WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:04.220
<v Chair>Good morning. Our first hymn will be Jesus Wants Me for Sunday.

2
00:00:06.900 --> 00:00:09.200
<v Chair>You'll find the music on your seats.

3
00:00:12.960 --> 00:00:14.180
<v Chair>Why are you laughing?

4
00:00:14.980 --> 00:00:20.340
<v Chair>Look, this session, which I'll get around to introducing properly in a minute,

5
00:00:20.460 --> 00:00:23.180
<v Chair>is going to be reincarnated as a broadcast.

6
00:00:24.300 --> 00:00:28.780
<v Chair>It'll go out, I hope, as a late night live

7
00:00:28.780 --> 00:00:32.080
<v Chair>and for that reason and for others,

8
00:00:32.840 --> 00:00:35.060
<v Chair>when we get to questions, where are the microphones?

9
00:00:35.400 --> 00:00:36.500
<v Chair>Do we have mics for questions?

10
00:00:38.280 --> 00:00:40.060
<v Chair>Everyone's pointing, I can't see the damn thing.

11
00:00:40.200 --> 00:00:43.060
<v Chair>Oh, it's there, okay. And is there one upstairs in the gods?

12
00:00:44.640 --> 00:00:46.620
<v Chair>A woman just fell on the stairs upstairs.

13
00:00:47.100 --> 00:00:48.180
<v Chair>Oh, she's done it again.

14
00:00:48.420 --> 00:00:50.480
<v Chair>Okay, there's a microphone up there as well.

15
00:00:50.600 --> 00:00:54.360
<v Chair>So when we get to social intercourse with the panel,

16
00:00:55.280 --> 00:00:57.440
<v Chair>please use the appropriate instrument.

17
00:00:58.220 --> 00:00:58.660
<v Chair>Okay.

18
00:00:58.780 --> 00:01:00.320
<v Chair>Okay, let's get started.

19
00:01:02.900 --> 00:01:06.560
<v Chair>Welcome back to the Adelaide Festival of Ideas,

20
00:01:07.160 --> 00:01:10.760
<v Chair>taking place in the highly ecclesiastic Benithon Hall.

21
00:01:11.960 --> 00:01:14.520
<v Chair>The subject, One World Ready or Not.

22
00:01:15.500 --> 00:01:18.880
<v Chair>Globalisation, long accused of being a vector for Americanisation.

23
00:01:19.900 --> 00:01:21.280
<v Chair>If this is so, it doesn't matter.

24
00:01:22.320 --> 00:01:25.660
<v Chair>Are we not gaining prosperity at the cost of only shedding some

25
00:01:25.660 --> 00:01:27.980
<v Chair>recidivist cultural tendencies?

26
00:01:29.000 --> 00:01:32.060
<v Chair>Examine the promises of globalisation and the costs.

27
00:01:32.140 --> 00:01:36.860
<v Chair>Are the benefits going disproportionately to the so-called freedom-loving nations,

28
00:01:37.120 --> 00:01:41.180
<v Chair>while the costs in terms of human misery are visited on the poor?

29
00:01:41.380 --> 00:01:45.260
<v Chair>Is there a transnational global elite which is profiting,

30
00:01:45.340 --> 00:01:49.060
<v Chair>while opportunities for the poor and less mobile recede?

31
00:01:49.600 --> 00:01:52.800
<v Chair>Have we perhaps seen the high watermark of globalisation,

32
00:01:53.040 --> 00:01:58.760
<v Chair>and is the world starting to divide into blocks along cultural trade and trade?

33
00:01:58.760 --> 00:01:59.240
<v Chair>Are we seeing the rise of the globalisation of the world's most important and most important

34
00:01:59.240 --> 00:01:59.680
<v Chair>and most important political lines?

35
00:02:00.320 --> 00:02:06.960
<v Chair>Now, to analyse this from the various vantage points,

36
00:02:07.260 --> 00:02:13.520
<v Chair>we have Amy Dean, recognised by the New York Times as one of the most innovative figures

37
00:02:13.520 --> 00:02:14.480
<v Chair>in Silicon Valley.

38
00:02:14.820 --> 00:02:21.300
<v Chair>She leads the labour movement there, where she's the Chief Executive Officer of the South

39
00:02:21.300 --> 00:02:23.840
<v Chair>Bay AFL-CIO Labour Council.

40
00:02:24.380 --> 00:02:28.740
<v Chair>Her immense credentials are, of course, detailed for you in the slides.

41
00:02:28.740 --> 00:02:31.420
<v Chair>Given everyone

42
00:02:51.860 --> 00:03:01.840
<v Chair>Messiah. No. It says here, well, first of all, he's not the son of God, but he is the son of the

43
00:03:03.220 --> 00:03:12.320
<v Chair>boss of the Conservative Party. More or less the same thing. And down here it says, and this is a

44
00:03:12.320 --> 00:03:17.660
<v Chair>really interesting and significant matter, and I ask you to think about this, he was pronounced

45
00:03:17.660 --> 00:03:37.740
<v Chair>clinically dead of cerebral malaria in Kenya, only to rise again. I rest my case. The Black Prince,

46
00:03:37.900 --> 00:03:47.140
<v Chair>as I call him, Zia Sadar. He's my new best friend.

47
00:03:47.660 --> 00:03:54.720
<v Chair>Very amusing. Very energetic. And look, his credentials go on and on. He's like a Superman

48
00:03:54.720 --> 00:04:01.740
<v Chair>critic. He's a writer, a broadcaster, a futurist, a cultural critic. But best of all, he has a

49
00:04:01.740 --> 00:04:07.220
<v Chair>remarkable uncle. And those of you who have attended Zia's performances will know about

50
00:04:07.220 --> 00:04:12.760
<v Chair>his uncle, who I don't think is of this planet. I think he's an extraterrestrial.

51
00:04:14.360 --> 00:04:16.720
<v Chair>Michael Woolcock. Now, Michael,

52
00:04:17.660 --> 00:04:23.300
<v Chair>you've got to be very nice to Michael. When I say that he works at the World Bank, you're not

53
00:04:23.300 --> 00:04:29.320
<v Chair>allowed to hiss, okay? He's a senior social scientist with the development research group

54
00:04:29.320 --> 00:04:34.240
<v Chair>at the World Bank, and they're okay. And an adjunct lecturer in public policy at Harvard

55
00:04:34.240 --> 00:04:39.880
<v Chair>University's Kennedy School of Government. So, once again, immense credentials.

56
00:04:45.580 --> 00:04:47.300
<v Chair>So our cup runneth over.

57
00:04:47.980 --> 00:04:50.020
<v Chair>Ladies and gentlemen, Amy Dean.

58
00:04:53.880 --> 00:05:01.200
<v Amy Dean>Thank you, Philip. Good afternoon. I thought there was so many different ways I could go with this

59
00:05:01.200 --> 00:05:06.400
<v Amy Dean>topic, such a broad topic, that I decided to just sort of pick one word out, the word

60
00:05:06.400 --> 00:05:11.280
<v Amy Dean>Americanization, and take a minute or two to reflect on that, which you've got to give me

61
00:05:11.280 --> 00:05:17.320
<v Amy Dean>a little bit of credit for. I was a little bit brave in this audience. But I thought that the

62
00:05:17.320 --> 00:05:17.640
<v Amy Dean>first thing I wanted to do was to talk about the Americanization of the world. And I thought that's

63
00:05:17.660 --> 00:05:20.720
<v Amy Dean>a great way to start off. And I thought that the phrase Americanization was a convenient one to use,

64
00:05:20.880 --> 00:05:26.520
<v Amy Dean>and in an odd way, that it was almost comforting to the extent that it implies that a nation's

65
00:05:26.520 --> 00:05:31.740
<v Amy Dean>boundaries still really even matter. And if you've ever had the misfortune like I had the other day

66
00:05:31.740 --> 00:05:36.660
<v Amy Dean>when I was 20 minutes before getting ready to give a presentation, and my computer stopped working,

67
00:05:37.380 --> 00:05:42.220
<v Amy Dean>I had to take out the components in my laptop, and I noticed as I was doing that,

68
00:05:42.300 --> 00:05:46.980
<v Amy Dean>that most of the parts were either manufactured in Indonesia and half a dozen other countries.

69
00:05:47.780 --> 00:05:55.440
<v Amy Dean>Well, okay, you may say, well, the software is at least American. But is it if, as is very often the case,

70
00:05:55.540 --> 00:05:59.960
<v Amy Dean>and I know this because my husband works in the industry, if the software engineer that's

71
00:05:59.960 --> 00:06:04.800
<v Amy Dean>developing in California is Indian? Or if at the end of the day, that person's day,

72
00:06:05.560 --> 00:06:09.960
<v Amy Dean>another engineer in Asia or Australia or Europe turns on their computer,

73
00:06:10.160 --> 00:06:17.020
<v Amy Dean>opens a common file, and continues to work on the same project. And is it good? If it can be,

74
00:06:17.020 --> 00:06:23.200
<v Amy Dean>I think, if each of the workers who are part of the process are respected and paid fair wages and have opportunities for advancement.

75
00:06:24.360 --> 00:06:31.020
<v Amy Dean>The fact that this is often isn't the case has, I think, less to do with whether a corporation's executives are American

76
00:06:31.020 --> 00:06:33.200
<v Amy Dean>than whether they are greedy. And

77
00:06:33.200 --> 00:06:37.460
<v Amy Dean>rumors to the contrary, greed has never been a uniquely American characteristic trait.

78
00:06:38.120 --> 00:06:40.420
<v Amy Dean>Even though I realize at times it may seem that way.

79
00:06:41.660 --> 00:06:46.740
<v Amy Dean>After all, Royal Dutch, Shell, BP, Nestle, they did not get to where they are

80
00:06:47.020 --> 00:06:48.300
<v Amy Dean>through good works and altruism.

81
00:06:49.460 --> 00:06:52.140
<v Amy Dean>For that matter, neither did Rupert Murdoch.

82
00:06:55.040 --> 00:07:01.160
<v Amy Dean>What is most American, I think, has been our success in fusing together greed and marketing expertise

83
00:07:01.160 --> 00:07:05.820
<v Amy Dean>to determine the content of what people see after the components go into that computer.

84
00:07:06.140 --> 00:07:10.000
<v Amy Dean>They turn it on, they go online, and they click onto a service like AOL.

85
00:07:10.680 --> 00:07:13.100
<v Amy Dean>And when they do, it's going to feel American to them.

86
00:07:13.220 --> 00:07:17.000
<v Amy Dean>And of course, the same applies to films and television, music, books,

87
00:07:17.020 --> 00:07:17.400
<v Amy Dean>and more.

88
00:07:18.180 --> 00:07:20.680
<v Amy Dean>None of this, however, I think, is particularly new.

89
00:07:21.580 --> 00:07:26.820
<v Amy Dean>For the last 40 years or so, a lot's been said about American cultural imperialism,

90
00:07:26.820 --> 00:07:29.860
<v Amy Dean>and some countries have adopted different strategies to cope with it.

91
00:07:30.360 --> 00:07:34.000
<v Amy Dean>The fear was that their cultures would be replaced by America's,

92
00:07:34.020 --> 00:07:37.340
<v Amy Dean>and I think, to some extent, those fears were exaggerated.

93
00:07:38.200 --> 00:07:44.600
<v Amy Dean>Now, while the bad news may have been that the U.S. content continued to play a more prominent role throughout the world,

94
00:07:44.780 --> 00:07:47.000
<v Amy Dean>the good news that, I believe,

95
00:07:47.000 --> 00:07:50.800
<v Amy Dean>is that its impact hasn't been quite the disaster that some have feared.

96
00:07:51.960 --> 00:07:55.600
<v Amy Dean>Now, I was hesitant to bring this up in such a smart crowd of people,

97
00:07:55.700 --> 00:07:58.560
<v Amy Dean>but does anybody ever remember the show Dallas back in the 1980s?

98
00:07:58.560 --> 00:07:59.180
<v Amy Dean>Just raise your hand.

99
00:07:59.600 --> 00:08:00.360
<v Amy Dean>Oh, phew!

100
00:08:01.240 --> 00:08:04.200
<v Amy Dean>Because I thought, oh, I'm going to be in a crowd where nobody's going to remember Dallas.

101
00:08:05.460 --> 00:08:07.960
<v Amy Dean>Well, the program had an enormous following worldwide.

102
00:08:08.700 --> 00:08:12.440
<v Amy Dean>But what research found was that rather than having a homogenizing impact,

103
00:08:12.680 --> 00:08:15.800
<v Amy Dean>viewers in different countries saw it through their own unique cultural prism.

104
00:08:16.220 --> 00:08:16.660
<v Amy Dean>And,

105
00:08:16.660 --> 00:08:20.620
<v Amy Dean>Arab viewers interpreted it differently from Dutch viewers.

106
00:08:21.400 --> 00:08:25.800
<v Amy Dean>And in 1988, a researcher that I recently came across by the name of Eric Michaels,

107
00:08:25.940 --> 00:08:30.140
<v Amy Dean>he found that Aboriginal people reinterpreted Dallas through their notions of kinship

108
00:08:30.660 --> 00:08:32.460
<v Amy Dean>in a way much different than Americans did.

109
00:08:32.780 --> 00:08:37.340
<v Amy Dean>And what's more, in Japan and Brazil, Dallas was a flop and it never even caught on.

110
00:08:38.620 --> 00:08:44.540
<v Amy Dean>So, what can happen is that instead of foreign content changing the way people see their own culture,

111
00:08:44.540 --> 00:08:48.300
<v Amy Dean>native culture changes the way people interpret foreign content.

112
00:08:48.960 --> 00:08:52.280
<v Amy Dean>What I find troubling today is that unlike the 1980s,

113
00:08:52.280 --> 00:08:56.540
<v Amy Dean>we're not only talking about a few American TV shows, McDonald's and Kentucky Fried Chicken,

114
00:08:57.120 --> 00:09:07.480
<v Amy Dean>today we're faced with a small group of powerful conglomerates whose control over the media and its content exceeds anything that we've seen in the past.

115
00:09:07.860 --> 00:09:12.260
<v Amy Dean>And the products that they're peddling make shows like Dallas seem like high art.

116
00:09:13.160 --> 00:09:13.720
<v Amy Dean>.

117
00:09:15.200 --> 00:09:22.020
<v Amy Dean>And the reason for that is that these companies aren't in the business of producing TV shows, publishing magazines, or making films.

118
00:09:22.420 --> 00:09:24.300
<v Amy Dean>Fundamentally, they're in the business of making money.

119
00:09:24.660 --> 00:09:26.520
<v Amy Dean>Consider MTV, Music TV.

120
00:09:27.060 --> 00:09:34.600
<v Amy Dean>Here's a TV network that's essentially 24 hour a day, 7 day a week series of advertisements carefully targeted for teenage consumers.

121
00:09:35.720 --> 00:09:41.580
<v Amy Dean>They broadcast videos produced by record labels that select which musicians to promote based on focus group research.

122
00:09:42.880 --> 00:09:53.360
<v Amy Dean>Interspersed with it are original shows like Spring Break, in which real college students attending an MTV produced beach party are often invited to participate in sexual contests on stage.

123
00:09:54.080 --> 00:09:55.480
<v Amy Dean>Now who owns MTV?

124
00:09:56.400 --> 00:09:57.080
<v Amy Dean>Viacom.

125
00:09:57.300 --> 00:10:11.560
<v Amy Dean>And among its holdings, Viacom owns CBS Television in the US, Comedy Central, United Paramount Network, Nickelodeon, Paramount Film Studios, Blockbuster Video Stores, and Simon & Schuster Book Publishing.

126
00:10:12.240 --> 00:10:17.040
<v Amy Dean>This means Viacom can use each of its divisions to promote its other divisions' products.

127
00:10:17.420 --> 00:10:21.180
<v Amy Dean>For example, Howard Stern. Has anybody ever heard of Howard Stern? I was all so reluctant.

128
00:10:21.340 --> 00:10:23.520
<v Amy Dean>Oh, thank God for this young brother up here.

129
00:10:24.120 --> 00:10:24.600
<v Amy Dean>.

130
00:10:25.460 --> 00:10:28.040
<v Amy Dean>He's an obnoxious radio show host in the US.

131
00:10:28.280 --> 00:10:35.260
<v Amy Dean>And he's on 50 syndicated stations of Viacom's infinity radio stations.

132
00:10:35.800 --> 00:10:38.360
<v Amy Dean>And he actually hosted the MTV Music Awards.

133
00:10:39.360 --> 00:10:41.540
<v Amy Dean>Viacom, Simon & Schuster published his best selling album.

134
00:10:41.560 --> 00:10:42.300
<v Amy Dean>It was a great selling autobiography.

135
00:10:42.440 --> 00:10:45.860
<v Amy Dean>The book was then turned into a movie that was produced by Viacom's Paramount Pictures.

136
00:10:46.720 --> 00:10:52.460
<v Amy Dean>The movie grossed $40 million in the US alone and millions of dollars more through Viacom's Blockbuster Video.

137
00:10:52.960 --> 00:10:57.200
<v Amy Dean>Now, Howard Stern isn't a phenomenon of American culture, but of corporate marketing.

138
00:10:57.640 --> 00:11:00.460
<v Amy Dean>And it's even worse when it affects how the news is reported.

139
00:11:00.980 --> 00:11:05.960
<v Amy Dean>A bit earlier, I had mentioned to you someone who's no stranger to Australians, Rupert Murdoch.

140
00:11:06.780 --> 00:11:11.540
<v Amy Dean>Here's someone whose company, News Corporation, owns more media outlets than I could have imagined.

141
00:11:11.560 --> 00:11:12.360
<v Amy Dean>And I have time to list.

142
00:11:12.920 --> 00:11:20.300
<v Amy Dean>In the US, he's known principally for Fox TV, which offers by far the most conservative news coverage on American television.

143
00:11:20.940 --> 00:11:35.100
<v Amy Dean>There was a column in Columbia Journalism Review in the US where the writer recalled how the author of a book on Murdoch wrote that while trying to win Chinese government support for his proposal for a satellite television system when he was there,

144
00:11:35.200 --> 00:11:38.420
<v Amy Dean>the publishing house of HarperCollins, which Murdoch owns,

145
00:11:39.560 --> 00:11:41.540
<v Amy Dean>reneged on publishing a memoir about Christopher Perkins.

146
00:11:41.560 --> 00:11:44.440
<v Amy Dean>And he was the last British governor of Hong Kong.

147
00:11:45.420 --> 00:11:46.900
<v Amy Dean>The author wrote, quote,

148
00:11:46.960 --> 00:11:51.380
<v Amy Dean>It was common that Murdoch detested Patton, who was extremely unpopular with the Chinese leadership.

149
00:11:51.900 --> 00:11:59.820
<v Amy Dean>Not surprisingly, even though the controversy afterwards was reported around the world, Murdoch's newspapers, including the Times of London, hardly reported it.

150
00:12:00.240 --> 00:12:04.940
<v Amy Dean>Now, it's in this sense that I think the real issue isn't Americanization of culture.

151
00:12:05.120 --> 00:12:06.740
<v Amy Dean>It's the corporatization of culture.

152
00:12:06.880 --> 00:12:10.660
<v Amy Dean>And I think the ramifications of corporatization could be extremely devastating.

153
00:12:20.400 --> 00:12:21.280
<v Chair>Thank you.

154
00:12:22.320 --> 00:12:24.040
<v Chair>Thank you, Amy Dean.

155
00:12:24.220 --> 00:12:31.880
<v Chair>May another obnoxious radio presenter make one tiny point about American culture.

156
00:12:32.100 --> 00:12:40.520
<v Chair>I sacrificed my ample proportions on the altar trying to fight cultural imperialism in the film industry.

157
00:12:40.660 --> 00:12:41.540
<v Chair>And I think that's the real issue.

158
00:12:41.540 --> 00:12:43.940
<v Chair>And many of us spent generations doing it.

159
00:12:44.520 --> 00:12:51.760
<v Chair>At the moment, out of every $100 at the Australian box office, $94 goes to an American film,

160
00:12:52.480 --> 00:12:58.940
<v Chair>leaving $4 or $5 or, at the most, $6 to be divided up between Australia and the rest of the world.

