --> 00:29:12.820
<v Fran Baum>Thank you.

400
00:29:14.040 --> 00:29:14.600
<v Fran Baum>APPLAUSE

401
00:29:25.880 --> 00:29:27.220
<v Doug McEachern>Thank you, Fran.

402
00:29:27.960 --> 00:29:30.200
<v Doug McEachern>I'd now like to welcome Tim Flannery,

403
00:29:31.180 --> 00:29:32.620
<v Doug McEachern>who has been very important,

404
00:29:32.880 --> 00:29:35.660
<v Doug McEachern>and a very important figure in the intellectual life

405
00:29:35.660 --> 00:29:36.000
<v Doug McEachern>of Australia,

406
00:29:37.300 --> 00:29:40.220
<v Doug McEachern>largely through his concerted attempts

407
00:29:40.220 --> 00:29:42.980
<v Doug McEachern>to make Australians aware of the interaction

408
00:29:42.980 --> 00:29:47.460
<v Doug McEachern>between human culture and the environments that sustain them.

409
00:29:48.560 --> 00:29:50.580
<v Doug McEachern>His book, The Future Eaters,

410
00:29:50.600 --> 00:29:52.320
<v Doug McEachern>is one of the most important landmarks

411
00:29:52.320 --> 00:29:53.360
<v Doug McEachern>in that particular debate,

412
00:29:54.300 --> 00:29:56.860
<v Doug McEachern>and his continual interrogation

413
00:29:56.860 --> 00:30:00.280
<v Doug McEachern>of that interaction between human culture and environment

414
00:30:00.280 --> 00:30:02.960
<v Doug McEachern>has been one of the works that has placed

415
00:30:02.960 --> 00:30:05.400
<v Doug McEachern>that question of population policy on the public.

416
00:30:05.400 --> 00:30:05.420
<v Doug McEachern>It's a very important issue,

417
00:30:05.420 --> 00:30:06.160
<v Doug McEachern>and it's a very important issue for the public policy agenda.

418
00:30:08.720 --> 00:30:11.420
<v Doug McEachern>I think South Australia has been remarkably lucky

419
00:30:11.420 --> 00:30:14.120
<v Doug McEachern>that Tim Flannery came here, liked what he saw,

420
00:30:14.880 --> 00:30:16.940
<v Doug McEachern>and wanted not only to work here,

421
00:30:17.020 --> 00:30:19.080
<v Doug McEachern>but also to live in South Australia.

422
00:30:19.800 --> 00:30:22.420
<v Doug McEachern>And his impact as director of the museum,

423
00:30:22.640 --> 00:30:24.340
<v Doug McEachern>South Australian Museum, has been enormous.

424
00:30:24.760 --> 00:30:27.440
<v Doug McEachern>I'd like to welcome him now to talk about an issue

425
00:30:27.440 --> 00:30:29.600
<v Doug McEachern>close to his heart, population policy imperative.

426
00:30:30.500 --> 00:30:31.020
<v Tim Flannery>APPLAUSE

427
00:30:32.020 --> 00:30:32.540
<v Tim Flannery>APPLAUSE

428
00:30:36.360 --> 00:30:37.800
<v Tim Flannery>Thank you very much.

429
00:30:38.320 --> 00:30:41.360
<v Tim Flannery>I'd like to begin with just a couple of general observations

430
00:30:42.140 --> 00:30:45.620
<v Tim Flannery>about the sort of emotional issues that often drive the debate,

431
00:30:46.280 --> 00:30:48.040
<v Tim Flannery>the population debate, that is.

432
00:30:48.220 --> 00:30:51.540
<v Tim Flannery>And the most significant one to me really is that

433
00:30:51.540 --> 00:30:55.720
<v Tim Flannery>youth and vigour and growth are very seductive things.

434
00:30:56.100 --> 00:30:58.240
<v Tim Flannery>We all love them, we all admire them,

435
00:30:58.280 --> 00:30:59.700
<v Tim Flannery>we'd all love to be forever young,

436
00:31:00.560 --> 00:31:02.380
<v Tim Flannery>and yet we know that the reality of the world

437
00:31:02.540 --> 00:31:04.160
<v Tim Flannery>that we live in is not that.

438
00:31:04.560 --> 00:31:06.560
<v Tim Flannery>That the world is a limited place

439
00:31:06.560 --> 00:31:09.440
<v Tim Flannery>where growth can't continue forever,

440
00:31:10.060 --> 00:31:12.240
<v Tim Flannery>no matter how much we like the idea.

441
00:31:12.820 --> 00:31:14.620
<v Tim Flannery>So there is some sort of inevitability

442
00:31:14.620 --> 00:31:15.920
<v Tim Flannery>somewhere down the line

443
00:31:16.540 --> 00:31:18.500
<v Tim Flannery>that human population will have to stop growing.

444
00:31:19.160 --> 00:31:21.180
<v Tim Flannery>Demographers and biologists and others

445
00:31:21.900 --> 00:31:25.800
<v Tim Flannery>can put a fairly persuasive case that that limit is not that far away.

446
00:31:26.260 --> 00:31:28.840
<v Tim Flannery>I'm talking as a biologist here,

447
00:31:28.900 --> 00:31:31.500
<v Tim Flannery>so perhaps a century away for me is not that far away.

448
00:31:31.660 --> 00:31:32.520
<v Tim Flannery>Yeah? Not a thousand years away.

449
00:31:32.520 --> 00:31:33.420
<v Tim Flannery>A thousand years away anyway.

450
00:31:33.860 --> 00:31:38.180
<v Tim Flannery>But somewhere just over our collective horizons.

451
00:31:39.340 --> 00:31:43.720
<v Tim Flannery>And of course our economy is one of those forever young things.

452
00:31:43.840 --> 00:31:45.840
<v Tim Flannery>It's almost like the fountain of youth, you know.

453
00:31:46.300 --> 00:31:48.220
<v Tim Flannery>Growth of any sort is good for the economy.

454
00:31:49.120 --> 00:31:54.240
<v Tim Flannery>So if you ask an economist about issues of population or growth,

455
00:31:54.400 --> 00:31:56.160
<v Tim Flannery>well, it's just a case of the more the merrier.

456
00:31:56.740 --> 00:32:02.300
<v Tim Flannery>And of course our politicians put a lot of time into economic analysis,

457
00:32:02.900 --> 00:32:05.980
<v Tim Flannery>but not very much into other sorts of analysis

458
00:32:05.980 --> 00:32:07.420
<v Tim Flannery>that we might consider important,

459
00:32:07.620 --> 00:32:09.900
<v Tim Flannery>such as the social factors that affect us

460
00:32:09.900 --> 00:32:11.760
<v Tim Flannery>or the environmental factors that affect us.

461
00:32:12.220 --> 00:32:13.740
<v Tim Flannery>And so the population debate,

462
00:32:13.920 --> 00:32:16.000
<v Tim Flannery>or the immigration debate, if you want,

463
00:32:16.040 --> 00:32:18.620
<v Tim Flannery>has largely been driven, I think,

464
00:32:18.660 --> 00:32:22.180
<v Tim Flannery>by that twin association that growth is good,

465
00:32:22.280 --> 00:32:25.160
<v Tim Flannery>we'd love to be a country forever young, growing and dynamic,

466
00:32:26.120 --> 00:32:28.100
<v Tim Flannery>and that we'd have a thriving economy,

467
00:32:28.240 --> 00:32:29.860
<v Tim Flannery>which is, all of that is undoubtedly true.

468
00:32:30.800 --> 00:32:31.760
<v Tim Flannery>Absolutely true.

469
00:32:31.760 --> 00:32:32.940
<v Tim Flannery>But is it possible?

470
00:32:33.140 --> 00:32:35.960
<v Tim Flannery>That's the big question that we have to face today.

471
00:32:37.140 --> 00:32:39.900
<v Tim Flannery>And I think that we're coming to a point

472
00:32:39.900 --> 00:32:43.060
<v Tim Flannery>where answering that question is becoming ever more critical,

473
00:32:43.160 --> 00:32:48.440
<v Tim Flannery>because our current situation is a very dangerous one for the nation.

474
00:32:48.900 --> 00:32:51.800
<v Tim Flannery>What we have at the moment is an immigration program

475
00:32:51.800 --> 00:32:58.100
<v Tim Flannery>which has been driven by a now defunct and superannuated population policy.

476
00:32:58.360 --> 00:33:00.760
<v Tim Flannery>That policy hasn't been articulated since the mid-1940s.

477
00:33:01.760 --> 00:33:03.700
<v Tim Flannery>And that policy, when it was last talked about,

478
00:33:03.920 --> 00:33:06.760
<v Tim Flannery>Arthur Caldwell, I think, was the last to explicitly mention it,

479
00:33:06.820 --> 00:33:11.480
<v Tim Flannery>was designed to deliver 2% population growth per annum to Australia.

480
00:33:11.820 --> 00:33:15.180
<v Tim Flannery>Now, we're nowhere near doing that under the current level of immigration,

481
00:33:15.340 --> 00:33:18.560
<v Tim Flannery>but the program is delivering significant growth.

482
00:33:19.120 --> 00:33:22.940
<v Tim Flannery>The big problem has arisen, though,

483
00:33:23.000 --> 00:33:25.800
<v Tim Flannery>that that program, which had overwhelming support

484
00:33:25.800 --> 00:33:27.220
<v Tim Flannery>when it was first articulated,

485
00:33:27.540 --> 00:33:30.900
<v Tim Flannery>now has trivial social support in the community.

486
00:33:30.900 --> 00:33:35.400
<v Tim Flannery>And as of 2001, the people who you elect to Parliament

487
00:33:35.400 --> 00:33:38.340
<v Tim Flannery>and that serve you have never thought fit to turn around

488
00:33:38.340 --> 00:33:40.320
<v Tim Flannery>and ask the people of Australia

489
00:33:40.320 --> 00:33:42.700
<v Tim Flannery>what sort of population policy you actually want.

490
00:33:43.480 --> 00:33:48.060
<v Tim Flannery>In the absence of that, what we have is an immigration program

491
00:33:48.060 --> 00:33:50.820
<v Tim Flannery>which is driving some population growth,

492
00:33:51.060 --> 00:33:53.900
<v Tim Flannery>which is not supported by the majority of the community,

493
00:33:53.980 --> 00:33:57.860
<v Tim Flannery>nor is it justified by the politicians, by and large, that promote it.

494
00:33:58.060 --> 00:34:00.720
<v Tim Flannery>And that allows people like Pauline Hanson

495
00:34:00.720 --> 00:34:00.880
<v Tim Flannery>and the other people,

496
00:34:00.900 --> 00:34:01.100
<v Tim Flannery>like John and others,

497
00:34:01.260 --> 00:34:04.800
<v Tim Flannery>who have a very divisive effect on society,

498
00:34:04.960 --> 00:34:07.800
<v Tim Flannery>to stand up and say, without being able to be refuted,

499
00:34:07.920 --> 00:34:10.540
<v Tim Flannery>that the immigration program is bad for Australia,

500
00:34:10.720 --> 00:34:11.740
<v Tim Flannery>that we don't need it,

501
00:34:11.800 --> 00:34:13.740
<v Tim Flannery>or that we'd be better off without it.

502
00:34:14.480 --> 00:34:17.600
<v Tim Flannery>Now, that sort of perspective, as it currently stands,

503
00:34:17.720 --> 00:34:19.140
<v Tim Flannery>can't be refuted by politicians

504
00:34:19.140 --> 00:34:22.720
<v Tim Flannery>because we haven't had a well-thought-through population policy

505
00:34:22.720 --> 00:34:25.140
<v Tim Flannery>that the immigration program sits within.

506
00:34:25.480 --> 00:34:28.660
<v Tim Flannery>And I see that as a very signal danger for this nation

507
00:34:28.660 --> 00:34:30.880
<v Tim Flannery>because if things change,

508
00:34:30.880 --> 00:34:31.900
<v Tim Flannery>if things continue as they are,

509
00:34:31.980 --> 00:34:34.740
<v Tim Flannery>we will have a large number of unwelcome immigrants

510
00:34:34.740 --> 00:34:35.820
<v Tim Flannery>who will feel rejected,

511
00:34:36.660 --> 00:34:41.500
<v Tim Flannery>who will be themselves eventually a divisive force in our society.

512
00:34:41.800 --> 00:34:45.220
<v Tim Flannery>We need to develop support behind a population program

513
00:34:45.880 --> 00:34:48.360
<v Tim Flannery>that reflects the will of the people of Australia as a whole.

514
00:34:48.660 --> 00:34:51.440
<v Tim Flannery>And that's pretty axiomatic for a population policy.

515
00:34:51.720 --> 00:34:53.840
<v Tim Flannery>I mean, a population policy, first and foremost,

516
00:34:54.060 --> 00:34:58.660
<v Tim Flannery>must benefit and serve the people who have designed it.

517
00:34:58.860 --> 00:35:00.160
<v Tim Flannery>If it doesn't do that,

518
00:35:00.160 --> 00:35:02.040
<v Tim Flannery>then it won't have the support of the people,

519
00:35:02.140 --> 00:35:06.300
<v Tim Flannery>it will become a dangerous juggernaut, I believe, within society.

520
00:35:07.760 --> 00:35:12.420
<v Tim Flannery>That's not to say that immigration programs only relate to population.

521
00:35:12.900 --> 00:35:15.800
<v Tim Flannery>There's a very significant humanitarian enterprise

522
00:35:17.440 --> 00:35:19.420
<v Tim Flannery>encapsulated within our immigration program,

523
00:35:19.580 --> 00:35:22.060
<v Tim Flannery>and that itself is a worthy aim that we should never throw out

524
00:35:22.060 --> 00:35:25.040
<v Tim Flannery>just in pursuit of a population policy.

525
00:35:25.660 --> 00:35:28.600
<v Tim Flannery>But I do believe we need to reorganise the way we do things.

526
00:35:28.800 --> 00:35:30.140
<v Tim Flannery>We need to put all of the efforts

527
00:35:30.160 --> 00:35:32.060
<v Tim Flannery>and all of the money, the eggs, or the finances, if you want,

528
00:35:32.140 --> 00:35:34.420
<v Tim Flannery>that relate to population issues in one basket

529
00:35:35.000 --> 00:35:37.060
<v Tim Flannery>and all of the financial issues

530
00:35:37.060 --> 00:35:39.960
<v Tim Flannery>that relate to humanitarian enterprises in another.

531
00:35:40.620 --> 00:35:43.220
<v Tim Flannery>So what we might have if we had a population policy

532
00:35:43.220 --> 00:35:46.520
<v Tim Flannery>that was sensible and was reflecting the will of the people

533
00:35:47.260 --> 00:35:50.320
<v Tim Flannery>would be, first, a grand debate about where we want to go

534
00:35:50.320 --> 00:35:53.440
<v Tim Flannery>and some real informed analysis, people from both sides,

535
00:35:53.660 --> 00:35:58.120
<v Tim Flannery>from economists, sociologists, biologists,

536
00:35:58.120 --> 00:36:01.560
<v Tim Flannery>trying to nut out together what the general forward trend

537
00:36:01.560 --> 00:36:02.700
<v Tim Flannery>for the nation should be.

538
00:36:02.800 --> 00:36:05.440
<v Tim Flannery>And it should be a debate that's very widely publicised

539
00:36:05.440 --> 00:36:07.800
<v Tim Flannery>and engaged with everyone in society.

540
00:36:08.880 --> 00:36:11.720
<v Tim Flannery>Ultimately, we're going to have to set some sort of number in that debate,

541
00:36:11.800 --> 00:36:13.300
<v Tim Flannery>otherwise all our endeavours will be useless.

542
00:36:13.720 --> 00:36:16.780
<v Tim Flannery>Is the number going to be 23 million as an optimum population?

543
00:36:16.820 --> 00:36:18.480
<v Tim Flannery>Is it going to be 50? Is it going to be 10?

544
00:36:19.340 --> 00:36:21.000
<v Tim Flannery>But that number does need to be set,

545
00:36:21.060 --> 00:36:23.540
<v Tim Flannery>otherwise you haven't got a target to aim towards,

546
00:36:23.760 --> 00:36:25.340
<v Tim Flannery>to tailor your program towards.

547
00:36:25.920 --> 00:36:27.780
<v Tim Flannery>We all know that that number's going to be wrong.

548
00:36:28.120 --> 00:36:30.020
<v Tim Flannery>Because it's a projection about the future.

549
00:36:30.180 --> 00:36:33.440
<v Tim Flannery>And predicting the future is the most difficult thing you can ever do.

550
00:36:33.500 --> 00:36:34.480
<v Tim Flannery>You're guaranteed to be wrong.

551
00:36:34.680 --> 00:36:37.860
<v Tim Flannery>But it's better to be wrong in an informed way

552
00:36:37.860 --> 00:36:41.240
<v Tim Flannery>than to allow a de facto program

553
00:36:41.240 --> 00:36:44.940
<v Tim Flannery>to drive growth in whichever way it happens to go.

554
00:36:46.560 --> 00:36:48.780
<v Tim Flannery>So it seems to me that that's a program

555
00:36:48.780 --> 00:36:52.540
<v Tim Flannery>that any future government would be well served,

556
00:36:52.580 --> 00:36:54.400
<v Tim Flannery>and our nation will be well served by undertaking.

557
00:36:54.720 --> 00:36:56.560
<v Tim Flannery>And once we set that target, we can say,

558
00:36:56.680 --> 00:36:58.100
<v Tim Flannery>all right, we want to have 20 million people.

559
00:36:58.120 --> 00:37:00.160
<v Tim Flannery>We want to have 25 million people by the year 2030.

560
00:37:00.740 --> 00:37:03.800
<v Tim Flannery>How do we then go about delivering those goods

561
00:37:03.800 --> 00:37:05.860
<v Tim Flannery>in terms of pronatalist policies?

562
00:37:06.260 --> 00:37:10.480
<v Tim Flannery>And that's in terms of births, female births per woman,

563
00:37:10.600 --> 00:37:13.640
<v Tim Flannery>which is the way you measure that particular thing.

564
00:37:15.460 --> 00:37:17.520
<v Tim Flannery>And, of course, the immigration side of it.

565
00:37:17.580 --> 00:37:18.480
<v Tim Flannery>In terms of...

566
00:37:19.420 --> 00:37:23.700
<v Tim Flannery>You want government mucking around with our potential fertility.

567
00:37:23.940 --> 00:37:27.060
<v Tim Flannery>I agree with you that we must be very cautious about that.

568
00:37:27.060 --> 00:37:30.060
<v Tim Flannery>But the fact is that it happens right now as we live.

569
00:37:30.120 --> 00:37:32.180
<v Tim Flannery>The society that we have generated

570
00:37:32.180 --> 00:37:35.580
<v Tim Flannery>has a very big impact on the decision that women make

571
00:37:35.580 --> 00:37:37.140
<v Tim Flannery>about the number of children they're going to have.

572
00:37:37.360 --> 00:37:40.120
<v Tim Flannery>Again, we have a de facto policy already in place.

573
00:37:40.640 --> 00:37:42.940
<v Tim Flannery>We can tweak it to make better outcomes,

574
00:37:43.060 --> 00:37:45.900
<v Tim Flannery>both for society and for individual women, I think,

575
00:37:45.960 --> 00:37:48.580
<v Tim Flannery>by tackling that issue in a more head-on way

576
00:37:48.580 --> 00:37:51.200
<v Tim Flannery>and saying, well, here's what we need to do to make it...

577
00:37:53.160 --> 00:37:55.080
<v Tim Flannery>..to affect that cost-benefit analysis

578
00:37:55.080 --> 00:37:56.500
<v Tim Flannery>that every woman undertakes

579
00:37:56.500 --> 00:37:57.600
<v Tim Flannery>when they think about having children.

580
00:37:57.920 --> 00:38:01.000
<v Tim Flannery>Here's the sort of things that we need to deliver to make it easier.

581
00:38:01.240 --> 00:38:03.820
<v Tim Flannery>And human beings are a very strange sort of species.