161
00:12:59.740 --> 00:13:08.040
<v Chair>The fact that Rupert Murdoch is one of the owners of this phenomenal, concentrated industry doesn't do us much good.

162
00:13:08.860 --> 00:13:10.740
<v Chair>Ladies and gentlemen, the Messiah.

163
00:13:10.740 --> 00:13:11.740
<v Chair>George Monbiot.

164
00:13:19.080 --> 00:13:24.620
<v George Monbiot>Well, as those of you who've watched The Life of Brian will appreciate, I'm not the Messiah, just a very naughty boy.

165
00:13:26.340 --> 00:13:28.340
<v George Monbiot>And you are all individuals.

166
00:13:32.040 --> 00:13:32.760
<v George Monbiot>Thank you.

167
00:13:34.720 --> 00:13:39.580
<v George Monbiot>Now, I'm going to say something which many of you will regard as shocking and incomprehensible.

168
00:13:39.580 --> 00:13:43.300
<v George Monbiot>And will, in fact, demonstrate that I am, in fact, a very naughty boy.

169
00:13:43.600 --> 00:13:45.160
<v George Monbiot>And it's this.

170
00:13:45.600 --> 00:13:53.260
<v George Monbiot>That the world is suffering from a surfeit of internationalism and a deficit of globalization.

171
00:13:54.280 --> 00:13:55.540
<v George Monbiot>Well, what on earth do I mean?

172
00:13:55.880 --> 00:13:57.580
<v George Monbiot>And, of course, that's a good question.

173
00:13:57.640 --> 00:14:05.120
<v George Monbiot>Because one of the handicaps which the global justice movement has had to face is that the terms we deal with have been so poorly defined.

174
00:14:06.300 --> 00:14:09.520
<v George Monbiot>Globalization is a word which should possess clear meaning.

175
00:14:09.520 --> 00:14:09.560
<v George Monbiot>Globalization is a word which should possess clear meaning.

176
00:14:09.580 --> 00:14:12.220
<v George Monbiot>Which should trigger instant recognition.

177
00:14:13.020 --> 00:14:16.920
<v George Monbiot>Instead, it's become so loose as to be almost meaningless.

178
00:14:17.500 --> 00:14:22.080
<v George Monbiot>I've heard it used to describe everything from global terrorism to world music.

179
00:14:22.300 --> 00:14:26.280
<v George Monbiot>And, despite what some people might say, I can assure you they're not the same thing.

180
00:14:29.040 --> 00:14:38.800
<v George Monbiot>But most people, when they use the word globalization, intend, however vaguely, to refer to a number of simultaneous and connected processes.

181
00:14:38.800 --> 00:14:49.580
<v George Monbiot>One of them is the removal of controls on the movement of capital, permitting investors and speculators to shift their assets into and out of economies as they please.

182
00:14:50.120 --> 00:15:01.860
<v George Monbiot>Another is the removal of trade barriers and the merging of the rules which different nations imposed on the companies trading within their borders so that the rules worldwide become the same.

183
00:15:02.280 --> 00:15:08.700
<v George Monbiot>A third, which grows out of this, is the growth of multinational corporations and their displacement.

184
00:15:08.700 --> 00:15:10.960
<v George Monbiot>The development of local and national businesses.

185
00:15:11.560 --> 00:15:20.520
<v George Monbiot>Now, there's no question that these developments have contributed to the power of capital and, therefore, to the loss of citizens' ability to shape their own lives.

186
00:15:20.960 --> 00:15:27.420
<v George Monbiot>There's also no question that these processes have generated international debt, inequality, environmental destruction.

187
00:15:27.780 --> 00:15:31.720
<v George Monbiot>They've precipitated the collapse of several previously healthy economies.

188
00:15:32.880 --> 00:15:38.680
<v George Monbiot>But, like many others, I have in the past lazily used globalization as a tool to create a new world.

189
00:15:38.700 --> 00:15:46.940
<v George Monbiot>I've used it as shorthand for the problems we contest and internationalism as shorthand for the way in which we need to contest them.

190
00:15:47.300 --> 00:15:53.340
<v George Monbiot>And both terms have, over the course of generations, acquired their own currency among dissident movements.

191
00:15:53.900 --> 00:15:57.360
<v George Monbiot>Globalizations come to mean capitals escape from national controls.

192
00:15:58.340 --> 00:16:04.820
<v George Monbiot>Internationalism has come to mean unified action by citizens whose class interests transcend national borders.

193
00:16:05.420 --> 00:16:08.680
<v George Monbiot>But perhaps it's time we rescued these terms.

194
00:16:11.400 --> 00:16:17.180
<v George Monbiot>Internationalism, if it means anything, surely means interaction between or inter-nations.

195
00:16:18.240 --> 00:16:22.840
<v George Monbiot>Globalization means interaction beyond nations, unmediated by the state.

196
00:16:23.220 --> 00:16:31.120
<v George Monbiot>The global space, as opposed to the international space, is the one that we in the global justice movement inhabit.

197
00:16:31.500 --> 00:16:35.960
<v George Monbiot>It's the political space which has not been captured by nation states.

198
00:16:36.940 --> 00:16:38.680
<v George Monbiot>Take a look, for example, at the European Union.

199
00:16:38.700 --> 00:16:39.860
<v George Monbiot>The United Nations.

200
00:16:40.700 --> 00:16:44.700
<v George Monbiot>And here we see that its powers are delegated by nation states.

201
00:16:45.160 --> 00:16:50.000
<v George Monbiot>They claim to represent our concerns, but in fact they only represent their own.

202
00:16:51.020 --> 00:17:00.560
<v George Monbiot>The only issues they'll consider are those which are of interest to them, however repressive, unaccountable, and unrepresentative those nation states might be.

203
00:17:01.020 --> 00:17:07.460
<v George Monbiot>The nation state acts as a barrier between us and the body charged with resolving many of the problems affecting us.

204
00:17:07.460 --> 00:17:12.760
<v George Monbiot>The UN's problem is that global politics have been captured by nation states.

205
00:17:12.880 --> 00:17:17.940
<v George Monbiot>That globalization, in other words, has been forced to give way to internationalism.

206
00:17:18.920 --> 00:17:25.820
<v George Monbiot>The World Trade Organization deals with an issue which is more obviously international in character, the rules governing trade between nations.

207
00:17:26.120 --> 00:17:33.960
<v George Monbiot>And therefore, disastrous as its decisions have been, its international structure is arguably more appropriate than that of the UN.

208
00:17:34.560 --> 00:17:37.440
<v George Monbiot>But trade, of course, is an issue affected by nation states.

209
00:17:37.440 --> 00:17:45.280
<v George Monbiot>It is also affected by forces like the circulation of capital and the strategies of transnational corporations which are plainly global in character.

210
00:17:46.440 --> 00:17:53.840
<v George Monbiot>Internationalism alone appears to be an inadequate mechanism for restraining the destructive power of these global forces.

211
00:17:54.320 --> 00:18:05.480
<v George Monbiot>The global citizen whose class interests extend beyond the state and which are seldom represented by the state is left without influence over the way the global economy develops.

212
00:18:08.320 --> 00:18:12.660
<v George Monbiot>Globalization, if we are to understand the term correctly, is not the problem.

213
00:18:12.860 --> 00:18:19.800
<v George Monbiot>The problem is in fact the release from globalization which both corporations and nation states have been able to negotiate.

214
00:18:20.320 --> 00:18:27.160
<v George Monbiot>They have been able to operate so freely because the people of the world have no global means of restraining them.

215
00:18:28.260 --> 00:18:32.920
<v George Monbiot>Now, we recognize this reality even though we use the wrong terms to describe it.

216
00:18:33.060 --> 00:18:35.460
<v George Monbiot>We know that if we are to restrain the power of the world, we are to restrain the power of the world.

217
00:18:35.480 --> 00:18:41.900
<v George Monbiot>We know that if we are to restrain the power of capital and corporations and the policies of George Bush and Tony Blair and John Howard, we have to mobilize globally.

218
00:18:42.520 --> 00:18:51.780
<v George Monbiot>We know that if we act only at the level of the nation, we will achieve nothing, for the real decisions are being imposed on nation states by both global and international forces.

219
00:18:52.240 --> 00:19:00.340
<v George Monbiot>This is why in nearly every nation on earth there is now almost nothing to choose from between the ruling party and the main opposition party.

220
00:19:00.600 --> 00:19:05.460
<v George Monbiot>The role of national politicians has been reduced to the implementation of the international system.

221
00:19:09.420 --> 00:19:10.920
<v George Monbiot>Given everyone who thinks everyone can act at everyone's discretion, everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

222
00:19:11.060 --> 00:19:15.520
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

223
00:19:15.520 --> 00:19:16.080
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

224
00:19:16.080 --> 00:19:17.800
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

225
00:19:17.960 --> 00:19:18.800
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

226
00:19:18.800 --> 00:19:18.860
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

227
00:19:18.860 --> 00:19:18.920
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

228
00:19:18.920 --> 00:19:19.160
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

229
00:19:19.480 --> 00:19:19.920
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

230
00:19:19.920 --> 00:19:20.380
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

231
00:19:20.380 --> 00:19:21.320
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

232
00:19:21.540 --> 00:19:23.960
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

233
00:19:24.100 --> 00:19:24.940
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

234
00:19:24.940 --> 00:19:25.920
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

235
00:19:25.920 --> 00:19:27.100
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

236
00:19:27.400 --> 00:19:27.940
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

237
00:19:27.940 --> 00:19:29.280
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

238
00:19:29.620 --> 00:19:33.520
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

239
00:19:33.520 --> 00:19:35.440
<v George Monbiot>everyone can act at everyone's discretion,

240
00:19:35.460 --> 00:19:37.260
<v George Monbiot>the corporations and the nation states.

241
00:19:38.340 --> 00:19:40.800
<v George Monbiot>So let's not call the problem globalisation.

242
00:19:41.160 --> 00:19:44.160
<v George Monbiot>Let's call it what it is, exploitation, injustice.

243
00:19:45.160 --> 00:19:48.160
<v George Monbiot>And let's not call the solution internationalism.

244
00:19:48.800 --> 00:19:53.220
<v George Monbiot>Let's call it mobilisation, or even, if we dare, revolution.

245
00:20:03.020 --> 00:20:06.080
<v George Monbiot>I won't say much more, as I don't want to intrude too far

246
00:20:06.080 --> 00:20:08.580
<v George Monbiot>into the theme of my talk this afternoon.

247
00:20:09.200 --> 00:20:12.580
<v George Monbiot>But I'll say one thing now, which I will also say later on.

248
00:20:13.920 --> 00:20:16.600
<v George Monbiot>If we're serious about the work we've taken on,

249
00:20:17.160 --> 00:20:20.840
<v George Monbiot>if we really want to build a world that's fit for its people,

250
00:20:20.980 --> 00:20:23.200
<v George Monbiot>then we must recognise that we're not just a country

251
00:20:23.200 --> 00:20:23.960
<v George Monbiot>but a nation.

252
00:20:23.960 --> 00:20:26.540
<v George Monbiot>And I'm sure that our task is not to overthrow globalisation,

253
00:20:27.340 --> 00:20:30.960
<v George Monbiot>but to capture it and to use it as a vehicle

254
00:20:30.960 --> 00:20:35.280
<v George Monbiot>for humanity's first global democratic revolution.

255
00:20:35.640 --> 00:20:36.180
<v George Monbiot>Thank you.

256
00:20:37.560 --> 00:20:37.620
<v George Monbiot>APPLAUSE

257
00:20:53.200 --> 00:20:54.600
<v Chair>Thank you.

258
00:21:23.660 --> 00:21:24.140
<v Chair>Thank you.

259
00:21:53.200 --> 00:21:58.340
<v Chair>I'll take up, I'm sure, some of the points that George has placed,

260
00:21:58.460 --> 00:22:01.520
<v Chair>has put into play, about the definitions

261
00:22:02.320 --> 00:22:04.680
<v Chair>of globalisation versus international.

262
00:22:05.000 --> 00:22:07.260
<v Chair>Let us welcome Michael Walcock.

263
00:22:08.220 --> 00:22:08.820
<v Chair>APPLAUSE

264
00:22:13.880 --> 00:22:14.880
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK, MATTHEW WALCOCK,

265
00:22:14.880 --> 00:22:14.980
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

266
00:22:14.980 --> 00:22:15.080
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

267
00:22:15.120 --> 00:22:15.340
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

268
00:22:15.380 --> 00:22:15.780
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

269
00:22:15.780 --> 00:22:16.340
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

270
00:22:16.340 --> 00:22:16.500
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

271
00:22:16.500 --> 00:22:16.960
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

272
00:22:17.020 --> 00:22:18.220
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

273
00:22:18.220 --> 00:22:19.520
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

274
00:22:19.520 --> 00:22:20.640
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

275
00:22:20.640 --> 00:22:21.240
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

276
00:22:21.240 --> 00:22:23.000
<v Michael Woolcock>MATTHEW WALCOCK,

277
00:22:23.740 --> 00:22:33.540
<v Michael Woolcock>My task today, as I see it, is to try and get us beyond a debate in which the question is posed in terms of whether globalisation is good or bad.

278
00:22:33.680 --> 00:22:36.260
<v Michael Woolcock>Clearly it can be both, sometimes simultaneously.

279
00:22:37.060 --> 00:22:49.160
<v Michael Woolcock>The most constructive approach asks instead under what conditions does globalisation, and for that matter Americanisation, which isn't always the same thing, become good or bad.

280
00:22:49.840 --> 00:22:52.540
<v Michael Woolcock>I think it's important to begin with a historical perspective.

281
00:22:53.300 --> 00:23:00.600
<v Michael Woolcock>Measured by financial interdependence and freedom of movement, the world was more globalised in 1903 than it is in 2003.

282
00:23:01.560 --> 00:23:04.580
<v Michael Woolcock>Passports only came into existence in the 1910s.

283
00:23:04.740 --> 00:23:13.580
<v Michael Woolcock>A hundred years ago there were no global institutions at all, or no global rules to manage the exchange of goods, people, money and ideas.

284
00:23:14.260 --> 00:23:19.320
<v Michael Woolcock>But the failure to manage these flows is in large part what led to World War I,

285
00:23:19.460 --> 00:23:22.980
<v Michael Woolcock>and in its aftermath the failure to build...

286
00:23:23.000 --> 00:23:32.520
<v Michael Woolcock>a robust institutional solution through the League of Nations meant there was nothing to head off the global, economic and nationalistic political pressures that led to World War II.

287
00:23:33.260 --> 00:23:39.300
<v Michael Woolcock>So failure to manage our collective international and domestic challenges can have catastrophic consequences.

288
00:23:40.800 --> 00:23:43.520
<v Michael Woolcock>We face an equivalent challenge in the 21st century.

289
00:23:44.300 --> 00:23:52.980
<v Michael Woolcock>One key question then is whether the set of global institutions put in place at the end of World War II, such as the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, etc.,

290
00:23:52.980 --> 00:23:56.440
<v Michael Woolcock>and the general agreement on tariffs and trade, now the World Trade Organization,

291
00:23:57.580 --> 00:24:00.040
<v Michael Woolcock>and, more recently, the International Criminal Court,

292
00:24:00.160 --> 00:24:04.980
<v Michael Woolcock>are up to the geo-political challenges and technological realities of our time.

293
00:24:06.060 --> 00:24:09.460
<v Michael Woolcock>Geopolitically, we find ourselves with a single, global superpower,

294
00:24:09.840 --> 00:24:17.560
<v Michael Woolcock>at the helm of which we currently have a nationalist, unilateralist, militarist, imperialist, and quasi-theocratic, administration.

295
00:24:18.760 --> 00:24:21.840
<v Michael Woolcock>The countervailing European powers, such as they are,

296
00:24:21.940 --> 00:24:22.960
<v Michael Woolcock>find themselves, at the helm of which, a nationalist, unilateralist, militarist, imperialist, and quasi-theocratic, administration.

297
00:24:22.960 --> 00:24:28.540
<v Michael Woolcock>moving in the opposite direction, espousing pan-nationalist, multilateralist, demilitaristic,

298
00:24:28.640 --> 00:24:34.040
<v Michael Woolcock>humanitarian, and secular solutions. As my Kennedy School colleague Michael Ignatieff

299
00:24:34.040 --> 00:24:38.960
<v Michael Woolcock>astutely observes in his wonderful new book, Empire Light, a central geopolitical paradox

300
00:24:38.960 --> 00:24:46.260
<v Michael Woolcock>of our time is that the United States itself, a post-colonial nation and exemplar for subsequent

301
00:24:46.260 --> 00:24:51.820
<v Michael Woolcock>independence initiatives throughout Asia and Africa, is expanding its empire while Europe

302
00:24:51.820 --> 00:24:57.600
<v Michael Woolcock>tries to purge itself of its imperial past. As he also points out, however, both sides

303
00:24:57.600 --> 00:25:02.200
<v Michael Woolcock>are trying to do everything on the cheap, espousing lofty ideals and promising generous

304
00:25:02.200 --> 00:25:08.220
<v Michael Woolcock>resources, but in reality offering the least they can get away with. It's not just heedless

305
00:25:08.220 --> 00:25:12.400
<v Michael Woolcock>governments that are to blame. As citizens of these countries and electors of these leaders,

306
00:25:12.580 --> 00:25:18.880
<v Michael Woolcock>we are complicit in that duplicity. It was not always that way. The best of America,

307
00:25:19.060 --> 00:25:21.480
<v Michael Woolcock>on display with the Marshall Plan in the years immediately

308
00:25:21.480 --> 00:25:21.800
<v Michael Woolcock>14th and 15th, was the United States. It was the United States that was the first

309
00:25:30.840 --> 00:25:32.700
<v Michael Woolcock>US colonist,

310
00:25:51.800 --> 00:25:57.380
<v Michael Woolcock>world. Today they are among the most peaceful and prosperous places on the planet. Power,

311
00:25:57.580 --> 00:26:03.040
<v Michael Woolcock>even or especially American power, harnessed in the service of universally said interests and

312
00:26:03.040 --> 00:26:08.580
<v Michael Woolcock>ideals can achieve great and glorious things. These contemporary political and philosophical

313
00:26:08.580 --> 00:26:13.280
<v Michael Woolcock>fault lines between the United States and Europe and between the best of America and what we

314
00:26:13.280 --> 00:26:19.660
<v Michael Woolcock>currently see on display today existed before 9-11 but was both exposed and exacerbated by it.

315
00:26:19.660 --> 00:26:24.220
<v Michael Woolcock>In fact, candidate Bush, you will recall, campaigned on an anti-nation building platform,

316
00:26:25.080 --> 00:26:28.200
<v Michael Woolcock>mocking the efforts of the Clinton administration, minimalist as they were,

317
00:26:28.440 --> 00:26:34.240
<v Michael Woolcock>to risk American lives and military prestige in distant, unpronounceable places with little

318
00:26:34.240 --> 00:26:39.280
<v Michael Woolcock>obvious strategic significance. 9-11 jolted the United States government into the shocking

319
00:26:39.280 --> 00:26:44.420
<v Michael Woolcock>realization that, as Pulitzer Prize winning New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman deftly put

320
00:26:44.420 --> 00:26:49.060
<v Michael Woolcock>it soon thereafter, if we don't visit poor nations, they will soon visit us instead.

321
00:26:50.100 --> 00:26:55.560
<v Michael Woolcock>The subsequent visitation strategy, however, has been what Princeton economist Paul Krugman calls a

322
00:26:55.560 --> 00:27:02.300
<v Michael Woolcock>Marshall Plan, M-A-R-T-I-A-L, rather than a Marshall Plan. The Marshall Plan circa 1947,

323
00:27:02.420 --> 00:27:08.720
<v Michael Woolcock>he correctly calls America's finest hour. The Marshall Plan circa 2003, in contrast,

324
00:27:09.000 --> 00:27:14.640
<v Michael Woolcock>focuses on winning short, easy wars rather than patiently crafting a durable but less glamorous

325
00:27:14.640 --> 00:27:18.800
<v Michael Woolcock>peace. It stays as long as the media gaze and approval ratings permit,

326
00:27:18.800 --> 00:27:25.360
<v Michael Woolcock>captive to an attention span measured in hours rather than years. It regards dissent as treason,

327
00:27:25.480 --> 00:27:30.400
<v Michael Woolcock>structural disadvantage as moral failure, and intellectual ambiguity as political weakness.