582
00:38:04.160 --> 00:38:08.260
<v Tim Flannery>It's exceedingly difficult for one individual to bring up...

583
00:38:08.260 --> 00:38:10.060
<v Tim Flannery>..for one woman to bring up children.

584
00:38:10.240 --> 00:38:11.520
<v Tim Flannery>It's just the nature of our species.

585
00:38:11.680 --> 00:38:13.440
<v Tim Flannery>The investment is absolutely prodigious.

586
00:38:13.680 --> 00:38:16.420
<v Tim Flannery>It has always been a social undertaking ever since the Pleistocene,

587
00:38:16.460 --> 00:38:20.420
<v Tim Flannery>so we're not doing anything new in terms of looking at pronatalist policies

588
00:38:20.420 --> 00:38:22.960
<v Tim Flannery>or how we may deliver better outcomes in that area.

589
00:38:23.960 --> 00:38:25.100
<v Tim Flannery>In terms of immigration,

590
00:38:25.100 --> 00:38:26.820
<v Tim Flannery>we can do the same thing.

591
00:38:26.980 --> 00:38:28.980
<v Tim Flannery>We can say, well, if that's our target,

592
00:38:29.100 --> 00:38:32.700
<v Tim Flannery>then how many people can we bring into this country

593
00:38:32.700 --> 00:38:34.100
<v Tim Flannery>over the next five or ten years

594
00:38:34.100 --> 00:38:36.520
<v Tim Flannery>and still stay within the general bandwidths

595
00:38:36.520 --> 00:38:38.140
<v Tim Flannery>that's heading towards that target?

596
00:38:38.860 --> 00:38:41.620
<v Tim Flannery>We'll get a much better humanitarian result that way

597
00:38:41.620 --> 00:38:44.160
<v Tim Flannery>because it's not simply an annual gift of the minister

598
00:38:44.160 --> 00:38:46.980
<v Tim Flannery>that's just being reactive to circumstances.

599
00:38:47.480 --> 00:38:50.860
<v Tim Flannery>We can project further and say, well, if there's a crisis,

600
00:38:50.980 --> 00:38:52.560
<v Tim Flannery>for example, in Indonesia this year

601
00:38:52.560 --> 00:38:55.080
<v Tim Flannery>and we need to bring in 100,000 or 200,000 people,

602
00:38:55.100 --> 00:38:56.500
<v Tim Flannery>100,000 immigrants, we can do that,

603
00:38:56.520 --> 00:38:58.980
<v Tim Flannery>but then discount in future years to still stay on track.

604
00:38:59.220 --> 00:39:01.660
<v Tim Flannery>It gives you a much better humanitarian outcome.

605
00:39:02.900 --> 00:39:05.300
<v Tim Flannery>So it seems to me that that sort of program

606
00:39:05.820 --> 00:39:07.780
<v Tim Flannery>which builds consensus in the community,

607
00:39:08.600 --> 00:39:12.020
<v Tim Flannery>which develops a better lifestyle and outcome for all of us,

608
00:39:12.120 --> 00:39:14.020
<v Tim Flannery>it's an imperative thing to do.

609
00:39:14.160 --> 00:39:18.040
<v Tim Flannery>At the moment, we're running under a bankrupt system, if you want,

610
00:39:18.120 --> 00:39:21.160
<v Tim Flannery>population policy that's no longer relevant to what we need.

611
00:39:21.280 --> 00:39:24.180
<v Tim Flannery>We need to design a new system that will serve our needs

612
00:39:24.180 --> 00:39:25.580
<v Tim Flannery>and gain our support.

613
00:39:27.240 --> 00:39:31.160
<v Tim Flannery>Just to speak briefly about humanitarian outcomes in that area,

614
00:39:32.960 --> 00:39:35.560
<v Tim Flannery>it's clear to me that the immigration policy

615
00:39:35.560 --> 00:39:37.880
<v Tim Flannery>delivers very significant humanitarian outcomes

616
00:39:37.880 --> 00:39:39.720
<v Tim Flannery>and should continue to do so.

617
00:39:40.180 --> 00:39:43.500
<v Tim Flannery>But if we want to get the best bang for our buck, if you want,

618
00:39:43.540 --> 00:39:45.020
<v Tim Flannery>in terms of humanitarian outcomes,

619
00:39:45.220 --> 00:39:46.760
<v Tim Flannery>I think we need to look at total programs.

620
00:39:47.100 --> 00:39:48.880
<v Tim Flannery>We need to look at our foreign aid budget,

621
00:39:49.080 --> 00:39:51.440
<v Tim Flannery>the proportion of the immigration budget

622
00:39:51.440 --> 00:39:52.900
<v Tim Flannery>that's put to humanitarian needs,

623
00:39:52.900 --> 00:39:56.260
<v Tim Flannery>and work out where we can absolutely maximise human good

624
00:39:56.260 --> 00:39:58.980
<v Tim Flannery>given the limited number of dollars that we've got.

625
00:39:59.680 --> 00:40:00.520
<v Tim Flannery>Again, it's an exercise.

626
00:40:00.600 --> 00:40:02.820
<v Tim Flannery>It's not all that difficult. We could go through it.

627
00:40:02.900 --> 00:40:05.960
<v Tim Flannery>We may find that we need to put more money into immigration or less.

628
00:40:07.040 --> 00:40:10.160
<v Tim Flannery>But that analysis would certainly give us a much better result

629
00:40:10.160 --> 00:40:12.400
<v Tim Flannery>for the world in terms of our outcome

630
00:40:12.400 --> 00:40:14.580
<v Tim Flannery>to produce humanitarian good.

631
00:40:15.580 --> 00:40:17.880
<v Tim Flannery>So it seems to me we're doing things wrongly at the moment.

632
00:40:17.960 --> 00:40:19.640
<v Tim Flannery>Everyone is clear about that.

633
00:40:19.740 --> 00:40:21.560
<v Tim Flannery>But I think that there is a way forward,

634
00:40:21.560 --> 00:40:23.480
<v Tim Flannery>and we needn't be fearful about it.

635
00:40:23.540 --> 00:40:26.000
<v Tim Flannery>It's simply a matter of us really taking control,

636
00:40:26.220 --> 00:40:27.280
<v Tim Flannery>informing ourselves,

637
00:40:27.480 --> 00:40:30.060
<v Tim Flannery>and then setting in place the sort of policies

638
00:40:30.060 --> 00:40:31.820
<v Tim Flannery>that will serve us well in the long term.

639
00:40:32.140 --> 00:40:34.780
<v Tim Flannery>It all has to be done, however, within the understanding

640
00:40:34.780 --> 00:40:38.840
<v Tim Flannery>that as attractive as youth and growth and all that stuff is,

641
00:40:38.940 --> 00:40:41.300
<v Tim Flannery>the fountain of youth doesn't really exist,

642
00:40:41.460 --> 00:40:43.740
<v Tim Flannery>that there are real ecological limits.

643
00:40:43.960 --> 00:40:46.260
<v Tim Flannery>We don't know quite where they are at the moment,

644
00:40:46.340 --> 00:40:48.040
<v Tim Flannery>but that they are very much a reality

645
00:40:48.560 --> 00:40:50.320
<v Tim Flannery>and that we need to take that into account

646
00:40:50.320 --> 00:40:53.080
<v Tim Flannery>in terms of developing a future population policy.

647
00:40:53.340 --> 00:40:55.680
<v Tim Flannery>There is one sort of thing that does try to live forever,

648
00:40:58.520 --> 00:40:59.740
<v Tim Flannery>and that is cancer.

649
00:41:00.700 --> 00:41:02.400
<v Tim Flannery>Their cells just keep on growing.

650
00:41:02.920 --> 00:41:05.280
<v Tim Flannery>And that's what we're doing to our planet at the moment.

651
00:41:05.400 --> 00:41:07.760
<v Tim Flannery>So that, to me, is not an option.

652
00:41:07.820 --> 00:41:09.620
<v Tim Flannery>We actually need a sensible policy

653
00:41:09.620 --> 00:41:12.760
<v Tim Flannery>that serves us within the context of our place in the world.

654
00:41:12.900 --> 00:41:14.040
<v Tim Flannery>So thank you very much.

655
00:41:21.260 --> 00:41:21.900
<v Doug McEachern>APPLAUSE

656
00:41:21.900 --> 00:41:23.540
<v Doug McEachern>Thank you, Tim.

657
00:41:24.320 --> 00:41:26.340
<v Doug McEachern>Well, there we've had three presentations

658
00:41:26.340 --> 00:41:30.200
<v Doug McEachern>of different aspects relating to the history of Australia

659
00:41:30.200 --> 00:41:33.500
<v Doug McEachern>and the varying attitudes towards elements of our population policy,

660
00:41:34.400 --> 00:41:37.320
<v Doug McEachern>towards the character of argument

661
00:41:38.080 --> 00:41:41.840
<v Doug McEachern>that's required to be able to handle the issue of population policy,

662
00:41:42.120 --> 00:41:46.640
<v Doug McEachern>and the case made that regardless of whether one seeks greater,

663
00:41:46.840 --> 00:41:48.500
<v Doug McEachern>lesser or some other variation

664
00:41:48.500 --> 00:41:50.300
<v Doug McEachern>on the composition of the population,

665
00:41:50.320 --> 00:41:54.680
<v Doug McEachern>at least we need to have a publicly informed debate about it.

666
00:41:55.440 --> 00:41:58.420
<v Doug McEachern>This session runs through until 12.40.

667
00:41:58.800 --> 00:42:02.620
<v Doug McEachern>The opportunity is now for those who wish to raise questions

668
00:42:02.620 --> 00:42:04.220
<v Doug McEachern>of members of the panel,

669
00:42:04.380 --> 00:42:06.500
<v Doug McEachern>or indeed to make points, to do so.

670
00:42:07.060 --> 00:42:08.260
<v Doug McEachern>Just a couple of things.

671
00:42:08.440 --> 00:42:10.140
<v Doug McEachern>There's a microphone down here,

672
00:42:10.320 --> 00:42:13.920
<v Doug McEachern>about halfway back on my right-hand side, your left-hand side,

673
00:42:14.060 --> 00:42:16.700
<v Doug McEachern>and again, there's a microphone at the top,

674
00:42:16.800 --> 00:42:20.300
<v Doug McEachern>or you may choose to speak from wherever you are.

675
00:42:20.300 --> 00:42:21.040
<v Doug McEachern>You may not be seated.

676
00:42:21.220 --> 00:42:26.580
<v Doug McEachern>I will try to recognise and identify a sequence of speakers.

677
00:42:27.180 --> 00:42:29.620
<v Doug McEachern>OK. The session is open for discussion.

678
00:42:30.140 --> 00:42:32.480
<v Doug McEachern>One, two...

679
00:42:33.300 --> 00:42:36.280
<v Audience>According to the advertiser research lately,

680
00:42:36.860 --> 00:42:40.620
<v Audience>70% of us put environment first,

681
00:42:40.940 --> 00:42:44.960
<v Audience>and we've got threatens of salinity and so forth,

682
00:42:45.140 --> 00:42:48.300
<v Audience>and I feel that that's our first goal,

683
00:42:48.440 --> 00:42:49.600
<v Audience>to get that right,

684
00:42:50.300 --> 00:42:51.620
<v Audience>otherwise we might perish.

685
00:42:51.980 --> 00:42:52.860
<v Audience>Thanks. Thank you.

686
00:42:56.360 --> 00:42:56.760
<v Tim Flannery>Yvonne?

687
00:42:58.740 --> 00:43:01.560
<v Audience>I'd just like to address my question to Tim Flannery, thanks.

688
00:43:01.620 --> 00:43:04.520
<v Audience>Tim, I'd like to ask you, what do you think is going to happen to...

689
00:43:04.520 --> 00:43:06.560
<v Audience>What is likely to happen to the wildlife of Australia

690
00:43:06.560 --> 00:43:10.940
<v Audience>if we aim for the mid-level target, so around 25 million?

691
00:43:11.900 --> 00:43:15.800
<v Tim Flannery>I can say to you, I think, honestly, that I just don't know,

692
00:43:15.920 --> 00:43:19.220
<v Tim Flannery>because we haven't done enough research in that area.

693
00:43:19.220 --> 00:43:24.580
<v Tim Flannery>And what I see as a very vital part of developing this population policy

694
00:43:25.220 --> 00:43:27.460
<v Tim Flannery>and the community consensus that goes with it

695
00:43:28.220 --> 00:43:30.600
<v Tim Flannery>is to really develop a state of the nation,

696
00:43:30.740 --> 00:43:33.000
<v Tim Flannery>if you want, report relating to the economy,

697
00:43:33.140 --> 00:43:34.980
<v Tim Flannery>to social issues and to the environment.

698
00:43:35.260 --> 00:43:38.400
<v Tim Flannery>Now, we have had a state of the environment report published in 1994,

699
00:43:38.780 --> 00:43:40.240
<v Tim Flannery>but it hasn't been updated.

700
00:43:40.520 --> 00:43:44.220
<v Tim Flannery>It did recognise population as one of the ten biggest threats to the environment,

701
00:43:44.340 --> 00:43:47.640
<v Tim Flannery>but we haven't actually directed it in any meaningful way

702
00:43:47.640 --> 00:43:48.980
<v Tim Flannery>towards the development of a population.

703
00:43:49.220 --> 00:43:51.560
<v Tim Flannery>So, I can't answer the question at the moment.

704
00:43:51.760 --> 00:43:56.040
<v Tim Flannery>My gut feeling, if you want, is that it's potentially downwards.

705
00:43:56.140 --> 00:43:59.400
<v Tim Flannery>If everything else stays the same, then it will be a negative impact.

706
00:43:59.780 --> 00:44:03.360
<v Tim Flannery>But that's exactly the sort of question we need to answer

707
00:44:03.360 --> 00:44:06.220
<v Tim Flannery>in order to develop a sensible population policy.

708
00:44:07.400 --> 00:44:08.020
<v Doug McEachern>Thank you.

709
00:44:08.460 --> 00:44:09.220
<v Audience>Up at the top.

710
00:44:10.500 --> 00:44:12.660
<v Audience>Yes, I'm interested...

711
00:44:12.660 --> 00:44:17.020
<v Audience>I was interested to note how anxious all the speakers seemed,

712
00:44:17.120 --> 00:44:18.820
<v Audience>and I fully shared that.

713
00:44:19.220 --> 00:44:24.280
<v Audience>That sense that to talk about this is to step out into dangerous space.

714
00:44:24.920 --> 00:44:32.660
<v Audience>And given how debased the level of public debate is in this country at present,

715
00:44:32.800 --> 00:44:34.220
<v Audience>in what forums...

716
00:44:34.220 --> 00:44:39.520
<v Audience>How is this debate going to be carried on in an intelligent manner?

717
00:44:39.820 --> 00:44:42.440
<v Audience>How would one proceed to discuss policy?

718
00:44:42.780 --> 00:44:46.680
<v Audience>Because I think that's the one thing that we would all appear to be agreed on.

719
00:44:46.760 --> 00:44:48.720
<v Audience>How can you discuss population policy?

720
00:44:49.220 --> 00:44:51.760
<v Audience>Without the moral panics that Professor Bourne mentioned?

721
00:44:53.780 --> 00:44:55.640
<v Audience>Do you want to comment or would you like me to comment?

722
00:44:55.940 --> 00:44:57.220
<v Fran Baum>Is my microphone working?

723
00:44:57.240 --> 00:44:57.880
<v Fran Baum>Yes, it is.

724
00:44:58.000 --> 00:44:58.340
<v Fran Baum>Good.

725
00:44:58.460 --> 00:45:00.200
<v Fran Baum>Well, I mean, I think you're right.

726
00:45:00.280 --> 00:45:01.040
<v Fran Baum>We need to.

727
00:45:01.180 --> 00:45:04.080
<v Fran Baum>And unfortunately, because this area of population

728
00:45:04.080 --> 00:45:06.160
<v Fran Baum>buys into so many of those...

729
00:45:06.160 --> 00:45:07.920
<v Fran Baum>No, people can't hear.

730
00:45:08.760 --> 00:45:09.680
<v Fran Baum>Can you hear now?

731
00:45:10.000 --> 00:45:10.400
<v Fran Baum>Yes.

732
00:45:10.480 --> 00:45:11.800
<v Fran Baum>Okay, sorry about that.

733
00:45:12.160 --> 00:45:16.420
<v Fran Baum>Because this area of population buys into so many of those moral panics

734
00:45:16.420 --> 00:45:17.600
<v Fran Baum>that we've all talked about,

735
00:45:20.080 --> 00:45:22.720
<v Fran Baum>it's hard to know what are the public forums.

736
00:45:22.900 --> 00:45:25.500
<v Fran Baum>I mean, clearly, this Festival of Ideas is one of those.

737
00:45:26.040 --> 00:45:28.600
<v Fran Baum>Clearly, the universities, although increasingly,

738
00:45:29.180 --> 00:45:32.900
<v Fran Baum>universities are restricted in the amount to which they can enter public debate

739
00:45:32.900 --> 00:45:35.900
<v Fran Baum>and the pressure on academics are greater and greater.

740
00:45:36.220 --> 00:45:40.760
<v Fran Baum>But schools, universities, all the community,

741
00:45:42.640 --> 00:45:45.800
<v Fran Baum>residential associations might want to talk at the level

742
00:45:45.800 --> 00:45:47.980
<v Fran Baum>of what population they want in their area.

743
00:45:48.140 --> 00:45:49.200
<v Fran Baum>I mean, there should be widespread debate.

744
00:45:49.200 --> 00:45:50.500
<v Fran Baum>There should be widespread civic debate about this,

745
00:45:50.580 --> 00:45:52.060
<v Fran Baum>as I think Tim said.

746
00:45:52.340 --> 00:45:57.140
<v Fran Baum>But it is difficult in a situation when the level of political debate

747
00:45:57.140 --> 00:46:00.920
<v Fran Baum>is so absolutely woeful and the only thing that really matters

748
00:46:00.920 --> 00:46:02.920
<v Fran Baum>is the dollar sign and the economy.

749
00:46:03.380 --> 00:46:07.880
<v Fran Baum>But for me, there are some very basic issues here we have to consider

750
00:46:07.880 --> 00:46:09.480
<v Fran Baum>that in developed countries,

751
00:46:09.740 --> 00:46:12.100
<v Fran Baum>we're something like a fifth of the world's population,

752
00:46:12.400 --> 00:46:14.680
<v Fran Baum>but we consume four-fifths of the world's resources.

753
00:46:15.160 --> 00:46:17.780
<v Fran Baum>That's evidently both morally wrong,

754
00:46:17.780 --> 00:46:20.980
<v Fran Baum>but also ecologically wrong and is not sustainable.

755
00:46:21.360 --> 00:46:25.580
<v Fran Baum>So without considering that consumption issue,

756
00:46:26.320 --> 00:46:27.980
<v Fran Baum>along with the population issue,

757
00:46:28.100 --> 00:46:29.580
<v Fran Baum>I don't think you can have a real debate

758
00:46:29.580 --> 00:46:32.340
<v Fran Baum>because clearly the way that we all consume

759
00:46:32.340 --> 00:46:33.840
<v Fran Baum>and we are allowed to consume

760
00:46:34.880 --> 00:46:38.620
<v Fran Baum>is going to require strong policy to change that.

761
00:46:38.780 --> 00:46:40.900
<v Fran Baum>If I look at my area of public health,

762
00:46:41.000 --> 00:46:44.220
<v Fran Baum>all the public health success stories have not resulted from us

763
00:46:44.220 --> 00:46:45.880
<v Fran Baum>telling people to change their behaviour.

764
00:46:46.140 --> 00:46:47.760
<v Fran Baum>It's resulted from public policy.

765
00:46:48.460 --> 00:46:50.640
<v Fran Baum>Smoking in this state is a great example.

766
00:46:50.940 --> 00:46:52.120
<v Fran Baum>When we just said to people,

767
00:46:52.240 --> 00:46:53.780
<v Fran Baum>don't smoke because it affects your health,

768
00:46:53.860 --> 00:46:54.560
<v Fran Baum>it had no effect.