328
00:27:30.720 --> 00:27:36.500
<v Michael Woolcock>It prioritizes loyalty over truth and too often presumes foreigners guilty until proven innocent.

329
00:27:36.720 --> 00:27:42.660
<v Michael Woolcock>It rubbishes public servants. It sees diversity of opinion, skin color, and nationality as a threat

330
00:27:42.660 --> 00:27:47.400
<v Michael Woolcock>rather than opportunity, while simultaneously exacerbating diversity of wealth, opportunity,

331
00:27:47.500 --> 00:27:48.080
<v Michael Woolcock>and citizenship.

332
00:27:50.080 --> 00:28:01.800
<v Michael Woolcock>The Marshall Plan is a

333
00:28:01.800 --> 00:28:11.520
<v Michael Woolcock>powerful force, and as such can be used to do great good or great harm. We need to come to grips

334
00:28:11.520 --> 00:28:18.260
<v Michael Woolcock>politically, intellectually, and financially that in certain circumstances imperialism is acutely

335
00:28:18.260 --> 00:28:18.640
<v Michael Woolcock>necessary.

336
00:28:18.800 --> 00:28:18.920
<v Michael Woolcock>The Marshall Plan is a powerful force, and as such can be used to do great good or great harm. We need to come to grips

337
00:28:18.920 --> 00:28:25.720
<v Michael Woolcock>in order to bring about viable nation-states capable of ensuring equality, independence, and security for all its citizens,

338
00:28:26.500 --> 00:28:30.800
<v Michael Woolcock>but that failure to achieve these things has enduring and usually tragic consequences for everyone.

339
00:28:31.540 --> 00:28:37.600
<v Michael Woolcock>Perhaps most importantly, we need to change the tone and terms of the debate regarding the dilemmas of development and globalization,

340
00:28:38.040 --> 00:28:45.820
<v Michael Woolcock>not to obscure or downplay the reality of American power, but rather to harness it in the service of universally shared ideals and interests.

341
00:28:46.180 --> 00:28:48.780
<v Michael Woolcock>We need the best of America as embodied in the

342
00:28:48.780 --> 00:28:53.340
<v Michael Woolcock>Marshall Plan, not the worst of it currently on display in the other Marshall Plan.

343
00:28:54.400 --> 00:29:02.980
<v Michael Woolcock>Australia and Australians need to be part of the solution, not the problem. As it pertains to globalization, development policy, international affairs, and refugees, however,

344
00:29:03.180 --> 00:29:11.840
<v Michael Woolcock>the Americanization we currently see on display in our country is that of the other Marshall Plan, rather than our own version of the original Marshall Plan.

345
00:29:12.280 --> 00:29:18.760
<v Michael Woolcock>This is consistent with neither our history nor our values, and I want to quote here and promote a wonderful book that's forthcoming, which is called,

346
00:29:18.780 --> 00:29:22.220
<v Michael Woolcock>Coming From Some of My Australian Colleagues Who Are Students at the Kennedy School.

347
00:29:23.460 --> 00:29:30.640
<v Michael Woolcock>In 1945, in the shadow of the final months of World War II, delegates from 50 nations met in San Francisco to develop the charter for an institution

348
00:29:31.140 --> 00:29:35.180
<v Michael Woolcock>to ensure that the horrors of the first half of the 10th century would never be repeated.

349
00:29:35.880 --> 00:29:41.480
<v Michael Woolcock>However, while there was broad agreement on the goal of the United Nations, there was considerable debate about the shape it would take.

350
00:29:42.120 --> 00:29:47.780
<v Michael Woolcock>During the conference, serious disagreements arose between the major world powers, the United States, the Soviet Union, and Britain,

351
00:29:47.780 --> 00:29:52.360
<v Michael Woolcock>and the smaller, less powerful nations about the extent of their role in shaping the UN.

352
00:29:53.280 --> 00:30:01.300
<v Michael Woolcock>Australia was present in San Francisco, represented by a delegation headed by the then External Affairs Minister, Dr H. V. Everett.

353
00:30:01.800 --> 00:30:03.560
<v Michael Woolcock>Our presence was to prove crucial.

354
00:30:04.160 --> 00:30:12.580
<v Michael Woolcock>Although Australia was a close ally of Britain and the United States, we took a broad view of what was required to make the United Nations a success and to ensure world peace.

355
00:30:13.100 --> 00:30:16.280
<v Michael Woolcock>The future of the world was not just dependent on the Big Three Powers.

356
00:30:16.280 --> 00:30:19.680
<v Michael Woolcock>powers, it required the active and meaningful involvement of all nations.

357
00:30:20.560 --> 00:30:24.400
<v Michael Woolcock>Evatt was a strong advocate for the smaller powers and he succeeded in persuading the

358
00:30:24.400 --> 00:30:28.480
<v Michael Woolcock>reluctant great powers that the entire UN membership should have a wide role in the

359
00:30:28.480 --> 00:30:28.980
<v Michael Woolcock>General Assembly.

360
00:30:29.880 --> 00:30:31.720
<v Michael Woolcock>This was crucial to the success of the conference.

361
00:30:32.320 --> 00:30:33.820
<v Michael Woolcock>It was not our only contribution.

362
00:30:34.380 --> 00:30:38.840
<v Michael Woolcock>The Australian delegation boldly threw itself into the convention, sponsoring 20 successful

363
00:30:38.840 --> 00:30:40.120
<v Michael Woolcock>amendments to the Charter.

364
00:30:40.760 --> 00:30:45.040
<v Michael Woolcock>Consistent with our broad vision of the potential of the UN, Australia strongly advocated the

365
00:30:45.040 --> 00:30:49.680
<v Michael Woolcock>United Nations as an agent for social and economic reform and a protector of human rights.

366
00:30:50.480 --> 00:30:55.180
<v Michael Woolcock>So successful was Evatt and the Australian team that the modern UN's massive involvement

367
00:30:55.180 --> 00:30:58.860
<v Michael Woolcock>in economic, social and humanitarian issues can be traced to their influence.

368
00:30:59.360 --> 00:31:04.740
<v Michael Woolcock>Indeed, Article 56, under which member states agree to work towards higher standards of

369
00:31:04.740 --> 00:31:08.440
<v Michael Woolcock>living, full employment and conditions of economic and social progress and development,

370
00:31:08.660 --> 00:31:11.420
<v Michael Woolcock>became known as the Australian Pledge.

371
00:31:12.440 --> 00:31:15.020
<v Michael Woolcock>Australia's contribution won us the gratitude and the support of the UN.

372
00:31:15.040 --> 00:31:18.340
<v Michael Woolcock>It was the gratitude of the small nations, the respect of the Great Ones, membership

373
00:31:18.340 --> 00:31:24.020
<v Michael Woolcock>of the first Security Council and later, in 1948, the presidency of the fledgling UN General

374
00:31:24.020 --> 00:31:24.380
<v Michael Woolcock>Assembly.

375
00:31:24.980 --> 00:31:29.900
<v Michael Woolcock>The United Nations later summed up Dr Evatt's standing at the conference, when Dr Evatt

376
00:31:29.900 --> 00:31:32.800
<v Michael Woolcock>came here, he was virtually unknown, a second string delegate.

377
00:31:33.100 --> 00:31:37.780
<v Michael Woolcock>He leaves, recognised as the most brilliant and effective voice of the small powers, a

378
00:31:37.780 --> 00:31:41.460
<v Michael Woolcock>leading statesman for the small nations of the world.

379
00:31:42.380 --> 00:31:44.940
<v Michael Woolcock>I think John Lennon had it all wrong in his song.

380
00:31:45.040 --> 00:31:48.020
<v Michael Woolcock>Imagine, which is so much the anthem for many people these days.

381
00:31:48.720 --> 00:31:53.780
<v Michael Woolcock>While espousing noble ends, the means he proposed to realise them are not only those of a dreamer,

382
00:31:53.800 --> 00:31:56.620
<v Michael Woolcock>but are grounded in a political philosophy that is not even wrong.

383
00:31:56.840 --> 00:31:59.480
<v Michael Woolcock>I wish he were the only one that thought the way that he did.

384
00:32:00.520 --> 00:32:04.480
<v Michael Woolcock>We do not want a world where there are no religions and countries, no heaven or anything

385
00:32:04.480 --> 00:32:05.140
<v Michael Woolcock>to die for.

386
00:32:05.500 --> 00:32:11.280
<v Michael Woolcock>We will not all live as one in such a world, but rather be condemned to anarchy and ignorance.

387
00:32:11.900 --> 00:32:14.780
<v Michael Woolcock>Where there is nothing to die for, there is nothing to live for.

388
00:32:14.860 --> 00:32:15.020
<v Michael Woolcock>I think John Lennon, the Great Leader of the United Nations, was a great leader in his

389
00:32:15.380 --> 00:32:19.640
<v Michael Woolcock>Let us instead try to imagine a world in which our different identities and sources of meaning

390
00:32:19.640 --> 00:32:24.180
<v Michael Woolcock>are not merely respected but regarded as a vital asset rather than a liability.

391
00:32:25.020 --> 00:32:29.920
<v Michael Woolcock>Let us imagine a world, or at least in Australia, in which people don't wake up wondering where

392
00:32:29.920 --> 00:32:34.280
<v Michael Woolcock>their next meal is coming from, or watch helplessly while their babies die from easily preventable

393
00:32:34.280 --> 00:32:39.080
<v Michael Woolcock>diseases or have their basic human rights trampled upon by corrupt leaders, judges,

394
00:32:39.300 --> 00:32:43.200
<v Michael Woolcock>or in the case of many African nations, eight year olds brandishing AK-47s.

395
00:32:44.120 --> 00:32:47.800
<v Michael Woolcock>Getting to such a world requires more viable countries, not less or none at all,

396
00:32:47.920 --> 00:32:52.260
<v Michael Woolcock>and a credible set of institutionalised mechanisms for mediating between them.

397
00:32:52.620 --> 00:32:57.320
<v Michael Woolcock>In our technological information age, it means building on the strengths of our current global institutions,

398
00:32:57.700 --> 00:33:03.680
<v Michael Woolcock>but also improving and perhaps supplementing them in ways that ensure that decisions are made in transparent,

399
00:33:03.880 --> 00:33:06.040
<v Michael Woolcock>accountable and evidence-based ways.

400
00:33:06.840 --> 00:33:11.060
<v Michael Woolcock>Getting these in turn requires negotiating a broader base of political support

401
00:33:11.060 --> 00:33:17.200
<v Michael Woolcock>for the resources, mechanisms and patience so crucially needed to establish a world of functioning states

402
00:33:17.200 --> 00:33:20.700
<v Michael Woolcock>that are simultaneously independent but interdependent.

403
00:33:21.180 --> 00:33:26.200
<v Michael Woolcock>As Ignatius also points out, however, democracies make fickle imperialists.

404
00:33:26.480 --> 00:33:31.260
<v Michael Woolcock>The painful reality is that the technological and economic factors that make globalisation possible

405
00:33:31.260 --> 00:33:37.740
<v Michael Woolcock>and make it conceivable for the first time in history to put mass poverty, destitution and disease in the past tense

406
00:33:37.740 --> 00:33:41.040
<v Michael Woolcock>are the same factors that contain the potential to enhance the future of the world.

407
00:33:41.060 --> 00:33:45.760
<v Michael Woolcock>They are the same factors that contain the potential to enhance the future of the world.

408
00:33:45.760 --> 00:33:51.180
<v Michael Woolcock>In an interconnected age, everything is a package deal.

409
00:33:52.220 --> 00:33:56.020
<v Michael Woolcock>Globalisation can be our friend or our enemy, it can unite even as it divides.

410
00:33:56.620 --> 00:34:01.660
<v Michael Woolcock>The perennial social and political task, then, is to sort out the virtues and the vices,

411
00:34:01.780 --> 00:34:04.360
<v Michael Woolcock>the better to enhance the former and minimise the latter.

412
00:34:04.780 --> 00:34:08.540
<v Michael Woolcock>It is in this sense globalisation is not an enemy to dismantled or contained,

413
00:34:08.800 --> 00:34:10.940
<v Michael Woolcock>but rather a powerful force to be channelled,

414
00:34:11.060 --> 00:34:12.520
<v Michael Woolcock>and harnessed for our collective betterment.

415
00:34:12.980 --> 00:34:16.640
<v Michael Woolcock>Doing so requires us to find and sustain the moral and political energy,

416
00:34:16.760 --> 00:34:18.480
<v Michael Woolcock>the individual and collective will,

417
00:34:18.600 --> 00:34:21.960
<v Michael Woolcock>to use the institutions we have to build the ones we need.

418
00:34:22.280 --> 00:34:22.880
<v Michael Woolcock>Thank you.

419
00:34:36.180 --> 00:34:39.860
<v Chair>The first time I've met Michael today, the first time I've heard him speak,

420
00:34:40.000 --> 00:34:41.040
<v Chair>the first time I've met Michael today, the first time I've heard him speak,

421
00:34:41.040 --> 00:34:42.780
<v Chair>I've had a superb presentation.

422
00:34:44.060 --> 00:34:47.500
<v Chair>Two things alone made it worth the price of entering.

423
00:34:47.720 --> 00:34:53.500
<v Chair>The two martial laws, I shall now plagiarise that concept without attribution,

424
00:34:53.580 --> 00:34:59.660
<v Chair>and the glorious fact that Australia once played an honourable role in world affairs.

425
00:35:07.060 --> 00:35:10.700
<v Chair>Talking about world affairs, I was having a hard start at coffee

426
00:35:10.700 --> 00:35:12.260
<v Chair>this morning with Zia Sadaar,

427
00:35:12.440 --> 00:35:17.380
<v Chair>and he was telling me a story about trying to get re-entry into the US

428
00:35:17.380 --> 00:35:19.700
<v Chair>not long after September 11,

429
00:35:20.720 --> 00:35:25.580
<v Chair>when with his pigmentation, hairdo,

430
00:35:27.680 --> 00:35:29.380
<v Chair>he was having a bit of trouble.

431
00:35:30.440 --> 00:35:35.860
<v Chair>And you can imagine how they reacted when they opened up a suitcase full of books called

432
00:35:36.620 --> 00:35:39.660
<v Chair>Why Does Everyone Hate the United States?

433
00:35:44.280 --> 00:35:49.440
<v Chair>But if you've heard him talk on that issue, it is of course a subtle and calibrated argument.

434
00:35:49.500 --> 00:35:52.320
<v Chair>It is not in any sense a tub-thumper.

435
00:35:52.380 --> 00:35:54.580
<v Chair>Ladies and gentlemen, Zia Sadaar.

436
00:36:03.000 --> 00:36:06.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Thank you very much, gentle ladies and gentlemen.

437
00:36:08.460 --> 00:36:09.420
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Every morning,

438
00:36:10.700 --> 00:36:13.920
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I wake up and I have about three cups of coffee.

439
00:36:14.700 --> 00:36:16.440
<v Ziauddin Sardar>It takes me some time to get going,

440
00:36:16.600 --> 00:36:20.580
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and I switch my computer on and I check my email.

441
00:36:21.480 --> 00:36:26.500
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And every morning without fail pops this email which says,

442
00:36:26.640 --> 00:36:27.960
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Your penis is shrinking.

443
00:36:37.660 --> 00:36:40.000
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Just imagine how I feel.

444
00:36:41.600 --> 00:36:44.180
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I mean, inadequate as I am.

445
00:36:46.520 --> 00:36:55.300
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And then it offers me a special package of penis enlarger for $200.

446
00:36:57.260 --> 00:36:59.520
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Now, in this globalized world,

447
00:36:59.680 --> 00:37:01.820
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I want to find out who is this guy

448
00:37:03.000 --> 00:37:06.640
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who every morning without fail sends me this email

449
00:37:07.580 --> 00:37:09.220
<v Ziauddin Sardar>to make me feel inadequate

450
00:37:10.260 --> 00:37:11.440
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and totally useless.

451
00:37:12.240 --> 00:37:13.800
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And he also happens to be right.

452
00:37:16.140 --> 00:37:17.980
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Which makes everything totally impossible.

453
00:37:20.000 --> 00:37:22.880
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Now, hands up all those who have received similar emails.

454
00:37:23.000 --> 00:37:23.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Now, don't hide.

455
00:37:24.280 --> 00:37:25.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>On regular basis,

456
00:37:25.280 --> 00:37:26.580
<v Ziauddin Sardar>there we have it.

457
00:37:26.720 --> 00:37:27.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Now,

458
00:37:29.880 --> 00:37:32.060
<v Ziauddin Sardar>on my way to Adelaide,

459
00:37:32.140 --> 00:37:33.460
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I was reading the Australian,

460
00:37:33.680 --> 00:37:35.740
<v Ziauddin Sardar>which is a newspaper, by the way, if you don't know.

461
00:37:37.540 --> 00:37:39.380
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And you can check that out.

462
00:37:39.420 --> 00:37:40.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>About a week ago,

463
00:37:40.220 --> 00:37:43.100
<v Ziauddin Sardar>at the bottom of the cover,

464
00:37:43.900 --> 00:37:44.640
<v Ziauddin Sardar>the page,

465
00:37:45.940 --> 00:37:50.460
<v Ziauddin Sardar>it said that spam is becoming a major problem in the world.

466
00:37:50.800 --> 00:37:52.520
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And this story told me

467
00:37:53.160 --> 00:37:55.140
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that there are only 18 people,

468
00:37:55.140 --> 00:37:56.360
<v Ziauddin Sardar>all located in Miami,

469
00:37:56.560 --> 00:37:57.680
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who send out these emails.

470
00:37:58.060 --> 00:38:01.380
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And they send out 14 billion emails a day.

471
00:38:03.620 --> 00:38:06.620
<v Ziauddin Sardar>14 billion emails a day of spam.

472
00:38:07.840 --> 00:38:09.340
<v Ziauddin Sardar>That's two and a half,

473
00:38:09.400 --> 00:38:11.780
<v Ziauddin Sardar>almost two and a half for every global citizen.

474
00:38:12.160 --> 00:38:13.880
<v Ziauddin Sardar>18 Americans do that.

475
00:38:14.040 --> 00:38:15.080
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Just 18 Americans.

476
00:38:15.400 --> 00:38:17.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Now, I may be wrong.

477
00:38:17.140 --> 00:38:18.660
<v Ziauddin Sardar>If I am wrong, then the Australian is wrong.

478
00:38:18.820 --> 00:38:20.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>But I think there is some truth.

479
00:38:20.820 --> 00:38:22.640
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I think there is some truth in that.

480
00:38:23.020 --> 00:38:23.880
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And actually,

481
00:38:23.880 --> 00:38:26.140
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that's what globalization is all about, isn't it?

482
00:38:26.580 --> 00:38:28.720
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Yesterday, some of you may remember,

483
00:38:28.860 --> 00:38:31.080
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I compared this hall to a mighty river.

484
00:38:31.860 --> 00:38:35.620
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Today, think of this hall as a mighty highway.

485
00:38:37.420 --> 00:38:40.380
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And lane after lane after lane

486
00:38:41.880 --> 00:38:43.720
<v Ziauddin Sardar>of stuff coming this way.

487
00:38:45.920 --> 00:38:48.660
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Hollywood films, television programs,

488
00:38:50.420 --> 00:38:51.660
<v Ziauddin Sardar>junk food,

489
00:38:52.580 --> 00:38:53.860
<v Ziauddin Sardar>you name it.

490
00:38:53.880 --> 00:38:56.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Technology, gadgets,

491
00:38:57.280 --> 00:38:59.260
<v Ziauddin Sardar>you know, funny hairdos,

492
00:38:59.360 --> 00:39:02.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>hair cream to keep my hair the way it is,

493
00:39:02.160 --> 00:39:03.720
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and so on and so forth.