769
00:46:54.860 --> 00:46:55.780
<v Fran Baum>But when we said,

770
00:46:55.860 --> 00:46:57.500
<v Fran Baum>you can't smoke in workplaces,

771
00:46:57.520 --> 00:46:59.040
<v Fran Baum>you can't smoke in restaurants,

772
00:47:00.420 --> 00:47:02.420
<v Fran Baum>we won't have tobacco advertising,

773
00:47:02.780 --> 00:47:04.080
<v Fran Baum>the rates of smoking dropped.

774
00:47:04.340 --> 00:47:07.100
<v Fran Baum>And it will be the same with this consumption.

775
00:47:07.480 --> 00:47:08.740
<v Fran Baum>We will not cut consumption

776
00:47:08.740 --> 00:47:11.180
<v Fran Baum>until we have a government that's brave enough to say,

777
00:47:11.300 --> 00:47:13.980
<v Fran Baum>we want to become a properly ecological government

778
00:47:13.980 --> 00:47:17.580
<v Fran Baum>and we want to make decisions that ensure a sustainable future.

779
00:47:17.580 --> 00:47:20.140
<v Fran Baum>And that are informed not just by our needs

780
00:47:20.140 --> 00:47:21.980
<v Fran Baum>but by the needs of future generations.

781
00:47:22.400 --> 00:47:25.140
<v Fran Baum>And that's going to require a big, big shift.

782
00:47:31.260 --> 00:47:35.260
<v Alison McKinnon>Could I just say one quick word about that?

783
00:47:35.460 --> 00:47:36.520
<v Alison McKinnon>Can you hear me?

784
00:47:37.100 --> 00:47:38.440
<v Fran Baum>I think you need to...

785
00:47:38.440 --> 00:47:39.920
<v Audience>Oh, I need to...

786
00:47:40.580 --> 00:47:41.300
<v Alison McKinnon>Can you hear me?

787
00:47:41.780 --> 00:47:46.860
<v Alison McKinnon>I just wanted to respond to the last questioner's point

788
00:47:46.860 --> 00:47:47.220
<v Alison McKinnon>about,

789
00:47:47.580 --> 00:47:47.760
<v Alison McKinnon>you know,

790
00:47:47.760 --> 00:47:49.620
<v Alison McKinnon>the level of anxiety about raising these issues.

791
00:47:49.800 --> 00:47:51.900
<v Alison McKinnon>I think that that's not surprising

792
00:47:52.580 --> 00:47:55.180
<v Alison McKinnon>given that one can so quickly in this country

793
00:47:55.180 --> 00:47:57.340
<v Alison McKinnon>be painted into a particular corner.

794
00:47:57.520 --> 00:48:00.960
<v Alison McKinnon>If you talk about fear of declining fertility, for instance,

795
00:48:01.040 --> 00:48:04.300
<v Alison McKinnon>you might be seen as being a pronatalist,

796
00:48:04.340 --> 00:48:08.320
<v Alison McKinnon>pushing a particular line about a particular sort of family.

797
00:48:08.520 --> 00:48:11.360
<v Alison McKinnon>If you question immigration policy,

798
00:48:11.560 --> 00:48:14.200
<v Alison McKinnon>you might then be seen to be xenophobic or racist.

799
00:48:14.440 --> 00:48:17.240
<v Alison McKinnon>And we do have a level of debate quite often,

800
00:48:17.240 --> 00:48:19.880
<v Alison McKinnon>which just looks very briefly

801
00:48:19.880 --> 00:48:22.600
<v Alison McKinnon>and names people, labels people,

802
00:48:22.780 --> 00:48:24.020
<v Alison McKinnon>as having a particular view

803
00:48:24.020 --> 00:48:27.640
<v Alison McKinnon>without bringing all the issues out in their complexity.

804
00:48:28.200 --> 00:48:30.460
<v Alison McKinnon>I mean, I think, as Fran says,

805
00:48:30.640 --> 00:48:32.300
<v Alison McKinnon>this sort of a forum is wonderful

806
00:48:32.300 --> 00:48:36.300
<v Alison McKinnon>because increasingly, in all forms of the media,

807
00:48:36.420 --> 00:48:39.560
<v Alison McKinnon>it's not possible to have really complex debates.

808
00:48:39.860 --> 00:48:42.480
<v Alison McKinnon>So I think that's why perhaps you suspect

809
00:48:42.480 --> 00:48:46.460
<v Alison McKinnon>some sort of level of stepping out where angels fear to tread.

810
00:48:46.460 --> 00:48:46.920
<v Alison McKinnon>Thank you.

811
00:48:47.500 --> 00:48:49.540
<v Tim Flannery>Mr. Chairman, could I just ask...

812
00:48:50.360 --> 00:48:53.460
<v Tim Flannery>I just wanted to add a brief comment to Fran's comments there

813
00:48:53.460 --> 00:48:55.680
<v Tim Flannery>about sustainability and resource utilisation.

814
00:48:55.960 --> 00:48:58.620
<v Tim Flannery>I think there's a very great danger in running that

815
00:48:58.620 --> 00:49:02.020
<v Tim Flannery>in parallel with the population policy debate we're talking about,

816
00:49:02.180 --> 00:49:03.900
<v Tim Flannery>because what you do if you say,

817
00:49:04.000 --> 00:49:06.340
<v Tim Flannery>we're going to implement policy and here's going to be the outcome,

818
00:49:06.640 --> 00:49:08.680
<v Tim Flannery>you're starting to predict the future yet again.

819
00:49:09.400 --> 00:49:10.800
<v Tim Flannery>And we'll always be wrong.

820
00:49:11.120 --> 00:49:13.320
<v Tim Flannery>You have to deal with species as you find them,

821
00:49:13.360 --> 00:49:15.060
<v Tim Flannery>and we're just another species in the environment

822
00:49:15.060 --> 00:49:16.440
<v Tim Flannery>and we know what our level of resource use is.

823
00:49:16.460 --> 00:49:17.540
<v Tim Flannery>That's what resource utilisation is at the moment.

824
00:49:17.720 --> 00:49:19.820
<v Tim Flannery>That doesn't mean we can't strive very hard

825
00:49:19.820 --> 00:49:21.820
<v Tim Flannery>to change that level of resource utilisation.

826
00:49:22.320 --> 00:49:24.340
<v Tim Flannery>But perhaps the way it should work is to say,

827
00:49:24.440 --> 00:49:27.560
<v Tim Flannery>here's the population target given current resource utilisation.

828
00:49:28.200 --> 00:49:29.820
<v Tim Flannery>We'll revisit it in five years.

829
00:49:30.080 --> 00:49:32.920
<v Tim Flannery>If resource utilisation has declined, then we can up the target,

830
00:49:33.040 --> 00:49:34.780
<v Tim Flannery>if that's the will of the people.

831
00:49:35.120 --> 00:49:36.980
<v Tim Flannery>So it's a reactive system.

832
00:49:37.580 --> 00:49:39.280
<v Tim Flannery>I know it might not sound very different,

833
00:49:39.340 --> 00:49:40.920
<v Tim Flannery>but in terms of the practical way it would work,

834
00:49:40.940 --> 00:49:41.960
<v Tim Flannery>it would be a huge difference,

835
00:49:42.080 --> 00:49:44.080
<v Tim Flannery>because if we get bogged down in an argument

836
00:49:44.080 --> 00:49:47.500
<v Tim Flannery>about resource utilisation and start predicting the future

837
00:49:47.500 --> 00:49:49.480
<v Tim Flannery>or trying to predict the future yet again from that base,

838
00:49:49.680 --> 00:49:54.440
<v Tim Flannery>I think the potential for confusion is just too great.

839
00:49:54.660 --> 00:49:55.540
<v Tim Flannery>Better to be reactive.

840
00:49:56.020 --> 00:49:58.620
<v Tim Flannery>Deal with the species as we find it and then adjust.

841
00:49:59.380 --> 00:50:01.440
<v Tim Flannery>Can I just respond to that?

842
00:50:01.500 --> 00:50:04.500
<v Fran Baum>Because I think we need to have a vision.

843
00:50:04.900 --> 00:50:07.080
<v Fran Baum>And I don't think we should just be reacting

844
00:50:07.080 --> 00:50:10.080
<v Fran Baum>as if there's some God-given biological response.

845
00:50:10.260 --> 00:50:13.120
<v Fran Baum>We actually need to say, what kind of society do we want to live in?

846
00:50:13.120 --> 00:50:15.880
<v Fran Baum>What kind of social society do we want?

847
00:50:16.000 --> 00:50:18.400
<v Fran Baum>How do we want to consume resources?

848
00:50:18.660 --> 00:50:20.240
<v Fran Baum>And most of us don't think about that.

849
00:50:20.300 --> 00:50:23.340
<v Fran Baum>We just slip into high energy consumption

850
00:50:23.340 --> 00:50:25.040
<v Fran Baum>because that's the easy choice.

851
00:50:25.380 --> 00:50:27.500
<v Fran Baum>If we had a vision and everyone...

852
00:50:27.500 --> 00:50:29.100
<v Fran Baum>And I think one of the things,

853
00:50:29.140 --> 00:50:32.240
<v Fran Baum>my work when we do community-based needs assessment

854
00:50:32.240 --> 00:50:35.960
<v Fran Baum>shows that most people's vision of a healthy, sustainable society

855
00:50:35.960 --> 00:50:39.820
<v Fran Baum>is one where they have good social relationships,

856
00:50:39.900 --> 00:50:42.940
<v Fran Baum>where they're not having a heavy ecological footprint,

857
00:50:43.120 --> 00:50:45.160
<v Fran Baum>where they have sustainable, enjoyable work.

858
00:50:45.300 --> 00:50:48.360
<v Fran Baum>But we won't achieve that unless we say that's where we want to go

859
00:50:48.360 --> 00:50:51.860
<v Fran Baum>and we then use that vision to guide all our policy decisions.

860
00:50:52.220 --> 00:50:53.760
<v Fran Baum>I don't think we can just be reactive.

861
00:50:53.900 --> 00:50:57.460
<v Fran Baum>We've actually got to say, this is the sort of society we want to live in

862
00:50:57.460 --> 00:51:00.160
<v Fran Baum>and these are the policy decisions that will get us there.

863
00:51:00.380 --> 00:51:03.520
<v Fran Baum>Otherwise, we're at the mercy of the free market and that's the danger.

864
00:51:06.320 --> 00:51:11.080
<v Doug McEachern>Can I just respond by saying I fully agree with that

865
00:51:11.080 --> 00:51:13.100
<v Tim Flannery>but that I don't believe that should feed into a population.

866
00:51:13.120 --> 00:51:13.620
<v Tim Flannery>I don't believe that should feed into a population policy

867
00:51:13.620 --> 00:51:15.420
<v Tim Flannery>until we have the real outcomes in our hand.

868
00:51:15.720 --> 00:51:16.260
<v Doug McEachern>OK.

869
00:51:18.660 --> 00:51:20.220
<v Doug McEachern>No, no, one person before you.

870
00:51:20.300 --> 00:51:21.480
<v Doug McEachern>There you go.

871
00:51:21.720 --> 00:51:24.820
<v Audience>I just wanted to speculate a bit about the reasons

872
00:51:24.820 --> 00:51:30.720
<v Audience>why perhaps the fertility level is declining in Western societies

873
00:51:30.720 --> 00:51:33.160
<v Audience>and just get your reaction.

874
00:51:33.840 --> 00:51:37.220
<v Audience>I wonder to what degree it might be connected

875
00:51:37.220 --> 00:51:40.340
<v Audience>with our focus on the nuclear family

876
00:51:40.340 --> 00:51:42.000
<v Audience>as the essential sort of unit

877
00:51:43.120 --> 00:51:43.420
<v Audience>of the social organisation.

878
00:51:44.900 --> 00:51:49.200
<v Audience>That that has the effect of separating women

879
00:51:49.200 --> 00:51:52.620
<v Audience>from older women who've already had children

880
00:51:53.280 --> 00:51:57.720
<v Audience>and perhaps from other families who already have children

881
00:51:58.400 --> 00:52:02.400
<v Audience>so that there is a kind of broad exposure to children

882
00:52:02.400 --> 00:52:08.020
<v Audience>and connection with children, you know, for everyone in a sense

883
00:52:08.020 --> 00:52:12.500
<v Audience>and so that having a child becomes less of a...

884
00:52:13.480 --> 00:52:16.520
<v Audience>..you know, a prospect of doing something

885
00:52:16.520 --> 00:52:18.820
<v Audience>you have no experience of.

886
00:52:20.180 --> 00:52:26.840
<v Audience>And that the way we then try to provide facilities

887
00:52:26.840 --> 00:52:31.220
<v Audience>to get around that for women to combine work

888
00:52:31.220 --> 00:52:34.440
<v Audience>and having children with childcare and so on

889
00:52:34.440 --> 00:52:38.180
<v Audience>is a sense it's just a remedial kind of thing

890
00:52:38.180 --> 00:52:41.820
<v Audience>that doesn't touch that focus on the nuclear family.

891
00:52:41.820 --> 00:52:45.120
<v Audience>And that perhaps in the longer term we'd be better...

892
00:52:46.560 --> 00:52:48.480
<v Audience>..it'd be better for people to be living

893
00:52:48.480 --> 00:52:50.800
<v Audience>in a more extended family situation

894
00:52:50.800 --> 00:52:54.480
<v Audience>and a more micro-community situation

895
00:52:55.180 --> 00:52:58.680
<v Audience>and for more of the general childcare

896
00:52:58.680 --> 00:53:01.800
<v Audience>to occur in that kind of context

897
00:53:01.800 --> 00:53:05.460
<v Audience>and that that would actually provide a lot more

898
00:53:05.460 --> 00:53:10.060
<v Audience>of the kind of flexibility of lifestyle that we'd like to have.

899
00:53:10.640 --> 00:53:11.540
<v Doug McEachern>Thank you.

900
00:53:12.320 --> 00:53:13.960
<v Doug McEachern>Did you want to respond to that or not?

901
00:53:14.240 --> 00:53:17.720
<v Alison McKinnon>Well, actually, I'd just like to say I agree with all of that.

902
00:53:17.800 --> 00:53:19.940
<v Alison McKinnon>I think it is very much a problem

903
00:53:19.940 --> 00:53:24.140
<v Alison McKinnon>that children have become very much a problem

904
00:53:24.140 --> 00:53:27.040
<v Alison McKinnon>for particular women rather than for communities

905
00:53:27.040 --> 00:53:29.300
<v Alison McKinnon>and this is something I think we have all stressed,

906
00:53:29.460 --> 00:53:31.500
<v Alison McKinnon>that a growth of community,

907
00:53:33.840 --> 00:53:35.540
<v Alison McKinnon>particularly intergenerational communities,

908
00:53:35.860 --> 00:53:38.840
<v Alison McKinnon>would certainly assist that focus

909
00:53:38.840 --> 00:53:41.800
<v Alison McKinnon>on it not being such an individual issue.

910
00:53:41.820 --> 00:53:45.820
<v Alison McKinnon>But I think we have to also link some of these issues

911
00:53:45.820 --> 00:53:50.780
<v Alison McKinnon>to the whole way in which the values in our society

912
00:53:52.020 --> 00:53:53.400
<v Alison McKinnon>emphasise the individual.

913
00:53:53.900 --> 00:53:56.260
<v Alison McKinnon>And we now, for 100 years,

914
00:53:56.480 --> 00:54:01.220
<v Alison McKinnon>have pushed to have women educated in the same way as men have been

915
00:54:01.220 --> 00:54:04.440
<v Alison McKinnon>and, indeed, I've been a great supporter of that.

916
00:54:04.840 --> 00:54:09.620
<v Alison McKinnon>And we are educating women as men to be individuals,

917
00:54:09.700 --> 00:54:11.680
<v Alison McKinnon>to go out into the labour market,

918
00:54:11.820 --> 00:54:13.580
<v Alison McKinnon>to go out and to be treated as an individual.

919
00:54:14.820 --> 00:54:19.580
<v Alison McKinnon>And then we ask them to move into a quite different sort of situation

920
00:54:19.580 --> 00:54:20.680
<v Alison McKinnon>to raise children.

921
00:54:20.820 --> 00:54:22.600
<v Alison McKinnon>And the two are quite incompatible.

922
00:54:22.800 --> 00:54:25.180
<v Alison McKinnon>So, yes, I think you're right about all of that.

923
00:54:25.640 --> 00:54:26.260
<v Audience>Thank you.

924
00:54:28.060 --> 00:54:30.200
<v Audience>My question is,

925
00:54:31.000 --> 00:54:32.620
<v Audience>principally for the best of all,

926
00:54:32.860 --> 00:54:35.580
<v Audience>can we generally say that women,

927
00:54:36.820 --> 00:54:40.840
<v Audience>can they consider that the addition to the value of work,

928
00:54:41.820 --> 00:54:43.200
<v Audience>and the combination of women,

929
00:54:43.360 --> 00:54:44.820
<v Audience>and women based in Australia,

930
00:54:45.820 --> 00:54:49.820
<v Audience>have you considered the aspects of culture

931
00:54:49.820 --> 00:54:51.820
<v Audience>and bringing it to Australia,

932
00:54:52.040 --> 00:54:54.620
<v Audience>is radically different from culture?

933
00:54:54.940 --> 00:54:58.340
<v Audience>And we have heard that these cultures must be respected.

934
00:54:59.820 --> 00:55:04.280
<v Audience>These cultures must take traditional practices and beliefs

935
00:55:04.820 --> 00:55:10.020
<v Audience>which are quite as solid and to them as true

936
00:55:10.020 --> 00:55:11.400
<v Audience>as our own.

937
00:55:11.780 --> 00:55:17.640
<v Audience>And they include things like belief in the inferiority of women,

938
00:55:18.100 --> 00:55:23.640
<v Audience>belief in the practice of genital mutilation of females that exist,

939
00:55:25.120 --> 00:55:27.980
<v Audience>belief in the ritual of the culture of animals,

940
00:55:29.040 --> 00:55:36.040
<v Audience>belief that the family is justified in doing anything in life

941
00:55:36.040 --> 00:55:38.640
<v Audience>which the family is wholly responsible for,

942
00:55:38.640 --> 00:55:41.800
<v Audience>and a dislike of the rules of the law,

943
00:55:42.640 --> 00:55:48.600
<v Audience>and belief that things like crime are normal practices of Christmas.

944
00:55:48.900 --> 00:55:55.320
<v Doug McEachern>Now, these are all facts of life with large-scale dangers happening.

945
00:55:56.640 --> 00:55:59.240
<v Doug McEachern>Okay, can you bring your question to a close, please?

946
00:55:59.540 --> 00:56:00.880
<v Doug McEachern>My question is,

947
00:56:01.640 --> 00:56:07.620
<v Audience>does the panel consider that it is vital to allow large-scale innovation

948
00:56:07.620 --> 00:56:10.320
<v Audience>of people who have been...

949
00:56:10.320 --> 00:56:14.040
<v Doug McEachern>Okay, it's a standard question about immigration

950
00:56:14.040 --> 00:56:17.420
<v Doug McEachern>from those whose cultures are apparently different from our own.

951
00:56:17.640 --> 00:56:20.800
<v Fran Baum>I would have imagined that a little over 200 years ago,

952
00:56:21.000 --> 00:56:24.420
<v Fran Baum>the first Australians raised lots of questions like yours.

953
00:56:28.620 --> 00:56:32.000
<v Fran Baum>They would have been faced with an incoming culture

954
00:56:32.000 --> 00:56:33.700
<v Fran Baum>that thought they were inferior,

955
00:56:33.940 --> 00:56:37.300
<v Fran Baum>with an incoming culture that proceeded to introduce

956
00:56:37.620 --> 00:56:38.560
<v Fran Baum>infectious diseases,

957
00:56:38.760 --> 00:56:41.760
<v Fran Baum>that proceeded to totally devastate their culture.

958
00:56:41.900 --> 00:56:45.000
<v Fran Baum>So I think your question reflects a traditional Australian concern.