494
00:39:03.800 --> 00:39:05.460
<v Ziauddin Sardar>A vast amount of stuff coming down there.

495
00:39:06.660 --> 00:39:10.840
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And all targeted at poor sod like me,

496
00:39:11.060 --> 00:39:14.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who lives in some third world country.

497
00:39:16.540 --> 00:39:20.080
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And the only thing that is actually going that way,

498
00:39:21.440 --> 00:39:26.620
<v Ziauddin Sardar>in all the vast quantities of articulated lorries

499
00:39:26.620 --> 00:39:29.240
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and trucks and buses and things,

500
00:39:29.300 --> 00:39:30.460
<v Ziauddin Sardar>trains coming this way,

501
00:39:30.560 --> 00:39:33.620
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is a man in a pedal bike

502
00:39:33.620 --> 00:39:37.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>trying to sell his goods to America and Europe.

503
00:39:37.960 --> 00:39:39.980
<v Ziauddin Sardar>That's what globalization is all about.

504
00:39:41.320 --> 00:39:44.060
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Amy makes a distinction that is about cooperation

505
00:39:44.060 --> 00:39:45.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and not Americanization.

506
00:39:46.580 --> 00:39:47.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Maybe,

507
00:39:47.280 --> 00:39:47.400
<v Ziauddin Sardar>maybe,

508
00:39:49.420 --> 00:39:50.820
<v Ziauddin Sardar>as Michael says,

509
00:39:50.920 --> 00:39:52.860
<v Ziauddin Sardar>we can do something about it.

510
00:39:53.280 --> 00:39:54.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>It's a force for good,

511
00:39:54.620 --> 00:39:56.500
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and not necessarily a force for bad.

512
00:39:57.160 --> 00:39:58.380
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Maybe as George,

513
00:39:58.520 --> 00:39:59.740
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who I have to admit,

514
00:40:00.340 --> 00:40:02.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>only feels at ease

515
00:40:02.280 --> 00:40:03.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>when he has rolled his sleeves

516
00:40:04.300 --> 00:40:05.860
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and taken his jacket off.

517
00:40:08.560 --> 00:40:09.080
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Maybe,

518
00:40:09.180 --> 00:40:10.860
<v Ziauddin Sardar>maybe we need a revolution

519
00:40:10.860 --> 00:40:12.780
<v Ziauddin Sardar>to actually fight this globalization.

520
00:40:14.420 --> 00:40:16.260
<v Ziauddin Sardar>But as far as I'm concerned,

521
00:40:16.260 --> 00:40:17.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>the individual

522
00:40:17.940 --> 00:40:19.440
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who gets up in the morning

523
00:40:20.260 --> 00:40:20.620
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and is

524
00:40:22.360 --> 00:40:24.140
<v Ziauddin Sardar>actually bombarded by this rubbish

525
00:40:24.140 --> 00:40:26.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>day in, day out,

526
00:40:27.140 --> 00:40:30.360
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I'm not just an individual who suffers that.

527
00:40:30.500 --> 00:40:33.580
<v Ziauddin Sardar>The vast number of people around the world

528
00:40:33.580 --> 00:40:34.180
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who suffer that.

529
00:40:34.540 --> 00:40:36.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And you need to imagine

530
00:40:36.680 --> 00:40:37.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>the email,

531
00:40:37.680 --> 00:40:38.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>not just as email,

532
00:40:38.780 --> 00:40:40.180
<v Ziauddin Sardar>but email as junk food,

533
00:40:40.380 --> 00:40:41.960
<v Ziauddin Sardar>email as junk Hollywood,

534
00:40:42.160 --> 00:40:44.680
<v Ziauddin Sardar>email as television programs

535
00:40:44.680 --> 00:40:45.260
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that saturate

536
00:40:45.420 --> 00:40:49.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>the television screens

537
00:40:49.600 --> 00:40:50.960
<v Ziauddin Sardar>around the third world

538
00:40:50.960 --> 00:40:53.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and totally and utterly marginalize local production,

539
00:40:54.100 --> 00:40:55.800
<v Ziauddin Sardar>which means local culture dies.

540
00:40:56.120 --> 00:40:56.980
<v Ziauddin Sardar>There's nothing,

541
00:40:58.860 --> 00:41:00.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>there's nothing to sustain it

542
00:41:00.540 --> 00:41:02.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>because the American cheap products

543
00:41:02.020 --> 00:41:04.060
<v Ziauddin Sardar>are more or less dumped on this.

544
00:41:05.060 --> 00:41:06.880
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And as a result of that,

545
00:41:07.040 --> 00:41:08.780
<v Ziauddin Sardar>what globalization is doing

546
00:41:09.420 --> 00:41:11.220
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is actually shrinking space,

547
00:41:12.460 --> 00:41:14.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>continuously shrinking space.

548
00:41:15.420 --> 00:41:16.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>For individuals like me

549
00:41:16.600 --> 00:41:17.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>to be,

550
00:41:17.240 --> 00:41:19.500
<v Ziauddin Sardar>to exist as different individuals

551
00:41:20.420 --> 00:41:20.920
<v Ziauddin Sardar>other than

552
00:41:20.920 --> 00:41:22.440
<v Ziauddin Sardar>the individuals

553
00:41:22.440 --> 00:41:25.380
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who identify with the West in general

554
00:41:25.380 --> 00:41:26.700
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and America in particular.

555
00:41:27.160 --> 00:41:28.840
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And if that is the case,

556
00:41:28.880 --> 00:41:31.620
<v Ziauddin Sardar>then I think globalization is a bad thing,

557
00:41:31.720 --> 00:41:32.300
<v Ziauddin Sardar>full stop.

558
00:41:32.540 --> 00:41:33.240
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And I for one,

559
00:41:33.460 --> 00:41:34.400
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I'm gonna fight it.

560
00:41:42.420 --> 00:41:44.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>The point is that

561
00:41:44.020 --> 00:41:45.840
<v Ziauddin Sardar>we may all interpret Dallas

562
00:41:45.840 --> 00:41:47.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>in a different way.

563
00:41:47.800 --> 00:41:49.520
<v Ziauddin Sardar>You know, the Malays will look at Dallas

564
00:41:49.520 --> 00:41:51.560
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and see themselves as something different.

565
00:41:52.120 --> 00:41:53.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Pakistanis will look at Dallas

566
00:41:53.280 --> 00:41:54.180
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and see something different.

567
00:41:54.480 --> 00:41:55.860
<v Ziauddin Sardar>But it doesn't change the fact

568
00:41:55.860 --> 00:41:56.820
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that Dallas is junk,

569
00:41:57.500 --> 00:41:58.340
<v Ziauddin Sardar>total junk.

570
00:41:59.880 --> 00:42:01.740
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And American junk at that.

571
00:42:04.460 --> 00:42:04.980
<v Ziauddin Sardar>So,

572
00:42:06.860 --> 00:42:08.180
<v Ziauddin Sardar>how are we gonna resist?

573
00:42:09.540 --> 00:42:11.980
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I think the best way to resist globalization

574
00:42:11.980 --> 00:42:12.960
<v Ziauddin Sardar>for you folks

575
00:42:12.960 --> 00:42:15.340
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is to join the anti-globalization movement.

576
00:42:15.540 --> 00:42:16.740
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I don't care what it's called,

577
00:42:16.860 --> 00:42:18.680
<v Ziauddin Sardar>it's anti-globalization movement.

578
00:42:19.280 --> 00:42:21.960
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And the anti-globalization movement

579
00:42:21.960 --> 00:42:22.800
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is gonna succeed

580
00:42:22.800 --> 00:42:24.080
<v Ziauddin Sardar>for a very simple reason.

581
00:42:24.600 --> 00:42:26.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Because anti-globalization movement

582
00:42:26.540 --> 00:42:29.200
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is actually more learned,

583
00:42:29.440 --> 00:42:30.640
<v Ziauddin Sardar>more clever,

584
00:42:30.800 --> 00:42:32.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>more polished,

585
00:42:32.320 --> 00:42:33.700
<v Ziauddin Sardar>has more ideas

586
00:42:33.700 --> 00:42:35.340
<v Ziauddin Sardar>than the globalization lot,

587
00:42:35.520 --> 00:42:37.440
<v Ziauddin Sardar>especially those who come from the World Bank.

588
00:42:40.540 --> 00:42:41.200
<v Ziauddin Sardar>The,

589
00:42:42.960 --> 00:42:43.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>the reason,

590
00:42:44.100 --> 00:42:44.960
<v Ziauddin Sardar>the reason

591
00:42:46.140 --> 00:42:49.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>we are slightly more ahead of the game

592
00:42:49.020 --> 00:42:50.620
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is because we believe in chaos.

593
00:42:51.360 --> 00:42:52.340
<v Ziauddin Sardar>We have learned

594
00:42:53.440 --> 00:42:54.400
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that structures

595
00:42:55.380 --> 00:42:57.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>can be domesticated.

596
00:42:57.740 --> 00:42:59.060
<v Ziauddin Sardar>There's hardly a,

597
00:43:00.660 --> 00:43:01.480
<v Ziauddin Sardar>dissenting movement

598
00:43:01.480 --> 00:43:02.940
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that has not been domesticated.

599
00:43:03.140 --> 00:43:04.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Look at ecology,

600
00:43:04.260 --> 00:43:06.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>how ecology was started off as a great,

601
00:43:06.160 --> 00:43:07.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>you know,

602
00:43:07.340 --> 00:43:08.440
<v Ziauddin Sardar>anti-establishment movement

603
00:43:08.440 --> 00:43:09.580
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and it has been domesticated.

604
00:43:10.040 --> 00:43:10.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>In this,

605
00:43:10.940 --> 00:43:12.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>in the 70s and the 80s

606
00:43:12.540 --> 00:43:12.940
<v Ziauddin Sardar>when I used to work in the,

607
00:43:12.960 --> 00:43:13.940
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I used to work for New Scientist,

608
00:43:14.040 --> 00:43:15.880
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I used to write about alternative technology

609
00:43:15.880 --> 00:43:17.100
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and how alternative technology

610
00:43:17.100 --> 00:43:18.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is gonna change the world.

611
00:43:18.260 --> 00:43:19.760
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Then World Bank came along and said,

612
00:43:19.820 --> 00:43:21.300
<v Ziauddin Sardar>we like alternative technology too.

613
00:43:21.480 --> 00:43:22.960
<v Ziauddin Sardar>So the whole alternative technology movement

614
00:43:23.480 --> 00:43:24.560
<v Ziauddin Sardar>was domesticated.

615
00:43:25.260 --> 00:43:27.420
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Dissent is always domesticated.

616
00:43:28.600 --> 00:43:30.720
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Establishment has a way of domesticating dissent.

617
00:43:31.160 --> 00:43:32.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>The only way

618
00:43:32.700 --> 00:43:34.140
<v Ziauddin Sardar>dissent cannot be domesticated

619
00:43:34.140 --> 00:43:35.060
<v Ziauddin Sardar>if it's chaotic.

620
00:43:35.900 --> 00:43:36.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And in other words,

621
00:43:36.920 --> 00:43:37.800
<v Ziauddin Sardar>it doesn't have a leader,

622
00:43:38.000 --> 00:43:39.520
<v Ziauddin Sardar>it works as a network

623
00:43:39.520 --> 00:43:40.460
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and it's,

624
00:43:40.480 --> 00:43:41.680
<v Ziauddin Sardar>it is based on feedback.

625
00:43:41.680 --> 00:43:44.680
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And this is why the anti-globalization movement

626
00:43:45.560 --> 00:43:48.260
<v Ziauddin Sardar>was so successful in places like Seattle

627
00:43:48.260 --> 00:43:51.780
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and various other parts of the world.

628
00:43:52.520 --> 00:43:53.720
<v Ziauddin Sardar>That's what we need to do.

629
00:43:54.040 --> 00:43:56.200
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I would like you all to go out of here,

630
00:43:56.340 --> 00:43:56.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>this hall,

631
00:43:57.440 --> 00:43:58.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and promise yourselves

632
00:43:58.540 --> 00:43:59.920
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that from now on,

633
00:43:59.940 --> 00:44:02.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>you're going to cause absolute chaos.

634
00:44:02.520 --> 00:44:03.000
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Wherever,

635
00:44:03.580 --> 00:44:04.840
<v Ziauddin Sardar>wherever you will be,

636
00:44:04.860 --> 00:44:05.980
<v Ziauddin Sardar>you will cause chaos,

637
00:44:06.660 --> 00:44:08.000
<v Ziauddin Sardar>but ordered chaos

638
00:44:08.000 --> 00:44:09.640
<v Ziauddin Sardar>with genuine feedback.

639
00:44:09.960 --> 00:44:10.760
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And together,

640
00:44:10.760 --> 00:44:12.380
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I'm sure we can defeat this.

641
00:44:12.500 --> 00:44:12.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Thank you.

642
00:44:24.240 --> 00:44:25.920
<v Chair>Adelaide's Festival of Ideas

643
00:44:25.920 --> 00:44:27.940
<v Chair>coming from the Bonython Hall,

644
00:44:28.120 --> 00:44:28.900
<v Chair>the theme,

645
00:44:28.960 --> 00:44:30.120
<v Chair>One World Ready or Not.

646
00:44:30.400 --> 00:44:31.620
<v Chair>In the past,

647
00:44:31.680 --> 00:44:33.620
<v Chair>we have the advisory board

648
00:44:33.620 --> 00:44:34.800
<v Chair>of the Festival of Ideas

649
00:44:34.800 --> 00:44:37.980
<v Chair>have tried to focus on intellectual enlargement.

650
00:44:41.360 --> 00:44:42.920
<v Chair>Let me now announce

651
00:44:42.920 --> 00:44:43.780
<v Chair>that the next festival

652
00:44:43.780 --> 00:44:45.700
<v Chair>will focus on penis enlargement.

653
00:44:47.280 --> 00:44:49.020
<v Chair>There's obviously more money in it.

654
00:44:49.300 --> 00:44:49.620
<v Chair>Now,

655
00:44:50.320 --> 00:44:50.900
<v Chair>George,

656
00:44:51.620 --> 00:44:53.380
<v Chair>you want a revolution.

657
00:44:54.220 --> 00:44:57.380
<v Chair>You want to democratize the United Nations.

658
00:44:57.440 --> 00:44:59.240
<v Chair>You want to challenge

659
00:44:59.240 --> 00:45:01.160
<v Chair>all the existing structures,

660
00:45:01.280 --> 00:45:02.500
<v Chair>if you like,

661
00:45:02.580 --> 00:45:04.540
<v Chair>of internationalism.

662
00:45:05.240 --> 00:45:07.760
<v Chair>Do you think that there is a hope,

663
00:45:07.820 --> 00:45:08.500
<v Chair>a possibility,

664
00:45:08.500 --> 00:45:11.680
<v Chair>that organizations like the Monetary Fund

665
00:45:11.680 --> 00:45:15.020
<v Chair>can be renewed or transformed from within

666
00:45:15.020 --> 00:45:16.920
<v Chair>as a result of a sort of global debate?

667
00:45:17.260 --> 00:45:18.720
<v Chair>Can the World Bank,

668
00:45:18.840 --> 00:45:19.340
<v Chair>in fact,

669
00:45:19.340 --> 00:45:19.780
<v Chair>become,

670
00:45:20.500 --> 00:45:20.520
<v Chair>well,

671
00:45:20.540 --> 00:45:21.540
<v Chair>given Michael's,

672
00:45:21.560 --> 00:45:21.760
<v Chair>I think,

673
00:45:21.800 --> 00:45:24.480
<v Chair>extraordinary progressive line of argument,

674
00:45:24.680 --> 00:45:26.240
<v Chair>that the World Bank can become

675
00:45:26.240 --> 00:45:27.920
<v Chair>a real agent of change,

676
00:45:28.040 --> 00:45:28.840
<v Chair>of good change?

677
00:45:29.320 --> 00:45:29.880
<v George Monbiot>No,

678
00:45:29.920 --> 00:45:32.480
<v George Monbiot>they're constitutionally incapable of these things.

679
00:45:32.600 --> 00:45:33.280
<v George Monbiot>And, in fact,

680
00:45:33.300 --> 00:45:35.480
<v George Monbiot>I would take very serious issue with Michael

681
00:45:35.480 --> 00:45:37.700
<v George Monbiot>because I feel that he is promulgating

682
00:45:37.700 --> 00:45:39.420
<v George Monbiot>a pervasive and dangerous myth.

683
00:45:39.680 --> 00:45:40.720
<v George Monbiot>And this myth is

684
00:45:40.720 --> 00:45:42.520
<v George Monbiot>1940s America the good,

685
00:45:43.200 --> 00:45:44.480
<v George Monbiot>2000s America the bad.

686
00:45:45.220 --> 00:45:46.940
<v George Monbiot>All we are seeing now

687
00:45:46.940 --> 00:45:48.980
<v George Monbiot>is a unilateral approach to imperialism.

688
00:45:49.000 --> 00:45:49.700
<v George Monbiot>What we saw in the 1940s

689
00:45:50.280 --> 00:45:52.080
<v George Monbiot>was a multilateral approach to imperialism.

690
00:45:52.200 --> 00:45:53.020
<v George Monbiot>The institutions,

691
00:45:53.380 --> 00:45:54.700
<v George Monbiot>the US in particular,

692
00:45:54.700 --> 00:45:55.420
<v George Monbiot>set up then,

693
00:45:55.540 --> 00:45:56.960
<v George Monbiot>and especially the IMF

694
00:45:56.960 --> 00:45:57.700
<v George Monbiot>and the World Bank,

695
00:45:57.820 --> 00:46:00.200
<v George Monbiot>are strictly imperialist institutions.

696
00:46:00.720 --> 00:46:01.600
<v George Monbiot>Their purpose

697
00:46:01.600 --> 00:46:02.900
<v George Monbiot>is to ensure

698
00:46:02.900 --> 00:46:05.200
<v George Monbiot>that the key decisions made in the poor world

699
00:46:05.200 --> 00:46:06.780
<v George Monbiot>are made by the rich world.

700
00:46:07.000 --> 00:46:07.680
<v George Monbiot>Because those institutions

701
00:46:10.140 --> 00:46:11.180
<v George Monbiot>those institutions

702
00:46:11.180 --> 00:46:13.700
<v George Monbiot>those institutions

703
00:46:13.700 --> 00:46:15.400
<v George Monbiot>are controlled exclusively

704
00:46:15.400 --> 00:46:16.900
<v George Monbiot>by the rich nations.

705
00:46:17.140 --> 00:46:17.420
<v George Monbiot>In fact,

706
00:46:17.440 --> 00:46:18.000
<v George Monbiot>the US

707
00:46:18.000 --> 00:46:19.720
<v George Monbiot>has got a blocking veto

708
00:46:19.720 --> 00:46:20.860
<v George Monbiot>in both institutions.

709
00:46:21.180 --> 00:46:22.460
<v George Monbiot>It takes an 85% majority

710
00:46:22.460 --> 00:46:24.120
<v George Monbiot>to make any substantial resolution.

711
00:46:24.500 --> 00:46:27.000
<v George Monbiot>The US has 17% of the votes in the IMF,

712
00:46:27.060 --> 00:46:29.300
<v George Monbiot>18% of the votes in the World Bank.

713
00:46:29.440 --> 00:46:29.860
<v George Monbiot>As such,

714
00:46:29.860 --> 00:46:30.880
<v George Monbiot>they are unreformable.

715
00:46:31.120 --> 00:46:32.380
<v George Monbiot>That's not the only reason

716
00:46:32.380 --> 00:46:33.240
<v George Monbiot>why they are unreformable.

717
00:46:33.340 --> 00:46:35.080
<v George Monbiot>They also put the entire burden

718
00:46:35.080 --> 00:46:36.120
<v George Monbiot>of discharging debt

719
00:46:36.120 --> 00:46:37.600
<v George Monbiot>and discharging trade deficits

720
00:46:37.600 --> 00:46:37.680
<v George Monbiot>into the IMF.

721
00:46:37.680 --> 00:46:38.740
<v George Monbiot>They put the debtors

722
00:46:38.740 --> 00:46:39.860
<v George Monbiot>and the deficit nations

723
00:46:39.860 --> 00:46:40.140
<v George Monbiot>into the IMF.

724
00:46:40.140 --> 00:46:40.660
<v George Monbiot>Those nations

725
00:46:40.660 --> 00:46:41.620
<v George Monbiot>which are least capable

726
00:46:41.620 --> 00:46:42.680
<v George Monbiot>of dealing,

727
00:46:42.880 --> 00:46:44.320
<v George Monbiot>of re-establishing

728
00:46:44.320 --> 00:46:45.280
<v George Monbiot>the balance of trade

729
00:46:45.280 --> 00:46:46.740
<v George Monbiot>and of discharging debt.

730
00:46:47.040 --> 00:46:48.300
<v George Monbiot>There was a far better plan

731
00:46:48.300 --> 00:46:49.380
<v George Monbiot>put forward at the time,

732
00:46:49.400 --> 00:46:50.920
<v George Monbiot>put forward by John Maynard Keynes,

733
00:46:51.060 --> 00:46:52.520
<v George Monbiot>for an international clearing union

734
00:46:52.520 --> 00:46:53.160
<v George Monbiot>which automatically

735
00:46:53.160 --> 00:46:55.140
<v George Monbiot>discharged trade deficits.

736
00:46:55.420 --> 00:46:56.540
<v George Monbiot>The US blocked it

737
00:46:56.540 --> 00:46:57.520
<v George Monbiot>and it blocked it

738
00:46:57.520 --> 00:46:57.960
<v George Monbiot>because

739
00:46:57.960 --> 00:46:58.820
<v George Monbiot>it saw

740
00:46:58.820 --> 00:47:00.940
<v George Monbiot>that that system

741
00:47:00.940 --> 00:47:02.260
<v George Monbiot>would not ensure

742
00:47:02.260 --> 00:47:03.360
<v George Monbiot>its political

743
00:47:03.360 --> 00:47:04.520
<v George Monbiot>and economic hegemony.

744
00:47:04.680 --> 00:47:05.980
<v George Monbiot>It introduced instead

745
00:47:05.980 --> 00:47:07.060
<v George Monbiot>a system

746
00:47:07.060 --> 00:47:07.660
<v George Monbiot>which would

747
00:47:07.660 --> 00:47:08.920
<v George Monbiot>and that system

748
00:47:08.920 --> 00:47:09.380
<v George Monbiot>was called

749
00:47:09.380 --> 00:47:10.140
<v George Monbiot>the IMF

750
00:47:10.140 --> 00:47:10.720
<v George Monbiot>and the World Bank.

751
00:47:10.920 --> 00:47:11.680
<v George Monbiot>They have to go

752
00:47:11.680 --> 00:47:13.140
<v George Monbiot>and we have to replace them

753
00:47:13.140 --> 00:47:14.120
<v George Monbiot>by genuine,

754
00:47:14.160 --> 00:47:14.640
<v George Monbiot>progressive,

755
00:47:15.220 --> 00:47:15.780
<v George Monbiot>genuine,

756
00:47:15.900 --> 00:47:16.640
<v George Monbiot>in this case,

757
00:47:16.640 --> 00:47:17.760
<v George Monbiot>internationalist organisations

758
00:47:17.760 --> 00:47:18.640
<v George Monbiot>which in fact

759
00:47:18.640 --> 00:47:20.360
<v George Monbiot>involve the whole world

760
00:47:20.360 --> 00:47:21.980
<v George Monbiot>rather than being controlled

761
00:47:21.980 --> 00:47:23.180
<v George Monbiot>by the rich nations

762
00:47:23.180 --> 00:47:24.220
<v George Monbiot>which permit

763
00:47:24.220 --> 00:47:25.540
<v George Monbiot>the poor nations

764
00:47:25.540 --> 00:47:27.060
<v George Monbiot>to make the key decisions

765
00:47:27.060 --> 00:47:28.560
<v George Monbiot>over their own economic lives.

766
00:47:37.660 --> 00:47:39.160
<v Chair>Before giving Michael

767
00:47:39.160 --> 00:47:40.320
<v Chair>the right to reply

768
00:47:40.320 --> 00:47:42.440
<v Chair>I'd also like to invite you

769
00:47:42.440 --> 00:47:43.680
<v Chair>to start queuing

770
00:47:43.680 --> 00:47:44.680
<v Chair>at the microphones

771
00:47:44.680 --> 00:47:47.100
<v Chair>so that we can have interaction

772
00:47:47.720 --> 00:47:49.580
<v Chair>between audience and panel.

773
00:47:49.760 --> 00:47:50.820
<v Chair>There's a microphone

774
00:47:50.820 --> 00:47:51.960
<v Chair>I think in the middle

775
00:47:51.960 --> 00:47:53.040
<v Chair>of the downstairs

776
00:47:53.040 --> 00:47:55.520
<v Chair>and one up in the gods.

777
00:47:55.780 --> 00:47:57.240
<v Chair>Michael, defend yourself.

778
00:48:00.720 --> 00:48:03.260
<v Chair>No, that won't do it, Michael.

779
00:48:09.340 --> 00:48:11.260
<v Michael Woolcock>They can and they do change

780
00:48:11.260 --> 00:48:13.000
<v Michael Woolcock>and the moment you believe

781
00:48:13.000 --> 00:48:13.600
<v Michael Woolcock>they can't

782
00:48:13.600 --> 00:48:14.520
<v Michael Woolcock>is the day

783
00:48:14.520 --> 00:48:15.520
<v Michael Woolcock>that this debate

784
00:48:15.520 --> 00:48:16.340
<v Michael Woolcock>has no purpose.

785
00:48:16.920 --> 00:48:18.320
<v Michael Woolcock>The purpose of these kinds

786
00:48:18.320 --> 00:48:18.880
<v Michael Woolcock>of conversations

787
00:48:18.880 --> 00:48:20.000
<v Michael Woolcock>is to try

788
00:48:20.000 --> 00:48:20.900
<v Michael Woolcock>and understand

789
00:48:21.760 --> 00:48:22.660
<v Michael Woolcock>how organisations work

790
00:48:23.180 --> 00:48:24.500
<v Michael Woolcock>and George has given you

791
00:48:24.500 --> 00:48:24.960
<v Michael Woolcock>some sense

792
00:48:24.960 --> 00:48:26.160
<v Michael Woolcock>of how that works.

793
00:48:26.820 --> 00:48:28.020
<v Michael Woolcock>But it is also the case

794
00:48:28.020 --> 00:48:29.300
<v Michael Woolcock>that these are not

795
00:48:29.300 --> 00:48:30.540
<v Michael Woolcock>monolithic organisations.

796
00:48:31.000 --> 00:48:32.520
<v Michael Woolcock>They are not unchangeable

797
00:48:32.520 --> 00:48:34.300
<v Michael Woolcock>and I wouldn't be working there

798
00:48:34.300 --> 00:48:35.660
<v Michael Woolcock>if I thought that was the case.

799
00:48:35.800 --> 00:48:36.580
<v Michael Woolcock>I did not see myself

800
00:48:36.580 --> 00:48:37.300
<v Michael Woolcock>as an instrument

801
00:48:37.660 --> 00:48:38.980
<v Michael Woolcock>of a monolithic entity

802
00:48:38.980 --> 00:48:40.340
<v Michael Woolcock>that bows before the altar

803
00:48:40.340 --> 00:48:41.240
<v Michael Woolcock>of Milton Friedman

804
00:48:41.240 --> 00:48:41.800
<v Michael Woolcock>every morning

805
00:48:41.800 --> 00:48:42.840
<v Michael Woolcock>but rather an organisation

806
00:48:42.840 --> 00:48:44.420
<v Michael Woolcock>of very genuinely committed,

807
00:48:44.600 --> 00:48:45.720
<v Michael Woolcock>smart, well coordinated

808
00:48:46.320 --> 00:48:47.900
<v Michael Woolcock>and well resourced people

809
00:48:47.900 --> 00:48:49.540
<v Michael Woolcock>doing the kinds of things

810
00:48:49.540 --> 00:48:51.280
<v Michael Woolcock>that I've indicated in my talk.

811
00:48:51.560 --> 00:48:52.780
<v Michael Woolcock>So I'm not in that sense

812
00:48:52.780 --> 00:48:53.440
<v Michael Woolcock>an outlier

813
00:48:53.440 --> 00:48:56.100
<v Michael Woolcock>or some person speaking

814
00:48:57.320 --> 00:48:59.180
<v Michael Woolcock>outside of what the World Bank

815
00:48:59.180 --> 00:48:59.660
<v Michael Woolcock>is about.

816
00:49:00.180 --> 00:49:01.300
<v Michael Woolcock>What I'm talking about

817
00:49:01.300 --> 00:49:02.320
<v Michael Woolcock>is what the World Bank

818
00:49:02.320 --> 00:49:02.740
<v Michael Woolcock>should do.

819
00:49:03.660 --> 00:49:05.200
<v Michael Woolcock>Secondly, to argue that

820
00:49:05.200 --> 00:49:06.440
<v Michael Woolcock>they need to be dismantled,

821
00:49:06.480 --> 00:49:07.300
<v Michael Woolcock>reasonable people

822
00:49:07.300 --> 00:49:07.640
<v Michael Woolcock>can do that.

823
00:49:07.660 --> 00:49:07.760
<v Michael Woolcock>I don't think

824
00:49:07.760 --> 00:49:08.320
<v Michael Woolcock>that they can differ on that.

825
00:49:09.200 --> 00:49:11.140
<v Michael Woolcock>I believe that they can change

826
00:49:11.140 --> 00:49:11.800
<v Michael Woolcock>and that in fact

827
00:49:11.800 --> 00:49:13.280
<v Michael Woolcock>the more politically realistic task

828
00:49:13.280 --> 00:49:14.060
<v Michael Woolcock>is to change

829
00:49:14.060 --> 00:49:15.080
<v Michael Woolcock>and work with what we have

830
00:49:15.080 --> 00:49:16.840
<v Michael Woolcock>and to read my final sentence again,

831
00:49:16.940 --> 00:49:18.280
<v Michael Woolcock>to use the institutions we have

832
00:49:18.280 --> 00:49:19.580
<v Michael Woolcock>to build the ones we need.

833
00:49:19.820 --> 00:49:20.920
<v Michael Woolcock>We need a World Bank.

834
00:49:21.020 --> 00:49:21.840
<v Michael Woolcock>We need an international

835
00:49:21.840 --> 00:49:22.640
<v Michael Woolcock>monetary fund.

836
00:49:22.780 --> 00:49:23.560
<v Michael Woolcock>We need an international

837
00:49:23.560 --> 00:49:24.200
<v Michael Woolcock>clearinghouse.

838
00:49:24.320 --> 00:49:25.740
<v Michael Woolcock>We need the kinds of institutions

839
00:49:25.740 --> 00:49:27.040
<v Michael Woolcock>in place to do these things.

840
00:49:27.220 --> 00:49:28.480
<v Michael Woolcock>If they are not working

841
00:49:28.480 --> 00:49:29.380
<v Michael Woolcock>in the interests

842
00:49:29.380 --> 00:49:30.700
<v Michael Woolcock>of global citizens,

843
00:49:31.080 --> 00:49:32.900
<v Michael Woolcock>if you can demonstrate

844
00:49:32.900 --> 00:49:33.840
<v Michael Woolcock>that they are not working

845
00:49:33.840 --> 00:49:34.320
<v Michael Woolcock>in the interests

846
00:49:34.320 --> 00:49:35.040
<v Michael Woolcock>of poor people

847
00:49:35.040 --> 00:49:35.980
<v Michael Woolcock>as often they are not,

848
00:49:36.560 --> 00:49:37.640
<v Michael Woolcock>then it is the task

849
00:49:37.640 --> 00:49:38.500
<v Michael Woolcock>to use our own

850
00:49:38.500 --> 00:49:39.580
<v Michael Woolcock>domestic political institutions

851
00:49:39.580 --> 00:49:42.440
<v Michael Woolcock>to try and do the kinds of things

852
00:49:42.440 --> 00:49:43.700
<v Michael Woolcock>that democratic institutions

853
00:49:43.700 --> 00:49:45.100
<v Michael Woolcock>are supposed to be doing.

854
00:49:45.540 --> 00:49:47.640
<v Michael Woolcock>So we need to be working

855
00:49:48.200 --> 00:49:48.800
<v Michael Woolcock>with those things.

856
00:49:48.860 --> 00:49:49.600
<v Michael Woolcock>To argue that we should

857
00:49:49.600 --> 00:49:50.320
<v Michael Woolcock>dismantle them,

858
00:49:50.540 --> 00:49:52.040
<v Michael Woolcock>you can argue that,

859
00:49:52.080 --> 00:49:53.220
<v Michael Woolcock>I just think that's too easy.

860
00:49:53.680 --> 00:49:55.400
<v Michael Woolcock>I think it's way too easy

861
00:49:55.400 --> 00:49:55.680
<v Michael Woolcock>to do that.

862
00:49:55.680 --> 00:49:56.800
<v Michael Woolcock>A much more difficult task

863
00:49:56.800 --> 00:49:58.880
<v Michael Woolcock>is to actually try and work

864
00:49:58.880 --> 00:49:59.840
<v Michael Woolcock>with the people inside

865
00:49:59.840 --> 00:50:00.440
<v Michael Woolcock>those organisations

866
00:50:00.440 --> 00:50:01.540
<v Michael Woolcock>to set up the dialogues

867
00:50:01.540 --> 00:50:03.160
<v Michael Woolcock>and the positions in place.

868
00:50:04.080 --> 00:50:05.640
<v Michael Woolcock>Secondly, or thirdly rather,

869
00:50:05.840 --> 00:50:07.520
<v Michael Woolcock>I think we need to recognise

870
00:50:07.520 --> 00:50:07.620
<v Michael Woolcock>that we need to recognise

871
00:50:07.640 --> 00:50:08.340
<v Michael Woolcock>the enormous good

872
00:50:08.340 --> 00:50:09.780
<v Michael Woolcock>that imperialism can do.

873
00:50:09.880 --> 00:50:10.300
<v Michael Woolcock>And that's perhaps

874
00:50:10.300 --> 00:50:11.580
<v Michael Woolcock>a little bit more controversial,

875
00:50:11.820 --> 00:50:13.120
<v Michael Woolcock>but we have very pejorative notions

876
00:50:13.120 --> 00:50:14.600
<v Michael Woolcock>of what that can be.

877
00:50:14.960 --> 00:50:16.380
<v Michael Woolcock>The America of the Good of 1945,

878
00:50:16.720 --> 00:50:17.080
<v Michael Woolcock>as indicated,

879
00:50:17.320 --> 00:50:18.480
<v Michael Woolcock>was multilateralist

880
00:50:18.480 --> 00:50:19.180
<v Michael Woolcock>and that's how we should

881
00:50:19.180 --> 00:50:19.680
<v Michael Woolcock>be doing things.

882
00:50:19.740 --> 00:50:20.720
<v Michael Woolcock>It wasn't exclusively

883
00:50:20.720 --> 00:50:21.880
<v Michael Woolcock>a unilateralist power.

884
00:50:22.000 --> 00:50:22.860
<v Michael Woolcock>It was doing something

885
00:50:22.860 --> 00:50:23.820
<v Michael Woolcock>in coordination

886
00:50:23.820 --> 00:50:24.760
<v Michael Woolcock>with other people.

887
00:50:24.880 --> 00:50:25.720
<v Michael Woolcock>That's the kind of thing

888
00:50:25.720 --> 00:50:26.880
<v Michael Woolcock>we need to keep seeing happening.

889
00:50:27.260 --> 00:50:28.420
<v Michael Woolcock>We also need to recognise

890
00:50:28.420 --> 00:50:29.760
<v Michael Woolcock>that a lot of good things happen

891
00:50:29.760 --> 00:50:31.720
<v Michael Woolcock>because of conditions

892
00:50:31.720 --> 00:50:32.960
<v Michael Woolcock>that are set in the outside.

893
00:50:33.440 --> 00:50:34.540
<v Michael Woolcock>Certain countries would not

894
00:50:34.540 --> 00:50:35.620
<v Michael Woolcock>spend a cent on education

895
00:50:35.620 --> 00:50:36.720
<v Michael Woolcock>on women, for example,

896
00:50:36.720 --> 00:50:37.620
<v Michael Woolcock>if it wasn't for the fact

897
00:50:37.640 --> 00:50:38.540
<v Michael Woolcock>that outside agencies

898
00:50:38.540 --> 00:50:39.620
<v Michael Woolcock>were being able to do that.

899
00:50:40.280 --> 00:50:41.620
<v Chair>Michael looks a bit...

900
00:50:41.620 --> 00:50:42.180
<v Chair>I'm sorry,

901
00:50:42.300 --> 00:50:43.740
<v Chair>you look a bit peevish.

902
00:50:44.540 --> 00:50:46.440
<v George Monbiot>Well, I think we could ask

903
00:50:46.440 --> 00:50:47.460
<v George Monbiot>the people of the countries

904
00:50:47.460 --> 00:50:48.600
<v George Monbiot>of sub-Saharan Africa

905
00:50:48.600 --> 00:50:51.020
<v George Monbiot>just how much good imperialism

906
00:50:51.020 --> 00:50:52.180
<v George Monbiot>in the form of structural adjustment

907
00:50:52.180 --> 00:50:53.280
<v George Monbiot>has done their lives.

908
00:50:55.360 --> 00:50:57.440
<v George Monbiot>And I think I would also ask

909
00:50:57.440 --> 00:50:58.040
<v George Monbiot>another question

910
00:50:58.040 --> 00:50:58.860
<v George Monbiot>and this would be a question

911
00:50:58.860 --> 00:50:59.820
<v George Monbiot>I'd ask of Michael.

912
00:51:00.080 --> 00:51:01.880
<v George Monbiot>How can the other nations

913
00:51:01.880 --> 00:51:03.940
<v George Monbiot>of the world alter and reform

914
00:51:03.940 --> 00:51:05.780
<v George Monbiot>the World Bank and the IMF

915
00:51:05.780 --> 00:51:07.620
<v George Monbiot>when the US has a blocking vision

916
00:51:07.640 --> 00:51:07.860
<v George Monbiot>of the world's future?

917
00:51:07.860 --> 00:51:08.780
<v George Monbiot>have a veto within these organisations?

918
00:51:15.380 --> 00:51:16.620
<v Michael Woolcock>Then it's the task

919
00:51:16.620 --> 00:51:17.600
<v Michael Woolcock>of American citizens

920
00:51:17.600 --> 00:51:18.940
<v Michael Woolcock>and the democratic process

921
00:51:18.940 --> 00:51:20.200
<v Michael Woolcock>to try and reform that.

922
00:51:20.480 --> 00:51:21.200
<v Michael Woolcock>Oh, brilliant.

923
00:51:21.340 --> 00:51:22.360
<v George Monbiot>So the rest of the world

924
00:51:22.360 --> 00:51:24.040
<v George Monbiot>has to wait for American citizens

925
00:51:24.040 --> 00:51:24.480
<v George Monbiot>to act?

926
00:51:24.700 --> 00:51:25.000
<v George Monbiot>No,

927
00:51:25.060 --> 00:51:25.520
<v Michael Woolcock>It's the...

928
00:51:25.520 --> 00:51:27.620
<v Chair>I'd like to bring you in here, Amy,

929
00:51:27.720 --> 00:51:29.280
<v Chair>because the union movement...

930
00:51:29.280 --> 00:51:30.260
<v Chair>No, the union movement

931
00:51:30.260 --> 00:51:30.780
<v Chair>in the US

932
00:51:30.780 --> 00:51:31.980
<v Chair>also has to deal

933
00:51:31.980 --> 00:51:33.640
<v Speaker 6>with the implications

934
00:51:33.640 --> 00:51:35.480
<v Chair>of the World Bank and the IMF.

935
00:51:35.580 --> 00:51:36.500
<v Chair>Well, what's your view

936
00:51:36.500 --> 00:51:37.220
<v Chair>of these structures?