959
00:56:46.320 --> 00:56:50.560
<v Fran Baum>My viewpoint from the perspective of the 21st century

960
00:56:50.560 --> 00:56:55.580
<v Fran Baum>is that the multicultural nature of Australian society

961
00:56:55.580 --> 00:56:57.420
<v Fran Baum>is completely heartwarming.

962
00:56:57.780 --> 00:57:00.620
<v Fran Baum>I always feel so proud...

963
00:57:00.620 --> 00:57:02.760
<v Fran Baum>I mean, I'm a migrant myself from England,

964
00:57:02.880 --> 00:57:04.400
<v Fran Baum>as you can probably tell from my voice,

965
00:57:04.440 --> 00:57:07.600
<v Fran Baum>but when I go overseas and you look at different cultures,

966
00:57:07.620 --> 00:57:09.200
<v Fran Baum>and I always think back to Australia,

967
00:57:09.440 --> 00:57:11.400
<v Fran Baum>and I just think how amazing it is

968
00:57:11.400 --> 00:57:14.660
<v Fran Baum>and what a tribute to, collectively, Australia it is,

969
00:57:14.760 --> 00:57:18.240
<v Fran Baum>that we've managed to meld this wonderful multicultural society.

970
00:57:18.780 --> 00:57:20.720
<v Fran Baum>And you just look at Adelaide, where we've...

971
00:57:20.720 --> 00:57:23.960
<v Fran Baum>You know, the town has embraced English people,

972
00:57:24.200 --> 00:57:26.380
<v Fran Baum>Irish people, Greek people, Italian people,

973
00:57:26.560 --> 00:57:29.660
<v Fran Baum>Vietnamese, Cambodians, Spanish, and on and on and on.

974
00:57:29.820 --> 00:57:31.800
<v Fran Baum>And it's made it a much richer culture.

975
00:57:31.980 --> 00:57:34.120
<v Fran Baum>And out of that, we've got something different.

976
00:57:34.420 --> 00:57:36.440
<v Fran Baum>And I just think that's something to celebrate,

977
00:57:36.440 --> 00:57:37.760
<v Fran Baum>not to be scared of.

978
00:57:37.900 --> 00:57:39.820
<v Fran Baum>We just have to be able to embrace it.

979
00:57:40.620 --> 00:57:41.180
<v Doug McEachern>APPLAUSE

980
00:57:44.220 --> 00:57:47.300
<v Audience>Just a quick question.

981
00:57:47.460 --> 00:57:50.980
<v Audience>It appears that the population debate in Australia

982
00:57:50.980 --> 00:57:53.120
<v Audience>is characterised by commentators

983
00:57:53.120 --> 00:57:59.080
<v Audience>who derive numbers or goals following Dr Flannery's argument.

984
00:57:59.920 --> 00:58:02.220
<v Audience>And I'm just wondering where Professor MacKinnon

985
00:58:02.220 --> 00:58:04.640
<v Audience>has derived her figure of 23 million.

986
00:58:04.860 --> 00:58:06.420
<v Audience>Obviously, it's on the basis of...

987
00:58:06.420 --> 00:58:11.220
<v Audience>..her particular environmental, social or economic opinions

988
00:58:11.220 --> 00:58:12.020
<v Audience>from her field,

989
00:58:12.120 --> 00:58:14.580
<v Audience>and if she could just enlighten us about that.

990
00:58:16.220 --> 00:58:16.920
<v Doug McEachern>Alison.

991
00:58:17.260 --> 00:58:19.340
<v Alison McKinnon>Yes, I'm happy to.

992
00:58:20.620 --> 00:58:22.840
<v Alison McKinnon>..the government's very important

993
00:58:22.840 --> 00:58:25.320
<v Audience>about the first election year,

994
00:58:26.400 --> 00:58:30.100
<v Audience>which, my notes and my other artistic passages

995
00:58:30.100 --> 00:58:33.540
<v Audience>and the reasons were a fair go and a fair bid,

996
00:58:34.420 --> 00:58:34.980
<v Audience>and those...

997
00:58:34.980 --> 00:58:36.180
<v Audience>I'm not sure that...

998
00:58:36.180 --> 00:58:36.980
<v Fran Baum>..the government...

999
00:58:39.600 --> 00:58:40.280
<v Fran Baum>Yes.

1000
00:58:40.760 --> 00:58:42.940
<v Alison McKinnon>I'd have to agree with that statement too.

1001
00:58:43.080 --> 00:58:46.720
<v Alison McKinnon>But back to the earlier question about those figures.

1002
00:58:46.900 --> 00:58:50.580
<v Alison McKinnon>There has been a great deal of work done by demographers

1003
00:58:50.580 --> 00:58:53.560
<v Alison McKinnon>and others around the various figures.

1004
00:58:53.640 --> 00:58:57.720
<v Alison McKinnon>As you know, we have a population of 19 million now.

1005
00:58:58.440 --> 00:59:03.340
<v Alison McKinnon>If you project the birth rate,

1006
00:59:03.460 --> 00:59:04.960
<v Alison McKinnon>which is just a small number,

1007
00:59:04.960 --> 00:59:07.140
<v Alison McKinnon>which is slowly decreasing, as I pointed out,

1008
00:59:07.600 --> 00:59:12.500
<v Alison McKinnon>and you look at immigration levels of about 85,000 a year,

1009
00:59:12.660 --> 00:59:15.560
<v Alison McKinnon>which is the current immigration setting,

1010
00:59:15.800 --> 00:59:17.640
<v Alison McKinnon>although that varies a bit from year to year,

1011
00:59:17.760 --> 00:59:19.640
<v Alison McKinnon>if you move that all forward,

1012
00:59:19.860 --> 00:59:23.400
<v Alison McKinnon>you can get to a figure of about 23 million

1013
00:59:23.960 --> 00:59:27.400
<v Alison McKinnon>by about 2030 or 2040.

1014
00:59:28.000 --> 00:59:28.900
<v Alison McKinnon>And that...

1015
00:59:28.900 --> 00:59:31.920
<v Alison McKinnon>There has been a great deal of work around that figure,

1016
00:59:32.040 --> 00:59:33.980
<v Alison McKinnon>and that is one which is seen

1017
00:59:33.980 --> 00:59:38.800
<v Alison McKinnon>to be sustaining a population that isn't ageing too rapidly,

1018
00:59:38.960 --> 00:59:42.560
<v Alison McKinnon>that does keep some sort of balance.

1019
00:59:43.040 --> 00:59:46.260
<v Alison McKinnon>And I've heard Peter MacDonald, the demographer from ANU,

1020
00:59:46.260 --> 00:59:47.440
<v Alison McKinnon>talk about this quite a lot,

1021
00:59:47.480 --> 00:59:51.740
<v Alison McKinnon>and we think of traditional societies as rather like a triangle

1022
00:59:51.740 --> 00:59:55.620
<v Alison McKinnon>with a very large number of young people at the bottom

1023
00:59:55.620 --> 00:59:58.500
<v Alison McKinnon>decreasing as we go through the ages.

1024
00:59:59.200 --> 01:00:00.440
<v Alison McKinnon>And he has...

1025
01:00:00.440 --> 01:00:03.200
<v Alison McKinnon>He argues if we don't maintain...

1026
01:00:03.980 --> 01:00:05.160
<v Alison McKinnon>..this level...

1027
01:00:05.160 --> 01:00:06.160
<v Alison McKinnon>..a level of immigration,

1028
01:00:06.520 --> 01:00:09.480
<v Alison McKinnon>we will have rather more of a coffin shape

1029
01:00:09.480 --> 01:00:14.700
<v Alison McKinnon>with a narrow bottom and a sort of broadening area at the top.

1030
01:00:15.140 --> 01:00:19.400
<v Alison McKinnon>So these figures do come from Australian Bureau of Statistics.

1031
01:00:19.960 --> 01:00:22.280
<v Alison McKinnon>They're worked on quite a lot by demographers.

1032
01:00:22.460 --> 01:00:25.060
<v Alison McKinnon>But, of course, as Tim and others have pointed out,

1033
01:00:25.220 --> 01:00:28.600
<v Alison McKinnon>they're projections, and projections can be notoriously wrong.

1034
01:00:28.680 --> 01:00:30.580
<v Alison McKinnon>There might be a baby boom around the corner.

1035
01:00:30.720 --> 01:00:32.840
<v Alison McKinnon>Goodness knows. I don't think so. Thanks.

1036
01:00:32.840 --> 01:00:34.140
<v Doug McEachern>One last question.

1037
01:00:40.900 --> 01:00:46.560
<v Audience>Tim and Fran have both articulated some aspects of a vision for the future,

1038
01:00:46.640 --> 01:00:48.840
<v Audience>and I really don't quite understand

1039
01:00:48.840 --> 01:00:52.560
<v Audience>what is the fundamental difference between your two viewpoints.

1040
01:00:52.740 --> 01:00:54.340
<v Audience>Could you please clarify this?

1041
01:00:55.120 --> 01:00:57.480
<v Tim Flannery>Yeah. I suppose... Briefly.

1042
01:00:57.500 --> 01:01:01.260
<v Tim Flannery>It really... To me, the debate centres around...

1043
01:01:02.920 --> 01:01:04.740
<v Tim Flannery>..how you would set a population policy.

1044
01:01:05.120 --> 01:01:06.840
<v Tim Flannery>And what Fran is suggesting, really,

1045
01:01:06.900 --> 01:01:08.920
<v Tim Flannery>is that we assume that we'll get better,

1046
01:01:09.000 --> 01:01:11.880
<v Tim Flannery>that we assume that we'll become a different species, if you want,

1047
01:01:11.900 --> 01:01:13.780
<v Tim Flannery>that our resource utilisation will drop,

1048
01:01:13.880 --> 01:01:15.940
<v Tim Flannery>and we factor that into a population policy.