937
00:51:37.520 --> 00:51:37.620
<v Chair>Well, I think

938
00:51:38.520 --> 00:51:40.480
<v Amy Dean>there is very little ability

939
00:51:40.480 --> 00:51:42.060
<v Amy Dean>for us politically

940
00:51:42.060 --> 00:51:42.900
<v Amy Dean>within our countries

941
00:51:42.900 --> 00:51:44.460
<v Amy Dean>to get our hooks around them.

942
00:51:44.620 --> 00:51:45.380
<v Amy Dean>I mean, they really operate

943
00:51:45.380 --> 00:51:47.400
<v Amy Dean>above the political process

944
00:51:47.400 --> 00:51:50.880
<v Amy Dean>and very, very little political space

945
00:51:50.880 --> 00:51:51.860
<v Amy Dean>and will to be able

946
00:51:51.860 --> 00:51:53.180
<v Amy Dean>to have any impact from them.

947
00:51:53.300 --> 00:51:55.160
<v Amy Dean>And I think the challenge is,

948
00:51:55.160 --> 00:51:57.040
<v Amy Dean>is that for the labor movement,

949
00:51:57.080 --> 00:51:57.920
<v Amy Dean>there's been a debate

950
00:51:57.920 --> 00:51:58.740
<v Amy Dean>that's gone on

951
00:51:58.740 --> 00:51:59.720
<v Amy Dean>in the US labor movement

952
00:51:59.720 --> 00:52:00.420
<v Amy Dean>for the last...

953
00:52:00.420 --> 00:52:01.920
<v Amy Dean>really since NAFTA,

954
00:52:01.980 --> 00:52:02.600
<v Amy Dean>since 1992,

955
00:52:03.120 --> 00:52:03.960
<v Amy Dean>about what is

956
00:52:03.960 --> 00:52:04.960
<v Amy Dean>the appropriate response

957
00:52:04.960 --> 00:52:05.680
<v Amy Dean>in an attempt

958
00:52:05.680 --> 00:52:07.340
<v Amy Dean>to upwardly harmonize conditions

959
00:52:07.340 --> 00:52:07.620
<v Amy Dean>within the world.

960
00:52:07.640 --> 00:52:07.660
<v Amy Dean>And I think that's

961
00:52:07.660 --> 00:52:08.200
<v Amy Dean>and in the countries around the globe.

962
00:52:09.020 --> 00:52:10.480
<v Amy Dean>I think that increasingly

963
00:52:10.480 --> 00:52:11.400
<v Amy Dean>there's a consensus

964
00:52:11.400 --> 00:52:12.720
<v Amy Dean>among the US labor movement

965
00:52:12.720 --> 00:52:13.440
<v Amy Dean>that the rights

966
00:52:13.440 --> 00:52:14.940
<v Amy Dean>for workers around the world

967
00:52:14.940 --> 00:52:16.040
<v Amy Dean>to have freedom of association

968
00:52:16.040 --> 00:52:17.500
<v Amy Dean>becomes the most important thing

969
00:52:17.500 --> 00:52:17.860
<v Amy Dean>politically

970
00:52:17.860 --> 00:52:19.060
<v Amy Dean>that we can advocate for.

971
00:52:19.420 --> 00:52:21.000
<v Amy Dean>I think we see the strategy

972
00:52:21.000 --> 00:52:22.920
<v Amy Dean>as trying to make those values,

973
00:52:23.220 --> 00:52:23.700
<v Amy Dean>the extension

974
00:52:23.700 --> 00:52:24.800
<v Amy Dean>of those political values,

975
00:52:24.940 --> 00:52:26.180
<v Amy Dean>a part of our trade policies

976
00:52:26.180 --> 00:52:27.860
<v Amy Dean>and to connect them

977
00:52:27.860 --> 00:52:28.760
<v Amy Dean>as a condition of trade

978
00:52:28.760 --> 00:52:29.800
<v Amy Dean>and that's where most

979
00:52:29.800 --> 00:52:31.100
<v Amy Dean>of the political focus has been.

980
00:52:31.340 --> 00:52:32.080
<v Amy Dean>But in terms

981
00:52:32.080 --> 00:52:33.260
<v Amy Dean>of those two organizations,

982
00:52:34.080 --> 00:52:35.420
<v Amy Dean>in terms of the ability

983
00:52:35.420 --> 00:52:36.580
<v Amy Dean>to be able to reform them,

984
00:52:36.600 --> 00:52:37.620
<v Amy Dean>I think for the most part

985
00:52:37.640 --> 00:52:39.680
<v Amy Dean>people and even though

986
00:52:39.680 --> 00:52:40.200
<v Amy Dean>the labor movement

987
00:52:40.200 --> 00:52:41.280
<v Amy Dean>has somewhat power left,

988
00:52:41.420 --> 00:52:42.340
<v Amy Dean>people don't really see

989
00:52:42.340 --> 00:52:43.300
<v Amy Dean>any ability to be able

990
00:52:43.300 --> 00:52:44.180
<v Amy Dean>to make decisions

991
00:52:44.180 --> 00:52:44.980
<v Amy Dean>because they really...

992
00:52:44.980 --> 00:52:45.920
<v Amy Dean>to reform them

993
00:52:45.920 --> 00:52:46.700
<v Amy Dean>because they really do operate

994
00:52:46.700 --> 00:52:49.340
<v Amy Dean>outside of our political realm.

995
00:52:49.600 --> 00:52:50.720
<v Amy Dean>I mean these are institutions

996
00:52:50.720 --> 00:52:51.700
<v Amy Dean>that are exclusively

997
00:52:51.700 --> 00:52:52.800
<v Amy Dean>run by capital.

998
00:52:54.660 --> 00:52:55.380
<v Amy Dean>Elected leaders

999
00:52:55.380 --> 00:52:56.980
<v Amy Dean>have absolutely no ability

1000
00:52:56.980 --> 00:52:58.140
<v Amy Dean>to have impact on them.

1001
00:52:58.300 --> 00:52:59.320
<v Amy Dean>And so to think that

1002
00:52:59.320 --> 00:53:00.480
<v Amy Dean>we as individuals

1003
00:53:00.480 --> 00:53:01.660
<v Amy Dean>will be able to impact them

1004
00:53:01.660 --> 00:53:02.560
<v Amy Dean>when our elected leaders

1005
00:53:02.560 --> 00:53:03.640
<v Amy Dean>really can't is...

1006
00:53:05.060 --> 00:53:06.180
<v Amy Dean>I think it's naive.

1007
00:53:06.640 --> 00:53:07.620
<v Chair>So you have a question

1008
00:53:07.640 --> 00:53:08.620
<v Chair>for the brief coming from you.

1009
00:53:10.460 --> 00:53:12.180
<v Speaker 7>I'm going to defend Michael.

1010
00:53:14.680 --> 00:53:15.860
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Michael comes from

1011
00:53:15.860 --> 00:53:16.640
<v Ziauddin Sardar>a very good tradition.

1012
00:53:16.840 --> 00:53:17.920
<v Ziauddin Sardar>The World Bank has

1013
00:53:17.920 --> 00:53:18.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>a very good tradition

1014
00:53:18.900 --> 00:53:20.480
<v Ziauddin Sardar>of having very progressive people.

1015
00:53:20.700 --> 00:53:23.100
<v Ziauddin Sardar>It always had very progressive people

1016
00:53:23.940 --> 00:53:24.720
<v Ziauddin Sardar>within it.

1017
00:53:25.020 --> 00:53:26.780
<v Ziauddin Sardar>That's one way of domesticating,

1018
00:53:26.780 --> 00:53:28.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>you know, domesticating dissent

1019
00:53:28.120 --> 00:53:29.200
<v Ziauddin Sardar>in a sense.

1020
00:53:29.220 --> 00:53:30.740
<v Ziauddin Sardar>So you had good kind of

1021
00:53:30.740 --> 00:53:32.360
<v Ziauddin Sardar>homely domesticated dissenters

1022
00:53:32.360 --> 00:53:32.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>within you.

1023
00:53:33.000 --> 00:53:34.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>The classical example

1024
00:53:34.040 --> 00:53:35.340
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is Mahbub ul Haq

1025
00:53:35.340 --> 00:53:37.200
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who was a great World Bank

1026
00:53:37.200 --> 00:53:37.940
<v Ziauddin Sardar>thinker.

1027
00:53:37.960 --> 00:53:38.700
<v Ziauddin Sardar>He wrote a brilliant book

1028
00:53:38.700 --> 00:53:40.880
<v Ziauddin Sardar>called The Poverty Curtain

1029
00:53:40.880 --> 00:53:42.660
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and everybody was so enchanted

1030
00:53:42.660 --> 00:53:43.520
<v Ziauddin Sardar>that this man can really

1031
00:53:43.520 --> 00:53:44.220
<v Ziauddin Sardar>solve the problem.

1032
00:53:44.420 --> 00:53:45.560
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And so they made him

1033
00:53:45.560 --> 00:53:47.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>a minister for planning

1034
00:53:47.540 --> 00:53:48.680
<v Ziauddin Sardar>of finance of Pakistan.

1035
00:53:48.960 --> 00:53:50.040
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And he did exactly

1036
00:53:50.040 --> 00:53:50.760
<v Ziauddin Sardar>what the World Bank

1037
00:53:50.760 --> 00:53:51.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>wanted him to do

1038
00:53:51.540 --> 00:53:52.400
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and he destroyed Pakistan.

1039
00:53:52.720 --> 00:53:53.780
<v Ziauddin Sardar>But he was a great intellectual

1040
00:53:53.780 --> 00:53:54.780
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and a great dissenter.

1041
00:53:56.480 --> 00:53:58.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>So in that sense,

1042
00:53:58.100 --> 00:54:01.520
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I'm on Michael's side.

1043
00:54:01.720 --> 00:54:03.020
<v Ziauddin Sardar>But the interesting thing...

1044
00:54:05.880 --> 00:54:07.180
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Michael was still a man.

1045
00:54:07.180 --> 00:54:11.180
<v Chair>Okay, yeah,

1046
00:54:37.180 --> 00:54:39.240
<v Chair>peace and harmony amongst the panel again.

1047
00:54:40.260 --> 00:54:40.900
<v Chair>Sir,

1048
00:54:41.080 --> 00:54:41.840
<v Chair>a question.

1049
00:54:42.260 --> 00:54:44.420
<v Speaker 8>An obvious question.

1050
00:54:45.440 --> 00:54:47.140
<v Speaker 8>Should Australia sign a free trade

1051
00:54:47.140 --> 00:54:48.740
<v Speaker 8>agreement with the United States?

1052
00:54:50.800 --> 00:54:52.600
<v Chair>No one asked you, audience.

1053
00:54:54.960 --> 00:54:57.320
<v Chair>Dangerous democratic tendencies are emerging.

1054
00:54:58.460 --> 00:54:59.340
<v Speaker 8>Should we,

1055
00:54:59.380 --> 00:54:59.620
<v Speaker 8>Michael?

1056
00:55:10.380 --> 00:55:12.680
<v Michael Woolcock>There has to be something that would go with that.

1057
00:55:12.760 --> 00:55:13.480
<v Michael Woolcock>It can't just be,

1058
00:55:14.660 --> 00:55:17.100
<v Michael Woolcock>it would have to be

1059
00:55:17.100 --> 00:55:18.640
<v Michael Woolcock>something that simultaneously was

1060
00:55:19.220 --> 00:55:21.000
<v Michael Woolcock>something that the Australian people agreed

1061
00:55:21.000 --> 00:55:23.220
<v Michael Woolcock>upon, but also something that the Australian people

1062
00:55:23.220 --> 00:55:25.080
<v Michael Woolcock>had come to an agreement on

1063
00:55:25.080 --> 00:55:27.320
<v Michael Woolcock>on the basis of a detailed deliberation

1064
00:55:27.320 --> 00:55:28.320
<v Michael Woolcock>of what that means.

1065
00:55:28.320 --> 00:55:30.140
<v Michael Woolcock>And here I'm thinking of

1066
00:55:30.140 --> 00:55:32.300
<v Michael Woolcock>a wonderful innovation that's been done

1067
00:55:32.300 --> 00:55:33.800
<v Michael Woolcock>in some parts of Texas, ironically,

1068
00:55:35.020 --> 00:55:36.240
<v Michael Woolcock>with all the notions of

1069
00:55:36.240 --> 00:55:38.420
<v Michael Woolcock>deliberative democracy, which is to say

1070
00:55:38.420 --> 00:55:40.240
<v Michael Woolcock>looking at the kind of

1071
00:55:40.240 --> 00:55:42.060
<v Michael Woolcock>answers that people give to complex

1072
00:55:42.060 --> 00:55:44.300
<v Michael Woolcock>questions like this as a knee-jerk

1073
00:55:44.300 --> 00:55:46.160
<v Michael Woolcock>response versus what they

1074
00:55:46.160 --> 00:55:47.920
<v Michael Woolcock>give after having been engaged

1075
00:55:47.920 --> 00:55:49.900
<v Michael Woolcock>in a three or four hour debate

1076
00:55:49.900 --> 00:55:52.200
<v Michael Woolcock>by people on both sides of the fence coming to

1077
00:55:52.200 --> 00:55:53.560
<v Michael Woolcock>reach the kind of opinion that we do.

1078
00:55:54.120 --> 00:55:56.120
<v Michael Woolcock>So the Australian shouldn't, in general,

1079
00:55:56.240 --> 00:55:57.980
<v Michael Woolcock>and I would say trade, open

1080
00:55:57.980 --> 00:56:00.020
<v Michael Woolcock>trade is usually a good thing for people,

1081
00:56:00.140 --> 00:56:01.940
<v Michael Woolcock>providing it simultaneously

1082
00:56:01.940 --> 00:56:04.260
<v Michael Woolcock>is, has an adequate safety

1083
00:56:04.260 --> 00:56:05.980
<v Michael Woolcock>nets and provision for those people that will

1084
00:56:05.980 --> 00:56:07.720
<v Michael Woolcock>inherently lose out of something like that.

1085
00:56:07.900 --> 00:56:10.060
<v Michael Woolcock>And secondly, something that provided that it's

1086
00:56:10.060 --> 00:56:12.200
<v Michael Woolcock>done as something that's been itself a deliberate

1087
00:56:12.200 --> 00:56:13.960
<v Michael Woolcock>democratically deliberated and determined,

1088
00:56:14.240 --> 00:56:16.380
<v Michael Woolcock>not something that was a fear of the whims

1089
00:56:16.380 --> 00:56:17.220
<v Michael Woolcock>of a political moment.

1090
00:56:17.600 --> 00:56:19.980
<v Chair>George Monbiot, would you like to jerk your knee

1091
00:56:19.980 --> 00:56:20.540
<v Chair>on the subject?

1092
00:56:22.260 --> 00:56:24.640
<v George Monbiot>My knees already jerked, I nearly kicked the table over.

1093
00:56:26.400 --> 00:56:26.880
<v George Monbiot>The,

1094
00:56:28.420 --> 00:56:31.300
<v George Monbiot>what Bush is trying to do at the moment is to go

1095
00:56:31.300 --> 00:56:34.120
<v George Monbiot>around the world and strike individual trade agreements

1096
00:56:34.120 --> 00:56:34.680
<v George Monbiot>with nations.

1097
00:56:35.060 --> 00:56:38.000
<v George Monbiot>And the reason he's trying to do this is that he

1098
00:56:38.000 --> 00:56:40.420
<v George Monbiot>recognizes there's something wrong with the World Trade

1099
00:56:40.420 --> 00:56:40.880
<v George Monbiot>Organization.

1100
00:56:41.700 --> 00:56:45.380
<v George Monbiot>He recognizes that the World Trade Organization sets unfair

1101
00:56:45.380 --> 00:56:47.780
<v George Monbiot>rules, but unfortunately they're not unfair enough.

1102
00:56:48.720 --> 00:56:51.980
<v George Monbiot>And so he's effectively trying to bypass that organization

1103
00:56:52.840 --> 00:56:55.800
<v George Monbiot>and set even more unfair trade rules with individual nations.

1104
00:56:55.880 --> 00:56:57.680
<v George Monbiot>And he can do so with great power,

1105
00:56:57.680 --> 00:57:00.400
<v George Monbiot>because of course they have no collective bargaining power

1106
00:57:00.400 --> 00:57:03.660
<v George Monbiot>if they're negotiating individually with the U.S.

1107
00:57:03.720 --> 00:57:08.120
<v George Monbiot>And this is why we have this constant series of bilateral

1108
00:57:08.660 --> 00:57:12.180
<v George Monbiot>free trade agreements being negotiated in order to pin down

1109
00:57:12.180 --> 00:57:15.040
<v George Monbiot>other nations to extremely harsh,

1110
00:57:15.280 --> 00:57:20.100
<v George Monbiot>and extremely harsh terms of trade which favor the U.S.

1111
00:57:20.100 --> 00:57:22.240
<v George Monbiot>above its partners.

1112
00:57:22.620 --> 00:57:25.560
<v George Monbiot>So my answer is unequivocally no.

1113
00:57:25.660 --> 00:57:26.900
<v George Monbiot>Do not sign this.

1114
00:57:26.960 --> 00:57:27.660
<v George Monbiot>Do not sign this.

1115
00:57:27.680 --> 00:57:28.340
<v George Monbiot>Do not sign this treaty.

1116
00:57:30.920 --> 00:57:34.620
<v Chair>Amy, then before we go to the next question,

1117
00:57:34.660 --> 00:57:36.760
<v Chair>I must ask you to leap to your president's defense.

1118
00:57:38.240 --> 00:57:39.640
<v Chair>Where do you stand on this issue?

1119
00:57:40.480 --> 00:57:41.860
<v Amy Dean>About whether the U.S.

1120
00:57:41.860 --> 00:57:43.180
<v Amy Dean>and Australia should sign a trade agreement?

1121
00:57:43.320 --> 00:57:46.460
<v Amy Dean>Well, you know, as an American, I don't feel suited to answer

1122
00:57:46.460 --> 00:57:48.200
<v Amy Dean>the question for Australians, but, you know,

1123
00:57:48.200 --> 00:57:52.520
<v Amy Dean>I would say that I believe that we can't afford to,

1124
00:57:52.600 --> 00:57:55.100
<v Amy Dean>I think countries can't afford to sit out of trade agreements.

1125
00:57:55.180 --> 00:57:56.720
<v Amy Dean>I think they've got to use their political capital

1126
00:57:56.720 --> 00:57:57.660
<v Amy Dean>to influence them.

1127
00:57:57.660 --> 00:57:59.960
<v Amy Dean>And extend their political values into those agreements.

1128
00:58:00.280 --> 00:58:03.100
<v Amy Dean>I think that if you sit them out, then you have no,

1129
00:58:03.160 --> 00:58:04.120
<v Amy Dean>absolutely no leverage.

1130
00:58:04.580 --> 00:58:07.900
<v Amy Dean>I think the challenge in the U.S. context is

1131
00:58:07.900 --> 00:58:11.420
<v Amy Dean>that we've not been able to build sufficient enough power

1132
00:58:11.420 --> 00:58:13.680
<v Amy Dean>to even be able to leverage our political values

1133
00:58:13.680 --> 00:58:14.540
<v Amy Dean>into those agreements.

1134
00:58:14.660 --> 00:58:16.140
<v Amy Dean>But I believe that that day will come.

1135
00:58:16.280 --> 00:58:17.720
<v Amy Dean>I believe that there's more and more hope

1136
00:58:17.720 --> 00:58:19.740
<v Amy Dean>for activism in that regard.

1137
00:58:19.820 --> 00:58:23.220
<v Amy Dean>So I would say sitting out the agreements doesn't allow you

1138
00:58:23.220 --> 00:58:25.160
<v Amy Dean>to leverage the political will that,

1139
00:58:25.180 --> 00:58:26.700
<v Amy Dean>or space and will that you've got.

1140
00:58:26.860 --> 00:58:27.200
<v Amy Dean>Thank you.

1141
00:58:27.660 --> 00:58:30.480
<v Chair>Another question from the Benighted Hall.

1142
00:58:30.800 --> 00:58:35.320
<v Speaker 9>Yeah. Modern economic theory think they prove mathematically

1143
00:58:35.320 --> 00:58:37.320
<v Speaker 9>using linear mathematical modeling

1144
00:58:38.100 --> 00:58:40.200
<v Speaker 9>that governments must stay out of the economy.

1145
00:58:40.600 --> 00:58:43.840
<v Speaker 9>And this justifies their 19th century social Darwinism.

1146
00:58:44.000 --> 00:58:46.760
<v Speaker 9>Now how do you get the World Bank and the IMF economists

1147
00:58:46.760 --> 00:58:48.080
<v Speaker 9>to admit that not one

1148
00:58:48.080 --> 00:58:50.580
<v Speaker 9>of their linear mathematical equations are worth a pinch

1149
00:58:50.580 --> 00:58:50.880
<v Speaker 9>of shit?

1150
00:58:51.980 --> 00:58:53.340
<v Chair>Pinches of shit, Michael.

1151
00:58:53.420 --> 00:58:55.560
<v Chair>Is that a currency with which you're familiar?

1152
00:58:55.740 --> 00:58:56.300
<v Chair>.

1153
00:58:56.300 --> 00:58:56.960
<v George Monbiot>.

1154
00:58:56.960 --> 00:58:57.240
<v George Monbiot>.

1155
00:58:57.240 --> 00:58:57.640
<v George Monbiot>.

1156
00:58:59.020 --> 00:58:59.500
<v George Monbiot>.

1157
00:59:01.780 --> 00:59:04.460
<v Michael Woolcock>Modern economic theory in the best sense of the term

1158
00:59:04.960 --> 00:59:07.380
<v Michael Woolcock>acknowledges very strongly that order,

1159
00:59:07.580 --> 00:59:09.800
<v Michael Woolcock>which is to say governments, precede markets.

1160
00:59:10.040 --> 00:59:11.840
<v Michael Woolcock>You don't have this thing called a free market.

1161
00:59:11.960 --> 00:59:14.720
<v Michael Woolcock>You have a socially constructed thing called a market

1162
00:59:14.720 --> 00:59:17.460
<v Michael Woolcock>which depends crucially on the political underpinnings

1163
00:59:17.460 --> 00:59:19.260
<v Michael Woolcock>and the social and moral consensus of the people

1164
00:59:19.260 --> 00:59:19.900
<v Michael Woolcock>on which it rests.

1165
00:59:20.300 --> 00:59:24.140
<v Michael Woolcock>So there are a set of tools that we have in modern economics

1166
00:59:24.140 --> 00:59:26.960
<v Michael Woolcock>that are very useful for addressing the kinds of issues

1167
00:59:26.960 --> 00:59:27.520
<v Michael Woolcock>that we have.

1168
00:59:27.700 --> 00:59:31.720
<v Michael Woolcock>The problem with economics or with any other way of inquiry

1169
00:59:31.720 --> 00:59:34.260
<v Michael Woolcock>is when it becomes the way of solving a problem,

1170
00:59:34.380 --> 00:59:38.760
<v Michael Woolcock>when it assumes a fundamentalist or a hegemonic capacity

1171
00:59:38.760 --> 00:59:41.180
<v Michael Woolcock>to address issues that we have in the 21st century,

1172
00:59:41.360 --> 00:59:44.160
<v Michael Woolcock>which linear models of any kind can't really deal with.

1173
00:59:44.360 --> 00:59:47.220
<v Michael Woolcock>The problems that we have in our world today are ones

1174
00:59:47.220 --> 00:59:51.000
<v Michael Woolcock>that are much less, they're partly technocratic,

1175
00:59:51.100 --> 00:59:53.580
<v Michael Woolcock>but at the end of the day most of the problems we have are ones

1176
00:59:53.580 --> 00:59:56.940
<v Michael Woolcock>that require detailed negotiation, and I think, you know,

1177
00:59:56.960 --> 01:00:00.820
<v Michael Woolcock>a sense of deliberation towards outcomes and resolutions

1178
01:00:00.820 --> 01:00:02.360
<v Michael Woolcock>that are not obvious from the outset.

1179
01:00:02.720 --> 01:00:06.060
<v Michael Woolcock>So when any particular form of thinking, whether it be economic

1180
01:00:06.060 --> 01:00:08.700
<v Michael Woolcock>or any other, thinks that it has the answers,

1181
01:00:08.780 --> 01:00:11.480
<v Michael Woolcock>then it in fact becomes part of the problem, not the solution.

1182
01:00:11.960 --> 01:00:14.360
<v Chair>George, I always thought that linear models were women

1183
01:00:14.360 --> 01:00:17.040
<v Chair>on catwalks, but do you have a view on that?

1184
01:00:19.420 --> 01:00:21.960
<v George Monbiot>There's a fantastic contradiction at the heart

1185
01:00:21.960 --> 01:00:23.280
<v George Monbiot>of World Bank and IMF policies.

1186
01:00:23.560 --> 01:00:26.120
<v George Monbiot>They're always saying government should stay out of the economies,

1187
01:00:26.960 --> 01:00:29.960
<v George Monbiot>but no government institutions intervene as much

1188
01:00:29.960 --> 01:00:32.380
<v George Monbiot>in economic planning as the World Bank and the IMF.

1189
01:00:32.840 --> 01:00:35.240
<v George Monbiot>Their central planning of the economies

1190
01:00:35.240 --> 01:00:38.140
<v George Monbiot>of other nations is Maoist in its approach.

1191
01:00:38.800 --> 01:00:42.300
<v George Monbiot>It's a Maoist fundamentalist approach which says,

1192
01:00:43.140 --> 01:00:44.800
<v George Monbiot>whatever the market might say, you are going

1193
01:00:44.800 --> 01:00:48.020
<v George Monbiot>to do precisely what we tell you to, through structural adjustment

1194
01:00:48.020 --> 01:00:49.280
<v George Monbiot>and all these other mechanisms.

1195
01:00:49.820 --> 01:00:51.980
<v George Monbiot>And what they're really doing, it seems to me,

1196
01:00:52.080 --> 01:00:53.980
<v George Monbiot>they're clearing the governments out of the way

1197
01:00:53.980 --> 01:00:56.920
<v George Monbiot>so that they get untrammeled access to deciding how the

1198
01:00:56.960 --> 01:00:58.360
<v George Monbiot>economy is planned.

1199
01:00:59.620 --> 01:01:00.180
<v Chair>Absolutely not true.

1200
01:01:01.840 --> 01:01:03.080
<v Speaker 10>Sir, upstairs.

1201
01:01:04.800 --> 01:01:05.540
<v Speaker 10>You hear me?

1202
01:01:05.920 --> 01:01:06.180
<v Speaker 10>Yep.

1203
01:01:07.440 --> 01:01:12.000
<v Speaker 10>I liked the point Amy made about the corporatization of culture,

1204
01:01:12.180 --> 01:01:16.500
<v Speaker 10>and I think all of you touched on how American culture is just

1205
01:01:16.500 --> 01:01:19.860
<v Speaker 10>so pervasive these days and gets around a bit.

1206
01:01:20.520 --> 01:01:24.780
<v Speaker 10>It occurred to me that, first of all,

1207
01:01:26.200 --> 01:01:26.940
<v Speaker 10>we should be thinking about the economy as a whole.

1208
01:01:26.960 --> 01:01:29.120
<v Speaker 10>We should recognize that there are limits to American power,

1209
01:01:29.840 --> 01:01:36.440
<v Speaker 10>and that possibly if under, say, the Murdoch regime,

1210
01:01:37.220 --> 01:01:40.540
<v Speaker 10>things like that, and if we are going to constantly sacrifice

1211
01:01:41.140 --> 01:01:46.280
<v Speaker 10>art for money and manufacture MTV and things like that,

1212
01:01:46.440 --> 01:01:49.460
<v Speaker 10>and possibly as well with the current governments we have,

1213
01:01:49.640 --> 01:01:54.500
<v Speaker 10>do you think that there's a hope of a reemergence, say,

1214
01:01:54.620 --> 01:01:56.940
<v Speaker 10>of possible realisation?

1215
01:01:56.960 --> 01:01:57.940
<v Speaker 10>Of possible re-enactment of art and real culture?

1216
01:01:59.400 --> 01:02:02.580
<v Speaker 10>And also the thing that struck me is that if, as George says,

1217
01:02:03.180 --> 01:02:06.600
<v Speaker 10>once a revolution comes, do you think that kind of culture can

1218
01:02:07.200 --> 01:02:08.000
<v Speaker 10>still succeed?

1219
01:02:09.780 --> 01:02:12.840
<v Amy Dean>I think the challenge that all of us are struggling with is what

1220
01:02:12.840 --> 01:02:15.100
<v Amy Dean>are the appropriate institutional arrangements look

1221
01:02:15.100 --> 01:02:18.900
<v Amy Dean>like to countervail this huge structure of capital?

1222
01:02:19.100 --> 01:02:24.280
<v Amy Dean>And I think that there's lots of experimentation going on in the

1223
01:02:24.280 --> 01:02:26.460
<v Amy Dean>environmental movement that demonstrate that there are ways

1224
01:02:26.460 --> 01:02:31.260
<v Amy Dean>to come together and extend political values into a global

1225
01:02:31.260 --> 01:02:33.620
<v Amy Dean>context, but I think we still have a long way to go.

1226
01:02:34.580 --> 01:02:39.580
<v Amy Dean>I guess the point is that I think we'll eventually get to that point,

1227
01:02:39.700 --> 01:02:43.080
<v Amy Dean>and when we do, I think we'll find that we'll be able to harness

1228
01:02:43.080 --> 01:02:47.260
<v Amy Dean>in this completely unfettered rule of capital.

1229
01:02:47.760 --> 01:02:54.500
<v Amy Dean>I guess the point that I was trying to make is that I'm not condoning

1230
01:02:55.980 --> 01:02:56.440
<v Amy Dean>what's happening in the world today.

1231
01:02:56.460 --> 01:02:58.840
<v Amy Dean>I'm not saying that it's happening, or I've never seen Dallas myself,

1232
01:02:59.080 --> 01:03:00.980
<v Amy Dean>but the point I guess I make is that I have a lot...

1233
01:03:00.980 --> 01:03:01.340
<v Amy Dean>What?

1234
01:03:03.280 --> 01:03:07.320
<v Amy Dean>I have a lot more faith and confidence in people's ability to

1235
01:03:07.320 --> 01:03:09.880
<v Amy Dean>perpetuate their peoplehood, and I have a lot more faith and

1236
01:03:09.880 --> 01:03:12.620
<v Amy Dean>confidence that people don't just turn the TV on and look at this

1237
01:03:12.620 --> 01:03:15.660
<v Amy Dean>stuff and are completely brainwashed, and I really do believe in

1238
01:03:15.660 --> 01:03:17.720
<v Amy Dean>people's ability to make their own individual decisions.

1239
01:03:18.000 --> 01:03:23.240
<v Amy Dean>And I, again, I'm not trying to make the case that this is a good

1240
01:03:23.240 --> 01:03:26.420
<v Amy Dean>thing, but I'm ultimately optimistic about people's

1241
01:03:26.460 --> 01:03:29.360
<v Amy Dean>ability to perpetuate their own faith and their own culture and their

1242
01:03:29.360 --> 01:03:33.920
<v Amy Dean>own peoplehood, so long as peoplehood is being defined in the context of

1243
01:03:33.920 --> 01:03:34.540
<v Amy Dean>what we're for.

1244
01:03:35.640 --> 01:03:37.940
<v Amy Dean>If peoplehood is defined in the context of...

1245
01:03:37.940 --> 01:03:40.840
<v Amy Dean>In an affirmative context, then I believe it will perpetuate over time,

1246
01:03:40.920 --> 01:03:45.060
<v Amy Dean>in spite of what kinds of things people confront from growing

1247
01:03:45.060 --> 01:03:45.920
<v Amy Dean>commercialization.

1248
01:03:46.860 --> 01:03:51.620
<v Amy Dean>And so I guess that's really the point I'm trying to make.

1249
01:03:53.740 --> 01:03:56.240
<v Chair>George, sort of a variation.

1250
01:03:56.460 --> 01:03:57.080
<v Chair>I think there's a question on that question.

1251
01:03:57.180 --> 01:04:02.240
<v Chair>It was argued that globalization would intensify localization, that

1252
01:04:02.240 --> 01:04:04.540
<v Chair>the two would form some sort of balance.

1253
01:04:04.700 --> 01:04:06.320
<v Chair>That's a variation on Amy's proposition.

1254
01:04:06.600 --> 01:04:08.280
<v Chair>Do you see that happening culturally?

1255
01:04:08.640 --> 01:04:14.100
<v George Monbiot>I think it's only going to happen if we see a massive democratization

1256
01:04:14.100 --> 01:04:19.460
<v George Monbiot>of global politics, because it's only in democracy that diversity

1257
01:04:19.460 --> 01:04:20.720
<v George Monbiot>can really flourish.

1258
01:04:20.880 --> 01:04:25.500
<v George Monbiot>That's my experience at any rate, that one of the characteristics of a

1259
01:04:26.460 --> 01:04:31.160
<v George Monbiot>global democracy is that it allows minorities to explain themselves to

1260
01:04:31.160 --> 01:04:31.540
<v George Monbiot>the majority.

1261
01:04:32.220 --> 01:04:37.920
<v George Monbiot>It gives them the space for advocacy, to say, well, I may have been born out of

1262
01:04:37.920 --> 01:04:42.380
<v George Monbiot>wedlock, or I may belong to a religious or ethnic minority, or I may be a

1263
01:04:42.380 --> 01:04:45.980
<v George Monbiot>homosexual or whatever it is, but I'm still a human being and I've still got

1264
01:04:45.980 --> 01:04:46.580
<v George Monbiot>human needs.

1265
01:04:46.720 --> 01:04:47.960
<v George Monbiot>And democracy permits that.

1266
01:04:48.220 --> 01:04:52.100
<v George Monbiot>The problem with globalization as it exists today is that it's an

1267
01:04:52.100 --> 01:04:53.080
<v George Monbiot>undemocratic process.

1268
01:04:53.300 --> 01:04:56.220
<v George Monbiot>It's run by a few self-appointed men in the rich world.

1269
01:04:56.460 --> 01:05:00.620
<v George Monbiot>My hope is that if we can democratize globalization and

1270
01:05:00.620 --> 01:05:04.980
<v George Monbiot>globalize democracy, in other words, to democratize the realm in which

1271
01:05:04.980 --> 01:05:09.960
<v George Monbiot>there's real choice still to be made, because it can't be made anymore at the

1272
01:05:09.960 --> 01:05:12.680
<v George Monbiot>local and the national level because the real decisions are being made at the

1273
01:05:12.680 --> 01:05:17.380
<v George Monbiot>global level, then we create the space in which diversity can continue to flourish.

1274
01:05:17.660 --> 01:05:18.940
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Can we democratize the spam?

1275
01:05:19.940 --> 01:05:20.580
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Democratize spam?

1276
01:05:23.580 --> 01:05:25.680
<v George Monbiot>Yes, I think we should have a vote.

1277
01:05:25.780 --> 01:05:26.440
<v George Monbiot>Here in New York.

1278
01:05:26.460 --> 01:05:29.900
<v George Monbiot>We have a vote now to decide how big Zia's penis should be allowed to get.

1279
01:05:31.840 --> 01:05:32.520
<v George Monbiot>Thank you.

1280
01:05:32.580 --> 01:05:33.420
<v George Monbiot>I should have gone on the water.

1281
01:05:33.980 --> 01:05:34.800
<v George Monbiot>You are fit.

1282
01:05:35.360 --> 01:05:37.880
<v Chair>Would you discuss Zia's penis privately, please?

1283
01:05:39.260 --> 01:05:42.120
<v Chair>One world, ready or not, we're ready for our next question.

1284
01:05:43.400 --> 01:05:47.740
<v Speaker 6>My question is mainly for Zia, but other members of the panel may wish to answer.

1285
01:05:48.440 --> 01:05:53.080
<v Speaker 6>The Western universal view is very pervasive throughout the world and is

1286
01:05:53.080 --> 01:05:53.980
<v Speaker 6>becoming more so.

1287
01:05:54.960 --> 01:05:56.440
<v Speaker 6>What do you think are the challenges that we face in the world?

1288
01:05:56.460 --> 01:06:01.080
<v Speaker 6>What are the two or three things that the West should learn from most of all of the

1289
01:06:01.080 --> 01:06:03.560
<v Speaker 6>most of all from the non-Western world?

1290
01:06:04.700 --> 01:06:07.120
<v Speaker 6>Why and how can the West learn these things?

1291
01:06:10.420 --> 01:06:11.220
<v Ziauddin Sardar>This is a...

1292
01:06:11.220 --> 01:06:12.560
<v Chair>You want me to answer that?

1293
01:06:12.700 --> 01:06:15.100
<v Chair>Zia, you are the builder of bridges, please.

1294
01:06:16.120 --> 01:06:22.100
<v Ziauddin Sardar>This is a huge question and I recommend that you read my book, Postmodernism and the Other.

1295
01:06:26.460 --> 01:06:27.160
<v Chair>Thank you.

1296
01:06:28.100 --> 01:06:31.780
<v Chair>We interrupt this advertisement for an answer.

1297
01:06:34.160 --> 01:06:39.940
<v Ziauddin Sardar>What I will do is answer the question which was asked two questions before, which I noticed

1298
01:06:39.940 --> 01:06:41.120
<v Ziauddin Sardar>you didn't allow me to answer.

1299
01:06:42.860 --> 01:06:50.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And that was, should Australia join America in creating a free trade zone or whatever?

1300
01:06:50.480 --> 01:06:53.520
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And my answer is yes, George, it should.

1301
01:06:53.720 --> 01:06:54.260
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Why?

1302
01:06:54.260 --> 01:06:59.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Because within two years, when America really starts to screw Australia, you will all know

1303
01:06:59.600 --> 01:07:03.000
<v Ziauddin Sardar>really well from personal experience why so many people out there hate America.

1304
01:07:07.060 --> 01:07:08.100
<v Chair>Second reason...

1305
01:07:08.100 --> 01:07:11.580
<v Chair>As you can see, ladies and gentlemen, I've entirely lost control of this session.

1306
01:07:12.300 --> 01:07:14.160
<v Chair>Sir, would you ask another question?

1307
01:07:14.160 --> 01:07:15.440
<v Ziauddin Sardar>May I continue and make the second point?

1308
01:07:15.500 --> 01:07:15.920
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Oh, okay.

1309
01:07:17.640 --> 01:07:23.420
<v Ziauddin Sardar>At the same time, when the South Asian countries get together and create their own free zone

1310
01:07:23.420 --> 01:07:24.240
<v Ziauddin Sardar>and leave the world, they are not going to be able to do that.

1311
01:07:24.260 --> 01:07:25.320
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And they are not going to leave Australia out.

1312
01:07:25.800 --> 01:07:29.220
<v Ziauddin Sardar>It will be a good experience for you to discover how it is to be marginalized.

1313
01:07:36.500 --> 01:07:38.000
<v Michael Woolcock>Philip, can I answer that question?

1314
01:07:38.040 --> 01:07:38.380
<v Chair>Oh, hang on.

1315
01:07:38.500 --> 01:07:39.060
<v Chair>No, you can't.

1316
01:07:39.340 --> 01:07:40.560
<v Speaker 11>I can't impact it.

1317
01:07:40.640 --> 01:07:45.840
<v Speaker 11>How many people in the audience are aware free trade negotiations are going on in and

1318
01:07:45.840 --> 01:07:47.400
<v Speaker 11>why a couple of weeks ago...

1319
01:07:47.400 --> 01:07:52.020
<v Speaker 11>How many people are aware that the Australian government refused...

1320
01:07:52.020 --> 01:07:54.240
<v Speaker 11>Didn't want labor and peace and they refused to leave Australia and they refused to leave

1321
01:07:54.240 --> 01:08:01.540
<v Speaker 11>agreements in the agreement. And amazingly, the Bush government insisted that later agreements

1322
01:08:01.540 --> 01:08:02.340
<v Speaker 11>be incorporated.