1049
01:01:16.420 --> 01:01:19.060
<v Tim Flannery>Now, as a hard-nosed biologist, I'd say, you know,

1050
01:01:19.080 --> 01:01:21.340
<v Tim Flannery>I know how many leaves a koala eats a day,

1051
01:01:21.420 --> 01:01:24.220
<v Tim Flannery>and if you ask me how many koalas will fit into a particular-sized reserve,

1052
01:01:24.380 --> 01:01:26.060
<v Tim Flannery>I can tell you, but I'm not going to assume

1053
01:01:26.060 --> 01:01:28.180
<v Tim Flannery>that they're going to eat half as many leaves to do it, you know?

1054
01:01:28.500 --> 01:01:31.920
<v Tim Flannery>So while I want to see us change, I really want to see us become

1055
01:01:31.920 --> 01:01:34.560
<v Tim Flannery>much more conservative society, obviously,

1056
01:01:35.200 --> 01:01:37.880
<v Tim Flannery>I wouldn't dare factor that into a population policy.

1057
01:01:38.180 --> 01:01:41.300
<v Tim Flannery>What I think should happen is that the population policy should react.

1058
01:01:41.440 --> 01:01:43.000
<v Tim Flannery>So as we become better conservators,

1059
01:01:43.080 --> 01:01:45.060
<v Tim Flannery>we have more latitude to increase population,

1060
01:01:45.340 --> 01:01:46.440
<v Tim Flannery>if that's what we wish to do,

1061
01:01:46.620 --> 01:01:49.480
<v Tim Flannery>but not to assume that we're a different sort of species from what we are.

1062
01:01:49.920 --> 01:01:50.580
<v Tim Flannery>OK, Fran.

1063
01:01:52.640 --> 01:01:56.580
<v Fran Baum>I guess, in lots of ways, there's not that much difference between us,

1064
01:01:56.660 --> 01:01:58.780
<v Fran Baum>but you want an interesting debate, so we have to...

1065
01:01:58.780 --> 01:02:01.180
<v Fran Baum>But I think the one difference would be

1066
01:02:01.180 --> 01:02:05.560
<v Fran Baum>that I'm wary of any public policy that gets abstracted from other public policies,

1067
01:02:05.720 --> 01:02:07.840
<v Fran Baum>because I think there's a real synergy between them.

1068
01:02:08.140 --> 01:02:12.440
<v Fran Baum>And, of course, I hear similar arguments to Tim's about population

1069
01:02:12.440 --> 01:02:13.740
<v Fran Baum>as I do from economists.

1070
01:02:14.200 --> 01:02:17.140
<v Fran Baum>You know, get the economy right, then we'll be able to deal with the other things.

1071
01:02:17.240 --> 01:02:18.620
<v Fran Baum>But, of course, the economy's never right.

1072
01:02:18.920 --> 01:02:21.800
<v Fran Baum>So, for me, public policy should be integrated,

1073
01:02:22.280 --> 01:02:25.800
<v Fran Baum>and we should be looking at the synergies between them

1074
01:02:25.800 --> 01:02:28.140
<v Fran Baum>rather than saying, well, population or economy

1075
01:02:28.140 --> 01:02:30.380
<v Fran Baum>or any other public policy area is special.

1076
01:02:30.560 --> 01:02:31.160
<v Fran Baum>And if we're going to do that,

1077
01:02:31.180 --> 01:02:33.380
<v Fran Baum>then, in fact, we want a sort of a balance

1078
01:02:33.380 --> 01:02:36.120
<v Fran Baum>between social, economic and environmental factors,

1079
01:02:36.320 --> 01:02:38.700
<v Fran Baum>and it's in the middle of that that we get good policy

1080
01:02:38.700 --> 01:02:40.440
<v Fran Baum>when we've considered those three areas.

1081
01:02:40.640 --> 01:02:42.280
<v Fran Baum>So, for me, that's something of a difference.

1082
01:02:42.640 --> 01:02:43.580
<v Doug McEachern>OK, thank you.

1083
01:02:47.500 --> 01:02:50.880
<v Doug McEachern>Well, we've made a beginning by being able to prove,

1084
01:02:51.000 --> 01:02:53.520
<v Doug McEachern>I think, without too much qualification,

1085
01:02:54.080 --> 01:02:57.720
<v Doug McEachern>that it is possible to have a debate about population policy

1086
01:02:58.520 --> 01:03:00.120
<v Doug McEachern>even if we can't actually have

1087
01:03:00.120 --> 01:03:01.440
<v Doug McEachern>a population policy.

1088
01:03:02.400 --> 01:03:03.000
<v Doug McEachern>The...

1089
01:03:04.940 --> 01:03:07.780
<v Doug McEachern>When I taught Australian politics,

1090
01:03:07.940 --> 01:03:08.860
<v Doug McEachern>which wasn't all that long ago,

1091
01:03:09.760 --> 01:03:12.960
<v Doug McEachern>I always used to set the topic of population policy

1092
01:03:12.960 --> 01:03:14.720
<v Doug McEachern>very early in the piece

1093
01:03:15.460 --> 01:03:19.040
<v Doug McEachern>because it showed an issue that,

1094
01:03:19.960 --> 01:03:21.440
<v Doug McEachern>to my mind at least,

1095
01:03:22.140 --> 01:03:25.280
<v Doug McEachern>lies behind so many of the anxieties and concerns

1096
01:03:25.280 --> 01:03:27.960
<v Doug McEachern>that make public policy throughout the history of Australian politics,

1097
01:03:28.040 --> 01:03:29.220
<v Doug McEachern>from the white Australia policy

1098
01:03:29.220 --> 01:03:33.020
<v Doug McEachern>through to the attitude towards World War I, World War II,

1099
01:03:33.160 --> 01:03:34.560
<v Doug McEachern>post-war migration,

1100
01:03:34.800 --> 01:03:40.280
<v Doug McEachern>right down to questions of IVF and modern biological techniques.

1101
01:03:40.680 --> 01:03:43.600
<v Doug McEachern>Lurking behind it are arguments about population policy,

1102
01:03:44.240 --> 01:03:46.800
<v Doug McEachern>the question of migration about refugees,

1103
01:03:46.960 --> 01:03:48.300
<v Doug McEachern>and at all points,

1104
01:03:48.400 --> 01:03:52.700
<v Doug McEachern>we find great tension inside the Australian political community

1105
01:03:52.700 --> 01:03:54.740
<v Doug McEachern>as it tries to answer those questions.

1106
01:03:55.960 --> 01:03:58.160
<v Doug McEachern>It's a policy that I always like to take

1107
01:03:58.160 --> 01:04:00.480
<v Doug McEachern>because it has so much heat in it and scope for heat,

1108
01:04:01.320 --> 01:04:04.560
<v Doug McEachern>and that it continually returns to haunt the political imagination.

1109
01:04:06.500 --> 01:04:08.120
<v Doug McEachern>The problem that we face today

1110
01:04:08.120 --> 01:04:09.780
<v Doug McEachern>was not in raising the issues,

1111
01:04:10.500 --> 01:04:12.400
<v Doug McEachern>not in going through what would be required

1112
01:04:12.400 --> 01:04:14.260
<v Doug McEachern>for an argument about population policy,

1113
01:04:14.520 --> 01:04:16.640
<v Doug McEachern>what kind of research agenda would be required,

1114
01:04:17.620 --> 01:04:20.440
<v Doug McEachern>but the question about what kind of public debate,

1115
01:04:21.280 --> 01:04:23.520
<v Doug McEachern>what kind of policy framework,

1116
01:04:23.820 --> 01:04:25.560
<v Doug McEachern>and how would it be engendered.

1117
01:04:26.300 --> 01:04:27.140
<v Doug McEachern>In other words,

1118
01:04:27.140 --> 01:04:28.620
<v Doug McEachern>to ask the same kind of question

1119
01:04:29.140 --> 01:04:30.380
<v Doug McEachern>that people like me would have been asking

1120
01:04:30.380 --> 01:04:32.760
<v Doug McEachern>when the white Australia policy was first put on the books.

1121
01:04:33.260 --> 01:04:36.900
<v Doug McEachern>How do you actually decide these kinds of questions

1122
01:04:36.900 --> 01:04:38.720
<v Doug McEachern>in ways that makes for resolution?

1123
01:04:40.000 --> 01:04:41.780
<v Doug McEachern>And the argument that we've had today,

1124
01:04:41.880 --> 01:04:43.040
<v Doug McEachern>or the discussion we've had today,

1125
01:04:43.240 --> 01:04:45.900
<v Doug McEachern>says that there is a responsibility on our part

1126
01:04:45.900 --> 01:04:49.800
<v Doug McEachern>to make the issues work for resolutions,

1127
01:04:49.960 --> 01:04:52.140
<v Doug McEachern>to find ways of thinking through the issues

1128
01:04:52.140 --> 01:04:54.080
<v Doug McEachern>that can then become politically effective.

1129
01:04:54.620 --> 01:04:56.600
<v Doug McEachern>And as all three speakers said,

1130
01:04:57.140 --> 01:04:58.880
<v Doug McEachern>in recognising the importance of this issue,

1131
01:04:59.020 --> 01:05:01.240
<v Doug McEachern>the limits of the public debate

1132
01:05:01.240 --> 01:05:04.300
<v Doug McEachern>prevents us from being successful in this regard.

1133
01:05:05.240 --> 01:05:08.220
<v Doug McEachern>And though Tim and Fran and Alison

1134
01:05:08.220 --> 01:05:10.160
<v Doug McEachern>were arguing about different ways

1135
01:05:10.160 --> 01:05:11.900
<v Doug McEachern>of thinking through the population policy,

1136
01:05:12.080 --> 01:05:14.660
<v Doug McEachern>they all agreed on one fundamental point.

1137
01:05:14.800 --> 01:05:17.440
<v Doug McEachern>The arena of public debate has narrowed

1138
01:05:17.440 --> 01:05:19.340
<v Doug McEachern>and it needs to be made broader

1139
01:05:20.140 --> 01:05:21.700
<v Doug McEachern>so that we can hold these conversations.

1140
01:05:22.360 --> 01:05:25.600
<v Doug McEachern>And so I would like you all to thank these three speakers,

1141
01:05:25.720 --> 01:05:27.120
<v Doug McEachern>but also to recognise...

1142
01:05:27.140 --> 01:05:28.920
<v Doug McEachern>..the challenge for us all. Thank you.