1323
01:08:03.120 --> 01:08:08.080
<v Chair>Look, we're just having an immense amount of silence on Radio National, Radio Australia

1324
01:08:08.080 --> 01:08:12.600
<v Chair>and the World Wide Web because you're not on a microphone, so I'm sorry. Sir, can you

1325
01:08:12.600 --> 01:08:14.180
<v Chair>ask your question, please?

1326
01:08:14.560 --> 01:08:20.900
<v Speaker 7>Thank you. One of the things that underpins today's discussion, it seems to me, is the

1327
01:08:20.900 --> 01:08:26.560
<v Speaker 7>turning of human beings into consumers and the commodification of everything. And this

1328
01:08:26.560 --> 01:08:31.040
<v Speaker 7>is going on on a global scale, and I fear that we're already a long way down that path.

1329
01:08:31.760 --> 01:08:38.820
<v Speaker 7>But I wanted to pick up on the talk that George Monbiot gave yesterday on the looming energy

1330
01:08:38.820 --> 01:08:46.260
<v Speaker 7>crisis and how this impacts on today's discussion. It seems to me, from what you said yesterday,

1331
01:08:47.200 --> 01:08:50.880
<v Speaker 7>that the world of the future is one in which trade in heavy goods is going to be a big

1332
01:08:50.880 --> 01:08:56.320
<v Speaker 7>deal. And that the goods will be very much limited. But hopefully, there will be a great

1333
01:08:56.320 --> 01:09:02.880
<v Speaker 7>sharing of ideas. And several things which cut right across this is the hegemony of the

1334
01:09:02.880 --> 01:09:09.940
<v Speaker 7>rich with respect to intellectual property, with respect to patenting, with respect to

1335
01:09:09.940 --> 01:09:11.120
<v Speaker 7>copyright.

1336
01:09:11.600 --> 01:09:18.520
<v Speaker 7>And I wonder whether you'd comment on how we address those situations, because it seems

1337
01:09:18.520 --> 01:09:20.860
<v Speaker 7>to me, putting both the energy situation and the economic situation at the heart of the

1338
01:09:20.860 --> 01:09:27.640
<v Speaker 7>situation, together with the other things that have been mentioned today, they are

1339
01:09:27.640 --> 01:09:31.700
<v Speaker 7>some of the things which underpin the hegemony of the rich.

1340
01:09:32.560 --> 01:09:38.300
<v George Monbiot>Yes, thanks. And this is a crucial issue, this idea of complete intellectual property

1341
01:09:38.300 --> 01:09:44.540
<v George Monbiot>control we're now seeing developing, where corporations are exercising control, not just

1342
01:09:44.540 --> 01:09:50.760
<v George Monbiot>over software and, indeed, hardware, but over plants and animals.

1343
01:09:50.860 --> 01:09:56.000
<v George Monbiot>Over human genes, over human body parts. They are claiming these as their exclusive

1344
01:09:56.000 --> 01:10:03.860
<v George Monbiot>private property. This is an outrage. But it's an outrage in which the current organs

1345
01:10:03.860 --> 01:10:13.360
<v George Monbiot>of global governance conspire. And what it does is two things. First of all, as you suggest,

1346
01:10:13.600 --> 01:10:20.840
<v George Monbiot>it greatly limits freedom of speech and freedom of action. It limits the ability to control,

1347
01:10:22.540 --> 01:10:25.220
<v George Monbiot>at large, everyone,

1348
01:10:49.460 --> 01:11:00.820
<v George Monbiot>of human intellectual development and also shut out of scope for developing our own responses

1349
01:11:00.820 --> 01:11:06.400
<v George Monbiot>to the very serious problems we're faced with. But the other major problem is this, that

1350
01:11:06.400 --> 01:11:14.080
<v George Monbiot>poor nations simply can't acquire the sort of wealth they need to drag themselves out

1351
01:11:14.080 --> 01:11:18.560
<v George Monbiot>of the worst excesses of poverty without what is called technology transfer, without being

1352
01:11:18.560 --> 01:11:24.040
<v George Monbiot>able to get their hands on intellectual property. And at the moment that is almost completely

1353
01:11:24.040 --> 01:11:31.620
<v George Monbiot>forbidden to them. And this is one of the great impediments to the benign development

1354
01:11:31.620 --> 01:11:32.920
<v George Monbiot>of the poor world today.

1355
01:11:33.580 --> 01:11:34.780
<v Chair>A response, Michael?

1356
01:11:35.280 --> 01:11:43.380
<v Michael Woolcock>Yeah, I agree, actually. You look at the – and this is in principle what a free – truly

1357
01:11:43.380 --> 01:11:48.100
<v Michael Woolcock>a – truly free – the problem is we have such hypocrisy. We do actually have what's

1358
01:11:48.100 --> 01:11:48.540
<v Michael Woolcock>two-fold.

1359
01:11:49.580 --> 01:11:52.700
<v Michael Woolcock>It's not just capitalism for the poor, it's capitalism for the rich and capitalism

1360
01:11:52.700 --> 01:11:57.680
<v Michael Woolcock>for the poor. It's – there are – the gains that would be gained to poor countries

1361
01:11:57.680 --> 01:12:02.660
<v Michael Woolcock>by having a much more open set of trading mechanisms that allowed all these types of

1362
01:12:02.660 --> 01:12:05.800
<v Michael Woolcock>technologies to flow into them would be enormous, and it's rich countries that are stopping

1363
01:12:05.800 --> 01:12:07.140
<v Michael Woolcock>those happening, not the World Bank.

1364
01:12:07.940 --> 01:12:12.380
<v Chair>There was a figure on the balcony who was contemplating either a question or suicide.

1365
01:12:14.640 --> 01:12:17.760
<v Chair>No, I think he's just leaving. Sir, your turn.

1366
01:12:33.860 --> 01:12:48.520
<v Speaker 12>Okay, yeah,

1367
01:12:48.520 --> 01:12:49.860
<v Speaker 12>the directions that you're coming from.

1368
01:12:49.980 --> 01:12:55.000
<v Speaker 12>And it sounds like what's evolving from the conversation

1369
01:12:55.000 --> 01:13:01.080
<v Speaker 12>is that globalization and international relations

1370
01:13:02.620 --> 01:13:04.300
<v Speaker 12>can mean many things,

1371
01:13:05.280 --> 01:13:07.960
<v Speaker 12>and is actually quite a complicated thing.

1372
01:13:08.060 --> 01:13:11.760
<v Speaker 12>I mean, it means both the ideas of Americanization

1373
01:13:11.760 --> 01:13:16.360
<v Speaker 12>and also stuff to do with the environment.

1374
01:13:16.360 --> 01:13:21.260
<v Speaker 12>Anyway, I'm trying to get on with it, I'm sorry.

1375
01:13:24.820 --> 01:13:26.620
<v Speaker 12>Basically, what I'm trying to ask is,

1376
01:13:26.700 --> 01:13:29.480
<v Speaker 12>do you think there's a trend happening in the world,

1377
01:13:29.560 --> 01:13:33.640
<v Speaker 12>like, to bring harmony out of all the different viewpoints,

1378
01:13:33.680 --> 01:13:36.120
<v Speaker 12>which are all good, it's good to feel dissent,

1379
01:13:36.200 --> 01:13:40.280
<v Speaker 12>do you think there's a trend evolving in humanity

1380
01:13:42.480 --> 01:13:45.240
<v Speaker 12>that is headed in a certain direction?

1381
01:13:45.820 --> 01:13:46.260
<v Speaker 12>Yeah.

1382
01:13:46.260 --> 01:13:47.600
<v Chair>That's a very good question.

1383
01:13:47.660 --> 01:13:48.280
<v Chair>Leave it at that.

1384
01:13:48.320 --> 01:13:52.180
<v Chair>Is there a trend in humanity that is leading us in the right direction?

1385
01:13:52.280 --> 01:13:52.820
<v Chair>Can we agree?

1386
01:13:53.680 --> 01:13:55.540
<v Chair>Can we end on an optimistic note?

1387
01:13:57.400 --> 01:13:58.700
<v Michael Woolcock>No, apparently not.

1388
01:14:01.480 --> 01:14:03.240
<v Michael Woolcock>I'll set myself up here again.

1389
01:14:04.240 --> 01:14:05.960
<v Michael Woolcock>I think we have to recognize

1390
01:14:07.420 --> 01:14:11.200
<v Michael Woolcock>that this whole idea of development is a modernist idea,

1391
01:14:11.380 --> 01:14:12.320
<v Michael Woolcock>an Enlightenment idea,

1392
01:14:12.500 --> 01:14:15.300
<v Michael Woolcock>which means that we believe there is this thing called progress

1393
01:14:15.300 --> 01:14:15.920
<v Michael Woolcock>that we...

1394
01:14:16.260 --> 01:14:17.260
<v Michael Woolcock>believe it is measurable,

1395
01:14:17.440 --> 01:14:19.240
<v Michael Woolcock>that it is achievable.

1396
01:14:20.420 --> 01:14:22.720
<v Michael Woolcock>And perhaps I'll answer my...

1397
01:14:22.720 --> 01:14:24.260
<v Michael Woolcock>give my response to the question

1398
01:14:24.260 --> 01:14:26.100
<v Michael Woolcock>that we didn't get a serious answer to before,

1399
01:14:26.280 --> 01:14:29.120
<v Michael Woolcock>which was, what can we learn from the third world here?

1400
01:14:29.460 --> 01:14:31.680
<v Michael Woolcock>And a lot of that is about...

1401
01:14:31.680 --> 01:14:33.520
<v Michael Woolcock>Actually, there's a lot in common

1402
01:14:33.520 --> 01:14:35.280
<v Michael Woolcock>before we actually start saying there are differences.

1403
01:14:35.300 --> 01:14:37.200
<v Michael Woolcock>Most poor people don't like being poor.

1404
01:14:37.480 --> 01:14:40.540
<v Michael Woolcock>Most poor people want to be able to have

1405
01:14:40.540 --> 01:14:44.100
<v Michael Woolcock>and live the kinds of lives of dignity and purpose

1406
01:14:44.100 --> 01:14:45.820
<v Michael Woolcock>that, of course, they would want to have happen.

1407
01:14:46.260 --> 01:14:47.740
<v Michael Woolcock>But that...

1408
01:14:48.600 --> 01:14:49.480
<v Michael Woolcock>in our...

1409
01:14:49.480 --> 01:14:50.000
<v Michael Woolcock>in our...

1410
01:14:50.000 --> 01:14:52.280
<v Michael Woolcock>the means by which we get there

1411
01:14:52.280 --> 01:14:53.680
<v Michael Woolcock>are going to be enormously varied.

1412
01:14:53.920 --> 01:14:56.540
<v Michael Woolcock>And how people conceive of those kinds of ends

1413
01:14:56.540 --> 01:14:59.000
<v Michael Woolcock>is, in fact, enormously varied all over the world.

1414
01:14:59.060 --> 01:15:00.240
<v Michael Woolcock>And we need to recognize that.

1415
01:15:00.540 --> 01:15:04.340
<v Michael Woolcock>And that's what a true engagement with poor people

1416
01:15:04.340 --> 01:15:07.120
<v Michael Woolcock>can help us to provide a more sophisticated understanding.

1417
01:15:07.420 --> 01:15:07.680
<v Michael Woolcock>But we...

1418
01:15:07.680 --> 01:15:08.580
<v Michael Woolcock>At the end of the day,

1419
01:15:08.660 --> 01:15:10.100
<v Michael Woolcock>I think we have to believe...

1420
01:15:10.100 --> 01:15:11.420
<v Michael Woolcock>We can't believe in anarchy.

1421
01:15:11.580 --> 01:15:13.300
<v Michael Woolcock>We have to believe in order and progress.

1422
01:15:13.560 --> 01:15:15.140
<v Michael Woolcock>There needs to be conflict to get us there,

1423
01:15:15.200 --> 01:15:16.220
<v Michael Woolcock>precisely because how we...

1424
01:15:16.220 --> 01:15:17.960
<v Michael Woolcock>how we do that is not self-evident before we start.

1425
01:15:19.020 --> 01:15:21.500
<v Chair>Zia, optimistic on human progress?

1426
01:15:22.600 --> 01:15:25.100
<v Ziauddin Sardar>I think I mentioned earlier on that I'm never optimistic,

1427
01:15:25.340 --> 01:15:27.600
<v Ziauddin Sardar>but I'm always hopeful because the distinct...

1428
01:15:27.600 --> 01:15:29.900
<v Ziauddin Sardar>Optimism seems to me to be a very statistical thing.

1429
01:15:30.080 --> 01:15:31.220
<v Ziauddin Sardar>You know, you do this, you do this,

1430
01:15:31.220 --> 01:15:33.660
<v Ziauddin Sardar>therefore I'm optimistic, you know, kind of.

1431
01:15:33.980 --> 01:15:35.380
<v Ziauddin Sardar>So I'm very hopeful.

1432
01:15:35.940 --> 01:15:38.320
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And I'm very hopeful because I am...

1433
01:15:38.320 --> 01:15:40.980
<v Ziauddin Sardar>At the end of the day, I really do want to change the world.

1434
01:15:41.080 --> 01:15:42.540
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And I want to go out and change the world.

1435
01:15:42.660 --> 01:15:44.700
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And what gives me hope more than anything else

1436
01:15:44.700 --> 01:15:46.140
<v Ziauddin Sardar>is to see 700 people here,

1437
01:15:46.220 --> 01:15:47.100
<v Ziauddin Sardar>who are willing to follow me.

1438
01:15:54.160 --> 01:15:57.640
<v Chair>Amy, is there a new dynamic in world affairs?

1439
01:15:58.680 --> 01:16:01.180
<v Amy Dean>You know, I don't know if the trend is...

1440
01:16:01.180 --> 01:16:03.240
<v Amy Dean>I don't know if what we're experiencing is unprecedented,

1441
01:16:03.320 --> 01:16:05.120
<v Amy Dean>but I do think that things are cyclical.

1442
01:16:05.220 --> 01:16:06.140
<v Amy Dean>Culture is cyclical.

1443
01:16:06.200 --> 01:16:07.020
<v Amy Dean>Power is cyclical.

1444
01:16:07.100 --> 01:16:08.560
<v Amy Dean>And I think that we are approaching a moment

1445
01:16:08.560 --> 01:16:10.620
<v Amy Dean>where people recognize that we need to wrestle in

1446
01:16:10.620 --> 01:16:12.260
<v Amy Dean>these unfettered forces of capital.

1447
01:16:12.440 --> 01:16:15.140
<v Amy Dean>I think that where we're struggling is trying to figure out...

1448
01:16:15.140 --> 01:16:15.900
<v Amy Dean>It's so big.

1449
01:16:15.920 --> 01:16:16.200
<v Amy Dean>It's so big.

1450
01:16:16.220 --> 01:16:16.500
<v Amy Dean>It's so huge.

1451
01:16:16.560 --> 01:16:18.400
<v Amy Dean>We're trying to figure out what are the building blocks,

1452
01:16:18.500 --> 01:16:19.760
<v Amy Dean>what are the institutional building blocks

1453
01:16:19.760 --> 01:16:22.060
<v Amy Dean>for being able to restore parity of power

1454
01:16:22.060 --> 01:16:23.800
<v Amy Dean>and parity of influence.

1455
01:16:24.220 --> 01:16:26.660
<v Amy Dean>But I'm convinced that because it's gotten so far

1456
01:16:26.660 --> 01:16:28.460
<v Amy Dean>to one side of the aisle,

1457
01:16:28.600 --> 01:16:30.680
<v Amy Dean>that people really are trying to figure out

1458
01:16:30.680 --> 01:16:35.020
<v Amy Dean>how we restore the values that we hold near and dear to our heart

1459
01:16:35.020 --> 01:16:37.780
<v Amy Dean>as a part of what's happening in the economy around the world.

1460
01:16:37.900 --> 01:16:39.180
<v Amy Dean>And so I'm optimistic,

1461
01:16:39.280 --> 01:16:41.540
<v Amy Dean>in spite of how large the challenge appears to be,

1462
01:16:41.660 --> 01:16:44.200
<v Amy Dean>because I feel like I see a lot of things going on,

1463
01:16:44.240 --> 01:16:45.720
<v Amy Dean>not just in the U.S., but around the world.

1464
01:16:46.220 --> 01:16:48.980
<v Chair>George, I'm going to slightly rephrase the question for you.

1465
01:16:49.300 --> 01:16:53.820
<v Chair>Is the dynamic, this strange thing that's going on

1466
01:16:53.820 --> 01:16:56.000
<v Chair>amongst millions of people around the world,

1467
01:16:56.060 --> 01:16:59.680
<v Chair>sufficient to lead to the revolution that you want?

1468
01:17:00.660 --> 01:17:01.840
<v George Monbiot>It's not yet sufficient,

1469
01:17:02.060 --> 01:17:05.680
<v George Monbiot>but it's almost been driven by the very economic globalization

1470
01:17:05.680 --> 01:17:07.260
<v George Monbiot>which we can test,

1471
01:17:07.420 --> 01:17:10.000
<v George Monbiot>because what's happening is that that process

1472
01:17:10.000 --> 01:17:14.240
<v George Monbiot>is tearing down the barriers between us and other people.

1473
01:17:14.320 --> 01:17:16.080
<v George Monbiot>It's forcing us together into a sort of

1474
01:17:16.080 --> 01:17:16.900
<v George Monbiot>global citizenship.

1475
01:17:17.140 --> 01:17:20.460
<v George Monbiot>It's forcing us to see that those of us

1476
01:17:20.460 --> 01:17:23.740
<v George Monbiot>who are being done in by a transnational company in Australia

1477
01:17:23.740 --> 01:17:26.860
<v George Monbiot>have the same class interests as those being done in

1478
01:17:26.860 --> 01:17:29.780
<v George Monbiot>by the same transnational company in Bangladesh.

1479
01:17:30.180 --> 01:17:33.420
<v George Monbiot>We suddenly begin to see that we are global citizens first

1480
01:17:33.420 --> 01:17:35.380
<v George Monbiot>and national citizens second.

1481
01:17:35.660 --> 01:17:38.000
<v George Monbiot>And so there's a sort of dialectic here

1482
01:17:38.000 --> 01:17:41.260
<v George Monbiot>developing between the economic globalization we can test

1483
01:17:41.260 --> 01:17:45.500
<v George Monbiot>and the opportunities that that creates for us to fight it,

1484
01:17:45.500 --> 01:17:49.200
<v George Monbiot>and to devise a world which is good for us

1485
01:17:49.200 --> 01:17:50.980
<v George Monbiot>rather than just good for capital.

1486
01:17:51.600 --> 01:17:57.320
<v George Monbiot>And so what we see happening is almost an inexorable process.

1487
01:17:57.920 --> 01:18:00.720
<v George Monbiot>Many people have been saying recently

1488
01:18:00.720 --> 01:18:02.560
<v George Monbiot>that they believe a better world is possible.

1489
01:18:02.760 --> 01:18:05.520
<v George Monbiot>I'm beginning to believe that a better world is inevitable.

1490
01:18:07.100 --> 01:18:07.700
<v Ziauddin Sardar>.

1491
01:18:11.580 --> 01:18:12.280
<v Ziauddin Sardar>.

1492
01:18:14.420 --> 01:18:17.460
<v Ziauddin Sardar>And as the organ surges,

1493
01:18:19.020 --> 01:18:21.220
<v Chair>I'd like to thank you for attending today's church service,

1494
01:18:21.360 --> 01:18:25.260
<v Chair>and would you now applaud Amy Dean,

1495
01:18:25.500 --> 01:18:26.440
<v Chair>George Monbiot,

1496
01:18:26.680 --> 01:18:27.720
<v Chair>Sia Soudar,

1497
01:18:27.840 --> 01:18:28.900
<v Chair>and Michael Wolcott.

1498
01:18:29.960 --> 01:18:30.660
<v Chair>.

1499
01:18:34.480 --> 01:18:35.380
<v Chair>Thank you.

1500
01:18:35.500 --> 01:18:35.880
<v Chair>.

1501
01:18:38.920 --> 01:18:40.320
<v Chair>.

